Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Email sent by colleagues addressed to 'Gents'

232 replies

funkymonkey55 · 07/08/2023 13:18

AIBU to be annoyed by a male colleague starting an email chain to other male colleagues where he addresses them as "Gents" and then he loops me in a few days later - when the actions around the original email topic (gathering information together) need to be picked up (by me of course!)?

It annoys me because I feel 1) I should have been cc'd in the first instance, 2) Isn't starting an email chain where you know females will have to be cc'd in / included with the phrase Gents a little rude?

I don't know if I am being a bit overly sensitive.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
GalaApples · 10/08/2023 10:48

It sounds as though the colleague who wrote this is flexing his muscles and those of his male colleagues, to try out the possibility of a new dynamic with the replacement manager who is less pro woman. Its a power thing, as ever.
Would HR help with sexism in the office?

EBearhug · 10/08/2023 10:40

Most people aren’t maliciously trying to sabotage their colleagues.

No, they're not. (Though there are those who do.) But it can be done unconsciously by always defaulting to male, only remembering there's a woman in the team as an afterthought. As some said upthread, it's othering and divisive - even if it isn't deliberate. That's how unconscious bias works. None of these things on their own matter, but they all add up - death by 1000 cuts.

LunaLula83 · 09/08/2023 22:24

I personally wouldn't reply to emails addressing 'gents' because I'm not a gent

Boomboom22 · 09/08/2023 22:08

BroomHandledMouser · 09/08/2023 15:31

Pisses me off.

DD plays in an all boys U12 football team and the coaches still say ‘well done lads’ ‘right listen up boys’ etc.

Twats

So it's not all boys?

CasperGutman · 09/08/2023 21:08

BroomHandledMouser · 09/08/2023 15:31

Pisses me off.

DD plays in an all boys U12 football team and the coaches still say ‘well done lads’ ‘right listen up boys’ etc.

Twats

But that's a completely different situation. In the OP's story all the people addressed as 'gents' were male. I've underlined this because it's a really important point which many people seem to be missing.

I'm also slightly confused by those saying it was sexist/misogynistic for the OP not to be included in the original email. There are 1001 situations in a workplace where one person might need to be made aware of a communication which was entirely appropriately addressed to one or more colleagues and not to them. Unless the OP has explains the specifics of the content of the email (which would almost certainly not be appropriate on a public forum) nobody has any way of knowing whether this was okay here or not.

One useful thing I am taking away from this thread is that a fair few posters feel that any gendered language in the workplace is inappropriate. I can't quite get my head round this personally - as far as I can tell addressing Jim and Mike as "Jim and Mike" would exclude Mary just as much as calling them "Gents" would exclude her. And indeed, excluding others who aren't being addressed is appropriate and the whole point of using any form of address - it delineates the group being spoken or written to and distinguishes them from any others who are present or who may see the message. But it's common enough for people to find "gents" problematic that I'll be trying hard to avoid using language like this at work in future.

BroomHandledMouser · 09/08/2023 15:31

Pisses me off.

DD plays in an all boys U12 football team and the coaches still say ‘well done lads’ ‘right listen up boys’ etc.

Twats

Neverseenbefore · 09/08/2023 15:23

Hereforaglance · 09/08/2023 14:34

Im female but in my line of work hearing right lads lets go is a common phrase lol any one snowflakey or easily offended gets left behind lol

Anyone saying anyone was snowflakey would be in trouble in my line of work. Likewise anyone who think it’s “lol”.

Hereforaglance · 09/08/2023 14:34

Im female but in my line of work hearing right lads lets go is a common phrase lol any one snowflakey or easily offended gets left behind lol

AnSolas · 09/08/2023 12:43

TheBerry · 09/08/2023 11:20

Sure, but ultimately that’s still going to reflect badly on him, not her. It’s clear from the email thread when the info got passed to her. If he didn’t let her know as soon as he received it, that’s his oversight.

So yeah I can’t see why he’d do it deliberately.

Even if it wasn’t going to reflect badly on him, I’d still assume it was genuine error. Most people aren’t maliciously trying to sabotage their colleagues. People just make mistakes from time to time.

If there is a problem and applying for the award is her job, OP is to blame.
As in OP failed to ask for the data from the employee who should not have gotten involved in a task which was outside his job description.

If there is no problem and the award is given to the company he is the named person directly linked to managing the process.

That is not maliciously trying to sabotage their colleagues its trying to use office politics to outshine and upstage OP with a new manager.
At year end he can now say he went the extra mile and his finished task "organised the award" should be recognised as taking on extra responsibilty. In some places extra = a bonus
For the OP "organised the award" is doing her regualar job. (No bonus).

You have worked for nice people in nice organisations but not all jobs are like that.

Neverseenbefore · 09/08/2023 12:32

Dotjones · 09/08/2023 09:57

Whether or not you should have been copied in from the start is a seperate issue to the form of greeting used.

The only people who have to decide whether "gents" is an appropriate form of greeting are the people the original email was directed to. Anyone who is copied on later down the line doesn't really have the right to a say.

This is because it's no different to Manager A emailing Employee B, starting the message with "Hi Employee B". If later on they forward/copy Employee C into the email chain, Employee C doesn't really have the right to be offended that the original email specifically excluded them from the greeting. It wasn't directed to them.

As an aside, I had a female manager once who always said "Morning Ladies" as she entered the office. The one male employee in the room never seemed to give a shit that he was being included in this form of address.

No. The writer of the email doesn’t get to decide that - or shouldn’t. “Gents” is a completely inappropriate form of address in the workplace. So is “ladies” too.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 09/08/2023 11:25

@Gladragsy
Sorry to hear you’re still having to deal with that sort of crap. Early on I did have some real dinosaurs as bosses. Like the one who was surprised when I refused to cover the phones when the team assistant was off especially when I suggested he asked one of the 3 males who was more junior than me.

TheBerry · 09/08/2023 11:20

AnSolas · 09/08/2023 11:02

He is not the manager of the department.

He is at the same level as OP emailing department heads who instruct their staff to supply him with the data.
He then sends a second email to department heads asking that the data be sent to OP as OP has been instructed to do the grunt work.

If the other department heads send the data to OPs team contact (not her) the data has been received by X date and its an interdepartment fight with her name being dragged in to why the award application was not made.

Sure, but ultimately that’s still going to reflect badly on him, not her. It’s clear from the email thread when the info got passed to her. If he didn’t let her know as soon as he received it, that’s his oversight.

So yeah I can’t see why he’d do it deliberately.

Even if it wasn’t going to reflect badly on him, I’d still assume it was genuine error. Most people aren’t maliciously trying to sabotage their colleagues. People just make mistakes from time to time.

AnSolas · 09/08/2023 11:02

TheBerry · 09/08/2023 10:39

How is that to his benefit? Wouldn’t it be to his benefit to cc OP as early as possible to make sure the work got done? Isn’t it more likely that he just made a genuine mistake in omitting OP?

I feel like people who make these kinds of negative assumptions are the ones who are constantly mithering and dissatisfied and falling out with people.

OP should just do her job now she has the info she needs. If she’s questioned why it’s taken so long, she can say she only received the info on x date.

He is not the manager of the department.

He is at the same level as OP emailing department heads who instruct their staff to supply him with the data.
He then sends a second email to department heads asking that the data be sent to OP as OP has been instructed to do the grunt work.

If the other department heads send the data to OPs team contact (not her) the data has been received by X date and its an interdepartment fight with her name being dragged in to why the award application was not made.

Gladragsy · 09/08/2023 10:51

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 09/08/2023 08:57

Yes, I was the only woman on my team for several years. On one particularly memorable occasion I was representing my company at a trade association meeting - 40 people in the room and the only women were me and the woman taking the minutes.

Some of the men genuinely care and make an effort like the very senior male director who always did the drinks in meetings to avoid the idea that one of the women should do it. Others do it because they will be marked down at their appraisal because being able to demonstrate inclusiveness is one of their objectives.

It’s not perfect but compared to when I started (in the last millennium 😱) real progress has been made.

I'm glad things have improved for you. I started work in 2006 and regularly got the gents emails. Get it now too. The last one I got, the writer assumed I was an assistant on the legal team. But I was a manager who had been pulled in to sort a problem

TheBerry · 09/08/2023 10:39

billy1966 · 09/08/2023 10:15

The real issue is deliberately excluding you in the original email, yet cc you as you are needed to do the work involved.

Nothing accidental in that.
Absolutely deliberate.

He is hugely aware of the shift in culture and using it to his benefit.

Keep a note of everything.

Are you in a union?

I hope you are.

Do not reward him by doing as he asks.

He needs to be shown to have fxxked up by excluding you.

How is that to his benefit? Wouldn’t it be to his benefit to cc OP as early as possible to make sure the work got done? Isn’t it more likely that he just made a genuine mistake in omitting OP?

I feel like people who make these kinds of negative assumptions are the ones who are constantly mithering and dissatisfied and falling out with people.

OP should just do her job now she has the info she needs. If she’s questioned why it’s taken so long, she can say she only received the info on x date.

billy1966 · 09/08/2023 10:15

The real issue is deliberately excluding you in the original email, yet cc you as you are needed to do the work involved.

Nothing accidental in that.
Absolutely deliberate.

He is hugely aware of the shift in culture and using it to his benefit.

Keep a note of everything.

Are you in a union?

I hope you are.

Do not reward him by doing as he asks.

He needs to be shown to have fxxked up by excluding you.

Dotjones · 09/08/2023 09:57

Whether or not you should have been copied in from the start is a seperate issue to the form of greeting used.

The only people who have to decide whether "gents" is an appropriate form of greeting are the people the original email was directed to. Anyone who is copied on later down the line doesn't really have the right to a say.

This is because it's no different to Manager A emailing Employee B, starting the message with "Hi Employee B". If later on they forward/copy Employee C into the email chain, Employee C doesn't really have the right to be offended that the original email specifically excluded them from the greeting. It wasn't directed to them.

As an aside, I had a female manager once who always said "Morning Ladies" as she entered the office. The one male employee in the room never seemed to give a shit that he was being included in this form of address.

JudgeRudy · 09/08/2023 09:44

If the 'team' its addressed to are all male this seems perfectly reasonable to me. If the email has been forwarded or you're cc'd you are being made aware of the email sent to them. He's not addressing you as 'Gents'.
If eg I worked in a school and the email I was ccd into/forwarded said 'Dear Parent/Guardian' I would feel affronted because I'm not a parent.
I think you're looking for problems where ghey don't exist!

Middlelanehogger · 09/08/2023 09:29

I've exclusively worked in male-dominated industries for my entire career. It's been excellent because they're generally better paid, which makes it very easy to breeze past "micro aggressions" that everyone feels I need to worry about.

I've advanced quite far in my career by never getting involved in the "trade award nomination committee" too

Noodles1234 · 09/08/2023 08:58

Wouldn’t bother me at all, if it does you just reply and say Ladies and Gentleman or Team. Have to say I like receiving one addressed with Ladies, Team feels a bit cold but each to their own.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 09/08/2023 08:57

Gladragsy · 09/08/2023 07:15

Have you worked in a male dominated sector? This is common and annoying. As it's the practice of a group of men referring to each other as sir, in person as a sign of respect. But you get called by your name

Yes, I was the only woman on my team for several years. On one particularly memorable occasion I was representing my company at a trade association meeting - 40 people in the room and the only women were me and the woman taking the minutes.

Some of the men genuinely care and make an effort like the very senior male director who always did the drinks in meetings to avoid the idea that one of the women should do it. Others do it because they will be marked down at their appraisal because being able to demonstrate inclusiveness is one of their objectives.

It’s not perfect but compared to when I started (in the last millennium 😱) real progress has been made.

MissHavershamReturns · 09/08/2023 07:32

It’s a huge barrier - like saying you don’t exist.

Gladragsy · 09/08/2023 07:17

Middlelanehogger · 09/08/2023 05:17

I love that this whole thread is pure outrage that anyone would even notice the sex of their colleagues in 2023 when the rest of Mumsnet is all about how you can clock a transwoman at a thousand paces...

There are some barriers to women advancing further in the workplace but this isn't one.

But it is a barrier. It's othering and makes a division. Hard to be promoted when this is company culture

Gladragsy · 09/08/2023 07:15

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 07/08/2023 18:31

I’ve worked in the City for over 20 years and I can’t think of a single person who would address an email to Gents. I tend to use “Dear All” or just “Good Morning/Afternoon” on group emails. I know some managers that might use “Hi Team”.
Everyone avoids exclusionary language because it is well…exclusionary.

Like other posters my immediate reaction was sounds like a boy’s club is gradually coalescing and the OP is outside it. A lot of management training deals now with these informal cliques that can easily start to shut people out. eg beers after work may exclude people of either sex who don’t drink for religious reasons. “Gents” excludes women (and anyone else who doesn’t apply that term to themselves).

OP, keep a record, and make sure that you get credit for any contributions you make. Put ever bit of input in writing and make sure you are the one reporting your contribution not Mr Gents.

Have you worked in a male dominated sector? This is common and annoying. As it's the practice of a group of men referring to each other as sir, in person as a sign of respect. But you get called by your name

AnSolas · 09/08/2023 07:12

TheBerry · 08/08/2023 19:36

“As for not including you in the first place, it sounds as though he messed up there - but couldn’t it just’ve been human error / oversight? Unless he constantly makes mistakes like that, I’d be giving him benefit of the doubt.”

He had no intent to do the work but took charge of telling people in other departments their team needed data to win an award.

If he had no intent to do the hard bit why make the OP's job harder?

Lots of jobs would just send the data back to the requester and remove other's off the email.
it can be that manager in the purchase department has no interest in having spend time reading what the other deparrments send back or communication chains between other departments. Or a manager forward instructions to staff even removing the sender as again the sender only needs work product not the email by email detail of how the data is collected.