Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rereading Harry Potter as an adult and finding it difficult

283 replies

Dasisr · 06/08/2023 10:41

Obsessed with Harry Potter as a teenager but finding it a difficult read as an adult. How badly he is treated by the Dursleys. How deprived of love he was and in later books how he was kept away from his friends/family. All the death of loved ones he had to witness. Honestly finding it tough to get through. AIBU or anyone else the same?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Papergirl1968 · 10/08/2023 20:04

I haven't read the books for some years but saw the films again recently and it struck me afresh what a great imagination JKR has, and what a wonderful message runs through the series about loyalty, the power of love and good overcoming evil. There is a powerful scene in one of the later films where the students stand shoulder to shoulder, wands raised at the sky, united in their determination to defeat a common enemy despite tremendous risk.
Harry saving his enemy Draco's life, Snape's mixed feelings for Harry - he clearly loathed him because he looks like his father but he protects him too because he loved his mother, the development of Neville from a bumbling schoolboy to a hero...characters are complex, and not black or white.
I don't think they're badly written but I do think the later books needed a darned good editing.
Oh and Daniel Radcliffe and Emma Watson were terrible actors, especially in the first few films!

NotTodaySanta · 10/08/2023 17:40

Supernova23 · 06/08/2023 12:33

I'm more disturbed by adults that like Harry Potter.

Me too. I am at hogwarts universal studios as we speak and there are a lot of hard-core fans here!

Createbeauty1 · 10/08/2023 17:38

I know what you mean OP it is amazing how we see things so differently once we get older i have this with songs books and movies i have re watched in my twenties and thought oh my goodness it wasn't the fairy-tale my mind made it to be.

greglet · 10/08/2023 16:09

@OriginalBliss was that Cassandra Clare? Or another BNF I haven't heard of?!

OriginalBliss · 09/08/2023 13:15

LylaLee · 08/08/2023 18:56

A lot of great fanfics are 'fix its' where Harry (1) is taken in by a loving family - Remus/Sirius/Weasleys/Mrs Figg/Snape or (2) where Petunia LTB and looks after Harry properly or (3) where the Dursley family is prosecuted for abuse and neglect.

So yes, op, a lot of people feel the same and have rewritten the story for a happier outcome.

Mind you, back when I was more attuned to fandoms, those stories were substantially outweighed by the numbers of angst-ridden ones where Harry and Draco were tormented lovers, or Lupin and Sirius Black like getting it together in a mildly S and M way the dungeons, or where Snape and Hermione are forced to get married in a dystopian take on the universe when the Ministry starts a pureblood eugenics programme.

There was a BNF (who later turned to writing commercial YA under her real name) with a harrowing fic where Draco is in Azkaban and Harry has to race against time to prevent him getting the Dementor's Kiss, but fails and then brings post-Kiss zombie Draco home to live with him.

Then again, there is David Cameron/Ed Miliband slash out there. People are dark. Grin

LylaLee · 08/08/2023 18:56

A lot of great fanfics are 'fix its' where Harry (1) is taken in by a loving family - Remus/Sirius/Weasleys/Mrs Figg/Snape or (2) where Petunia LTB and looks after Harry properly or (3) where the Dursley family is prosecuted for abuse and neglect.

So yes, op, a lot of people feel the same and have rewritten the story for a happier outcome.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 08/08/2023 18:47

plus there was the problem of who exactly the implied reader was -- a child? A young adult? Someone who had grown up along with the series? It's mirrored in the twee Disneyish Chris Columbus early films, and the much darker tone that Alfonso Cuarón introduced.

This is a valid point, but judging by the unusually large age range of people who have read HP (for themselves rather than, or as well as, to their children), it doesn't seem to have been a problem. My dc started reafing them about age 7, which was a bit early really, and I had to hold them back from moving onto the later ones too quickly. They re-read them multiple times into their early teens.

I still enjoy re-reading the early ones just as much as the later ones. It feels kind of vicariously nostalgic - as if you're seeing little Harry through older Harry's eyes. I was an adult when the first book was released, so I didn't grow up with them.

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 08/08/2023 17:30

There are more evil thin people overall. The vast majority of the Death Eaters( Bellatrix, werewolf dude, the Malfoys etc) for example. Even James and Sirius are quite big arseholes and Remus follows along. Tom Riddle of course. The various ministers and minister workers.Barty Crouch JR. That's just off the top of my head.

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 08/08/2023 17:20

Dragonwindow · 08/08/2023 16:55

I know there are unpleasant thin characters. But some people were saying there are "many" examples of overweight characters who are not unpleasant, but I could only think of Mrs Weasley.

I'd say there was a fairly equal amount of thin and overweight people on both sides of the spectrum, to be honest.

InsomniacsWife · 08/08/2023 17:17

Wait until you get to Dobby.... ☠️😭

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 08/08/2023 17:16

@Dragonwindow that's more to do more with your memory than the writer's intent?

Mrs Weasley
Professor Sprout
Neville
Hagrid
Madame Maxine (sorry she's big boned 😬)
The fat lady
The fat friar

And if I'm not mistaken, Helga Hufflepuff, one of the founding members is overweight as well or at least portrayed as such.

I know the actress that plays madam Rosmerta isn't overweight, but she's also not as curvy as I imagined her in my head. She's also taller .

Dragonwindow · 08/08/2023 16:55

DdraigGoch · 08/08/2023 06:41

Piers Polkiss. Dudley's right-hand man when bullying at school:

Piers was a scrawny boy with a face like a rat. He was usually the one who held people's arms behind their backs while Dudley hit them.

I know there are unpleasant thin characters. But some people were saying there are "many" examples of overweight characters who are not unpleasant, but I could only think of Mrs Weasley.

MargaretThursday · 08/08/2023 16:37

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 08/08/2023 12:15

Being hard to read out loud is not a strength.

No, it's not. I've just never encountered anyone else who said they found the books hard to read aloud. Presumably thousands if not millions of parents have read HP aloud to their children, and many teachers have probably read it to their classes. I found it a joy to read the first couple to my dc before they took over and read them independently.

I don't normally listen to fiction audiobooks except foreign ones, and have listened to some of the Potter books in several different languages as an easy, lighthearted way to keep my language knowledge ticking over. I'm happy to say that I find them just as un-clumsy in other languages, and it's fun to see how the translators have dealt with the invented vocab, place names etc.

I found the first hard to read out loud. I read daily through lots of books over a number of years and I only struggled with two books when reading out loud. I didn't for that reason read beyond the first and told ds to read the others himself if he was interested.

I'm not sure exactly why it was hard. The other book had lots of pages that were just brief dialogue:
"Mummy!"
"Really?"
"Please!"
"Are you sure..?"
"Yes."
"Okay, then."
"Thank you, mummy..."

Both stories read fine in my head, but just felt wrong reading out loud.

OriginalBliss · 08/08/2023 15:22

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 08/08/2023 12:15

Being hard to read out loud is not a strength.

No, it's not. I've just never encountered anyone else who said they found the books hard to read aloud. Presumably thousands if not millions of parents have read HP aloud to their children, and many teachers have probably read it to their classes. I found it a joy to read the first couple to my dc before they took over and read them independently.

I don't normally listen to fiction audiobooks except foreign ones, and have listened to some of the Potter books in several different languages as an easy, lighthearted way to keep my language knowledge ticking over. I'm happy to say that I find them just as un-clumsy in other languages, and it's fun to see how the translators have dealt with the invented vocab, place names etc.

I have also read them aloud to my DS and found them difficult in the mouth, though I think it's the combination of prose that is serviceable at best and the increasingly endless detail as the series moves towards its close, that makes it unpleasant to read aloud, and I always find myself wanting to cut as I go.

Enid Blyton is equally banal as a prose writer, but has a lighter touch as a world-builder, and of course wrote these short, strictly-disciplined, formulaic novels, and wrote them very rapidly. She would knock out a Famous Five novel in a week, rather than the increasingly length, complexity etc of the HP novels.

I think the HP series just changes so much as it continues, and part of the issue is JKR's disabling sense of responsibility to her own massive fan base, who just wanted more words, more detail, more backstory, more explanation of how magic concept x actually worked, so every possible pudding got over-egged, stopped working as novels, plus there was the problem of who exactly the implied reader was -- a child? A young adult? Someone who had grown up along with the series? It's mirrored in the twee Disneyish Chris Columbus early films, and the much darker tone that Alfonso Cuarón introduced.

Have also read some of them in French to my French godchildren, and wasn't keen on the French translations, either. The Irish version of Philosopher's Stone was better, I thought. I do feel a lot of affection for the series, though.

stuckdownahole · 08/08/2023 13:19

The Da Vinci Code is a bestseller for a reason - it has tremendous pace and twists. Right at the end, the author tries to wrap up the relationship between the main protagonists and it is very clumsy because he can't write people and his characters are just pawns who keep the plot moving along. But that won't stop people enjoying the book.

JKR is much better and her characters are properly fleshed out to the extent that you care about them as individuals. Yes, some of the books are overlong and the series is not aimed at an adult audience. But Lord of the Rings is also overlong with lots of pointless wordy descriptions.

I've got an English degree. I wish I could write like JKR. I wish I could write like Dan Brown. I wouldn't be embarrassed at all.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 08/08/2023 12:19

In fact I always recommend this to my older students and anyone wanting to improve or brush up on a language they know a bit of. Listening to a familiar English book whose storyline you know well is a great way to do tons of listening, improve vocab and feel for the language.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 08/08/2023 12:15

Being hard to read out loud is not a strength.

No, it's not. I've just never encountered anyone else who said they found the books hard to read aloud. Presumably thousands if not millions of parents have read HP aloud to their children, and many teachers have probably read it to their classes. I found it a joy to read the first couple to my dc before they took over and read them independently.

I don't normally listen to fiction audiobooks except foreign ones, and have listened to some of the Potter books in several different languages as an easy, lighthearted way to keep my language knowledge ticking over. I'm happy to say that I find them just as un-clumsy in other languages, and it's fun to see how the translators have dealt with the invented vocab, place names etc.

bruffin · 08/08/2023 12:14

What does it matter if you found it hard to read out loud, it was never really meant to be read out loud in the first place. They are aimed at readers of an sge thst reading independently

MasterBeth · 08/08/2023 11:57

Qilin · 08/08/2023 11:47

*It's clumsily written.

Stephen Fry can make the most of clumsily written text - and here he has to.*

You claim you found it hard to read due to it being clumsily written.

I'm pointing out that many able readers don't find that to be the case, as in the case if Stephen Fry. He reads the exact words, as written, and - having read interviews by him - as guided by JK Rowling. He doesn't add or change any of the prose, yet reads it exceptionally well with no apparent difficulty.

Yes, it's fine. You don't like it. That's allowed. To be fair - I doubt you are the target market for it anyway.

I claim (I don't claim - I did!) I found it hard to read out loud.

I am more than happy to admit that Stephen Fry is better at reading out loud than I am. Stephen Fry is one of the nation's great readers-out-loud.

"You claim to find this marathon course difficult, yet Mo Farah ran it with ease!"

Qilin · 08/08/2023 11:56

EscapeRoomToTheSun · 07/08/2023 23:18

Whatever you think about jk, Harry Potter is an utter piece of crap with no literary merit whatsoever. I'm glad it's falling out of favour with children.

Stand near most primary schools on world book day. You still see many a HP character showing up - it's not diminishing that much from what I can tell!

Qilin · 08/08/2023 11:53

EscapeRoomToTheSun · 07/08/2023 23:18

Whatever you think about jk, Harry Potter is an utter piece of crap with no literary merit whatsoever. I'm glad it's falling out of favour with children.

Is it?

I teach primary. Many of the children reach a stage where they become obsessed with it for a while ime. I haven't seen that drop.
Granted I suspect many don't buy it so much these days - I suspect lots of households already have the whole series already so no need.

Qilin · 08/08/2023 11:47

*It's clumsily written.

Stephen Fry can make the most of clumsily written text - and here he has to.*

You claim you found it hard to read due to it being clumsily written.

I'm pointing out that many able readers don't find that to be the case, as in the case if Stephen Fry. He reads the exact words, as written, and - having read interviews by him - as guided by JK Rowling. He doesn't add or change any of the prose, yet reads it exceptionally well with no apparent difficulty.

Yes, it's fine. You don't like it. That's allowed. To be fair - I doubt you are the target market for it anyway.

MasterBeth · 08/08/2023 11:40

SophieinParis · 08/08/2023 08:16

Im sure it makes you feel very literary to say this, but honestly, its simply not true. There is no one way to write well. Her characters are strong, the world is rich and detailed and the narrative is well paced and full. Hence their popularity.
They are not, however, written to be read out loud. Definitely not. I think pretty much everyone I know who has attempted to read them out loud has found similar.
I don’t know your children’s ages but if they are old enough for the HP series then they should be old enough to read it to themselves.

Her characters are strong, the world is rich and detailed and the narrative is well paced and full. Hence their popularity.

Yes. The strength is in the storytelling, not in the clumsy prose. Being hard to read out loud is not a strength.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 08/08/2023 11:07

I'm glad it's falling out of favour with children.

I fear you have been misinformed.

Caipirovska · 08/08/2023 10:56

I think harry Potter on it long journey to be a classic series more than falling in out of favour.

Dan Brown's writing was also slated as being very poor, but so what? It's a rattling good tale that carried you along, and it got him reading after so many years

I've seen Agatha Christie writing disparaged on here - got my Dad reading as a struggling teen reader- did same for me and was a set of many books including Harry Potter that did same for my teens.