Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you leave a partner who's not ready for marriage after 4 years?

90 replies

Isthebusstillrunning · 06/08/2023 21:22

Don't want to give away too much specific info but if your partner is 29, you are 32, and together for approx 4 years. He wasn't ready after 3 years, and now after 4 years hasn't proposed/said he wants a child at this time, regardless of the reasons.
Would you at this point call it quits or is it still too early in the relationship/him too 'young"?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Olika · 07/08/2023 11:38

As pps said Discussing marriage and children early on is a really important. I had this convo with my now husband during our first phone call before deciding on a 1st date. He knew when I meet the right person I want marriage, a child and raise the child out of London. That's what I have now.

Marblessolveeverything · 07/08/2023 10:44

The biological reality is he has plenty of time, possibly 20 years. Women simply don't, yes plenty succeed in conceiving at 40+, but for everyone that does there are plenty who were not as lucky.

If you want children with a marriage commitment move on. Neither of you are wrong, you just both have very different opportunities.

I have a few friends who stayed now mid 40s and there will be no children nor marriage. And some are then left for the women 10, 15 years younger because their timelines match up.

Merryoldgoat · 07/08/2023 10:38

Aprilx · 07/08/2023 07:47

I am often puzzled as to how somebody ends up living with somebody for three years without any talk of future plans and timelines. I wouldn’t (and didnt) even think about living with somebody without having that mapped out first.

I had been thinking maybe another year, until he was 30, would be ok at a push, had you not already been living together. But seeing as you have and he still isn’t sure, no I think he is wasting your time.

Me too.

I told DH that I wanted children and wouldn’t have them outside of marriage on our first date (we had been friends a year before so not like talking to a stranger).

Obviously didn’t scare him as that conversation was 18 years ago.

Buninthecorner · 07/08/2023 10:32

I wish I read this thread 10 years ago.
I left my marriage nearly 2 years ago now. We had some good years but mostly everything was down to me making things happen from grocery shopping, managing the household, having the higher earning job, pushing him in his career. Then if that wasn't enough I pushed him into marriage and then was deluded enough to have a child. He went along with it all, but was only ever half interested in us as a couple. It meant that when DS was born he was also still only half interested. All cracked under the lockdown. I left nearly 2 years ago with my DS so I didn't have to drag along a fully grown but immature man for the rest of my life.

Honestly if I could go back I should've left him before marriage and kids because now I'm a single parent with all the struggle that brings and I'm still bound to him because of our DS.

Aprilx · 07/08/2023 07:47

I am often puzzled as to how somebody ends up living with somebody for three years without any talk of future plans and timelines. I wouldn’t (and didnt) even think about living with somebody without having that mapped out first.

I had been thinking maybe another year, until he was 30, would be ok at a push, had you not already been living together. But seeing as you have and he still isn’t sure, no I think he is wasting your time.

Sugarfree23 · 07/08/2023 07:42

Sorry Op but I wouldn't waste more time with him. You've lived together 3 years, he either wants marriage and children or he doesn't.

Please don't be like a friend, together from school, but late 30s before they got married and by then it was too late for children. Yes plenty do have babies in their early 40s but 30% of women who start TTC at 37 will never have children.

Vettrianofan · 07/08/2023 07:36

*is dithering 🤦🏻

VictoriaVenkman · 07/08/2023 07:36

After 4 years together and no sign of a proposal, I wouldn't assume he didn't want marriage / kids, I would assume he didn't want them with me. Personally, I'd be off.

Vettrianofan · 07/08/2023 07:35

I got engaged two years after getting together with DH, married three months after being engaged. First baby born two months after wedding. Got several children now.

My advice is be direct explain what you want. If he isn't dithering, move on and meet some else.

I got married and had my first baby at 24. I was very direct about what I wanted.

CurlewKate · 07/08/2023 07:27

You can love someone very much indeed and not want to marry. You can't love someone very much and not have a grown up conversation about it.

Ladybug14 · 07/08/2023 06:29

Isthebusstillrunning · 06/08/2023 21:50

Lived together for 3 years.
I suppose the answer is simply that he doesn't want it with me/doesn't love me enough, no?
Thanks for all your answers.

Yes, I'd say that is correct.

Hes not into you enough for you to be the mother of his children

CurlewKate · 07/08/2023 06:10

If you want marriage, you need to have a grown up conversation with him about it. You need to know where you stand, not just wait for a proposal.

Blankscreen · 07/08/2023 06:08

Sorry OP but I think it is time to go your separate ways.

I was with my x boyfriend for 6 years until I was 28. We'd bought a house together and then moved up the ladder and I thought the next step was to get engaged etc.

Then he proclaimed in front of our all our friends that he didn't believe in marriage and didn't want kids. I was so embarrassed.

Well needless to say things went downhill. Long story short he went off with his boss from work. She was pregnant within a year and they were married a couple of years later.

He just didn't want those things with me. Sad but true.

HAF1119 · 07/08/2023 05:55

Given he's giving no reason/timeframe/talk of future when you have been clear on your intentions yes I would leave

Different if he said he would like to wait 2 more years and have that time travelling/saving/any plan whatsoever. Again if he discussed being unsure due to recent issues in the relationship and wanted to work on them to be sure of compatibility etc that would be worth contemplating as there is an element of knowledge and communication so you can both work out if it works/doesn't. You have no idea if he will ever decide to have children with you and deserve a person who can at least be honest about their future plan, or be mature enough to begin to make one.

Nothing wrong with never wanting children/marriage, what I dislike is when someone just says 'not ready' without rhyme or reason, and I wouldn't stay with that

Cloudburstings · 07/08/2023 05:35

Isthebusstillrunning · 06/08/2023 21:53

I hate how we infantalise (if that's a word) men these days. Any man under 30 is supposed to be given a free pass for being devoid of any sort of commitment or responsibility, because he's 'only 29' bless him.
It's hardly 18/19.
Why do we do this?

Agree with this OP. I also hate how ALL the societal discussion about ‘women having children later’ is framed as WARNING WOMEN NOT TO LEAVE IT TOO LATE yet it’s usually that she’s ready and he wants to ‘wait’

we should be warning MEN not to leave it too late if they want kids.

And making it clear that stringing a woman along if you DONT want kids yet / with her / at all is an awful thing to do.

post 25 a couple of years living together is enough to decide if you’re in or out. Once she’s past 30 the time you have to decide gets shorter and shorter.

weve got to start telling men to behave like adults not make us the baddies for advocating for our own lives

Beseen22 · 07/08/2023 04:41

If after a year of serious dating we weren't on the same page then I would have thought about moving on. I don't really see it as an ultimatum, it's not a "if you don't propose by January I'm leaving situation" it's more if we aren't on the same page about this incredibly important life decision after a period of time then do our values and goals align? And if not then I can't imagine it being the marriage I would have wanted.

Marriage is very important to me (nothing to do with a wedding, hated being a bride and certainly nothing to do with a ring most days I wear a plain thin band). I wanted to be married before commiting financially with someone to buy a home. I love that we have our own family unit together and have grown together and been through good and bad times together. I understand that is not the case for everyone and can absolutely respect that view. I just think people should be able to discuss these massive life decisions together rather than waiting for the man to propose. If you don't think being married is important then that's fine but realistically we are not that compatible so let's discuss it and decide if its a deal breaker rather than dragging it out.

mathanxiety · 07/08/2023 04:38

*costs

mathanxiety · 07/08/2023 04:38

fullbloom87 · 06/08/2023 23:11

I wasn't infantilising him. I'm saying you've been with him for just 4 years, you are older and more ready then him to settle down and do the family thing. There are high expectations these days for standards of living. A man can't just get a job down the coal mines and raise a family of 6 kids anymore. They're expected to have the perfect house, car, fancy job etc
Maybe he's waiting until he's at the right point financially, which might not be yet.
It's up to you if you want to chuck away the last 4 years or give him a bit more time and if you're worried about getting too old, it might take another 2+ years to find the right man and you might even go through this a 2nd time and be even older by then.

In other words, "Swallow the sunken coats fallacy, hook, line, and sinker."

What has happened is that men are no longer expected to be married to women they sleep with or to feel any obligation to women.

Octosaurus · 07/08/2023 04:21

100% if you want kids and marriage you should definitely leave otherwise you will waste your whole fertility on this man

hippygirllucky · 07/08/2023 04:18

I left ex after 5. I asked if we could move in together and he said he'd prefer to live with friends (he was living with mum at the time). I wanted in to propose, he didn't even want to live together. Sometimes not wanting the same things is the same as not being compatible.

Met my now husband while I was still with ex and it couldn't have been different, we had the exact same life plans and it felt so right.

montecarlo7 · 07/08/2023 04:04

Isthebusstillrunning · 06/08/2023 21:28

It does seem to be later in London for some reason.
Just cannot give a specific time frame. I would like to before 35 preferably.

If he can't give a specific timeframe, and you know you want children, I would leave in your situation. Especially if you want more than one child.

I am of the opinion that it's ideal to have kids when you're younger where possible. When I think back to how much energy I had in my 20s vs how much I have late 30s, it makes sense.

porridgeisbae · 07/08/2023 03:05

Yep. Would've been binned, hopefully quite a while ago.

I went through that when I was about your age OP, so I know how upsetting it is 😔 x

Somewhereovertherainbowweighapie · 07/08/2023 03:01

I have him 2.5 years. He wasn’t ready so I left.

RugglesB · 07/08/2023 02:31

In my experience men know quite quickly if they want to get married. Sorry OP but this one isn't likely the one. I wouldn't waste any more time.

RobertaFirmino · 07/08/2023 01:15

It took me and DH 17 years to get married. Neither of us was particularly bothered about it until he had a cancer scare and that's when we decided to do it for legal reasons. Even then, it was a case of him saying 'Do you think we should get married so you can be my next of kin?' and me saying 'Yeah, probably' and we had a classic MN £200 wedding.

I'd probably end it. Why would you want to be married to someone who had to be cajoled and threatened into it? Surely you deserve a husband who wants to be married to you of his own free will.