Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I just not that much of a mother bear or whatever they call it ?

39 replies

Sistaas · 06/08/2023 17:00

I've been spending a few days with my sister and her family..

I noticed some significant differences in our parenting styles. Her kids are a little older but I feel like she's always been like this and I just don't have the same instinct and I'm wondering whether I'm missing something and should be more like my sis or if she's OTT.

I'll give a couple of examples. If anyone even tries to reprimands her kids in any way, she gets really pissed off. For example she told me about how at nursery the teacher told her that her DD hadn't been kind one particular time and they'd had to have words with her about her behaviour. Standard stuff. My sis was so angry about this inside. She told me she thought 'you fucking bitch ' about the teacher for criticising her child.

Sometimes her kids get into the usual squabbles at nursery and this makes her so mad at the children. ' it's not ok! These kids are animals '.. it's just normal nursery stuff in my opinion. Nothing extreme. I get told that my child has been in a scuffle about sharing and I just tell the teacher we will work on kind hands at home. It doesn't make me angry or outrage me if a teacher says my child behaved less than favourably.

Well, unless it's constant ( which it was at one of her nurseries so I took my child out ). But the occasional ' this happened today ' from a teacher, doesn't make me angry.

Same with if I say anything to her children, like please can you put this down, or please remember to close the door. Minor stuff. She's always right there to defend the slightest thing. I don't have a go at her kids or anything like that. Just minor safety things. ' oh she didn't know she needs to shut the door ' 'ok that's fine but I just reminded her to please do it '...

Yet when it comes to my kids, there's a lot of nasty talk about how they behave. If we reversed that, she would go nuts.

Also just generally out and about when someone accidentally bumps her kid, she gets really annoyed.

Something happened today at soft play where my DD tried to touch a baby in a pram ( not on ) and the parent forcefully removed her arm. My DD held her arm and said it hurts after the parent did it. I didn't love it. I know my DD did something wrong there of course. But I think the parent could have swatted her hand away more gently. The parent grabbed her arm really hard. I didn't do anything about it. But my sister would go absolutely nuts if someone did that to her children. The fact remains that the parent probably was accidentally forceful, but could have said sorry for hurting your arm to mu DD, but can't touch my baby. That's what I would have done. I would have felt bad if I hurt a child in the process or protecting my own.

Anyway, it made me think that maybe I need to stand up for my children more. I could have said to the parent ' I'm sorry my child tried to touch your baby and I was too far to stop her myself , but please take care because you were quite rough and hurt her in the process and you don't seem to care '. ( I apologised for my DD ) and the parent just walked on.

OP posts:
PinkyU · 06/08/2023 18:02

How old is your dd and did her arm have a mark on it?

Your sister is ott but it does sound like your dd needs a closer eye on her if she is prone to acting out (having behaviour reports daily from nursery suggests some issues around behaviour). How do you know your dd wasn’t attempting to harm the baby in the pram, you weren’t close enough to get to her or see what was happening?

Its rarely if ever appropriate for a child to be handled roughly but I’d say when another, more vulnerable, child is at risk from them might be an occasion where you react quickly and do so with a bit less attention to strength.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 06/08/2023 17:48

Nobody likes their child to be criticised, but there's a difference between having a strop about a nursery worker doing their job by informing you about behaviour incidents involving your child and feeling justifiably a bit hurt when your sister makes constant little jjbes about their own niece/nephew.

I can't stand that 'I'm a mama bear' trope. It's usually code for 'I have created entitled brats who in my eyes are perfect and never wrong, and will trample over anybody else to get them exactly what they want whenever they want, and criticise other children to make mine look better.'

Smartiepants79 · 06/08/2023 17:40

BarbaraV · 06/08/2023 17:16

I would go nuts if someone forcibly grabbed my child's arm. I don't know many who wouldn't.

I wouldn’t ‘go nuts’ unless the grabbing involved them trying to snatch my child.
If they’d really hurt them I might tell them so and perhaps expect an apology.
Its does depend on context and the behaviour of the child prior to the incident.
OP your sister sounds very intense and is going to potentially end up with a set of kids who take zero responsibility for their own behaviour. Not doing them any favours in the long run. Are they ever in the wrong?

Sistaas · 06/08/2023 17:33

SiousieSoo · 06/08/2023 17:26

That is so awful your daughter's arm was hurt by this adult man, how dare he touch a child so forcefully? I am like you, I never felt aggreived if a teacher had words with my children and welcome honest and open comments. I can totally understand how, in the heat of the moment, you could not find the words to challenge this horrible man. You were maybe fearful of escalating the situation as if he can do this to a child what is he capable of doing to an adult? All these people saying they would rip his throat out, go mental etc.... Exactly how would this manifest itself? Would you actually physically attack him or start screaming?

You sound like you have an appropriate set of reactions and your sister sounds woeful to be so elevated in her responses. I do think you need to retaliate to her if she criticises your child. She sounds very irritating and overbearing. It does sound like you are a bit too passive with her.

I feel rubbish every time she leaves and like a bad mum. The behaviour isn't outright nasty towards my children, like I said in my opening post.

She's really really sweet to them. But when they misbehave, she rolls her eyes and makes fun of them. Especially my DD who she believes shouldn't be having the kind of tantrums she has anymore. She just says ' omg that noise ' ' how do you live with that noise ' ' here we go again ' 'off she goes '. That kind of thing.

At the time it doesn't seem proper nasty. But then afterwards I reflect on it and think that if I ever said that about how her kids behave, she'd be really pissed off.

She never says anything directly to my kids. Just to me and in front of hers. Hers are a bit older. Mine are still under 5. Hers are all over 5.

Anyway yeah not my proudest moment with that man today. I should have told him to be gentler next time.

OP posts:
SiousieSoo · 06/08/2023 17:26

That is so awful your daughter's arm was hurt by this adult man, how dare he touch a child so forcefully? I am like you, I never felt aggreived if a teacher had words with my children and welcome honest and open comments. I can totally understand how, in the heat of the moment, you could not find the words to challenge this horrible man. You were maybe fearful of escalating the situation as if he can do this to a child what is he capable of doing to an adult? All these people saying they would rip his throat out, go mental etc.... Exactly how would this manifest itself? Would you actually physically attack him or start screaming?

You sound like you have an appropriate set of reactions and your sister sounds woeful to be so elevated in her responses. I do think you need to retaliate to her if she criticises your child. She sounds very irritating and overbearing. It does sound like you are a bit too passive with her.

POWL01 · 06/08/2023 17:20

I was with you all the way, I'm a very relaxed parent much to my in-laws chagrin, until you said an adult forcefully grabbed your DD's arm and hurt her, I'd have ripped their fucking throat out quite honestly 🤷‍♀️

TimeToMoveIt · 06/08/2023 17:20

Your sisters ott some parents are. They tend to be total pitas as well and quite often so are their kids

Sistaas · 06/08/2023 17:19

CherryMaDeara · 06/08/2023 17:16

I agree with @fuschia1981 , your sister is OTT, but you are too passive. What that parent did was too much. You should have pushed her hand away and asked her not to touch your child.

Yet when it comes to my kids, there's a lot of nasty talk about how they behave. If we reversed that, she would go nuts.

Your sister is nasty about your kids? Stop exposing your kids to her. Kids are like sponges, they will realise that they are lesser than their cousins and feel inferior. Either stand up for your kids or stop seeing your sister.

Yeah I should have reacted to the man doing that today. I was really angry inside but I didn't want to cause a scene.

With regards to being really ' nasty ' about my kids. Maybe that's not the right way to say it. My DD has tantrums when she can't get her way and my sis just says stuff like ' here we go again ' etc. I guess it's not ' really nasty ' but I don't love it.

OP posts:
HandInMine · 06/08/2023 17:18

Your sister is ridiculous but you should have said something to the parent at soft play, that’s not on.

Peony654 · 06/08/2023 17:17

I think there’s a middle ground, your sister is too extreme one way, but you should have reacted more strongly to them grabbing the arm. It’s really inappropriate she’s nasty about your kids as well.

CherryMaDeara · 06/08/2023 17:16

I agree with @fuschia1981 , your sister is OTT, but you are too passive. What that parent did was too much. You should have pushed her hand away and asked her not to touch your child.

Yet when it comes to my kids, there's a lot of nasty talk about how they behave. If we reversed that, she would go nuts.

Your sister is nasty about your kids? Stop exposing your kids to her. Kids are like sponges, they will realise that they are lesser than their cousins and feel inferior. Either stand up for your kids or stop seeing your sister.

BarbaraV · 06/08/2023 17:16

I would go nuts if someone forcibly grabbed my child's arm. I don't know many who wouldn't.

CopperSeahorses · 06/08/2023 17:15

I don't have an issue with people reprimanding my child if appropriate but I would have an issue with them doing it in a way that hurt them, that is not on.

fuschia1981 · 06/08/2023 17:09

Your sister is OTT but you should have dealt with that parent appropriately. If a grown adult hurt my child's arm for any reason I would go mental.