Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rereading Harry Potter as an adult and finding it difficult

283 replies

Dasisr · 06/08/2023 10:41

Obsessed with Harry Potter as a teenager but finding it a difficult read as an adult. How badly he is treated by the Dursleys. How deprived of love he was and in later books how he was kept away from his friends/family. All the death of loved ones he had to witness. Honestly finding it tough to get through. AIBU or anyone else the same?

OP posts:
Twyford · 06/08/2023 14:52

Notbeinfunnehbut · 06/08/2023 11:42

It’s not a lazy take people are entitled to their own opinions

But people are not entitled to their own facts.

JFDIYOLO · 06/08/2023 14:50

I remember being horrified by the fate of the children from the chronicles of Narnia. So I only read The Last Battle once, the others countless times.

I've just finished reading every HP book aloud to my partner. Doing all the voices. We got them as they came out and this is the only time we've ever immersed in them as one whole arc. Really enjoyed it, with some thoughts. I think JK would have benefited from the guiding hand of an editor in the later gas giants. The earlier books are tighter and more controlled. Long long passages of exposition and story dead ends like Hagrid, Maxime and the giants sometimes dull and weigh down the inventiveness and the energy.

Now we're watching a film a day and marvelling watching the children grow up and realising just how much had to be cut to create a film script.

If a TV series is ever made the long form option could be very interesting.

SpidersAreShitheads · 06/08/2023 14:49

I think there’s nothing wrong with enjoying HP books, or any other book aimed at teens. Or adults.

Reading is all about being immersed in a fictional world - almost like dipping your head into a Pensieve and entering another person’s thoughts!

Reading is magical. It doesn’t have to be literary heavyweight to be enjoyable.

We don’t all have to like the same books. That’s fine. What moves me to tears might leave you cold. And that’s partly to do with the writing but it’s also because we all experience books - and films - through the lens of our own life.

Central trends like loss, abandonment, grief, abuse affect us all differently.

Guardians of the Galaxy is a great comedy film but fuck me, those opening couples of minutes with his mum……I cry every time.

My children laugh at me as I’m regularly found wailing “why do they have to always kill the mum off?!”

I don’t understand people mocking the OP. Surely you have felt moved by a fictional book? Or if you’re not a big reader, a fictional film??

Art and literature explores very real themes which can be hard emotionally - even if they are wrapped up with wizards, house elves and butter beer!

LaMaG · 06/08/2023 14:48

If the room of requirement changes according to who needs it the most desperately how on earth did a kid die in there? The room could have opened an exit at any time. And he was a student too. This blows my mind!

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 06/08/2023 14:48

Dragonwindow · 06/08/2023 14:40

Oh absolutely, Neville is a true hero. Don't forget, he could easily have become "the chosen one". But his character arc is such that he grows into this hero from an unfortunate, clumsy, feckless, chubby little boy. The "chubby" is totally unnecessary 🤷‍♀️

Lots of kids are chubby and then lose weight as they get older. I don't think his weight was meant to be seen as a negative characteristic - in the same way that it wasn't negative for Molly Weasley.

ChronicallyUnhappy · 06/08/2023 14:44

SmokyForTheWin · 06/08/2023 11:06

I have serious concerns about safeguarding at Hogwarts. Is there a magical Ofsted?

Why was Dumbledore never investigated for how many children died or were seriously injured at that school????

Why was Snape never done for child abuse????

Why did no one find it odd that that old man put a secret chamber in the little girl’s bathrooms?!?!

Limth · 06/08/2023 14:41

Absolutely don't try reading "My Dark Vanessa", "What I Loved", "The People in the Trees" or "A Little Life"

Or any Dickens

Or any decent adult literary fiction come to think of it.

Dragonwindow · 06/08/2023 14:40

SapphireSeptember · 06/08/2023 14:18

Yup! Him, Luna and Ginny are referred to as the 'silver trio' by the fandom and were running resistance at Hogwarts after it was taken over by Voldemort. He also went off to the Ministry of Magic without a second thought in Order of the Phoenix. He pulled the sword of Gryffindor out of the sorting hat during the final battle, only a true Gryffindor can do that.

Oh absolutely, Neville is a true hero. Don't forget, he could easily have become "the chosen one". But his character arc is such that he grows into this hero from an unfortunate, clumsy, feckless, chubby little boy. The "chubby" is totally unnecessary 🤷‍♀️

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 06/08/2023 14:40

Dragonwindow · 06/08/2023 14:36

I find this hard as well. When Dudley is out on a diet, and we as readers are meant to gleefully celebrate that he's only allowed grapefruit whereas skinny Harry is allowed to enjoy cake and sweets (in secret, from his friends).

I understand that Dudley is a nasty piece of work, but I hate the narrative that skinny people deserve treats (the students at Hogwarts are always merrily tucking into feasts) but useless, lazy fat people deserve nothing.

I don't think this is meant to be about weight. It's about the fact that Dudley is described as greedy and unpleasant and we're meant to laugh at him suffering because he can't have the stuff he's used to (sweets, cake, unlimited food).

As has been said loads of times, lots of other characters are described as overweight and none of them are unpleasant or evil people. Molly, Neville, Professor Sprout and Hagrid are the obvious ones, though I'm sure there are others.

Lifeomars · 06/08/2023 14:40

10HailMarys · 06/08/2023 11:11

What other books have you read as an adult? Have you never read books where bad things happen to people?

I wouldn’t recommend you try A Little Life.

I read very widely, fiction and non-fiction on all sorts of themes and topics. I was intrigued by the premise of "A Little Life" and read lots of reviews. That helped me decide that it was possibly not for me. What are your thoughts? I do sometimes think I ought to attempt it

MargaretThursday · 06/08/2023 14:38

I don't think the books are brilliantly written. The first two don't flow as easily as I'd expect from a published author, and the fourth onwards suffer from not enough editing as they tried to get them out quickly not to lose the momentum.
The third is imo by far the best writing. I wish that she'd had the luxury of being able to take her time on the others, but I guess then probably none of us would have heard of her.

Her big talent is her imagination, much like Enid Blyton. The little bits she has, the side additions to the main plot are fantastic.

I agree with the comparisons to Dahl in a lot of ways. I'm not terribly keen on Dahl but the similarity to me is that they go OTT at times, taking it into the realms of silliness. Some children love that, I always found it too much. For example Dudley's school uniform in the first book. I can't remember the exact description, but it's so dreadful there's no way a school would have that. To my mind it would have been better if it had been dreadful but plausible. Perhaps I'd put it in the category of cheap laughs.

For me the child abuse comes across as too much. Fine have him under the stairs, unloved. But his aunt and uncle are all about the look. There is absolutely no way they'd have risked anyone saying they treated him badly. It would have been "oh my darling, poor nephew who we are so generous taking in for not a scrap of money, but we wouldn't take any money because we love him so much..." in front of others, and basking in how everyone thinks they're wonderful.
And it was so extreme that there's no way schools wouldn't have picked up on it by the time Harry was 10yo-especially the difference in the way Harry and Dudley are treated. I'm sure parents would have commented too.

Dragonwindow · 06/08/2023 14:36

Notbeinfunnehbut · 06/08/2023 11:11

The way in which JK Rowling writes about overweight people aswell 🙄

they are either evil - Dudley , Vernon etc

or a bit dim- Neville

I find this hard as well. When Dudley is out on a diet, and we as readers are meant to gleefully celebrate that he's only allowed grapefruit whereas skinny Harry is allowed to enjoy cake and sweets (in secret, from his friends).

I understand that Dudley is a nasty piece of work, but I hate the narrative that skinny people deserve treats (the students at Hogwarts are always merrily tucking into feasts) but useless, lazy fat people deserve nothing.

Bromptotoo · 06/08/2023 14:35

SmokyForTheWin · 06/08/2023 11:06

I have serious concerns about safeguarding at Hogwarts. Is there a magical Ofsted?

I always thought the Dolores Umbridge character was a piss take on Offsted and all it stood for...

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 06/08/2023 14:32

luckylavender · 06/08/2023 14:28

Is Neville overweight?

Yes - he's described as chubby with a round face. He's also blonde in the books.

luckylavender · 06/08/2023 14:28

Notbeinfunnehbut · 06/08/2023 11:11

The way in which JK Rowling writes about overweight people aswell 🙄

they are either evil - Dudley , Vernon etc

or a bit dim- Neville

Is Neville overweight?

AccountCreateUsername · 06/08/2023 14:25

I’ve reread and rewatched them many times over the years. They’re comforting and the way that love and strength of character triumphs evil is a beautiful and hopeful message. I think JK is absolutely amazing.

greglet · 06/08/2023 14:23

@OriginalBliss Yes I agree with that analysis. And actually, if you were reading it hoping for increasingly graphic misery porn, you'd probably end up disappointed because, apart from a brief section in the middle, there wasn't a huge amount of explicit content - so the author managed to overpromise and underdeliver in a really crass way.

Whiskyinajar · 06/08/2023 14:23

Supernova23 · 06/08/2023 12:33

I'm more disturbed by adults that like Harry Potter.

I'm disturbed by anyone that judgemental.

Still, you do you and those of us with a wider perspective can get on enjoying books whoever they are aimed at

JudgeJ · 06/08/2023 14:23

readbooksdrinktea · 06/08/2023 11:10

Never read Oliver Twist.

Or any of the fairy tales with their original meanings, Sleeping Beauty especially, it wasn't a kiss he woke her with! Many children's stories have their origins in some dark places which is why they're not fit for adult perusal!

SapphireSeptember · 06/08/2023 14:21

Supernova23 · 06/08/2023 12:33

I'm more disturbed by adults that like Harry Potter.

What's wrong with liking Harry Potter? I still enjoy reading Heidi, The Little Princess, The Secret Garden and the Anne of Green Gables series. Is that disturbing too?

JudgeJ · 06/08/2023 14:20

SmokyForTheWin · 06/08/2023 11:06

I have serious concerns about safeguarding at Hogwarts. Is there a magical Ofsted?

Isn't all Ofsted make-believe?

DeeCee77 · 06/08/2023 14:18

Charrington · 06/08/2023 13:41

I find most children’s literature, all of the Disney catelogue of movies very difficult as an adult.

I think it’s a combination of life experience, but also the unprecedented rapid cultural changes over the last 150 years.

My dc were shocked at the start of Malory Towers and disinclined to continue reading about a school with so much nastiness and bullying in the opening chapter. As a child it didn’t occur to me to sympathise with Gwen because she, and her mother, were committing the terrible sin of failing to conform and socially mask. Those expectations have diminished drastically in the meantime.

One of the things I like about HP is that the series opens as a light hearted tale with cartoonish villains and abuse. But each subsequent book gets more difficult and nuanced. But JKR’s initial audience grew up between books too. It’s one of the reasons I didn’t let my dc read the whole lot. We did the first three. Waited a few years to test the waters with book 4. And then held off again until they were a bit more mature for the last three. I know it’s fashionable on MN to declare that little darling read the whole series at the age of 5 though.

I think that there is enormous value in emotionally challenging children’s literature (although I’d happily bin the nasty creepy Dahl stuff)

That "nasty creepy stuff" is life, and Dahl does it better than anyone.

Quote from American novelist Bret Easton Ellis on James and the Giant Peach:

"It changed my life. My aunt read it to me, my sisters and my three cousins in two sittings over vacation at a beach house when I was about six. The idea that the world was meaner, crueller, more absurd and fantastical than anything that picture books had previously showed me made a real impact. That was the moment I couldn’t go back [as a reader]".

JKR is a great writer in her own right, but being viewed as an heir to Dahl was a somewhat overblown claim.

LimeCheesecake · 06/08/2023 14:18

Interesting to see this today - earlier I saw a tweet by a comedy writer who’d just rewatched Four Weddings and a Funeral and posted that the funeral scene when first watched as a young man seemed a good plot device, as an older man, hit hard. I guess having the experience of being the age of having been in long term relationships the loss was easier to emphasise with (esp as the gay couple who at the time were unable to marry)

j can see why as a parent, you would suddenly see this is a story with an abused child at the centre would be tough to read.

SapphireSeptember · 06/08/2023 14:18

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 06/08/2023 13:15

Some adult readers seem to have very poor comprehension skills. Yes, Neville is described as plump and is bullied and mistreated. But we are very obviously meant to like Neville and dislike his bullies. Harry et al are largely actively nice to Neville and encourage him to stand up for himself and value himself. Plus he turns out to be a brave hero!

Yup! Him, Luna and Ginny are referred to as the 'silver trio' by the fandom and were running resistance at Hogwarts after it was taken over by Voldemort. He also went off to the Ministry of Magic without a second thought in Order of the Phoenix. He pulled the sword of Gryffindor out of the sorting hat during the final battle, only a true Gryffindor can do that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread