Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you want to live with little quality of life?

140 replies

Isthebusstillrunning · 06/08/2023 20:38

I work in dementia care, and yesterday was in a nursing dementia home. The entire home smelled of faeces, a large number of patients were bedridden, had to be spoon fed baby food, doubly incontinent, could no longer communicate. Basically just being kept alive.
There are residents shouting and wailing out loud all day long 'help me, help me, I want to go home, where are my Mum and Dad'. All day.
There are some that are still very physically mobile but their minds are completely gone, there were some ladies who used to be nurses or carers themselves in their younger days.
Residents would try to go to the toilet on the floor, sexually and verbally assault other residents and staff, strip naked in public rooms, and so on.
I had a pounding headache by the end of the day. It turns people into overgrown toddlers in a way, having to constantly stop residents from touching things they shouldn't, going into rooms they shouldn't, throwing food.
Some of the permanent care staff were quite abrupt and short tempered, however it's an incredibly demanding job for little over minimum wage, and they're often pressured into working ridiculous hours. I don't think 12 hour days should be the standard, it's too much.
Anyway, I always read people saying that as soon as they start to lose capacity, or lose their independence, they're off to Dignitas, or will just end their own lives some way.
I look at these residents and others and I think, well what happened to them all? Did they ever consider doing that? Perhaps it's something that people say but understandably could not bring themselves to carry out.
It was just heartbreaking though. What do you do when you know you'll only decline?

OP posts:
Greenqueen40 · 06/08/2023 22:48

Astounding naivety on here. 12hr shifts are perfectly standard in healthcare, may seem like a long time but you get used to them incredibly quickly. I don't think you can judge a home from what has been said. It takes one person being incontinent in the lounge to make the place stink of faeces and the truth is a lot of people with advanced dementia do all the things mentioned. People saying their relative is in a care home and its not like that.... it probably is at times, just not when you are there.

Elphame · 06/08/2023 22:45

Isthebusstillrunning · 06/08/2023 22:34

The problem is you can go to reassure someone 10000 times in a day, but with dementia they will forget that you have reassured them a few minutes later. Ideally each resident would have their own 1-1 who sits with them through the day, but there will never be adequate staffing.

It's awful

We didn't tell my FIL's sister when he died. She had advanced dementia and would not have remembered us telling her for more than a few minutes. To inflict that grief on her would have been cruel and every time she was retold she'd have felt it as a fresh new grief.

venusandmars · 06/08/2023 22:45

A generalised living will isn't really enough, especially for people with any kind of advanced dementia. For my parents it covered - not taking them to hospital (for iv antibiotics) if oral antibiotics weren't effective; not taking them to hopsital if suspected stoke; no CPR; not artificially feeding them if they were 'near the end' and refusing to eat.

As I understood it (and I may be wrong) they would still be given oral antibiotics for a treatable UTI, chest infection or tonsillitis etc. And refusal to eat (in general) was seen as one of the many behaviours and the staff did as much as they could to encourage eating and to give nutritional meal replacement drinks.

I also found out that routine vaccinations were still being given: COVID, flu, pneumonia, and that there was a new prescription for statins to protect against CVD!!

Having lived through (and currently living through) the long proccess with older relatives, my current plan is to 100% engage with my family members and to engage them in my wishes. They mostly involve a sunny afternoon, a comoftable spot in the garden surrounded by my favourite flowers, a lot of wine, and a selection of sleeping tablets - siphoned off gradually from a regular supply.

Mamai90 · 06/08/2023 22:44

Going off to Dignitas isn't an option for a lot of people, surely you'd know that? There are several reasons, firstly is the cost, as far as I'm aware it's around £10,000. Then there's asking family members to help out, a lot of people wouldn't be comfortable asking their children to help them die, and they'd be asking them to break the law, they can be jailed for assisting suicide. Then there's having to go long before your dementia is in anyway advanced.

I'm surprised you didn't know this stuff before making an ignorant comment about how did this happen to all these patients, didn't they consider Dignitas?🙄

cansu · 06/08/2023 22:38

We are it seems completely incapable of facing reality as a society. We won't allow people to choose euthanasia and yet we are not willing to pay for decent care through higher taxes. I would like people to be able to write living wills where they specify what they want and in what circumstances before they lose capacity. I cannot however see it happening.

MavisMcMinty · 06/08/2023 22:37

Can you get life insurance at the age of 70?

LaMaG · 06/08/2023 22:36

ForestGoblin · 06/08/2023 22:24

To manage expectations - living wills won't stop you from being kept alive. Post-Shipman, medics take NO chances and will err on the side of preserving you in hell.

I worry about my parents. Hope to God they live long lives and drop down at 90.

I'm killing myself at 70. Two score years and ten is all I need.

What about life insurance? Wouldn't that invalidate it? You'd have to make your family very clear about it in case they were expecting a pay out.

GardeningIdiot · 06/08/2023 22:35

Bandyarsia · 06/08/2023 22:12

No. That is just existing and not living. I would rather be put out of my misery. I will have something in place to make sure this does not happen.

What will ensure that?

Isthebusstillrunning · 06/08/2023 22:34

The problem is you can go to reassure someone 10000 times in a day, but with dementia they will forget that you have reassured them a few minutes later. Ideally each resident would have their own 1-1 who sits with them through the day, but there will never be adequate staffing.

OP posts:
AuntieJune · 06/08/2023 22:34

I agree op. None of the politicians want to address it though. Talking about this stuff is a vote loser, older demographics will say we're trying to kill them off.

BLT24 · 06/08/2023 22:31

Yo me they need care like a baby/toddler and you wouldn’t leave them to wail all day, alone and scared. No I don’t agree with ending life early, just better quality care.

MavisMcMinty · 06/08/2023 22:31

AmyandPhilipfan · 06/08/2023 22:25

I once read a novel about a woman in her 50s who gets early onset dementia. She can't stand the thought of totally losing her mind so she buys enough pills to kill herself and she writes down about 5 questions that she knows the answers to. She asks herself these questions regularly and on the day she can't remember any of the answers she gets a glass of water and the pills and she goes upstairs to take the pills, lie down in bed and die. That has always been her plan. She has held onto the fact that when things get too bad she can kill herself before she gets any worse.

But by the time she gets upstairs on that planned for day she can't remember why she's there, and so she doesn't kill herself. And so she gradually declines in a way that she was always scared of doing. It was the most depressing book I've ever read!

Yes, that’s the trouble with suicide/assisted suicide with dementia. Once you’ve forgotten your intention to die, nobody else can legally carry out your wishes.

In my nurse training I met a GP who had tried to kill himself when he self-diagnosed the early signs of Alzheimer’s. Unfortunately he was found by someone who ignored the letter he’d left explaining why and what he’d done, was recovered in ICU, and spent the next 5 years in a long-stay psychiatric ward, becoming exactly what he’d tried to avoid.

matchamate · 06/08/2023 22:30

Rachie1973 · 06/08/2023 22:01

12 hours is pretty standard. Some are 14 hour days.

I know

Stressfordays · 06/08/2023 22:30

ForestGoblin · 06/08/2023 22:24

To manage expectations - living wills won't stop you from being kept alive. Post-Shipman, medics take NO chances and will err on the side of preserving you in hell.

I worry about my parents. Hope to God they live long lives and drop down at 90.

I'm killing myself at 70. Two score years and ten is all I need.

I agree but its our best hope, plus telling everyone you know about your wishes. I do believe doctors fearing litigation is the biggest issue here. The amount of families insisting their 97 year old nanny with advanced dementia doesn't have a dnar and needs full treatment, the doctors are too scared to say no!

LaMaG · 06/08/2023 22:29

I know nothing about dementia or elderly care really, so I may be wrong here... but I wonder about the drugs provided to extend life, I suspect big pharma are milking all this, its in their interests to have as many of these people hanging on as possible. How many would drift off sooner if there was no medical intervention. I'm talking stuff like blood thinners and standard stuff like that. If a person is non compus mentus then why not withdraw all meds, maybe with the exception of pain relief if they need it and let nature take over.

It sounds heartless but every person I have ever talked to says they don't want to end up like that yet they do. It's morally wrong to try to extend that person's suffering IMO.

GardeningIdiot · 06/08/2023 22:29

Isthebusstillrunning · 06/08/2023 20:48

I think it was really due to staffing issues. The existing staff were stretched to the limit, some residents definitely needed 1-1 staff but I imagine there isn't the funding.
You get residents going in others' rooms, even though they aren't doing it of sound mind. It isn't fair to the residents all round.

It's really concerning to see a professional witness this level of care and seemingly not be willing to report.

It doesn't matter what the cause is, the result is inadequate care and increased suffering. Low staffing levels alone are a reason to report.

matchamate · 06/08/2023 22:28

ForestGoblin · 06/08/2023 22:24

To manage expectations - living wills won't stop you from being kept alive. Post-Shipman, medics take NO chances and will err on the side of preserving you in hell.

I worry about my parents. Hope to God they live long lives and drop down at 90.

I'm killing myself at 70. Two score years and ten is all I need.

You say that but if you get to 70 and are still enjoying life would you really?

AmyandPhilipfan · 06/08/2023 22:25

I once read a novel about a woman in her 50s who gets early onset dementia. She can't stand the thought of totally losing her mind so she buys enough pills to kill herself and she writes down about 5 questions that she knows the answers to. She asks herself these questions regularly and on the day she can't remember any of the answers she gets a glass of water and the pills and she goes upstairs to take the pills, lie down in bed and die. That has always been her plan. She has held onto the fact that when things get too bad she can kill herself before she gets any worse.

But by the time she gets upstairs on that planned for day she can't remember why she's there, and so she doesn't kill herself. And so she gradually declines in a way that she was always scared of doing. It was the most depressing book I've ever read!

ForestGoblin · 06/08/2023 22:24

To manage expectations - living wills won't stop you from being kept alive. Post-Shipman, medics take NO chances and will err on the side of preserving you in hell.

I worry about my parents. Hope to God they live long lives and drop down at 90.

I'm killing myself at 70. Two score years and ten is all I need.

Louisetopaz21 · 06/08/2023 22:22

I am a best interests assessor and I love working with people who have a diagnosis of dementia. Not all people present the same and it is possible to have a good quality life with a diagnosis. Just depends that we go along with the person's reality and don't try to make them conform with ours

Isthebusstillrunning · 06/08/2023 22:20

That is very true. I've previously cared for a 31 year old tetraplegic male who was bedridden 24h a day, paralysed from the neck down.

OP posts:
Stressfordays · 06/08/2023 22:19

EspressoPatronum · 06/08/2023 22:12

After caring for my mil with dementia I fully intend on writing a living will when I get older, which will include the provision of refusing antibiotics if I get to a certain stage of that sort of disease and a dna.

Id encourage you to do it now, rather then when you are older. I did mine at the age of 28 when during my nursing career I looked after someone who had an horrific brain injury from a traffic accident and basically lays in bed 24 hours a day and is fed via tube. Dementia is not the only disease that can cause a reduced quality of life.

gogomoto · 06/08/2023 22:18

I was pretty upset at the whole system, that we can't just prescribe an overdose of morphine once dementia becomes very advanced if all family are in agreement.

It felt a bit like every 2 weeks we went to visit this pet we kept at a house, they didn't recognise us, would only show any interest if i brought pink wafers and fell asleep as you talked amongst yourselves. Meanwhile taxpayers (this was fully funded 1:1) were paying £2k a month! In our case covid took her, a relief all around

MavisMcMinty · 06/08/2023 22:13

My Mum had Alzheimer’s so it’s one of my greatest fears that I’ll get it too, particularly as her brother and sister also had it. My paternal grandfather had vascular dementia, so my Dad (86) is also scared of it, although so far he seems fine cognitively.

We have discussed it, he says he’d like to go to Dignitas if he got dementia, and I said I’d take him, but the trouble is, when do you go? If your quality of life is fine to begin with, isn’t there a risk that you won’t do it in time, that you’ll forget you ever wanted assisted dying? If you don’t do it at the first sign of disease, can you be considered competent to take that decision later on?

My Mum was a nurse and would have HATED what she became. My Dad looked after her at home for much longer than he should have, he had to lock them both inside the house to stop her escaping “home” (to Ireland!). When she went into a care home it was terrible, even worse than when she died 18 months later, the pain and guilt we all felt. I was relieved when she died, had been wishing for it for a long time, which of course brought its own guilt.

Swipe left for the next trending thread