Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does your car show your status?!

244 replies

Dibbydoos · 06/08/2023 23:10

I was a BMW X3 for 7 years - a prowling beast of a thing, fast like heckers! I loved that car! But it's now retired and I didn't want another big SUV, so I bought from the same stable, a Mini Countryman and everyone is giving me stick! I keep getting with your money you could afford better etc etc.

It's jarring.

I blinking love this Mini. It drives like my BMW even the general controls - cruise, nav, wipers are the same.

Why are people so fixated on spending more money than you need?

Am I being unreasonable to not waste money on a flash car?

OP posts:
Sloth66 · 07/08/2023 14:42

My car is 20, it drives well and is reliable.
now I wfh I don’t use it much, I’ll keep it till it fails in a major way..

Sigmama · 07/08/2023 14:01

Thats me then, I judge townies in 4w drives

Droppit · 07/08/2023 13:43

People who judge you on the car you drive or the house in which you live are generally twats IMO.

Sigmama · 07/08/2023 13:39

The number of motors on the U.K's roads have been allowed to double - to 41 million - in 30 years.

60% of all U.K journeys between 1-2km are taken by car.

Almost 20% of journeys under 1km are also driven.

This obsession with cars is a bit much

countdowntonap · 07/08/2023 13:30

I’ve been driving for 19 years, and I’m still on my third car! A Micra, Jazz (have to admit this didn’t feel cool in my mid-20s 🤣) and a small Mazda now. In total, have paid £12,000 for these cars - the Micra was written off after a bump and I got £1000 for it to put towards the Jazz.
If I’d had even just a budget car (£250?) on finance over that period it would have cost £57000! Never mind how much a stays car would cost.

We’re both high earners, both drive bangers, and both don’t give a hoot!

dottiedodah · 07/08/2023 13:04

I love my old banger! Really easy to drive .Was pissed off as an idiot called out "Nice Car love" I just laughed my friend is the same!

MissDollyMix · 07/08/2023 12:56

'Not playing the game'

I think is an excellent quote from a pp and summarises how I feel about driving my old banger.

francesthebadger · 07/08/2023 12:56

I don't feel very charitable towards 'trophy' 4x4s purchased as city runabouts. Not good for the environment or pedestrian safety. If your need for conspicuous consumption overrides these considerations, well...

DatumTarum · 07/08/2023 12:55

This is the real reason so many drivers hate cyclists, isn't it?

Because we're not playing this game

Grin
Thatboymum · 07/08/2023 12:44

It deffo doesn’t give a true reflection on who you are no , I have a big sporty brand new 4x4 but only because I like cars and that’s more important to me than a big fancy house. I have a lovely home but wouldn’t be seen as what others would assume I lived in based on my car. If I didn’t have my car we could have a big house but I don’t want that

Bluevelvetsofa · 07/08/2023 12:42

There’s a reverse snobbery about much of this, as though it’s a competition to claim who has the most money and the least status car.

People are allowed to spend their money on what they choose. For some, that might be a lease or PCP car, for others, it might be what I would regard as expensive holidays, or costly golf equipment, or cycling, or any of the other things that people spend their disposable income on.

Someone might choose a 4x4 for reasons we don’t know. My neighbour has one because it’s high up and better for her bad back to get in and out of. I choose cars for comfort and convenience. They have some of the bells and whistles, because they make driving easier and more comfortable.

honeylulu · 07/08/2023 12:30

Sigmama · 07/08/2023 12:18

Honeylulu if you only need a car for local short trips, do you need a car?

Good point and I could probably just about manage (it's the second car) but it's really the time I save. I work long hours and need the car to get to after school club pick up etc. I could walk but if have to find an extra hour I don't have. I suppose I could do some work over the weekend to make up the lost hours but I dunt really want to.

Then at weekends I often end up having to drop two different kids at two different activities at different ends of town and pick up again two hours later. And it was a godsend when eldest was learning to drive as the practice was so valuable and no way we'd have been able to get him insured on his dad's bigger car.

So do I really "need" a car? Possibly not. But we all have to go without stuff that we enjoy.

Sigmama · 07/08/2023 12:28

Onefinemess, must be pretty remote if you've never sat in a traffic jam

Peacelily001 · 07/08/2023 12:25

My aunt is worth serious money, millions.
She no longer drives due to ill health, but when she did she had an old Ford Fiesta with wind up windows (and plenty of dents)
She saw cars as being something to get her from A to B and had no interest in ‘status’ vehicles at all.

Ponoka7 · 07/08/2023 12:21

My son in law's family meet up has a lot of "what are you driving these days?" In a very snobby way. My DD had, had enough after nearly two hours if bullshit oneupmanship, so started singing ' I drive a combined harvester'. They go for practical estates, Volvo /VW, but second hand, they go on hikes with their dogs. They but to suit their needs.

Bideshi · 07/08/2023 12:21

ReginaRegina · 07/08/2023 00:36

I think that's just a mumsnet trope tbh. Working for a construction company I see a lot of big expensive houses and there's usually a BMW or two on the drive and a sports car in the garage. Sometimes they will be driving an old jag or land rover though tbf.

Yes but big expensive house doesn't equate with old country estates of which there are plenty in these parts. I find, on a quick riffle through the ones I know that the cars are either:
Old Landrover Defender, especially if the estate runs shoots or has enough land for an estate manager. Or-
Something decent and generic but often bought in bulk.ie - one family I know has several VWs of various sizes used according to need (estate car if the dogs are going) and to what's available. Nanny and kids are expected to take the smaller cars.Or-
Anything that happens to come their way. Usually something cheapish and anonymous, usually mid-range, seldom anything considered high-end.

The richest person I've ever known- I mean seriously rich - had a 14 year old Golf. When it was stolen he didn't bother to replace it. Just cycles or takes Ubers and hires for longer journeys.
So no, I don't think cars are an indicator of status although there is an element of reverse snobbery sometimes. Old country money (at least in these parts) doesn't like to be seen to try too hard.

onefinemess · 07/08/2023 12:21

Sigmama · 07/08/2023 12:06

Onefinemess - a place where you sit for hours in traffic jams belching noxious fumes into the atmosphere

Maybe where you live. And I couldn't give a stuff about "the environment". You can freeze in your Air Pump chilled home and get soaked as you cycle to work, all while conveniently ignoring the greenwashing related to electric vehicles and the double standards of people who have children lecturing others on "climate change".

I'll continue to sit in my 2l, turbo charged, all fossil fueled SUV. At least I'll be warm and dry.

PTSDBarbiegirl · 07/08/2023 12:19

IME people who display their desperation to be seen as part of a certain social class are usually just aspirational and not really from the class they want to be aligned with. We have a classic car which doesn't requite tax or mot and one of the other cars is a limited edition type thing that enthusiasts would be impressed with but nobody else including me but it's very well looked after by my extreme petrol head DH.

Sigmama · 07/08/2023 12:18

Honeylulu if you only need a car for local short trips, do you need a car?

FarmGirl78 · 07/08/2023 12:16

PickAChew · 06/08/2023 23:34

A mini countryman is pretty expensive for what it is, anyhow, isn't it? It's hardly a bargain basement option.

This!!

Very "let them eat cake".

onefinemess · 07/08/2023 12:15

ErrolTheDragon · 07/08/2023 11:57

Nah. I may remember a few things that happened in a car but unlikely to remember which one.

Then you need to live a more exciting life.

honeylulu · 07/08/2023 12:14

No, my car doesn't reflect my status and I don't give a shit. I think it's quite funny how much tossers who think cars confer status must underestimate me driving around in my small, very basic, 10 year old runaround!

I'm not interested in cars except as a convenient mode of transport. My car is great for exactly what I need it for and mega cheap to run (and easy to park in small spaces!) I also let my 18 year old son drive it as I'm not bothered if it gets the odd ding or scrape. I commute to London by train so I only really need my car for local short trips.

I earn 120k and no one would ever guess from my car. We also have a nice but not huge/flash house because we prefer to be mortgage free. Giving the impression of being modest earners is very useful. We've found if people think we're comfortably off they expect us to pay for everything. Er, no thanks!

Myfavouritecolourisanimalprint · 07/08/2023 12:12

I work in an area where many of the local population have multiple expensive German cars with personalised number plates parked outside £70k houses, which is the most ridiculous display of 'status' I have ever seen. Each to their own, but if I had the money for a new Audi, I would put it towards moving to a better area instead

Sigmama · 07/08/2023 12:10

The sooner we move away from private car ownership the better

DyslexicPoster · 07/08/2023 12:08

I have a 7 seater so that says everything you need to know about me. Also live in a village where every second person seems to have a Tesla. My next car I want is a old XF. Always wanted a XJS but they seem to have shot up in price recently. I'd never spend mad money on a car even if I was loaded. They depreciate too fast

Swipe left for the next trending thread