Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you leave a partner who's not ready for marriage after 4 years?

90 replies

Isthebusstillrunning · 06/08/2023 21:22

Don't want to give away too much specific info but if your partner is 29, you are 32, and together for approx 4 years. He wasn't ready after 3 years, and now after 4 years hasn't proposed/said he wants a child at this time, regardless of the reasons.
Would you at this point call it quits or is it still too early in the relationship/him too 'young"?

OP posts:
uncomfortablydumb53 · 07/08/2023 00:53

If he hasn't committed to you in 4 years, it seems unlikely he will, even if he says he wants to
Have a serious chat where you put your cards on the table
Set a deadline( in your mind only
If no progress Walk

CKL987 · 07/08/2023 00:05

You don't say what conversations you have had with him? It reads as if he has said nothing but how much have you discussed it with him?

Personally, the marriage thing wouldn't bother me because (ignoring the financial security aspect MN users go on about) I find the need to sign a piece of paper to confirm your love and commitment weird. The children thing is a different matter though. If he hasn't committed to it at some point then yes leave but if he just isn't ready not then I wouldn't necessarily.

Nousername94 · 06/08/2023 23:29

No I wouldn’t but I don’t care about getting married

MammaTill2Pojkar · 06/08/2023 23:26

Depends on reasons why. My OH proposed around 6 months after we started dating but we didn't actually get married until about 6/7 years after we started dating, this was mostly spurred by my dad becoming very ill and me wanting to be able to tell him (my dad) that we were finally going to get married so that he at least knew about it before he potentially died (which he did). Getting married in a hurry was not a big concern for us otherwise, but then he had at least proposed early on...

With having children, we discussed and agreed early on that we both wanted children eventually, I ideally wanted to have them between the ages of 25-30 but my husband was never ready back then and I did agree with his reasons re finances, living situation (him being at uni, us not bringing in much money, moving around a lot, chasing job contracts, not having a permanent job and such), in the end when I turned 30 we were finally in a more secure financial situation and I kind of put my foot down, said I had already put off my plans re children for 5 years to support him and we were in the best situation work wise/housing wise that we had ever been in so it was time to try for a baby. He agreed, but technically from first starting dating to actually trying to conceive we waited about 11 years. I am an older mother than I ideally wanted to be, but I have my 2 children I always wanted and am overall happy and agree that doing it earlier likely would not have worked out for us. So it does depend on the reasons he gives, is there any truth or validity to them or does he just say he doesn't want to yet and nothing more, if it's the latter then yes I would be thinking about whether I wanted to stay with him or not.

However, we had more time on our side as we got together at around age 20, I can imagine the biological clock feeling you might be feeling as I felt it around age 30. I would probably be talking ultimatums with my OH if we had got to me being age 32 and still not agreed to start TTC yet. I think when I did put my foot down at age 30 my husband was still not really ready, still felt trepidation about TTC, he ultimately agreed but I wonder if men just don't feel the same pressure and worries or are more likely to just never feel truly ready.

DarkSpark · 06/08/2023 23:18

I have a close friend who met her ex partner around the same time as I met DH. He eventually moved in with her after 2 years under duress, 4 years after that he switched from saying he just wasn't ready for marriage and children yet to wasn't sure he'd ever be ready or want that. My friend had always been clear that those were things that were important to her long term. She ended it.
He moved on to another (younger) woman and did the same routine, 8 years later he's knocking on the door of 40 and still not 'ready'.
If both partners go in fully in agreement that they aren't interested in marriage and/or are happy to be childfree then great. In this situation I wouldn't waste my time dragging someone along who wasn't invested in the same things I am and trying to persuade him to want to marry me.

fullbloom87 · 06/08/2023 23:11

Isthebusstillrunning · 06/08/2023 21:53

I hate how we infantalise (if that's a word) men these days. Any man under 30 is supposed to be given a free pass for being devoid of any sort of commitment or responsibility, because he's 'only 29' bless him.
It's hardly 18/19.
Why do we do this?

I wasn't infantilising him. I'm saying you've been with him for just 4 years, you are older and more ready then him to settle down and do the family thing. There are high expectations these days for standards of living. A man can't just get a job down the coal mines and raise a family of 6 kids anymore. They're expected to have the perfect house, car, fancy job etc
Maybe he's waiting until he's at the right point financially, which might not be yet.
It's up to you if you want to chuck away the last 4 years or give him a bit more time and if you're worried about getting too old, it might take another 2+ years to find the right man and you might even go through this a 2nd time and be even older by then.

Callyem · 06/08/2023 23:10

Id weigh up whether they just didn't want the faff yet but certainly saw their future married to me, or if they were not proposing because they were not entirely sure and keeping their options open. If I felt it was the latter, I'd leave.

justasking111 · 06/08/2023 23:06

Both my DILs were very smart had their own homes and didn't live together until they got engaged and planning the wedding. The weddings were within a year and they started families straight away.

I don't think either of my sons feet touched the ground, they were smitten very quickly.

Tanfastic · 06/08/2023 23:04

Isthebusstillrunning · 06/08/2023 21:50

Lived together for 3 years.
I suppose the answer is simply that he doesn't want it with me/doesn't love me enough, no?
Thanks for all your answers.

As hard as this sounds, maybe he's not sure about you.

I definitely think this was the case with me, he just wasn't as into me as I was to him. He didn't even seem that upset when I ended it tbh which confirmed it for me. I was devastated though.

Olika · 06/08/2023 23:03

In my opinion you should have a chat with him. Then you know what his timeline is in comparison to yours and what guy do next. As you are 32 I wouldn't wait too much longer to start trying for a baby if that's what you want.

Tanfastic · 06/08/2023 23:02

I did this, together for five years but I was a bit younger than you, I was 28 when I ended it. I could never see him settling down with me and I wanted kids and he was non committal
About anything even living together.

Took me another 4 years before I met my husband at 32, married two years later, child a year after that at 35. so I'm glad I came out when I did.

RuthTopp · 06/08/2023 23:00

My friend had her first baby at age 37 , and I started my menopause around age 38/39 .
You really don't know what your fertility is , if your feeling like you are ready to try to conceive and he isn't , or if it's important to you to be married before you do , then probably it's time you got rid of him and find someone who is aligned with you.

WorryWorryWort · 06/08/2023 22:59

3 years in he needs to give you an indication of his intentions or thoughts regarding marriage and children if they are important to you.

It also means you dont hang about coyly waiting for a romantic proposal you need to insist on a direct conversation and commitment to timelines so you know where you stand and can make an informed decision.

justasking111 · 06/08/2023 22:59

Mari9999 · 06/08/2023 22:57

@Isthebusstillrunning
I don't think that we infantalize men so much as we encourage fantasies in little girls. Have you ever heard a little boy, preteen, teenage, or young adult man talk about his fantasy wedding? At most a teenager may say he expects to marry a "hot girl."

Little girls from early stages on will talk about the wedding that they want to have someday. Some will actually have pretend weddings. It is heart breaking to hear an adult female saying " since I was a little girl , I have dreamed of my wedding. ". To bad that we don't encourage them to say ," since I was a little girl I dreamed of becoming a doctor or an engineer. "

For many men, I think living together is much like an internship. They get to decide that this is not the job that they want or they may want the job but not with this company. Women on the otherhand tend to feel that having invested time into this internship that they are owed a job offer. Many women will feel entitled to the job offer even if the internship has been a less than positive experience.

Both parties should feel free to move at their own speed, and should feel free to walk away without pressure or acrimony if things are not moving at a pace that works for them.

Perfect analogy 😂

Mari9999 · 06/08/2023 22:57

@Isthebusstillrunning
I don't think that we infantalize men so much as we encourage fantasies in little girls. Have you ever heard a little boy, preteen, teenage, or young adult man talk about his fantasy wedding? At most a teenager may say he expects to marry a "hot girl."

Little girls from early stages on will talk about the wedding that they want to have someday. Some will actually have pretend weddings. It is heart breaking to hear an adult female saying " since I was a little girl , I have dreamed of my wedding. ". To bad that we don't encourage them to say ," since I was a little girl I dreamed of becoming a doctor or an engineer. "

For many men, I think living together is much like an internship. They get to decide that this is not the job that they want or they may want the job but not with this company. Women on the otherhand tend to feel that having invested time into this internship that they are owed a job offer. Many women will feel entitled to the job offer even if the internship has been a less than positive experience.

Both parties should feel free to move at their own speed, and should feel free to walk away without pressure or acrimony if things are not moving at a pace that works for them.

caringcarer · 06/08/2023 22:55

My DD lived with her partner for 5 1/2 years before her partner proposed. They wanted to buy their house first so they saved hard for a deposit. Then after engagement they saved for 2 years for their wedding and honeymoon. 2 years later my DD got pregnant which was planned. 3 years later 2nd DC also planned. Do 7 1/2 years together before marriage. They were both on agreement though.

MrsElsa · 06/08/2023 22:54

In future set a time limit !! 18 months to propose and set a wedding date or ty next.

Co habiting isn't a great idea unless def "the one", marriage on the cards. Yeah it's considered normal these days but it doesn't work in women's favour. Plenty of threads on that

Totalwasteofpaper · 06/08/2023 22:52

User37652 · 06/08/2023 22:18

Yes I would leave. I was given a piece of advice - if he hasn’t proposed/committed within 18 months then you are not ‘the one’ for him. Now this doesn't mean that he won’t marry you in the end, he may get to the point that he can’t be bothered to look for anyone else, realise no one else wants him, he’s settled enough and may propose in the end but you were not his ideal. Men know very quickly if they want to marry you and if they don’t know then they don’t want to. I put this to the test and found the love of my life, we were discussing marriage and a family very early on and he proposed at 17 months in the most beautiful way. Don’t settle for any less than you deserve and remember you are fantastic and deserve someone who worships you.

I really dislike admitting it as it feels so anti - feminst / unmodern / i dont know

But this is my experience based on friends / people i know.
The guys who were decisive and keen to "lock it in" because they couldnt believe their luck that they found someone so amazing are the ones who have strong marriages and are good husbands / fathers.
The ones who were talked into it or did it after yearsssss of heel dragging are disappointly true to form (even the ones that seemed like good eggs) in thinking their wives careers should be deprioritised / sleeping in diff rooms when they have a newborn so they can work the next day / generally shirking responsibility.

VeniVidiWeeWee · 06/08/2023 22:48

Isthebusstillrunning · 06/08/2023 21:53

I hate how we infantalise (if that's a word) men these days. Any man under 30 is supposed to be given a free pass for being devoid of any sort of commitment or responsibility, because he's 'only 29' bless him.
It's hardly 18/19.
Why do we do this?

This is a load of bollocks.

What discussion did you have with him when you decided to live together?

I was very clear with my partner that I did not want children.

We are still together 40+ years later.

LocalHobo · 06/08/2023 22:42

Do you want to be with him forever i.e. marriage?
Do you only want DC with this particular man?
Would you only have DC within a marriage?
Do you want a child ? Not to bothered if it is with him or someone else.
Four totally separate questions. The answers will tell you if you should walk away.

Idrankyourbananamilk · 06/08/2023 22:40

In my experience men know if they want to commit and they do it. Especially if there is a risk they will lose a woman they love. They are usually pretty keen about the kids thing too, if they want them.

et12 · 06/08/2023 22:37

As others have said, it depends what's most important to you.

When I was 31 I asked my then boyfriend what his intentions were (we'd been together roughly 3 years and were living together) and he said he was happy with how things were.

It honestly didn't occur to me to leave him. I guess I valued being with him on whatever terms over getting married, etc. But it would be totally legitimate to feel the opposite, especially if you want children and you're not sure if he does. If something is important to you, you deserve clarity on whether he wants it too.

Fwiw, it took him another 3 years to propose. We've now been happily married 6 years and have two children.

CantThinkOfANameAtAll · 06/08/2023 22:34

If he knows marriage, and children within that marriage, is important to you but won't commit then it's time to move on and find someone who feels the same as you. You might end up resenting him for not marrying you if you continue the relationship for several more years which will surely kill it anyway.

Burningthroughthesky · 06/08/2023 22:31

Have you talked about this with him?

ChristmasCrumpet · 06/08/2023 22:25

Isthebusstillrunning · 06/08/2023 21:50

Lived together for 3 years.
I suppose the answer is simply that he doesn't want it with me/doesn't love me enough, no?
Thanks for all your answers.

He may not want it with anyone. He might just date women indefinitely until each one realises he's not the man they thought.

This doesn't have to be a "you" thing. It could just be how he is and how he'll live the rest of his life.

I have a male friend. Gorgeous. Funny. Very successful (albeit started with daddy's money) and has a new gorgeous girlfriend every 3yrs approximately. Because he will not commit. And each woman gets sick of the groundhog day. It's always the same, flash holidays, fine dining, skiing, and that seems to make them hang around for a bit, then they slowly realise if they want either a husband or a family, it's never gonna happen and they leave/he dumps them after a big argument about never getting married.

Swipe left for the next trending thread