Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rereading Harry Potter as an adult and finding it difficult

283 replies

Dasisr · 06/08/2023 10:41

Obsessed with Harry Potter as a teenager but finding it a difficult read as an adult. How badly he is treated by the Dursleys. How deprived of love he was and in later books how he was kept away from his friends/family. All the death of loved ones he had to witness. Honestly finding it tough to get through. AIBU or anyone else the same?

OP posts:
azlazee1 · 07/08/2023 20:38

I read all the Harry Potter books as an adult and loved them. Sounds like they are not for you.

SpidersAreShitheads · 07/08/2023 19:53

This is a far better critique of JKR - I don't necessarily agree with it all, but it's not the same self-indulgent waffle as the article in the Guardian.

Interesting to note though, this critique is not of the HP books but her other work.

Anyway.

I think this reviewer has a point when he says her opening sentence could be punchier, but I disagree that it's hard to understand or confusing.

And also this comment from the review: "Later, the narrator calls the proposal “the most perfect.” What does that mean? There aren’t levels of perfection."

The reviewer is beginning to sound like a bit of an arse, tbh. It's a colloquial turn of phrase and we all know what it means. There's nothing wrong with describing something as "the most perfect" in casual dialogue as it's a phrase that many adults might use. It's a tool in establishing a tone of voice, surely?

I would say that this reviewer has succeeded in critiquing her style, but failing to identify errors, as he claims to do.

DeeCee77 · 07/08/2023 19:51

TeenDivided · 07/08/2023 06:56

I don't think it matters whether or not it is 'poor prose'. It doesn't need to be beautifully crafted with wonderful descriptive phrases or superb dialogue or whatever.
It has a cracking good plot in a wonderful world that has inspired reading in nearly 30 years of children. That's what matters.

(Though I have to say I don't really understand why parents read HP aloud to their children, I don't see the rush. Let them come to it aged 10-12 when they can read it for themselves)

Absolutely.

Is the story gripping? Is it a page turner? Does it inspire you? Questions like these are the most important ones when it comes to what books to read. My mum (a teacher) mention Dahl as being critiqued for his prose, but when it comes to capturing your imagination there are none better.

SpidersAreShitheads · 07/08/2023 19:38

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 07/08/2023 09:23

Good lord, what a pompously twatty article.

I couldn't have phrased it better myself @AllProperTeaIsTheft!

I had a browse through that critic's reviews. Almost without exception, his reviews are of serious pieces of literature. And he apparently works very hard to use the maximum amount of words to express any single thought.

His review of a children's book seems bizarrely out of place - especially when he confesses that he's writing a damning review of a book that hasn't actually been released yet, and that he's not read.

He provides scant examples of why the writing is so poor in his opinion, other than to be scathing about JKR's use of adverbs. I wonder if he's forgotten who the target audience is here? I fail to see anything wrong with her use of adverb, especially as it makes the dialogue much clearer for children.

As for other vague accusations such as plodding text, surely that's very subjective? I didn't find it to be plodding, nor overly descriptive. What I did find to be plodding and overly descriptive were his reviews. Not just the HP one, but all of his others. He seems determined to cram together a sequence of words that he thinks expresses his superior knowledge of the English language. In reality, his reviews are ponderous, lack detail, and often veer from the subject. I find him to be self-indulgent, and extremely pleased with himself - but I also accept that it's a subjective opinion that others might not share.

I enjoyed JKR's books and I disagree with a PP - you can't make a silk purse out of a sow's ear. Stephen Fry may be a marvellous orator, but if the writing was poor, the audio book would still be dire.

It doesn't really matter to me if a book is "written well" if I enjoyed it. But I was curious to find out what I had evidently missed, and so far there's nothing to objectively show that the writing is poor. It doesn't matter to me either way whether JKR's writing is good or not, I don't have any reason to defend her. But I can't see any of the accusations of poor writing have any substance other than subjective opinion.

ZombiesAreClammyDodgers · 07/08/2023 18:50

Everything is derivative of something else.

SunsetOverParadise · 07/08/2023 14:44

YeahOkWhatever · 06/08/2023 11:13

This! They are really badly written on the second read. Also, The Casual Vacancy is terrible. I couldn't even finish it and this is from a person who finished Victoria Beckham's "autobiography ". 😳

Perhaps you’ve identified your problem. You’re used to a vacuum.

A Casual Vacancy was brilliant - if you understand how local government works. Very accurate.

AmazingSnakeHead · 07/08/2023 14:21

maratara · 06/08/2023 15:10

These kind of comments always amuse me. Obviously you could write several of the best selling books in the history of the world but just haven't had the time to get around to it , right @MasterBeth ?

This comment is mad. I can't write, why does that mean I should read badly written fiction? I couldn't perform surgery, I sincerely hope that if ever I needed surgery they'd not use that a reason to give me a surgeon who can't perform surgery either.

AmazingSnakeHead · 07/08/2023 14:11

I understand OP, annoyingly I have become far more sentimental since becoming a mum. I full on sob at puff the magic dragon now, loved it as a child. But remember that these stories are important for children. It's developmentally healthy to engage with painful things via the safe medium of fiction, it teaches empathy and emotional intelligence among other things.

AppleKatie · 07/08/2023 14:11

It isn’t sneery to not like something. However, sentences like this:

It's hardly a hot take that JK Rowling is a great storyteller before she is a great wordsmith.

and

If you have to be told why the prose in Harry Potter is not great, then you aren't the kind of reader who will appreciate why the prose in Harry Potter is not great. Just read it!

Are sneery in the extreme 😂

Goatymum · 07/08/2023 14:08

I read it as an adult, I lost my parents young, and related to a lot of the ‘loss’ themes.

Twyford · 07/08/2023 14:02

MasterBeth · 07/08/2023 10:07

No, it's spot on:

If you have the patience to read it without noticing how plodding it is, then you are self-evidently someone on whom the possibilities of the English language are largely lost.

And that sums it up. If you have to be told why the prose in Harry Potter is not great, then you aren't the kind of reader who will appreciate why the prose in Harry Potter is not great. Just read it!

That quoted sentence is in itself incredibly pretentious and pompous. I'm in no way someone on whom the possibilities of the English language are lost, and for what it's worth I have the qualifications to prove it. I don't find the HP books plodding. I don't suggest JKR's style is problem-free, but the author of that article comes over as unbelievably self-satisfied and up himself. It's noteworthy that at the time he wrote the article he had only just started work on The Guardian and was probably trying to get noticed, and that his own literary career has definitely been less than sparkling.

bruffin · 07/08/2023 13:48

MasterBeth · 07/08/2023 13:41

It's clumsily written.

Stephen Fry can make the most of clumsily written text - and here he has to.

"The lady doth protest too much, methinks"

It's your opinion , but constantly repeating it doesn't make it right.

Twyford · 07/08/2023 13:45

TeenDivided · 07/08/2023 06:56

I don't think it matters whether or not it is 'poor prose'. It doesn't need to be beautifully crafted with wonderful descriptive phrases or superb dialogue or whatever.
It has a cracking good plot in a wonderful world that has inspired reading in nearly 30 years of children. That's what matters.

(Though I have to say I don't really understand why parents read HP aloud to their children, I don't see the rush. Let them come to it aged 10-12 when they can read it for themselves)

I read the first two or three books to DS just because part of his bedtime routine was me reading to him, and it was something we both enjoyed. I must say, when I discovered them I was delighted, as I didn't particularly enjoy much of what I read to him and some of it sent me to sleep quicker than it did him. But with HP I found myself wondering what happened next just as much as he did, and I remember keeping him awake longer than I should have reading the climax of Philosopher's Stone just because there was no way either of us could go to sleep not knowing. There are very few children's books that could achieve that.

As time went on, DS started reading them for himself, but I continued to read them too, sometimes before he did, because I too was hooked by then.

MasterBeth · 07/08/2023 13:41

Qilin · 07/08/2023 10:35

MasterBeth - get the audiobooks. It isn't clumsily read when it's Stephen Fry reading them.

It's clumsily written.

Stephen Fry can make the most of clumsily written text - and here he has to.

RattleRattle · 07/08/2023 13:39

This reply has been deleted

This user is a goady troll so we've removed their posts.

MasterBeth · 07/08/2023 13:38

AppleKatie · 07/08/2023 11:15

I’m halfway through Deathly Hallows having read all the preceding books aloud to my DC (I have read them all myself several times). I don’t agree that they are badly written.

I do accept that perhaps I’m just so stupid/limited I wouldn’t notice. However with 2 academic literary degrees and a 20 year teaching career behind me I do wonder if it matters? I mean just how complex and perfect does something need to be before the sneery are satisfied!?

No-one mentioned stupid or limited, did they? The claim is that the prose is plodding and functional. It doesn't sparkle. It's overly pedantic. It doesn''t need to be more complex, it needs to be less.

Also, why is it sneery to not like something. Or find it less than perfect? It's hardly a hot take that JK Rowling is a great storyteller before she is a great wordsmith.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 07/08/2023 13:31

Just reread with DS and I agree, the lack of supervision of the dursleys as adoptive parents is criminal.

Is that a criticism of the book though? Children's fiction has always been full of children being put in dangerous and unwise situations, having unrealistic amounts of autonomy or having mean or incompetent parents. Otherwise the escapades and drama wouldn't actually be able to happen and they wouldn't be able to rise above their miserable lot in life!

MasterBeth · 07/08/2023 13:27

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 07/08/2023 10:37

You can be smart and have no taste.

Smart people know that taste is a matter of opinion.

Of course... and?

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 07/08/2023 13:27

They pale into insignificance besides earlier fantasy series for younger readers, like Alan Garner's "Brisingamen" series, Ursula Leguin's "Earthstar" books, and even the Lord of the Rings books.

I love all of the above and also love Diana Wynne Jones and Susan Cooper. I don't find Potter inferior to those, just different. I don't think LotR can really be compared with the others or Potter though - it's a whole different kettle of fish and aimed at adults.

Oddly, I quite enjoyed the Coromoran Strike books, and think they're much better written.

As a JKR fan I wanted to like them,but I found the first one very dull. Not my genre really.

PansyP · 07/08/2023 11:17

Just reread with DS and I agree, the lack of supervision of the dursleys as adoptive parents is criminal.

AppleKatie · 07/08/2023 11:15

I’m halfway through Deathly Hallows having read all the preceding books aloud to my DC (I have read them all myself several times). I don’t agree that they are badly written.

I do accept that perhaps I’m just so stupid/limited I wouldn’t notice. However with 2 academic literary degrees and a 20 year teaching career behind me I do wonder if it matters? I mean just how complex and perfect does something need to be before the sneery are satisfied!?

JFDIYOLO · 07/08/2023 11:12

I was a 70s child and loved and still do love Alan Garner, Diana Wynne Jones, CS Lewis, Tolkien, Tove Jansson - all the fantasy greats.

This little girl loved battles, swordplay, monsters, horses, fantasy landscapes, magical creatures, spaceships, robots, pirates, aliens, Vikings - and this big one still does.

So when Harry came along and I was already middle aged, I jumped in and love the whole world.

I feel the earlier books are better written, tighter, less inclined to go off on a tangent.

As the series and the book size grew, I do think quantity won over quality in the writing style.

Having read the lot aloud recently, there are some interminable, clunky, exposition-heavy passages that are something of a challenge to bring to life in the later books.

But the imagination, world-building, characters, relationships etc are captivating throughout (Eng Lit grad hat on here).

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 07/08/2023 11:05

I recently reread the books and I really enjoyed all the stuff I forgot/missed the first time round. Still a fan, and can't wait for the tv show when/if it gets made. It is however clumsy in parts and I found it impossible to read it out loud to DD. However, the plot and story makes up for it.

I didn't find it upsetting, but I did find it highly frustrating (characters actions/decisions) , a lot more than I did when I first red it. Tbh, that's the sign of a good book in my eyes, the ability to still cause strong(if different) emotions even when it's a re read and you're very familiar with the plot,ending ,dynamics etc.

LakieLady · 07/08/2023 10:58

I think they're worse than "difficult", imo they're trite, derivative, shallow and dull.

They pale into insignificance besides earlier fantasy series for younger readers, like Alan Garner's "Brisingamen" series, Ursula Leguin's "Earthstar" books, and even the Lord of the Rings books.

Oddly, I quite enjoyed the Coromoran Strike books, and think they're much better written.