Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rereading Harry Potter as an adult and finding it difficult

283 replies

Dasisr · 06/08/2023 10:41

Obsessed with Harry Potter as a teenager but finding it a difficult read as an adult. How badly he is treated by the Dursleys. How deprived of love he was and in later books how he was kept away from his friends/family. All the death of loved ones he had to witness. Honestly finding it tough to get through. AIBU or anyone else the same?

OP posts:
NooNakedJacuzziness · 06/08/2023 12:58

MarshaArt · 06/08/2023 12:40

OP, could you put it in the fridge, like Joey in Friends? 😀

Ha - was just about to say the same! Also to reiterate a PP never ever pick up A Little Life, you'll be in therapy for decades.

Polik · 06/08/2023 12:55

While discussing gillyweed, can I mention the Triwizards Contest as a pointless addition to plot progression?

Every time I re-read book 4 it makes me annoyed.

bruffin · 06/08/2023 12:51

Purplebunnie · 06/08/2023 12:35

Going to be pernickety here but in the book Dobby gave Harry the Gillyweed not Neville

In the film it was Neville , in the books it was Dobby

Neville is no good at magic because he is not using his own wand, it was his father's wand and not one he chose. Once he got his own wand after his father's is broken he flourishes at magic

OriginalBliss · 06/08/2023 12:47

Weefreetiffany · 06/08/2023 12:29

Lol love how everyone is suddenly a literary critic with a phd in literary analysis and senior editorship as soon as it comes to criticising one of the most bought, borrowed and read series in the world. The lack of “quality” certainly hasn’t held it back, but by all means tell us all the problems you’ve spotted.

Just like the people who seem really proud of rolling their eyes at someone having an emotional response to a book they read as a kid while reading it with the life experience of an adult.

At times mumsnet really seems to bring out the emotionless sociopaths.

I am a literary critic with a PhD in literary analysis. It was in no way 'sudden'. It took quite a while.

Whatswhatwhichiswhich · 06/08/2023 12:45

Sobbed my heart out when Dobby was murdered and I was 13. It’s just a story, a poorly written one with massive plot holes at that (love JK and HP before anyone comes for me) Grin

CapEBarra · 06/08/2023 12:45

Whatever you do, don’t read James and the Giant Peach - that little boy had to live IN AN ACTUAL PEACH.

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 06/08/2023 12:43

Weefreetiffany · 06/08/2023 12:34

When Harry spends a lot of time with Ron one on one, Ron becomes quite the little dickhead. The same happens to Hermione to a lesser degree. Likewise all the boys in the same dorm get moody, which we pass off as teenage angst, but if you reframe that they’re being affected by Harry the horcrux.

The Dursley’s started from a position of hating/envying Harry, his family and magic. Whereas his friends started from a place of like and awe. Which could explain why the Dursley’s were more negatively affected than his peers.

I realised this rereading the books as an adult.

I just don't buy it - Ron and Hermione were both seriously affected by that necklace, yet they somehow hung out with Harry for six years and didn't even come close to having the same problems?

SapphireSeptember · 06/08/2023 12:41

No, I get what you mean OP. Even her later works (The Ickabog and The Christmas Pig) are quite dark stories. My brother commented on that after reading The Christmas Pig to our niece. There is a lot of darkness in children's stories, I loved Hans Christian Andersen's fairy tales, Roald Dahl, The Secret Garden and The Little Princess when I was fairly young, and read Harry Potter when I was a teenager just as I was becoming a Goth, so the dark themes didn't really bother me, I was listening to some pretty dark music a couple of years later. (And honestly having to deal with music snobs who think Evanescence are 'lightweight' need to listen to their albums and not just the songs that got released as singles.)

(Side note, reading the graveyard scene in Goblet of Fire while listening to the song Whisper by Evanescence was quite a spooky experience, highly recommend if you like that sort of thing.)

MrsRachelDanvers · 06/08/2023 12:41

When I was young, my home life wasn’t nice. I enjoyed reading novels where the protagonist had to overcome setbacks, adversity and cruelty. Like The Little Princess, Jane Eyre etc. I saw those characters as inspirational-that you could deal with challenges, not be overcome by them. That you could be unloved but still have character and intelligence. Those books got me through my childhood so I think YABU.

MarshaArt · 06/08/2023 12:40

OP, could you put it in the fridge, like Joey in Friends? 😀

Poivresel · 06/08/2023 12:40

My dd insisted I read Harry Potter and brought back the books from the school library.
I read the first 5 and honestly 15 years later could not tell you what any of the plots are.
They're a bit like fast food imo, easy to digest but don't really sustain you.
Tbf Jeffrey Archer novels are the same and Mills and Boon.
I admire JKR though, she seems like a good person.

MarshaArt · 06/08/2023 12:39

Kabbalah · 06/08/2023 12:33

I read the first one over Christmas because there was so much hype about it at the time. It burnt well on the fire.

Ok… have you burnt every book you’ve disliked?

SeeHearMe · 06/08/2023 12:38

OfficerChurlish · 06/08/2023 11:52

I never read Dudley as evil - he's a victim of his parents as much as Cinderella Harry is, just superficially treated "well" because he's theirs.

Neville is definitely portrayed as smart and competent, just lacking in self-confidence and "acceptable" (flashy Hermione-style) academic gloss. For instance, nobody would have survived the underwater scene in the Tri-Wizard Tournament without his botanical knowledge.

It is a suprisingly bleak story for the target age group, in terms of some of the details and ongoing periods of misery/little hope - but I think a large part of that is the way the series kind of "grows up" with the readers, progressing in complexity with each book. It wouldn't have been as effective or successful or realistic if it were happier. And there is a lot of happiness/relief for Harry throughout - he always has his unbreakable friendships, Sirius, Dumbledore, the Order, etc. And (spoiler alert) a happy ending - for those who like that sort of thing.

It was Dobby who told Harry about the gillyweed not Neville. Neville gets credited for a lot of things in the films that Dobby does in the books. Very little about the house elves make it into the films. I don’t even think Winky appears in the films at all? In saying that the films omit loads about Neville eg his mum giving him an empty bubblegum wrapper every time he visits her.

Kabbalah · 06/08/2023 12:38

Supernova23 · 06/08/2023 12:33

I'm more disturbed by adults that like Harry Potter.

Me too.

MarshaArt · 06/08/2023 12:37

Weefreetiffany · 06/08/2023 12:29

Lol love how everyone is suddenly a literary critic with a phd in literary analysis and senior editorship as soon as it comes to criticising one of the most bought, borrowed and read series in the world. The lack of “quality” certainly hasn’t held it back, but by all means tell us all the problems you’ve spotted.

Just like the people who seem really proud of rolling their eyes at someone having an emotional response to a book they read as a kid while reading it with the life experience of an adult.

At times mumsnet really seems to bring out the emotionless sociopaths.

This.

Purplebunnie · 06/08/2023 12:35

OfficerChurlish · 06/08/2023 11:52

I never read Dudley as evil - he's a victim of his parents as much as Cinderella Harry is, just superficially treated "well" because he's theirs.

Neville is definitely portrayed as smart and competent, just lacking in self-confidence and "acceptable" (flashy Hermione-style) academic gloss. For instance, nobody would have survived the underwater scene in the Tri-Wizard Tournament without his botanical knowledge.

It is a suprisingly bleak story for the target age group, in terms of some of the details and ongoing periods of misery/little hope - but I think a large part of that is the way the series kind of "grows up" with the readers, progressing in complexity with each book. It wouldn't have been as effective or successful or realistic if it were happier. And there is a lot of happiness/relief for Harry throughout - he always has his unbreakable friendships, Sirius, Dumbledore, the Order, etc. And (spoiler alert) a happy ending - for those who like that sort of thing.

Going to be pernickety here but in the book Dobby gave Harry the Gillyweed not Neville

Weefreetiffany · 06/08/2023 12:34

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 06/08/2023 12:26

Yes - but my point was that him being a Horcrux is irrelevant to why the Dursleys treated him badly. They treated him badly because he was the child of magical parents and the Dursleys are terrified of magic. Petunia is probably also scared because magic took Lily away to a Hogwarts and (in her eyes) ultimately got her killed by Voldemort.

If Harry being a Horcrux was the reason the Dursleys treated him badly, why didn't that translate to Hogwarts and his friendships? The only time Ron and Hermione were shown to be impacted by a Horcrux was when they were wearing it and trying to destroy it.

When Harry spends a lot of time with Ron one on one, Ron becomes quite the little dickhead. The same happens to Hermione to a lesser degree. Likewise all the boys in the same dorm get moody, which we pass off as teenage angst, but if you reframe that they’re being affected by Harry the horcrux.

The Dursley’s started from a position of hating/envying Harry, his family and magic. Whereas his friends started from a place of like and awe. Which could explain why the Dursley’s were more negatively affected than his peers.

I realised this rereading the books as an adult.

Kabbalah · 06/08/2023 12:33

I read the first one over Christmas because there was so much hype about it at the time. It burnt well on the fire.

Supernova23 · 06/08/2023 12:33

I'm more disturbed by adults that like Harry Potter.

Highdaysandholidays1 · 06/08/2023 12:32

I would find reading any of the books difficult as they are not well-written.

I do like the world of HP in the films and we have been rewatching them- and there are lots of eyebrow-raising stuff that seems horrific if you step back, but take part of a magical world so we kind of accept them.

The worst for me is Dobby- Dobby is an indentured slave who abuses and harms themselves when they feel they have done something wrong- Dobby irons his hands at one point as he's done something he feels is terrible and holds the bandaged arms up to show HP. My teens eyes nearly popped out of their heads at this- we are now much more aware of self-harm and it seemed odd in a children's movie.

Other issues: lack of safeguarding at Hogwarts, we are told that evil is coming into the school and the adults can't do much about it, so gathering the children there makes them sitting ducks. The adults do this repeatedly in each film whilst looking vaguely concerned!

HP's abuse by the Dursleys is also included, although JKR rights this wrong by having bad things happen to Dudley and his family.

It's all quite awful if you apply reality laws to it- but it's not reality, it's a fantasy magic world and good and evil have to be part of that (I could have done without the Dobby self-harm though).

Weefreetiffany · 06/08/2023 12:29

Lol love how everyone is suddenly a literary critic with a phd in literary analysis and senior editorship as soon as it comes to criticising one of the most bought, borrowed and read series in the world. The lack of “quality” certainly hasn’t held it back, but by all means tell us all the problems you’ve spotted.

Just like the people who seem really proud of rolling their eyes at someone having an emotional response to a book they read as a kid while reading it with the life experience of an adult.

At times mumsnet really seems to bring out the emotionless sociopaths.

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 06/08/2023 12:28

beetr00 · 06/08/2023 12:22

That's the one Grin

LadyBird1973 · 06/08/2023 12:28

I really enjoyed Casual Vacancy. It was a hard read though.

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 06/08/2023 12:26

TeenDivided · 06/08/2023 11:58

Isn't the point more that for the plot to work he has to be treated badly and this want to leave on his 17th birthday?

In the same way that Harry & Ron don't read 'Hogwarts, A history' so that Hermione can explain to them, and thus the reader, all the info they need to know.

Yes - but my point was that him being a Horcrux is irrelevant to why the Dursleys treated him badly. They treated him badly because he was the child of magical parents and the Dursleys are terrified of magic. Petunia is probably also scared because magic took Lily away to a Hogwarts and (in her eyes) ultimately got her killed by Voldemort.

If Harry being a Horcrux was the reason the Dursleys treated him badly, why didn't that translate to Hogwarts and his friendships? The only time Ron and Hermione were shown to be impacted by a Horcrux was when they were wearing it and trying to destroy it.

CherryCokeFanatic · 06/08/2023 12:26

I think you need to toughen up a bit