Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rereading Harry Potter as an adult and finding it difficult

283 replies

Dasisr · 06/08/2023 10:41

Obsessed with Harry Potter as a teenager but finding it a difficult read as an adult. How badly he is treated by the Dursleys. How deprived of love he was and in later books how he was kept away from his friends/family. All the death of loved ones he had to witness. Honestly finding it tough to get through. AIBU or anyone else the same?

OP posts:
FizzingAda · 08/08/2023 08:51

My OH was not brought up with books (I hoovered up books from childhood). When Dan Brown's book the da Vinci code came out I persuaded him to read it as it's all very very short chapters. He did so, and enjoyed it, and since then he's been reading books (he was 50 at the time). Dan Brown's writing was also slated as being very poor, but so what? It's a rattling good tale that carried you along, and it got him reading after so many years. If Harry Potter does the same for children, then great. Personally I love the books and the films.

Tidlywinks · 08/08/2023 08:39

@EscapeRoomToTheSun

That’s a silly comment. You should go into the primary schools I work in. Children still reading the novels, which are still getting kids to read (which is great whatever you think of the books) and playing Harry Potter in the playground. It is definitely not a disappearing set of novels.

JFDIYOLO · 08/08/2023 08:26

Neville got actual housepoints for bravery in film 1. He's lived with PTSD from what he witnessed, losing his parents to their torture and being bullied and belittled by his grandmother, the thing he's most afraid of, and stands up to the boggart who uses that. Joins the DA and is part of the resistance and gets to wield the sword that takes out Nagini. I think focussing on his story might have been even more interesting!

And no sorry, whoever tried it, interest in HO is not dwindling. Cursed Child is huge, the books are huge, boys especially are reading because of the books. Did you see the blind girl in ecstasy because she realised her present was a giant Braille HP and she could now read it for herself?

SophieinParis · 08/08/2023 08:16

MasterBeth · 06/08/2023 11:07

I struggled with reading it to the kids because it is so clumsily written.

Im sure it makes you feel very literary to say this, but honestly, its simply not true. There is no one way to write well. Her characters are strong, the world is rich and detailed and the narrative is well paced and full. Hence their popularity.
They are not, however, written to be read out loud. Definitely not. I think pretty much everyone I know who has attempted to read them out loud has found similar.
I don’t know your children’s ages but if they are old enough for the HP series then they should be old enough to read it to themselves.

Twyford · 08/08/2023 08:06

EscapeRoomToTheSun · 07/08/2023 23:18

Whatever you think about jk, Harry Potter is an utter piece of crap with no literary merit whatsoever. I'm glad it's falling out of favour with children.

Unfortunately for you, it isn't falling out of favour, as teachers all over the world have confirmed.

Twyford · 08/08/2023 08:01

I don't even like the films and my daughter always said it was unbelievable

Flying cars, fire-breathing dragons and turning teacups into mice are unbelievable? Give that child a medal.

110APiccadilly · 08/08/2023 08:00

I reread it while breastfeeding a newborn, so I had pretty heightened reactions to some of it. The bit that I'd forgotten about though and that really surprised me by how dark it was the treatment of the Muggle family at the beginning of Goblet of Fire.

TeenDivided · 08/08/2023 08:00

EscapeRoomToTheSun · 07/08/2023 23:18

Whatever you think about jk, Harry Potter is an utter piece of crap with no literary merit whatsoever. I'm glad it's falling out of favour with children.

What makes you say it is falling out of favour with children?
Do you have evidence for that?

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 08/08/2023 07:50

Totally agree with you. I don't believe she is a good writer. She was just at the right place when children were crying out for something different other than the traditional fiction they were use to.

That makes no sense whatsoever. There was no shortage of children's authors writing in the years before and during the time when the HP books were released. Why did none of them achieve that level of success? And what makes you say HP isn't traditional children's fiction? Because it's about magic?! Hardly unusual in children's fiction!

DdraigGoch · 08/08/2023 06:43

EscapeRoomToTheSun · 07/08/2023 23:18

Whatever you think about jk, Harry Potter is an utter piece of crap with no literary merit whatsoever. I'm glad it's falling out of favour with children.

Is that really the best argument that you can construct?

I'll take the views of 500 million people over those of a Guardian critic.

DdraigGoch · 08/08/2023 06:41

Dragonwindow · 06/08/2023 16:54

Maybe I'm forgetting some? The only other overweight characters I think of just now:

Mrs Wesley. Pleasantly plump, mumsy figure, obviously firmly a "goodie". But sometimes referred to as "dumpy".

Horace Slughorn. Pompous, weak. Grown fat from too many years stuffing down crystallised pineapple from suck-up students.

Crabbe and Goyle. Gorilla-like, stupid, oafish henchmen. See also Millicent Bullstrode who has a "large, square build" and who is a bully.

Delores Umbridge. Small and squat, like a toad.

(Hagrid? Is he overweight, or just half giant?)

It's not that being fat makes them unfortunate/unpleasant, or vice versa, it's just that the two things nearly always seem to go hand in hand.

Piers Polkiss. Dudley's right-hand man when bullying at school:

Piers was a scrawny boy with a face like a rat. He was usually the one who held people's arms behind their backs while Dudley hit them.

SheSaidHummingbird · 08/08/2023 03:33

Put the book in the freezer.

SpidersAreShitheads · 08/08/2023 03:01

Actually, whatever your view on JKR’s writing and the Harry Potter series, I’m just loving a bunch of adults arguing passionately about books.

Reading so many heartfelt views about the characters, and the rights and wrongs of the plot is just great to see.

Books were my world as a child, my coping mechanism, and they’re still my greatest pleasure. I genuinely love listening to people who are enthusiastic about books.

TheDogAndDogAtCrutchley · 08/08/2023 01:12

Uhm, no, because the entire series is fab and there are bits that are supposed to tug the heartstrings. Dude, it ain’t that dark.

SwordToFlamethrower · 08/08/2023 00:12

Notbeinfunnehbut · 06/08/2023 11:11

The way in which JK Rowling writes about overweight people aswell 🙄

they are either evil - Dudley , Vernon etc

or a bit dim- Neville

You've clearly not read the Strike Novels then... the main protagonist is 4 stone overweight and is disabled.

LadyMaryTalbotCrawleysEyebrows · 07/08/2023 23:59

AllOfThemWitches · 06/08/2023 11:09

I thought about this while watching Matilda. And also the safeguarding issue. Why did no one call Ofsted or maybe more appropriately, the police? The kids must have mentioned chokey to their parents??

Although I think Matilda was written in early 90s I have a feeling it was set in an earlier period (post war?) I could be wrong but the Quentin Blake illustrations seem to suggest not a modern school.

Mouldyfoodhelp · 07/08/2023 23:53

Personally love Harry Potter i read the series and watch the films at least once a year. It's not the greatest literary works but most things aren't.

DdraigGoch · 07/08/2023 23:51

Notbeinfunnehbut · 06/08/2023 11:11

The way in which JK Rowling writes about overweight people aswell 🙄

they are either evil - Dudley , Vernon etc

or a bit dim- Neville

Neville wasn't dim at all. He was using a wand that hadn't chosen him, which meant that it wouldn't work properly. He also lacked confidence because for his grandmother he was always in his father's shadow. Being bullied by Professor Snape didn't help. He was courageous from the start.

Notmyfandango · 07/08/2023 23:45

Every. Single. Fairytale.
FFS do you do the same for Cinderella, Snow White, Jack and the Beanstalk???
🙄❄

willstarttomorrow · 07/08/2023 23:36

So just opened this thread. It went mumsnet very quickly! Lots of people love Harry Potter including many of the disadvantaged children I work with. I snap up copies in charity shops to pass on for them to read. If it allows escapism and encourages reading you would have to be a pretty miserable, out of touch arsehole of a human being to be snobby about it. I used to read Malory Towers and the Famous Five, then as teenagers we all read Flowers in the Attic. I still managed to scrape a grade A in English Lit at A level and sometimes still read worthy, critically acclaimed stuff. But I really love well written fluff.

elliejjtiny · 07/08/2023 23:22

Forgot to add that someone (I think it was David Walliams) said that it's easier to write children's books where the adults are either dead or neglectful because that way the children can do more exciting things without being stopped from doing it by sensible adults.

EscapeRoomToTheSun · 07/08/2023 23:18

Whatever you think about jk, Harry Potter is an utter piece of crap with no literary merit whatsoever. I'm glad it's falling out of favour with children.

elliejjtiny · 07/08/2023 23:16

I find that if I read again as an adult the books that I read as a child then a lot of them are much less believable or have massive plot holes. Also tv programmes. There are hardly any parents who visit in children's ward. The secret seven boys go out at night repeatedly to solve crime while their parents never realise. And Josie Miller gets train track braces on her teeth when she is about 5 or 6!

YeahOkWhatever · 07/08/2023 23:05

SunsetOverParadise · 07/08/2023 14:44

Perhaps you’ve identified your problem. You’re used to a vacuum.

A Casual Vacancy was brilliant - if you understand how local government works. Very accurate.

Eh, it was to demonstrate that I can usually tolerate bad writing to finish a book, not sure what kind of vacuum you are referring to?
The Casual Vacancy, to me, was unreadable. A rarity as I normally plough on to the bitter end of my chosen read.

ednakenneth · 07/08/2023 21:18

Totally agree with you. I don't believe she is a good writer. She was just at the right place when children were crying out for something different other than the traditional fiction they were use to.
I don't even like the films and my daughter always said it was unbelievable

Swipe left for the next trending thread