Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rereading Harry Potter as an adult and finding it difficult

283 replies

Dasisr · 06/08/2023 10:41

Obsessed with Harry Potter as a teenager but finding it a difficult read as an adult. How badly he is treated by the Dursleys. How deprived of love he was and in later books how he was kept away from his friends/family. All the death of loved ones he had to witness. Honestly finding it tough to get through. AIBU or anyone else the same?

OP posts:
SpidersAreShitheads · 06/08/2023 18:27

Tanaria · 06/08/2023 18:15

You can still get absorbed in a book's magical system as an adult :) May I recommend Brandon Sanderson's Mistborn series as a good start? A different magic system, but so well-written!

@Tanaria - oooh! I hadn't heard of this series!! I've just had a quick google and it looks fabulous - thank you so much for the recommendation!

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 06/08/2023 18:19

It's not that being fat makes them unfortunate/unpleasant, or vice versa, it's just that the two things nearly always seem to go hand in hand.

But this ignores the fact that almost all the leading "evil" characters are skinny @Dragonwindow.

Off the top of my head - Voldemort, Bellatrix, Lucius Malfoy, Barty Crouch Jr, Snape, Dumbledore (who's not as nice as he first appeared), Igor Karkaroff - all skinny and arguably much more sinister and unpleasant than Dudley Dursley and Millicent Bulstrode.

Tanaria · 06/08/2023 18:15

LeonardCohensRaincoat · 06/08/2023 13:58

On a slightly different note, does anyone miss the days of childhood where you were completely absorbed in a book’s magical world ?

I would read constantly and I just loved it - I loved the stories, I loved the ‘worlds’, the characters, the events and all the unusual things that existed but I think mostly it was the agency of the main characters - how they encountered a difficulty, knew they had to do something, felt fearful but did it anyway. I always felt those books were somehow instructional for the real world.

I also think that the focus on criticism here is a bit misaligned - there is no point looking for holes in a story about wizards and magic - the whole point is that it’s a fictitious world, but are the events plausible within that world, do the characters act consistently within the plot? This is literary criticism, to me

I do remember thinking at the time they were written for film, not reading - they are, imv, badly written and as someone else said, entirely forgettable once read (although the volume is huge)

You can still get absorbed in a book's magical system as an adult :) May I recommend Brandon Sanderson's Mistborn series as a good start? A different magic system, but so well-written!

stuckdownahole · 06/08/2023 18:07

I think the other aspect of Neville's cluelessness is that although he loves his grandmother and vice versa, he's frightened of her. He's anxious about getting things wrong and is in a permanent semi-panic.

AppleKatie · 06/08/2023 18:00

Absolutely Neville is depicted as effectively worse off than an orphan.

when he is younger he loses things and forgets things - I always put that down to him being immature and lacking in parental guidance (after all hogwarts kids do have to look after themselves to quite an extraordinary degree if you think about the pastoral care on offer at school it does leave a fair amount to be desired!).

Feckless thought means: lacking initiative or strength of character; irresponsible. That he absolutely isn’t - as is shown in every book from PS onwards.

stuckdownahole · 06/08/2023 17:55

For me the bit that's impossible to get through now is the scene when Harry and friends visit Mr Weasley in the magical hospital. They bump into Neville who is visiting his parents, who are permanently brain damaged from being tortured.

As Neville goes to leave, his mother presses something into his hand. It's a piece of rubbish, an empty sweet wrapper, but he is absolutely desperate to see this as an expression of genuine parental love. Of course he's being chaperoned by his gruff old grandmother, who tells him to pull himself together. Absolutely heartbreaking.

These and other moments make you realise that several of the main characters (those who aren't schoolkids) fought in a war and are now traumatised. It's very skilfully rendered because for many of the characters their motivations are not revealed until later in the series.

garlictwist · 06/08/2023 17:46

I thought this when I reread Goodnight Mr Tom as an adult. Some really gruelling stuff that went over my head when I read it as a child.

SpidersAreShitheads · 06/08/2023 17:32

Dragonwindow · 06/08/2023 16:54

Maybe I'm forgetting some? The only other overweight characters I think of just now:

Mrs Wesley. Pleasantly plump, mumsy figure, obviously firmly a "goodie". But sometimes referred to as "dumpy".

Horace Slughorn. Pompous, weak. Grown fat from too many years stuffing down crystallised pineapple from suck-up students.

Crabbe and Goyle. Gorilla-like, stupid, oafish henchmen. See also Millicent Bullstrode who has a "large, square build" and who is a bully.

Delores Umbridge. Small and squat, like a toad.

(Hagrid? Is he overweight, or just half giant?)

It's not that being fat makes them unfortunate/unpleasant, or vice versa, it's just that the two things nearly always seem to go hand in hand.

I wouldn't necessarily view all of those descriptions as fat though?

A square build, for example, could be muscular and powerful. Bullies would obviously be large and intimidating because they'd need to be able to overpower their target, if needed. But large doesn't mean fat?

There are other witches/wizards who are described in less than flattering terms - like Professor Sprout who is dumpy but also described as extremely maternal and loyal.

Also, lots of the unpleasant characters in the book are thin and bony - Filch, Snape, Bellatrix, Voldemort etc.

I think too much significance is being placed on the weight of the characters. In many cases it's just a physical descriptor, nothing more. There are just as many unpleasant thin characters as there are fat characters, arguably more!

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 06/08/2023 17:27

There are lots of reasons why Harry Potter became a global phenomenon, but the quality of the prose really isn't one of them.

True, because most people don't read children's books (or indeed adults' books!) looking for immaculately-crafted prose. The story, the characters and the world-building are the main attractions in HP. The prose is appropriate to the book and its intended audience (and to many who were a lot older than its intended audience).

MasterBeth · 06/08/2023 17:10

Soontobe60 · 06/08/2023 17:08

That’s why its a worldwide best seller 😂

There are lots of reasons why Harry Potter became a global phenomenon, but the quality of the prose really isn't one of them.

MasterBeth · 06/08/2023 17:09

Pufflebow · 06/08/2023 17:03

No when I read the books as a child I was aware being locked in a cupboard or repeated murder attempts weren’t ideal

Lots of would be best selling authors here too, who knew MN was so full of literary talent

Wow, do you really believe you can't have an opinion on a book you've read unless you've written one that's sold as many copies?

Soontobe60 · 06/08/2023 17:08

MasterBeth · 06/08/2023 11:07

I struggled with reading it to the kids because it is so clumsily written.

That’s why its a worldwide best seller 😂

FrivolousTreeDuck · 06/08/2023 17:08

Pufflebow · 06/08/2023 17:03

No when I read the books as a child I was aware being locked in a cupboard or repeated murder attempts weren’t ideal

Lots of would be best selling authors here too, who knew MN was so full of literary talent

Are you saying that no one is allowed to criticise anything unless they could do it the same or better?

"I don't much like that house I've just viewed - not allowed to say that unless I am a builder"
"Not keen on those M&S T-shirts - not allowed to say that unless I'm a clothes designer".

Pufflebow · 06/08/2023 17:03

No when I read the books as a child I was aware being locked in a cupboard or repeated murder attempts weren’t ideal

Lots of would be best selling authors here too, who knew MN was so full of literary talent

OriginalBliss · 06/08/2023 17:02

MasterBeth · 06/08/2023 16:59

Jeffrey Archer, Dan Brown, Barbara Cartland, Enid Blyton... The world of publishing is full of big-selling authors whose feel for storytelling is much more advanced than their feel for prose.

That's true. Readers in general are far more forgiving of bad prose than bad plotting.

Hijinks75 · 06/08/2023 17:00

Some people are definitely mixing fact and fiction in regards to talking about health and safety etc

MasterBeth · 06/08/2023 16:59

ArseMenagerie · 06/08/2023 15:18

Clumsily written books don’t normally sell well…(with the exception of Fifty Shades of Shite)

Jeffrey Archer, Dan Brown, Barbara Cartland, Enid Blyton... The world of publishing is full of big-selling authors whose feel for storytelling is much more advanced than their feel for prose.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 06/08/2023 16:57

For the sake of my blood pressure I'm not going to click on that. I think Stuart Lee is a nasty piece of work. I used to find him funny, but his routines are all the same. He just sounds so contemptuous of everything and everybody (including the Harry Potter books, I'm assuming).

MasterBeth · 06/08/2023 16:54

maratara · 06/08/2023 15:10

These kind of comments always amuse me. Obviously you could write several of the best selling books in the history of the world but just haven't had the time to get around to it , right @MasterBeth ?

No, of course I couldn't. Where do I suggest that I could?

There are lots of reasons why Harry Potter became a global phenomenon, but the quality of the prose really isn't one of them.

Dragonwindow · 06/08/2023 16:54

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 06/08/2023 15:56

I don't know if it's my age, or a cultural shift, but it seems as though weight is less intrinsincly linked to personal attributes these days.

But it's not intrinsically so in the books either. As pp have pointed out, there are other chubby or overweight characters in the books who are not negatively viewed at all.

Dudley's horrible personal characteristics aren't to do with his weight, but both his personal characteristics and his weight are a result of the way he is brought up and treated by his parents. Dumbledore later says (paraphrasing) that the Dursleys inflicted more damage on Dudley than they did on Harry. But Dudley also has the beginnings of a character arc when he says he doesn't think Harry is a waste of space when they part ways.

Maybe I'm forgetting some? The only other overweight characters I think of just now:

Mrs Wesley. Pleasantly plump, mumsy figure, obviously firmly a "goodie". But sometimes referred to as "dumpy".

Horace Slughorn. Pompous, weak. Grown fat from too many years stuffing down crystallised pineapple from suck-up students.

Crabbe and Goyle. Gorilla-like, stupid, oafish henchmen. See also Millicent Bullstrode who has a "large, square build" and who is a bully.

Delores Umbridge. Small and squat, like a toad.

(Hagrid? Is he overweight, or just half giant?)

It's not that being fat makes them unfortunate/unpleasant, or vice versa, it's just that the two things nearly always seem to go hand in hand.

TeenDivided · 06/08/2023 16:51

Neville wasn't feckless.

tbh I always assumed he had dyspraxia, though maybe it was just his past trauma & living with his strict grandmother.

Dragonwindow · 06/08/2023 16:41

AppleKatie · 06/08/2023 16:08

Neville was never feckless Confused

Yes he was! He needed a remembrall to keep track of everything he kept on forgetting, but then he lost that when he completely ballsed up his first time ever on a broom (his grandma had never let him touch a broom before because he was so accident prone). And he couldn't hold onto poor Trevor for more than 5 minutes.

(Fwiw I'm a massive Neville fan! And of course he did show great strength of character even from when he tried to stop Harry, Ron and Hermione from sneaking out to stop "Snape" getting the Stone. But he was shown several times to be a bit useless).

maratara · 06/08/2023 16:16

FFS , she wrote some amazing books. Stories that kids and adults love and will for generations. Some of the most read books in history. JKR is not responsible for the societal view on weight. I've also heard people complaining that the female characters are not promoted enough. That it's not feminist.
The fecking book is called "Harry and the Philosopher's Stone". It's a book. The main character is a boy. Gahhhh!

AppleKatie · 06/08/2023 16:08

Neville was never feckless Confused