Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you want to live with little quality of life?

140 replies

Isthebusstillrunning · 06/08/2023 20:38

I work in dementia care, and yesterday was in a nursing dementia home. The entire home smelled of faeces, a large number of patients were bedridden, had to be spoon fed baby food, doubly incontinent, could no longer communicate. Basically just being kept alive.
There are residents shouting and wailing out loud all day long 'help me, help me, I want to go home, where are my Mum and Dad'. All day.
There are some that are still very physically mobile but their minds are completely gone, there were some ladies who used to be nurses or carers themselves in their younger days.
Residents would try to go to the toilet on the floor, sexually and verbally assault other residents and staff, strip naked in public rooms, and so on.
I had a pounding headache by the end of the day. It turns people into overgrown toddlers in a way, having to constantly stop residents from touching things they shouldn't, going into rooms they shouldn't, throwing food.
Some of the permanent care staff were quite abrupt and short tempered, however it's an incredibly demanding job for little over minimum wage, and they're often pressured into working ridiculous hours. I don't think 12 hour days should be the standard, it's too much.
Anyway, I always read people saying that as soon as they start to lose capacity, or lose their independence, they're off to Dignitas, or will just end their own lives some way.
I look at these residents and others and I think, well what happened to them all? Did they ever consider doing that? Perhaps it's something that people say but understandably could not bring themselves to carry out.
It was just heartbreaking though. What do you do when you know you'll only decline?

OP posts:
Isthebusstillrunning · 06/08/2023 21:24

It's not something I regularly thought about, but that home was emotionally distressing.
My own grandmother has dementia and has a home carer, but still relatively early stage. I think it was just seeing 27 residents with it all manifesting in different ways that was distressing.

OP posts:
User3456 · 06/08/2023 21:21

It's awful to think about and something we need further conversations about in this country.

In the meantime, I don't think there's enough focus on prevention and what people can do to keep themselves well. For example, social contact really helps to reduce risk of developing dementia. On the other hand, viral infections (and in particular covid -19) increase risks, there is an emerging body of research on this but it is not being well publicised. One linked below.

So in all seriousness, do what you sensibly can to avoid catching or spreading covid whilst getting on with your life. And in particular do what you can to maintain contact with older relatives but be as careful as you can not to give them covid. So the sort of things I mean are opening windows for ventilation, using antiviral nasal sprays, using masks in some settings (ideally FFP2 masks, at least wearing them in health settings but if you can on public transport and in shops too) and testing before visiting older relatives. And staying away if you have any symptoms, of course. Study shows: Risk of dementia may increase after viral infections - The Limited Times (newsrnd.com)

Study shows: Risk of dementia may increase after viral infections

Scientists from the U.S. National Institutes of Health used data from two biodatabases in Finland and the United Kingdom. People who have suffered certain viral infections have an increased risk of neurodegenerative diseases. Alzheimer's patients have...

https://newsrnd.com/life/2023-08-04-study-shows--risk-of-dementia-may-increase-after-viral-infections.Hytvz-5i3.html

Isthebusstillrunning · 06/08/2023 21:19

Yes, it was indeed an EMI unit and I know this is one of the most 'challenging' settings.
I am sorry to hear your stories xx

OP posts:
evrey · 06/08/2023 21:17

The home shouldn't smell of feaces, and the residents should be safe from other residents violent outbursts ,sexual assault,etc.
However emi nursing is very different from homes that just take dementia residents. To be classed as emi ,they must be unmanageable in a regular nursing home setting . Resisting personal care, violent, inappropriately sexual, they will eat non food items, defecate anywhere and sometimes smear it up the walls, attack staff and other residents amongst many other things.
These residents are extremely hard to manage and the balance between sedation and quality of life is a huge debate.
It is incredibly hard to work in, or even visit .
Please don't assume they are being neglected . Because the alternative is to just drug them up to the eyeballs so the place appears calm .

DuesToTheDirt · 06/08/2023 21:16

@Reddog1 how sad, nobody wants to end up like that. Sorry about your mother Flowers.

Reddog1 · 06/08/2023 21:14

When I was a teenager in around 1987, my mother (then aged about 55) and I were coming home one winter’s evening when we saw an elderly neighbour shuffling down the street with her thin nightie tucked into her underwear. She’d soiled herself and was ice cold and crying. We got her home and my mother cleaned her up and put her to bed (having changed the sheets which were stinking). Whilst this was going on I made her a cup of tea in the grimy, foul kitchen.

This woman was a retired professional, the first in our town to qualify and practise in her field. She had been clever, cultured and stylish. My mother had known her in a professional capacity three decades earlier and like many young women, had really looked up to her.

My mother rang social services and long story short …our neighbour eventually went into a care home and died soon after (mercifully).

My mother was so upset by this incident and told me that I was to make sure she never got like that at 80+. She now has. And it is bloody awful. But nothing has moved on in the past 35ish years, elderly people are still suffering because society is too squeamish about the whole thing.

Ketzele · 06/08/2023 21:11

I care for my ex, who has young onset Alzheimers. She is very unhappy. She is still (just about) able to take herself to the local shops, where she regularly buys Stanley knives to slash her wrists with. I look for them and confiscate them. Often I wonder why I do this. Because I couldn't live with myself if I didn't, I suppose, but honestly suicide is kinder than what's left for her. It's such a terrible disease.

UsingChangeofName · 06/08/2023 21:10

I think this thread is almost trying to cover too many different issues.

100% I agree that carers need to be better paid and work shorter shifts. Of course the first argument will be that those additional wages will have to be paid for in some way - by families generally, and the cost is crippling. However, I don't think anyone would disagree that more staff would alleviate some of what you describe. However much as we would all want to be cleaned up immediately, I suspect there are a great number of us that wouldn't want to be in that situation at all.

Then you come on to the 'wanting to take your life before you get to that state'.
As has been said, the issue is you don't get a nice clear timeline of 'on this date you will use this function, on this date you will lose that function'. Life, and then loss of faculties just isn't like that.

I am a big supporter of Dignity In Dying but even they are currently only hoping to get the law changed so that people with a terminal illness and mental capacity will be offered the opportunity to end their life when they choose. That doesn't cover those with dementia.

Dignity in Dying - Join the campaign

Dying people are taking their own lives here and abroad. The current law offers them no protection or support. Join us and help change the law.

https://www.dignityindying.org.uk

Throckmorton · 06/08/2023 21:10

Not everyone could afford Dignitas (approx £10k), which is why, if this is something you think people should have the right to, you should join the campaign to make assisted suicide legal in the UK.

BoobyDazzler · 06/08/2023 21:09

No. It’s inhumane and the fact we allow people to live their final years like that lets us down as a species. I’ve worked on dementia care and some people have an absolutely wretched end of life. Even in the best care homes.

Clefable · 06/08/2023 21:07

I was reading something recently about death and how, as wonderful as medical advances are, it means that people are often a lot less willing to accept death, even when it's an appropriate time for someone to die. Death is inevitable, and a peaceful death is a gift.

AuntieMarys · 06/08/2023 21:04

I would rather be dead than go in a home.

Isthebusstillrunning · 06/08/2023 21:03

I am sorry about your Mum. I'm glad to hear she's in a more decent home.

OP posts:
Stressfordays · 06/08/2023 21:03

I'm a nurse in a nursing home and ending up in one is my biggest fear. I have a living will stating I am not to be kept alive by artificial means if it is not likely I will make a full recovery and that I am not to be artificially fed unless I have the capacity to make the decision. I have let every friend and family member know my wishes too. I have even made a pact with one of my fellow nurses that we will not allow it to happen to each other.

What makes my job hard is I am literally keeping these people alive, we give medications to them to prolong their lives, treat their illnesses etc. A lot of families don't understand what you are doing to their relatives and often push you to treat everything even when you are gently saying maybe its best if we keep them comfortable. And the bloody doctors never put their foot down and just go with the family. Let people die with dignity!

Paq · 06/08/2023 21:03

I think people are completely naive about how dementia affects people. I have two relatives, neither terribly old, who have gone downhill very quickly recently. One is doubly incontinent and rips off incontinence pants all the time, meaning her clothes are constantly soiled and her house reeks. The other sexually assaulted his carers and any other woman in his vicinity at the drop of a hat. He can only be looked after by men now, even his adult daughter can't be around him.

The ability to keep them clean and safe without drugging them into a stupor on a daily basis is nil.

I will happily sign anything that gives my relatives permission to kill me off once I've lost my marbles.

PinkiOcelot · 06/08/2023 21:02

No definitely not.

You have just described my mam in your first paragraph. It’s horrific. If I was asked to sign a form asking if we could end her pain and suffering, I would sign it. An animal wouldn’t be left like this.

Her home is nothing like what you describe though.

Isthebusstillrunning · 06/08/2023 21:01

All very true.

OP posts:
DuesToTheDirt · 06/08/2023 21:00

Isthebusstillrunning · 06/08/2023 20:41

I just think it's interesting because so many people say they will do it, but there is an ever-growing population of care home residents. Maybe the will to live kicks in.

I think it's down to a few things.

  • how would you kill yourself? Switzerland? Needs money and planning. Tablets? Razor blade? Not appealing.
  • at what point would you decide to do it? For most of us there is hope that things will improve. And if your mind goes, you might not have the ability to actually make such decisions.
  • yes, there is a will to live, I think. It's easy to say, "Oh if that were me I would end it," but would you really, when it actually is you?
  • and I think people are, fundamentally, scared of death. Leaving your loved ones, not existing any more - that's frightening.
Isthebusstillrunning · 06/08/2023 21:00

Yeah, I don't know if Dignitas would accept people with a formal diagnosis, even if still lots of capacity?
Also, doesn't it cost thousands? I suppose that's not possible for everyone.

OP posts:
Isthebusstillrunning · 06/08/2023 20:59

I'm sorry about your Dad xx

OP posts:
Clefable · 06/08/2023 20:59

No, it's awful. I think I would rather go before I wanted than risk spending any time like that, but it's so difficult with something like dementia because often by the time it's diagnosed, it can be argued the person is lacking capacity to make the decision to end their life via Dignitas or something.

Charley50 · 06/08/2023 20:57

I have an advanced directive that I've given to my GP stating I don't want antibiotics or other treatments when I get dementia. So hopefully I'll die of pneumonia or something if I'm at that stage, rather than be kept alive by antibiotics.

Bananaman123 · 06/08/2023 20:57

My dad and I always said the same, weigh up options and decide what you want to do with your own life. His fear was dementia or motor neurons disease. He said he would take his own life if he felt he didn’t want to go on. He now has dementia, undiagnosed as he will not go to GP and they won’t do anything unless he goes to them and says something is wrong. Luckily he doesn’t realise what’s happening and so now his worst fear has come true but he isn’t in a position now to consider dignitas etc.

for 4yrs he’s been getting worse and is now struggling to walk for more than 10mins, eats food that goes down easily, spends most days in and out of bed and has zero memory. I’m being called all day long and through the night, he insists on having money but keeps losing it, I’ve got POA and he thinks I’m spending his money, gets angry very quickly and taking it out on everyone. My mum now sleeps in another room and still wakes her up, she looks like she’s aged 10 yrs. I dread this getting to the point you have mentioned, ina care home. it’s giving me so much stress and anxiety.

LoobyDop · 06/08/2023 20:57

No. The prospect absolutely terrifies me.

Janiie · 06/08/2023 20:54

MassDebate · 06/08/2023 20:44

I think the cruelty of dementia is that it creeps up on people, so there isn’t a realisation (for most) that their mind is going; rather a steady decline such that the mind never gets to have the flash of realisation that would allow someone to plan a dignitas type escape.

This. If those suffering with dementia could see how they'd end up I'm sure most would consider ending their lives but it is often a slow decline and people obviously then lack capacity and ability to make massive decisions.

I've no idea why GPs don't have those in the state like the op describes on whacking doses of valium. Not ethical perhaps but neither is leaving people screaming and distressed.

Swipe left for the next trending thread