Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Families are shit here?

106 replies

87to · 07/08/2023 13:10

That's it really

Nobody helps each other, siblings view siblings as unimportant and "not part of their life" mothers watch their offspring struggle.

That's it really.

I finally understand why old people get put in a care home.

OP posts:
WestwardHo1 · 07/08/2023 13:46

C1N1C · 07/08/2023 13:36

Following on with your generalisations comment

The fathers have all been booted after their mum was convinced to leave from the red flag brigade on MN.

Seriously though, I have noticed this too. You go abroad to Asia, even Spain, and it's ALL family... but conversely, I'd also hate for the majority of my birthing to be down to having someone to look after my parents when they're older...

What about the people who unfortunately don't have any family?

I know it's to do with tourism, but in Barcelona at the moment some restaurants are refusing to serve single people. How to make a single person feel like a leper. Not sure that attitude is anything to aspire to either.

TeenLifeMum · 07/08/2023 13:45

My grandmother is in a care home. She has mnd and needs specialist care. We do not have the skills and I work full time with 3 dc. We love granny dearly. She wants to stay near friends so I don’t visit much as it’s a 4 hour drive and will soon cost more due to ulez.

That aside, I don’t recognise the picture you paint as one I see around me. My dc and I are about to go on holiday with in laws then dc are spending a week with my parents while dh and I work, and my brother and his family just stayed with us over the weekend with dh’s brother staying with us in May.

my family is spread across the world but we make time for each other.

Clefable · 07/08/2023 13:44

Here where? Mumsnet? Britain?

I do think there's a weird cultural dichotomy and I said this on another thread the other day, where it seems to be frowned upon to offer financial help to your children when they are adults, but the thought of the tax man taking your money when you die is galling (even though this can often be avoided by, you know, giving financial help to your children). People seem to take pride in having a shitty struggle of a time because at least they didn't ask for help, when their parents are sitting on more money than they will ever spend. This is quite common with adults who have parents from the 'boomer' age, who are often quite well off and even bordering on rich, thanks to massive property gains, gold-plated pensions, etc.

There was a post on another thread where a poster said they were a single mum on the breadline and their dad was a millionaire and she'd never asked for or received help from him financially, which I think is incredibly sad and not my own experience of family or an ethos I want our family to have. If my kids are struggling at any point in their lives, I want them to tell me, and if I can help them then I will. I don't stop being their parent when they reach 18. My mum, who died recently, gave us some inheritance early (sadly not as early as it turned out, but at the time we didn't know that) and it allowed us to buy a much bigger house to start our family and also for me to work part-time with young DC. It's a gift I will never forget as it has made these years, and the rest of our lives, so much easier. I want to do that for my children, and am already planning how best to do that even though they are still at nursery age.

I don't want my children to feel obligated to help me or DH when I'm older and will hopefully have stuff in place to avoid that, but I would like to think I am bringing up children who are empathetic and are part of our family and who would probably want to be involved if there was no other choice (but as I say, I don't want them to be and will attempt to avoid this by leaving clear instructions and financial measures to allow my care to take place in a way that doesn't impact their day-to-day living).

I think it's sad when close family members who are in a comfortable position don't help out family members who are struggling, assuming the struggling isn't because of some sort of addiction or something where you are throwing money into a blah hole.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 07/08/2023 13:44

People are bound to post far more about problematical families than happy ones.
Who on earth ever posts to say all their family members are lovely, never a cross word? It just sounds smug and self satisfied and will very likely piss less fortunate people off. Or at least make them sad that they’re not so lucky.

Haretest · 07/08/2023 13:43

I agree OP. The amount of posters who seem to have only toxic parents/siblings/friends etc or are related to narcists and psychopaths. Seems more likely that many are dramatic and selfish.

I'm not talking about posters who have suffered horrible abuse, but those who seem to have issues with everyone in their lives.

WestwardHo1 · 07/08/2023 13:42

Also if a parent or sibling isn't a nice person, why should anyone be beholden to them and their bad behaviour?

WestwardHo1 · 07/08/2023 13:41

87to · 07/08/2023 13:10

That's it really

Nobody helps each other, siblings view siblings as unimportant and "not part of their life" mothers watch their offspring struggle.

That's it really.

I finally understand why old people get put in a care home.

My dad got "put in a care home" because he had severe Alzheimer's and my mum couldn't be his carer any more.

But judge away if you want.

AnneLovesGilbert · 07/08/2023 13:39

My mum has just come out of hospital, both my brothers came up to care for her, one brother’s gf of a year sat with her for hours while he was sorting practical things. I live the closest and have been juggling things around a baby and young child, I’ll step in when brothers go home. We love her, she’s supportive and wonderful and no one can do too much for her.

My husband’s family are horrible and no one wants to be around them.

People reap what they sew. No one is owed support by simple virtue of sharing genes.

whumpthereitis · 07/08/2023 13:39

A lot of people in collectivist societies are crippled by the weight of expectation placed upon them, and it is overwhelmingly women that are expected to sacrifice all in the name of ‘family’.

Personally I’m glad to live in societies where individuals are free to make their own choices.

87to · 07/08/2023 13:38

Fairyliz · 07/08/2023 13:34

You’ve clearly never experienced a parent with dementia. It’s a 24/7 job you literally cannot do anything else whilst caring for them, even going to the toilet is difficult.
Would you expect your child to sacrifice their life for you or would you prefer them to put you in a home where trained people can care for you?

I think that's an exception obviously And some people do want to go into care homes for community reasons, social etc

But I've worked in a care home many many many years ago and often spoke to elderly women and MEN that felt slighted their children wanted rid of them.

OP posts:
MrTiddlesTheCat · 07/08/2023 13:37

Not everyone is blessed with loving families. It's good that those who aren't are empowered to walk away rather than suffocate in the FOG.

87to · 07/08/2023 13:36

Xrays · 07/08/2023 13:19

I think there’s a move away from having to be nice to people and put up with them just because they’re related to you. And that’s a good thing. But it doesn’t mean no one cares about family in general or the concept of it.

I completely understand cutting off toxic family members. Nobody should have to take disrespect and toxic behaviour off anyone. I mean in general families you often witness a lack of warmth and everything is "me me me" and "nobody asked you"

I don't believe grandparents should be childminders out of obligation or expectation but I think not to offer a few hours babysitting once every few months or begrudge being asked a favour which doesn't inconvenience you is just weird.

I read that one mothers parent wouldn't even go get nappies for her own daughter? How sad is this.

I know children can take the piss and expect so much but generally there is a real coldness between families here (in the Uk and other countries like USA, west Europe)

OP posts:
C1N1C · 07/08/2023 13:36

DustyLee123 · 07/08/2023 13:16

If mothers are watching their offspring struggle, what are the fathers doing ?

Following on with your generalisations comment

The fathers have all been booted after their mum was convinced to leave from the red flag brigade on MN.

Seriously though, I have noticed this too. You go abroad to Asia, even Spain, and it's ALL family... but conversely, I'd also hate for the majority of my birthing to be down to having someone to look after my parents when they're older...

SpringViolet · 07/08/2023 13:36

I think it’s more common that most people who come from ‘normal’ (as in who love and care for each other which is a basic human need) families realise. I don’t think it’s anything new though just that now people actually talk it about through the medium of chat forums which is good as these families are so damaging and people carry a lot of misplaced shame and guilt that their families don’t love them.

My entire family cut me and my DC off completely just for challenging my narcissistic mother’s behaviour. I thought we were a ‘normal’ loving family but was in denial. I’m still in shock 10 years later and it does make me feel better that it’s not just me!

RhymesWithTangerine · 07/08/2023 13:34

Well, quite a lot of people want to come ‘here’ from places with stronger families that you’d approved of OP.

Quite a lot of people.

Fairyliz · 07/08/2023 13:34

You’ve clearly never experienced a parent with dementia. It’s a 24/7 job you literally cannot do anything else whilst caring for them, even going to the toilet is difficult.
Would you expect your child to sacrifice their life for you or would you prefer them to put you in a home where trained people can care for you?

Powaqa · 07/08/2023 13:33

I have noticed amongst my own friendship group that people are less inclined to put up with issues just because they are family
I am close with my parents but havent spoken to my brother for years - we have no relationship and I am happy with that
My DH is close to his parents but has no relationship with his brothers and his brother dont speak to each other either. He hasnt seen either of them for 14 - 15 years

Within my immediate family, both my grown up DC are extremely close and we all get on great

WeetabixTowels · 07/08/2023 13:31

So if not ‘here’ OP which country do you think we should be like? I dare you to find one where the burden of care for elderly family isn’t always on women, either daughters or daughters in law. I’ll wait.

TheNameIsDickDarlington · 07/08/2023 13:29

UltramarineViolet · 07/08/2023 13:19

What do you mean by 'here' - UK? Mumsnet? the area where you live?

It sounds like a big generalisation wherever you are referring to

I think the OP is talking about Mumsnet as I recognise the threads she's talking about.

Obviously on a forum like this people will be posting about things they're having difficulties with so it'll be mostly negative.

WaltzingWaters · 07/08/2023 13:27

Do you mean in the UK? That’s a huge generalisation.
I don’t personally know anybody who is no-contact with immediate family members, though I think it’s good when people do go no-contact with people who bring nothing good into their lives. And a lot of people just don’t have the resources to care for elderly parents when they have to continue working full-time so late in life with the cost of everything so care homes are needed.
Sure, some countries/cultures are incredibly generous with families and everyone living together, sharing childcare/elderly care etc. But sometimes that can also be toxic. I used to work with a couple of women from other countries who have been forced to give 90% of their wages to family and work non-stop having no life for themselves because their parents demanded it/it was expected of them.

RoseBucket · 07/08/2023 13:25

Yep and it shit, I have two estranged brothers and low contact with parents so my daughter has never had the big family events and Christmas, just me and her, I hope she marries into a huge big loving noisy family.

Soozikinzii · 07/08/2023 13:21

Actually yes I do know what you mean . Having been dropped by very close family so easily like a stone . You think why did I bother basically!

Sparklybutold · 07/08/2023 13:21

87to · 07/08/2023 13:10

That's it really

Nobody helps each other, siblings view siblings as unimportant and "not part of their life" mothers watch their offspring struggle.

That's it really.

I finally understand why old people get put in a care home.

I would kinda have to agree with this. Not all families are created equal. I am estranged from all my family. After year's of trying I finally stopped. No contact since. Although I know objectively it's for the best owing to dysfunction and abuse it still leaves a deep seated pain that I will forever be alone in this capacity. My husbands family are somewhat better but not close. His parents live close but are emotionally unavailable. It does hurt when I hear or see other families as it's just a reminder of how alone I am and everything falls on me. I have no backup.

UltramarineViolet · 07/08/2023 13:19

What do you mean by 'here' - UK? Mumsnet? the area where you live?

It sounds like a big generalisation wherever you are referring to

Xrays · 07/08/2023 13:19

I think there’s a move away from having to be nice to people and put up with them just because they’re related to you. And that’s a good thing. But it doesn’t mean no one cares about family in general or the concept of it.