Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dangerous dog near miss?

294 replies

volcan · 06/08/2023 23:59

I feel l Iike we had a near miss today and I feel awful about it. DC (5) was cycling around a housing estate where I was visiting a friend when he disappeared off round a corner with a group of kids. It was away from the main road so I wasn't overly concerned but when they didn't appear around the next corner I walked over to investigate. What I found was a massive bully type dog walking alongside my DC whilst it's owner was frantically trying to get it back into the house. The owner being a petite young girl holding a tiny baby. The dog was totally ignoring her and carried on tracking my DS. I told my DS to slow down so the dog would stop 'chasing' him and we got back to the car safely. My heart was in my mouth and still is. When I asked my DS what had happened he said the dog has escaped and he was trying to catch it to help the woman. I know this has been done a million times but my AIBU is that people should be prosecuted for allowing these animals out in public uncontrolled?

OP posts:
CBAanymoreTBH · 10/08/2023 11:05

CleverLilViper · 10/08/2023 05:42

Why pit bulls are being mentioned on here I don’t know as they’re banned in the UK. They’re not bred for aggression, either.

They were originally known as nanny dogs. Great with kids. The trouble is, many
people who get hold of pit bulls, XL bullies, Rottweilers, etc either want a status symbol and to look hard or don’t have a fucking clue.

It’s not the breed. It’s the backyard breeders and shitty owners. There’s a lot more people now trying to raise awareness of this and attract good owners to the breeds.

You can’t blame the dog when they’ve been raised to be aggressive. Or poorly trained or under stimulated. This idea that a breed is intrinsically aggressive is ludicrous and removes all human responsibility.

For every attack by one of the feared breeds (and there seems to be a new one every month- feared breed that is) there’s one hundred dogs of the same breed that is perfectly lovely and well behaved. You don’t hear about that because it wouldn’t suit the narrative.

It’s also a little known fact that the media loves to report on dog attacks and then use images of a breed not involved in said attack. Anything to push the narrative as most people won’t read beyond the headline to find out.

i used to be terrified of staffies. A couple of them had attacked my childhood dog multiple times. Now I realise that the owner made the dogs that way. They wanted a status symbol and made them aggressive. Now I just feel sad for the dogs.

This nanny dog thing is completely false! Yes pit bulls most definitely were bred for aggression as well as "gameness" which means tenacity...not backing down basically

primoseyellow · 10/08/2023 08:34

@sashagabadon completely agree with this. Breed genetics and traits can be very strong.

Prescottdanni123 · 10/08/2023 08:29

@M4J4

I'm just saying, keep things in proportion. A lot of people on mumsnet thinks that anything that has four legs, fur and barks is a bloodthirsty monster. The amount of dog related injuries/deaths is very low when compared to a lot of other dangers. The amount of dogs that bite or attack someone every year is tiny compared to the anount that don't.

whowhatwerewhy · 10/08/2023 07:02

You sat in a pub garden next to what you perceive as a dangerous dog . If you thought the dog was that dangerous surely you take your child and leave .

BlastedIce · 10/08/2023 06:41

@volcan what was the near miss?

That you child completely out of your view wasn’t snatched, because you do know that happens don’t you?

Hibiscrubbed · 10/08/2023 06:39

volcan · 10/08/2023 05:09

As luck would have it we were sat tonight in a pub garden next to what looked the first dog's brother or sister. Almost definitely an XL Bully. Huge thing. Maybe a local breeder? It was leashed to a chair and barking intermittently at people passing. Not comfortable. DS instructed to stay at the table.

Media hype yes but this breed is hugely over represented in dog attacks/deaths. So is the hype not justified?

amp.theguardian.com/uk-news/2023/jun/04/american-bully-dog-breed-spotlight-uk-fatal-attacks

So not a pit bill then? Because they’re banned. But an American bull dog. Which are legal. That you just luckily managed to see again in the pub?

I think if the woman was panicked, it was because her dog had wandered out of the garden and because she was trying to manage that and a small baby. And maybe because your child was chasing him on his bike, and he may have chased him onto the road. Not because she thought he was about to go full Cujo.

BlastedIce · 10/08/2023 06:38

volcan · 10/08/2023 05:09

As luck would have it we were sat tonight in a pub garden next to what looked the first dog's brother or sister. Almost definitely an XL Bully. Huge thing. Maybe a local breeder? It was leashed to a chair and barking intermittently at people passing. Not comfortable. DS instructed to stay at the table.

Media hype yes but this breed is hugely over represented in dog attacks/deaths. So is the hype not justified?

amp.theguardian.com/uk-news/2023/jun/04/american-bully-dog-breed-spotlight-uk-fatal-attacks

Of course you were!

local breeder? Best you move then.

BlastedIce · 10/08/2023 06:36

volcan · 07/08/2023 00:33

OK I get it. My 5-year old should be locked up and the bike binned whilst the dangerous dog is allowed to roam around unsupervised.

It was t allowed to roam round unsupervised though, the owner was getting it back in!

BlastedIce · 10/08/2023 06:34

volcan · 07/08/2023 00:17

Child was nowhere near cars. And if the dog was just having a laugh why did it's owner look completely panicked? I think I'm capable of reading a situation.

You’re not at all capable of reading a situation!

Owner “frantically” trying to get it back was because it might run off and get run over perhaps, not that it would savage your child.

Total drama over absolutely nothing happening.

Also, your ridiculous remark, they shouldn’t be allowed out in public uncontrolled? Well it was a mistake, they happen, the dog got out and was being called back.

Peanutbutter11 · 10/08/2023 06:06

This reply has been withdrawn

The OP has privacy concerns, so we've agreed to take this down now.

M4J4 · 10/08/2023 06:05

Prescottdanni123 · 10/08/2023 06:03

@M4J4

30 million dogs live in the UK. There have been 10 deaths from dog attacks this year.

150,000 people die or are injured in road traffic accidents.

500,000 children are abused by their parents.

Why only mention deaths? A dog attack is traumatising even if you survive it and don’t die. And there are thousands of those.

Oatycookies · 10/08/2023 06:04

Boomboom22 · 07/08/2023 23:46

I find it racist to say dog racism and have reported that post.
The poster is implying that stereotypes about race are true but we should ignore them. When actually stereotypes are untrue and dangerous about race but very useful to categorise dogs.
Also dogs are not comparable to men / children / Karen's?? Which now means mass murderers apparently not middle aged women who complain/ cars.

This. Well said.

Prescottdanni123 · 10/08/2023 06:03

@M4J4

30 million dogs live in the UK. There have been 10 deaths from dog attacks this year.

150,000 people die or are injured in road traffic accidents.

500,000 children are abused by their parents.

M4J4 · 10/08/2023 06:02

Oatycookies · 10/08/2023 05:58

That’s awful…dogs really seem everywhere nowadays so I’ve taken to doing a quick scan for dogs when I enter a cafe or restaurant. If I see a dog, I’m out.

It’s so easy for this kind of thing to happen, a dog in a strange confined place surrounded by noise and strangers, including some who may accidentally walk to close if they’re eating etc

Hope the owners were caught on cctv

Yep, there’s always lots of bravado on these threads from dog owners and then they’re typically quiet when a child gets attacked by a strange dog.

Oatycookies · 10/08/2023 06:02

CBAanymoreTBH · 09/08/2023 20:37

How rare?

Current statistics

Admissions then dropped to 7,424 during Covid lockdowns in 2020/21 but they rose again to 2021/22 to 8,819 before hitting a record high of 9,366 between 2022/23.
Of those cases 3,743 victims required reconstructive surgeryy_, and the majority of those undergoing surgery were children.

Yes people forget most dogs don’t kill yes but there are many who attack as thousands attend NHS every year and there are many more minor bites where the family probably decides not to go to hospital in case it highlights they have a dangerous dog.

I haven’t had a man or woman lunge at me aggressively the past few years but I’ve had two dogs do so.

CleverLilViper · 10/08/2023 05:59

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Oatycookies · 10/08/2023 05:58

M4J4 · 10/08/2023 05:53

And here’s a 7yo attacked by a dog in a pub in Dorset, the cowardly dog owners fled before police arrived.

That’s awful…dogs really seem everywhere nowadays so I’ve taken to doing a quick scan for dogs when I enter a cafe or restaurant. If I see a dog, I’m out.

It’s so easy for this kind of thing to happen, a dog in a strange confined place surrounded by noise and strangers, including some who may accidentally walk to close if they’re eating etc

Hope the owners were caught on cctv

Oatycookies · 10/08/2023 05:55

volcan · 06/08/2023 23:59

I feel l Iike we had a near miss today and I feel awful about it. DC (5) was cycling around a housing estate where I was visiting a friend when he disappeared off round a corner with a group of kids. It was away from the main road so I wasn't overly concerned but when they didn't appear around the next corner I walked over to investigate. What I found was a massive bully type dog walking alongside my DC whilst it's owner was frantically trying to get it back into the house. The owner being a petite young girl holding a tiny baby. The dog was totally ignoring her and carried on tracking my DS. I told my DS to slow down so the dog would stop 'chasing' him and we got back to the car safely. My heart was in my mouth and still is. When I asked my DS what had happened he said the dog has escaped and he was trying to catch it to help the woman. I know this has been done a million times but my AIBU is that people should be prosecuted for allowing these animals out in public uncontrolled?

I think two things can be true, this dog was possibly not under control if it’s ignoring it’s owners commands to come back which is a problem and I’d hate to be on that street especially with a kid if when that happened.
I steer clear of dogs like that in fact I am wary of all dogs not on a leash and don’t think it should be allowed in most places.

However you also need to teach your child not to be chasing after any kind of dog. They are old enough to know better and if they don’t it’s time to teach them.

M4J4 · 10/08/2023 05:53

And here’s a 7yo attacked by a dog in a pub in Dorset, the cowardly dog owners fled before police arrived.

PuddlesPityParty · 10/08/2023 05:45

OP nothing happened! What is your actual point? Did this even happen, or is it just another dog bashing thread?

The woman was probably stressed and wanted to get her dog back in whilst your child was leading it away!!!! Take some responsibility for your own child.

People like you who PANIC at the first sign at a big dog and immediately jump to them being aggressive and horrible are honestly pathetic. Yes, be weary & sensible around them if you feel unsure but there’s no need to jump to making the situation seem catastrophic.

CleverLilViper · 10/08/2023 05:42

Why pit bulls are being mentioned on here I don’t know as they’re banned in the UK. They’re not bred for aggression, either.

They were originally known as nanny dogs. Great with kids. The trouble is, many
people who get hold of pit bulls, XL bullies, Rottweilers, etc either want a status symbol and to look hard or don’t have a fucking clue.

It’s not the breed. It’s the backyard breeders and shitty owners. There’s a lot more people now trying to raise awareness of this and attract good owners to the breeds.

You can’t blame the dog when they’ve been raised to be aggressive. Or poorly trained or under stimulated. This idea that a breed is intrinsically aggressive is ludicrous and removes all human responsibility.

For every attack by one of the feared breeds (and there seems to be a new one every month- feared breed that is) there’s one hundred dogs of the same breed that is perfectly lovely and well behaved. You don’t hear about that because it wouldn’t suit the narrative.

It’s also a little known fact that the media loves to report on dog attacks and then use images of a breed not involved in said attack. Anything to push the narrative as most people won’t read beyond the headline to find out.

i used to be terrified of staffies. A couple of them had attacked my childhood dog multiple times. Now I realise that the owner made the dogs that way. They wanted a status symbol and made them aggressive. Now I just feel sad for the dogs.

Prescottdanni123 · 10/08/2023 05:39

@CBAanymoreTBH

That is still less than the amount of people being attacked by other humans.

The vast majority of dog attacks are caused by dogs either being abused by humans or bred for aggression by humans so we are the real monsters in this situation really.

M4J4 · 10/08/2023 05:39

I would have been scared too, OP. Dangerous breeds can cause horrific damage. Here a 5yo in the US after a neighbour encouraged her to pet her dog.

SquashPenguin · 10/08/2023 05:33

I’d panic if my pug ran out the front door because I don’t want him being stolen. He got out once before and when I went after him he was stood with his head through the fence and school kids were taking selfies with him.

Was it actually an xl or just a staffy? There’s a big difference.

WiddlinDiddlin · 10/08/2023 05:32

I'd panic if one of my three was off lead on the street, because 1 is blind and food obsessed (steroids) so has zero brains, 2 is deaf when he picks up a scent with zero clue I am not still with him and 3 can move at about 9billionty miles an hour, will chase birds and butterflies and has 0 sense whatsoever.

None are aggressive to people, but 1 might trip you up as he can't see and 2 is a hefty twat who thinks the world wants to cuddle him so he will jump up should anyone speak to him and then he lets go all his muscles fully expecting the person to catch and cuddle him resulting in almost 30kg of dead weight against his unsuspecting victim. 3 would come no where near you, you are Unclean and To Be Shunned, she is far superior to any mere human. I'd actually be most panicked if she was loose and she's least likely to approach a human or bite anyone (she might invite your child to join her on a journey then sell them to the faerie folk, she is a treacherous bitch!)

Whilst we do train in the street (if you only train in the park or field or dog club then you get a dog who only behaves in those places), we don't do it anywhere near as much as anywhere else and they'd only be there via some sort of accident which means increased stress, decreased listening/compliance in most dogs.

So yes, I would sound panicked.

In practical common sense land - avoid walking there with your child ahead of you and not under your control.
Find out where the dog lives and make a complaint that their dog was out of control in a public place to dog warden/police.
Teach your kid NEVER to touch strange dogs - not 'ask the owner' because frankly, there are a ton of owners out there who will say yes with NO idea if their dog is safe or happy about it at all. Teach kids NEVER to touch, not to even ask, touching other peoples dogs outside of family is not a thing.

S'gonna be a long old childhood if you're going to count all the things that didn't even nearly happen as 'near misses' though!