Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does your car show your status?!

244 replies

Dibbydoos · 06/08/2023 23:10

I was a BMW X3 for 7 years - a prowling beast of a thing, fast like heckers! I loved that car! But it's now retired and I didn't want another big SUV, so I bought from the same stable, a Mini Countryman and everyone is giving me stick! I keep getting with your money you could afford better etc etc.

It's jarring.

I blinking love this Mini. It drives like my BMW even the general controls - cruise, nav, wipers are the same.

Why are people so fixated on spending more money than you need?

Am I being unreasonable to not waste money on a flash car?

OP posts:
RiverWye · 07/08/2023 07:47

I'm 'retired' aged 37, have £100k in savings and live in a property worth 1mil, and own another property. I'm very lucky and doing well.

I drive a 66 plate Fiesta. I don't own any brand clothing, I use a cheap android phone, I'm not in the least bit motivated to buy things that make me look a certain way...I like the fact I just blend in and would hate people to think 'she's got money'.

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 07/08/2023 07:47

I love my car, it’s honestly the best car in the world and I feel bad for all those people driving around in what they think are their high status cars. They don’t know what they’re missing…..

my 10 year old i10 is everything you could want in a car. Cheap to run, reliable, easy to park, weirdly spacious.

imagine thinking you need to try and squeeze an enormous Range Rover into parking spaces to look good, when really you’d look so much better in a beaten up old i10.

Dragonwindow · 07/08/2023 07:44

I bought my boring car 10 years ago, when it was already 8 years old. I drive boringly, and it's still in very good nick. I cannot tell you the smug joy it brings me knowing that other people in a car park have spent tens of thousands of pounds on a vehicle that gets them from the same point A to the same point B as mine does.

LookItsMeAgain · 07/08/2023 07:40

I genuinely thought this was going to be about a feature on a new car that linked in with Facebook to show your status somewhere on the vehicle.

Bit disappointed now.

Timeturnerplease · 07/08/2023 07:38

Well, my car definitely says ‘teacher with two small children, no money and no time to clean the car’.

So yes, I suppose it is indicative of my status.

HaveYouHeardOfARoadAtlas · 07/08/2023 07:37

I find car brands odd. But I have no interest in cars other than a practical purpose and looking at reliability reviews. So I’ve mainly had Fords. Oddly enough I now drive a Vauxhall which isn’t great on reliability reviews but for me has been fine. When I wanted a diesel, automatic estate with AppleCar then my options were limited.

I could afford a bmw or an Audi but I just don’t see the point. I’m a member at an upmarket gym and the car park is full of range rovers, teslas, bmw and Audi and I rock up in my Astra lowering the tone. 😁

RampantIvy · 07/08/2023 07:31

PimpMyFridge · 06/08/2023 23:22

Sounds like having visible indications of wealth are important to the people making those comments.
Loads of people don't live this way though.
I know wealthy people who feel zero need to make sure their car advertises their financial health.
Plenty of people just view a car as a means to get about.
People who see cars as a way to show they're are doing well financially also exist as you know.
Personally, I think anyone who leans on someone else for doing things differently to how they do/would u are often insecure, certainly closed minded and just tiresome.

Well said.
My car is 10 years old and DH's is 8 years old. Both have been very reliable. I have just spent a four figure sum on my car to replace something that needed replacing before it failed and would have caused a much more expensive repair job had I not done so. So I am keeping mine for another year.

DD's ex's parents replace their much more expensive cars every two years and couldn't understand why we drive such old cars.

I don't understand why a car needs to be replaced so often. I don't view cars as status symbols. I just want something that is reliable, can get me from A to B without any hassle and can cope with our hills in the snow. In my case a 4WD is a necessity not something to brag about.

Myotherdogsanoodle · 07/08/2023 07:22

You should see all the Rolls Royces near me. The shock is, I live in what some would call a ‘third world’ country!

gogomoto · 07/08/2023 07:21

I thought minis were status cars these days!

No I have a 6 year old car, dp a 20 year old car, could easily afford 2 brand new German but I don't waste money on status symbols, if it goes it goes. Right now only interest is saving to retire!

Allhailkingcharlie · 07/08/2023 07:19

Well I've had a bloke laugh at me for my husbands choice of car last week and then someone else take the p out of my make of car by someone else. But we're ok financially. Better off than the one who laughed at my husbands car. So the answer is probably no!

Philandbill · 07/08/2023 07:18

Zanatdy · 07/08/2023 07:07

I’ve never bought into the flash car / status symbol thing. For me a car needs to get me from A-B and I don’t care what it is. Most of the people driving expensive cars have them on hire and pay ridiculous amounts. Friend of mine’s DH pays £700 a month, for a car. I find that unbelievable when he won’t ever own it either. It’s purley a ‘look at me’ - keeping up with the Jones thing. As I say, don’t buy into it and I really couldn’t care less what people think about the car I drive based on my salary

This 100%. But then I would say that as I own an old car. It gets me from A to B, is comfortable to drive and be a passenger in and I own it outright. I'm not spending lots of money in interest on a car loan or paying a fortune to a leasing company each month. I really don't care what other people think, too old for that rubbish.

InSpainTheRain · 07/08/2023 07:16

I don't know about showing my "status" but my Qashqai which I bloody love definitely says "Mum with 2 kids doing Uni drop offs". I love it - I can get everything in it, it's great for picnics, camping gear, a run to the recyling centre, any shopping. So YANBU.

Downdownunder · 07/08/2023 07:11

In my part of the country it is a badge of honour for the wealthy to drive beaten up old cars. Flash new cars are looked down upon.
Needless to say it is not the Home Counties!

Zanatdy · 07/08/2023 07:07

I’ve never bought into the flash car / status symbol thing. For me a car needs to get me from A-B and I don’t care what it is. Most of the people driving expensive cars have them on hire and pay ridiculous amounts. Friend of mine’s DH pays £700 a month, for a car. I find that unbelievable when he won’t ever own it either. It’s purley a ‘look at me’ - keeping up with the Jones thing. As I say, don’t buy into it and I really couldn’t care less what people think about the car I drive based on my salary

CurlewKate · 07/08/2023 07:02

Mine did until recently. It showed me to be a middleaged middle class countrywoman with dogs and horses. I'm like a Jilly Cooper parody! I drove a very old, very dirty dark green Subaru Forrester with a tow bar.

ObiKenobi · 07/08/2023 06:58

Nothing wrong with the mini its a classic. Plus many chaves have SUVs these days. So for some a big car will be the only thing that they have, along with the tracksuit.

Kaibashira · 07/08/2023 06:51

I can't drive (because of peripheral vision issues before anyone has a go) so ignore car = status, then I guess mine is zero?

I guess I just don't pay attention but, my God, agonising over car model? Having your kids chime in on what you "should" be driving? Cars not "matching up" to houses? I'm glad I'm no part of this extra life stress!

Freshair1 · 07/08/2023 06:44

I find it quite liberating to have my little car when surrounded by massive, boasty Range Rovers. I don't understand the need to upgrade or buy the biggest/best. I mean. I like my money where I can see it, in my house.

WaitingfortheTardis · 07/08/2023 06:38

DH is in London fairly regularly for work, we've had to replace his car because otherwise he'd have to pay the ULEZ fine. We've been called boring as it's just a VW with none of the added frills, but it's got a great safety score and the price was sensible and the best deal we could get when looking. My car is 15 years old and starting to struggle so I'll have his old one as it's still going strong. If anything I'm more interested in what colour cars are than whether they are a fancy or not brand!

Aquestioningmind · 07/08/2023 06:19

It depends why you’ve got the ‘flash car’ doesn’t it?

I work in London but live in rural East Sussex and need a 4x4 to get anywhere in winter (icy country lanes, hills etc). Neighbours were snowed in for a week Christmas just gone as they only have small cars.

I constantly get stick about having a ‘flash car’ as all my colleagues have ford fiestas or polos, but they seem to miss the part where, if I didn’t have the ‘flash Volvo’ I’d be stranded whenever it was icy or snowy. So having a good 4x4 when I live in a small semi makes sense…

So, YABU. Equally, YANBU as lots of people have the same car as me and live in places where they definitely do need it…looking at you Sevenoaks!

Mutabiliss · 07/08/2023 06:12

No-one has ever commented on the car I drive 😳 I can't imagine why they would. It's a 10 year old Focus, does the job, that's all I require. I dread it dying, it's much nicer to drive than our old car.

I hate the massive cars you get nowadays, no idea why anyone needs anything so big. They make it difficult to park and you can't see around them.

WandaWonder · 07/08/2023 06:01

It does I presume, it shows our love of invisibility gadgets as we don't have one, no idea what that shows really

Poppysmom22 · 07/08/2023 05:48

There's certainly a mindset that says fancy car =successful but people measure success in different ways. My car looks like what it is - a tool for transporting people animals and stuff from place to place. Is it clean nope is it smelly yep. I honestly don't have time for anyone who looks at something so extraneous and uses it to measure my worth as a human being.

Lilpop90 · 07/08/2023 02:43

SabrinaThwaite · 07/08/2023 02:31

I can see that the OP said they loved the X3 but didn’t need something that big. Ironically, the X3 isn’t massively bigger than a Countryman when you look at dimensions.

From the OP they think that the X3 gave them status whereas the Mini doesn’t.

An X3 is not a status car. It’s not really cost effective to retire the X3 for an expensive lease deal that her family tells her is not a status car either.

If OP likes the Mini then great. Tell the family to do one.

But I’d still think that OP is wasting money on a lease deal. Better the devil you know.

But as you say, people can spend their money however they want.

Totally agree with all of what you’ve said!

Sodullincomparison · 07/08/2023 02:42

our car alarms have gone off four times in the last half hour at the side of the house so I’m very happy for DHms posh car and it’s cameras right now. Less so for the very loud alarm music which will have just woken all our neighbours.