Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rereading Harry Potter as an adult and finding it difficult

283 replies

Dasisr · 06/08/2023 10:41

Obsessed with Harry Potter as a teenager but finding it a difficult read as an adult. How badly he is treated by the Dursleys. How deprived of love he was and in later books how he was kept away from his friends/family. All the death of loved ones he had to witness. Honestly finding it tough to get through. AIBU or anyone else the same?

OP posts:
DyslexicPoster · 06/08/2023 14:15

I don't like the way OP has been mocked for being absorbed by the book. That's what a good book does surely? On a non PhD level? Surely no one should need a literature PhD to enjoy a book?

Also saying its a good reason to go work with deprived children? Come on, I work with very vulnerable children and it moves me does that mean they are not worthy of my emotions? Are they a stepping stone for something really worthy of provoking an emotion? Do I need to see deeper, more meaningful trauma? I think not.

Some people cry and get deeply upset at seeing kittens die, some people watch child porn for the criminal justice system. It's not a educational path to righteousness. Once you have seen and felt every horror of this world is your opinion valid. To truly reach the highest level surely you need to inflict and enjoy it? It's not like that though is it?

BrightYellowDaffodil · 06/08/2023 14:12

The Dursleys didn’t hate Harry because he was a Horcrux, else you’d have seen other references throughout the novels to those who mysteriously didn’t like Harry/his company.

Petunia hated magic because she hadn’t been able to go to Hogwarts but Lily did. As a PP said, not only did Lily get to be “special” by going to a magical school and learning to do magic, but her involvement with the wizarding world was what ultimately killed her. Then she and Vernon had to bring up Harry who was either a constant reminder and/or seen as an unreasonable burden. They tried to squash the magic out of him, either in the hope that it wouldn’t arrive on their doorstep and “out” them as weird to their (presumably) equally small-minded neighbours, or perhaps - if I’m being charitable - to try and keep Harry away from the wizarding world to protect him.

Dumbledore left Harry with the Dursleys so that he would be protected by his blood family and so that he didn’t grow up famous.

OP, how about a nice bit of Thomas Hardy?

SummaLuvin · 06/08/2023 14:02

Purplebunnie · 06/08/2023 12:35

Going to be pernickety here but in the book Dobby gave Harry the Gillyweed not Neville

and how has no-one picked up on this gem

nobody would have survived the underwater scene in the Tri-Wizard Tournament without his botanical knowledge.

like really, the poster honestly thinks the schools would have drowned teenage contestants and their loved ones!!! Harry just would have faced public embarrassment at being unprepared and unable to compete.

LeonardCohensRaincoat · 06/08/2023 13:58

On a slightly different note, does anyone miss the days of childhood where you were completely absorbed in a book’s magical world ?

I would read constantly and I just loved it - I loved the stories, I loved the ‘worlds’, the characters, the events and all the unusual things that existed but I think mostly it was the agency of the main characters - how they encountered a difficulty, knew they had to do something, felt fearful but did it anyway. I always felt those books were somehow instructional for the real world.

I also think that the focus on criticism here is a bit misaligned - there is no point looking for holes in a story about wizards and magic - the whole point is that it’s a fictitious world, but are the events plausible within that world, do the characters act consistently within the plot? This is literary criticism, to me

I do remember thinking at the time they were written for film, not reading - they are, imv, badly written and as someone else said, entirely forgettable once read (although the volume is huge)

ZenNudist · 06/08/2023 13:56

There's huge tracts of it that are dull but the central story is good and she builds suspense at the end of each book.

midsomermurderess · 06/08/2023 13:53

‘People are entitled to their own opinions‘. Yes they are. And other people are entitled to say that those opinions are silly, ill-founded, nonsense, not worthy of notice.

RaraRachael · 06/08/2023 13:46

I read the first one as my daughter raved about all of them. I really struggled to finish it and couldn't bring myself to read any of the others. Far too long and just didn't hold my interest.

I'm the same with the Robert Galbraith books - tried and failed to read a couple of them yet FiL raves and says they're so well written. I enjoy the TV adaptations though.

Charrington · 06/08/2023 13:41

I find most children’s literature, all of the Disney catelogue of movies very difficult as an adult.

I think it’s a combination of life experience, but also the unprecedented rapid cultural changes over the last 150 years.

My dc were shocked at the start of Malory Towers and disinclined to continue reading about a school with so much nastiness and bullying in the opening chapter. As a child it didn’t occur to me to sympathise with Gwen because she, and her mother, were committing the terrible sin of failing to conform and socially mask. Those expectations have diminished drastically in the meantime.

One of the things I like about HP is that the series opens as a light hearted tale with cartoonish villains and abuse. But each subsequent book gets more difficult and nuanced. But JKR’s initial audience grew up between books too. It’s one of the reasons I didn’t let my dc read the whole lot. We did the first three. Waited a few years to test the waters with book 4. And then held off again until they were a bit more mature for the last three. I know it’s fashionable on MN to declare that little darling read the whole series at the age of 5 though.

I think that there is enormous value in emotionally challenging children’s literature (although I’d happily bin the nasty creepy Dahl stuff)

Dibbydoos · 06/08/2023 13:34

All HP fans have a huge soft spot for Harry. His life was so difficult, but he is resilient. That is what sets him apart and honestly, all heroes.

He gets through it inspite of everything.

To whoever said its not real.life - the magic might not be, but don't for one second think this doesn't happen in real.life. there are far too many examples of kids being brought up in worse situations than Harry 😞

NetZeroZealot · 06/08/2023 13:33

I struggle to read it because it's so badly written.

Pontiouspilate · 06/08/2023 13:22

It’s a running joke in our house that 90% of films about children start with the parent/s dying. If you went by films you’d be astonished by the amount of orphans out there

pikkumyy77 · 06/08/2023 13:22

You can’t help but grow, OP, and your ability to lose yourself in a particular made up world is bound to change. I used to read certain books over snd over. Then, suddenly, I found I couldn’t lose myself in them in the same way again. Its not wrong or right, or due to creeping political correctness, or because of the “woke mind virus” or JKR phobia. Its just a natural part of close reading, time, and personal evolution. You have had more experiences and some of them make specific scenes in the book more real, or painful, or annoying than when you were young. My youngest daughter used to play “having pneumonia” with her friends when she was a toddler. All great fun until she was rushed to the hospital and stayed four days with it. She was quite bitter about it after “I thought it would be fun! Its not!” Sometimes we know too much to enjoy a fictional account.

Qilin · 06/08/2023 13:21

Kabbalah · 06/08/2023 12:33

I read the first one over Christmas because there was so much hype about it at the time. It burnt well on the fire.

Do you burn all books you don't enjoy?
The charity shop would have been a much better place for an unwanted book. Let someone else enjoy it rather than the waste and description of a book.

pollykitty · 06/08/2023 13:17

10HailMarys · 06/08/2023 11:11

What other books have you read as an adult? Have you never read books where bad things happen to people?

I wouldn’t recommend you try A Little Life.

I just snorted tea everywhere. Such an amazing yet horrific read. i saw there’s a play now. I was like WHO THE FCK WANTS TO SEE THAT. And it’s honestly one of my favorite books.

Cosycover · 06/08/2023 13:15

Weefreetiffany · 06/08/2023 12:34

When Harry spends a lot of time with Ron one on one, Ron becomes quite the little dickhead. The same happens to Hermione to a lesser degree. Likewise all the boys in the same dorm get moody, which we pass off as teenage angst, but if you reframe that they’re being affected by Harry the horcrux.

The Dursley’s started from a position of hating/envying Harry, his family and magic. Whereas his friends started from a place of like and awe. Which could explain why the Dursley’s were more negatively affected than his peers.

I realised this rereading the books as an adult.

Nah mega over reaching here.
Harry being a horcrux didn't affect anyone else. Ever.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 06/08/2023 13:15

Some adult readers seem to have very poor comprehension skills. Yes, Neville is described as plump and is bullied and mistreated. But we are very obviously meant to like Neville and dislike his bullies. Harry et al are largely actively nice to Neville and encourage him to stand up for himself and value himself. Plus he turns out to be a brave hero!

OriginalBliss · 06/08/2023 13:15

greglet · 06/08/2023 13:12

@NooNakedJacuzziness I’ve just finished A Little Life. Enjoyed it to begin with but it quickly devolved into a self-indulgent bore fest. We were repeatedly told how brilliant the main character was but all we ever saw was him being a self-deprecating whingebag. I found it really hard to believe he'd inspire such slavish loyalty, tragic childhood or not.

That is a monumentally bad novel, though I think the misery porn is more problematic than the borefest element. It read like an overextended hurt/comfort fanfic which was trying to maintain the reader's interest by dangling the promise of more and more graphically-written voyeurism on child abuse, rape, self-harm etc to come, and then having to outdo itself again and again.

Qilin · 06/08/2023 13:13

Lilyhatesjaz · 06/08/2023 11:47

What I found hard about Harry Potter is the extent to which so much of the same thing is rewritten into each book they virtually all start the same I thought they were over long.

They were books aimed at children and most children like familiarity and some repeated aspects on the things they watch and read.

DeeCee77 · 06/08/2023 13:13

Xylophonearexylophones · 06/08/2023 11:39

This is such a lazy take, and not at all accurate. The Dursley males are fat because they are gluttons; overfed by Petunia as a token of her love. Nothing is too much for her beloved Vernon and Dudley. Harry, on the other hand, is left with just crumbs.

And, as others have said, Neville is a much loved character and one that JKR does flesh out in more detail than most.

Also, the biggest baddies in the series (Draco, Bellatrix, and, of course, Voldemort) aren’t fat at all.

Silly thing to say.

That's true.

Some overweight characters in HP are villains, some are good...in contrast with Dahl where they are invariably the former.

The aunties in James and the Giant Peach...my God when I saw the dinner table scene of Aunt Marge in Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkhaban ("you boy, clean this up"), I had serious deja vu.

greglet · 06/08/2023 13:12

@NooNakedJacuzziness I’ve just finished A Little Life. Enjoyed it to begin with but it quickly devolved into a self-indulgent bore fest. We were repeatedly told how brilliant the main character was but all we ever saw was him being a self-deprecating whingebag. I found it really hard to believe he'd inspire such slavish loyalty, tragic childhood or not.

Qilin · 06/08/2023 13:09

Notbeinfunnehbut · 06/08/2023 11:11

The way in which JK Rowling writes about overweight people aswell 🙄

they are either evil - Dudley , Vernon etc

or a bit dim- Neville

Dudley isn't evil - his easily led and a product of his parents and upbringing. In the final book you see him turning a corner from this when he says goodbye to Harry when they go off to be protected.

There's also the issue that Harry has a horcrux within him - this will make those around him struggle perhaps. Some are more affected by others. Though obviously there is some deep seated fear and mistrust of magic/wizards by the Dursleys due to Lily and Snape in their childhoods.

Neville also isn't dim. He's forgetful and shown as being quite young initially. But as he grows up he isn't portrayed as dim through the books, and ends up as one of the heroes more than once.

bruffin · 06/08/2023 13:07

@TeenDivided
It was broken in the Battle of Department of Ministries and it is commented that his new wand is probably one of the last wands Ollivander sold

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 06/08/2023 13:03

MasterBeth · 06/08/2023 11:07

I struggled with reading it to the kids because it is so clumsily written.

I actually enjoyed reading it out loud to DS more than when I read it in my 20s. There was also lots to talk about in terms of characters and foreshadowing etc.

OP - YANBU. Not sure why so many people thing YABU. Books (and films, music etc) can be upsetting, Grave of the Fireflies left me feeling sad for days, in Harry Potter I cried when Dobby died (book and film), Watership Down when Hazel dies (book, film, & song). I was crying watching Guardians of the Galaxy vol 3 last night.

TeenDivided · 06/08/2023 13:00

bruffin · 06/08/2023 12:51

In the film it was Neville , in the books it was Dobby

Neville is no good at magic because he is not using his own wand, it was his father's wand and not one he chose. Once he got his own wand after his father's is broken he flourishes at magic

Ooh, I don't remember that bit about Neville's wand. When did that occur?

TeenDivided · 06/08/2023 12:59

Polik · 06/08/2023 12:55

While discussing gillyweed, can I mention the Triwizards Contest as a pointless addition to plot progression?

Every time I re-read book 4 it makes me annoyed.

Doesn't Harry winning it mean he gives the money to Fred and George to start their joke shop, this meaning they have access to some clever bits of kit when they break into the Ministry?

It also introduces Fleur who later marries into the Weasley family, whereby we learn about the Goblins' view on treasure etc.

(Personally it was the Quidditch in that book that got me.)

Swipe left for the next trending thread