Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Families are shit here?

106 replies

87to · 07/08/2023 13:10

That's it really

Nobody helps each other, siblings view siblings as unimportant and "not part of their life" mothers watch their offspring struggle.

That's it really.

I finally understand why old people get put in a care home.

OP posts:
Nn9011 · 07/08/2023 14:31

I think there's two main reasons for this one is a move away from religion which means a move away from community and that kind of community spirit and two people just don't have the time or money of it they used to because they're working all hours of the day paying ridiculous prices for everything and are just stressed to the max so trying to find time to see family or support them through situations is tough.
I think we have a massive issue with all the things that come with poverty as well - alcohol, drugs, abuse etc and that causes a breakdown within families as well.

So I don't think it's just as easy to say people no longer want families. I think it's true that families may be aren't the same as they were before, but I also think it's easy to look at things through rose tinted glasses because I don't think they were all that great many years ago too.

GnomeDePlume · 07/08/2023 14:31

Not everyone has an extended family mindset. I'm not close to my DBs. We aren't no contact just don't have a lot of contact. If there is contact it is initiated by me.

DBs and I have little in common other than we grew up in the same house. We have never asked favours of them.

Coachvikki · 07/08/2023 14:30

If by 'here' you mean mumsnet, yes I do think they are all horrible. It seems like every second story is about families not helping. No one is entitle to help, but surely being a family is offering the help that someone isn't entitled to?

WhatNoRaisins · 07/08/2023 14:29

On a practical level many of us don't live near our families and have to work. How much help am I going to be giving my parents when they live 4 hours away and I'm working full time?

I'm not NC with any family but when it comes to extended family we are so far apart and rarely see one another that they simply aren't relevant to my life. If I had to choose I'd prioritise close friends that I do have a meaningful relationship with.

WestwardHo1 · 07/08/2023 14:28

87to · 07/08/2023 14:17

Why is nobody getting that I'm clearly talking about elderly parents who reap what they sow?

It wasn't clear initially to be fair.

Now you've explained your position a bit more the OP makes mores sense.

Susuwatariandkodama · 07/08/2023 14:27

It’s very true for my family, when I fell pregnant I was told not to expect help, my child, my responsibility whereas my husbands family (who live abroad) would be happy to do absolutely anything to help us as family is everything to them and that goes for both mothers and fathers, they are one close knit unit and they always have these huge get togethers and they truly want to be in each others lives, it was really eye opening to me as my family just put up with each other.

Crimeismymiddlename · 07/08/2023 14:27

OP you are very judgemental. I am a bit of a crap child but my parents are really against us helping them in anyway. I do what I can. I know people who come from horrible familys who suddenly expect them to drop everything for them when they need care-why should they.
Also, the burden of caring for family members is on women, not men.

Loopylooni · 07/08/2023 14:23

Its a cultural thing. That's why you see so few asian elderly people in homes, the family always look after them somehow, regardless of behaviour. There is no right or wrong here.

However, on the flip side, i think asians tolerate too much because of all my friends, the one who id say has the most problematic relationship with her parents, still puts up/shuts up and sees them weekly to help them out. Also, more often than not in asian families, they do the babysitting as a given.

I think the west have more of a choice and decide whether it's for them/not for them hence you have the whole no contact thing or you have grand parents saying they want to do other things than look after their grandchildren. I doubt very much on all these threads about childcare, that many of the posters are asian. Again, its probably because asian grandparents see their lives as for the children, nothing more. Also a sad situation.

87to · 07/08/2023 14:22

LizzieSiddal · 07/08/2023 14:17

But I've worked in a care home many many many years ago and often spoke to elderly women and MEN that felt slighted their children wanted rid of them.

You only got their side of the story didn’t you? You are very niave.
My DH’s parents were emotionally and physically abusive to him as a child, his mother is still extremely manipulative, he’s been in Therapy for 10 years trying to come to terms with it all. If you met his parents you’d think they were lovely people but that’s because they don’t tell the truth.

Actually I fully understood. I'm not going to turn around to him and say "it's your fault" but in my head I'm fully aware it was probably his fault.

My own mother and father are narcissists and chose drugs and alcohol over me and my sisters.

Actually my mother text me this morning asking if I would lend her £50.
I said no.

I get it

OP posts:
elizzza · 07/08/2023 14:21

If you mean based on what you see on Mumsnet, that’s surely skewed by the situations that drive people to ask for advice. If someone posts about feeling unsupported by family or distant from their siblings, it wouldn’t be helpful for me to reply that my family are super supportive and my sister is my best friend. So you’re naturally not hearing about more positive situations.

What’s your real life experience? I don’t know anyone who is totally estranged from their family (or maybe I do, but not well enough that they’ve mentioned it to me) and among the people I know with young children it’s common that grandparents or siblings help out.

ManateeFair · 07/08/2023 14:20

87to · 07/08/2023 13:10

That's it really

Nobody helps each other, siblings view siblings as unimportant and "not part of their life" mothers watch their offspring struggle.

That's it really.

I finally understand why old people get put in a care home.

What a nasty, thoughtless post.

My dad lives in a care home. He lives in a care home because at 81 he has an advanced neurological disease, cannot walk without harming himself, cannot use the toilet, wash or bathe unaided, and has episodes of psychosis where he hallucinates and suffers paranoid delusions and lashes out at people or behaving in a way that endangers himself and others. My mother and one of my siblings were caring for him but my mother can't physically lift him and my sibling who lives there has to work for a living to support their own children. My other sibling and I live three hours away, also have to work full-time, and also can't lift my father. My mother, who is also 81, eventually had a nervous breakdown and she and my sibling were both physically ill from the stress and sleep deprivation of looking after my dad. A daily home visit from a nurse or careworker isn't suitable for my dad because he needs round-the-clock supervision and medication every couple of hours.

We were all absolutely fucking devastated to see my dad going into a care home. We all adore him. My mum has PTSD from the whole experience of having to go through that decision and process, and I still have regular nightmares. It wasn't a decision anyone wanted to make or took lightly. So honestly, take your sneering judgements and shove them up the orifice of your choice.

87to · 07/08/2023 14:19

If my children have to put me in a care home for any reason I hope they do. I wouldn't expect my children to make their lives harder especially the way the world is going!

But if they begrudge helping me do my shopping when I'm frail then I would think iv done something seriously wrong for them to discard me

OP posts:
LizzieSiddal · 07/08/2023 14:17

But I've worked in a care home many many many years ago and often spoke to elderly women and MEN that felt slighted their children wanted rid of them.

You only got their side of the story didn’t you? You are very niave.
My DH’s parents were emotionally and physically abusive to him as a child, his mother is still extremely manipulative, he’s been in Therapy for 10 years trying to come to terms with it all. If you met his parents you’d think they were lovely people but that’s because they don’t tell the truth.

87to · 07/08/2023 14:17

NOTANUM · 07/08/2023 14:13

I finally understand why old people get put in a care home.

That's a horrible thing to say. The vast majority of people in care homes have extreme needs, mostly dementia or high physical needs like entirely paralysed or can't walk at all, sometimes both.. Their families agonise over those decisions but it's literally more than 1 person can ever do alone well.

But you finally understand it in the same breadth as families not liking each other very much. That's pretty insensitive.

Why is nobody getting that I'm clearly talking about elderly parents who reap what they sow?

OP posts:
ASGIRC · 07/08/2023 14:17

ObiKenobi · 07/08/2023 13:54

Siblings can get very jealous of each other, & the death of both parents can break a family up completely. It’s quite rare for families to get on.

No its not. Most families I know get on well. Siblings dont have to be best friends, but that doesnt mean they dont get along.

As for the OP... I actually know several elderly people who put THEMSELVES into care homes. They come and go as they please (covid was a bitch for that), but know that there is someone to take care of them, as they dont actually have kids.
One family friend still maintains her house, and goes there for lunch most days, but sleeps in the home.

Most families I know help each other and get along... But if I had the money, Id probably put my parents in a care home, as I doubt Id be able to care for them, nor would they want me to.

NOTANUM · 07/08/2023 14:13

I finally understand why old people get put in a care home.

That's a horrible thing to say. The vast majority of people in care homes have extreme needs, mostly dementia or high physical needs like entirely paralysed or can't walk at all, sometimes both.. Their families agonise over those decisions but it's literally more than 1 person can ever do alone well.

But you finally understand it in the same breadth as families not liking each other very much. That's pretty insensitive.

Namechange666 · 07/08/2023 14:13

Not in my family...

MoserRothOrangeandAlmond · 07/08/2023 14:12

OP I think your missing the point that a lot of families only have 1-2 children. Therefore if parents become unwell or require care it all falls on one person. (And if your married to an only child that's x4 parents to 2 children to provide that care as well as look after young families)
People are having children later in life. Therefore grandparents are older.... some have multiple health issues and unable to provide care for grandchildren.
I've been nursing for 16 years... my grandad put on palliative care 15 years ago, has had Alzheimer's for 14 years and my mother is an only child.
He is in a care home as he cannot be left alone AT ALL, doesn't sleep during the night, incontinent, won't allow you or carers to assist with personal care!

I come across a lot of older people who are late 90s who complain they don't see their children very much.... when in fact their children are in their 70s with health problems... trying to support their children and grandchildren... stressed to the max!

What an awful post OP! You have no idea what people have to deal with!

ManateeFair · 07/08/2023 14:08

Annachristie · 07/08/2023 13:14

It's not everyone, but seems quite prevalent on here. There have been a few posts recently about non contact or low contact with siblings and mothers.
I don't know anyone in real life like this.

It's prevalent on here because it's a forum for people to share problems and dilemmas, so a lot of the posts about family relationships involve conflict or difficult situations. That's not indicative of the population are large (or even of most people who use this forum).

Most people have a perfectly good relationship with their immediate family, but obviously nobody needs to start a thread called "AIBU to get on really well with my siblings and see my parents regularly?" or "Had lunch with my brother on Sunday and we had a really nice time like we always do" so we tend to hear only from the people whose families are a massive pain in the arse.

backtogrey · 07/08/2023 14:06

87to · 07/08/2023 13:10

That's it really

Nobody helps each other, siblings view siblings as unimportant and "not part of their life" mothers watch their offspring struggle.

That's it really.

I finally understand why old people get put in a care home.

Not my experience but hey ho.

PutinSmellsPassItOn · 07/08/2023 14:06

I think you need to spend less time online Op.......how the hell do you know how the majority of other families function ?? Instead of basing your opinions by what you've read online why don't you spend time with actual people ??

MrsElsa · 07/08/2023 14:06

Well no one is coming on MN to say "my mum was so helpful today, so grateful for my family" are they?
The people posting are having a crisis or painful situation and looking for advice.

Same with marriages, people who are happily married to a supportive spouse aren't on here posting constantly about how wonderful their lives are

RattleRattle · 07/08/2023 14:05

This reply has been deleted

This user is a goady troll so we've removed their posts.

MillicentTrilbyHiggins · 07/08/2023 14:05

martinouo · 07/08/2023 14:02

From their updates, I think they're talking about white people

Now that's interesting. Because I know more non white people who are low/no contact with relatives.

Although my experience of care homes (have worked in them and visited friends in them) is that they are predominantly white people.

Dinopawus · 07/08/2023 14:05

You know the saying about walking a mile in someone's shoes before you judge them?

Do you really think it's OK to criticise people without knowing their circumstances?

I didn't dump my parent in a nursing home. I found a lovely, new home where she would be cared for. This was after her mental health went in to sharp decline, and she had started to wander unsteadily in the street in her nightie. I lived 2 hours away and had 3 children and a full time job. Should I have ignored the situation? Let her be attacked in the street or fall on her hard stone floor? I mean I could have saved 5 years of nursing home fees if I had let her die, but hey.