Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think shared finances are not always fair?

147 replies

Gummybears6 · 06/08/2023 07:05

If there are children involved and one person is doing more of the childcare that's totally different, also barring disability and such.
But if there aren't any... I've heard of situations where one party (usually the man) earns well. The woman maybe less, or just works part-time or not at all.
However since people 'should' pool money when married, the woman has access to the same high earnings as the man for little of the work.
I would love to swan around with access to a lot of money and just work part-time. I haven't got that luxury and probably never will.
It's just one of those things in life I suppose. I probably sound resentful, but I am. If it were a high earning woman marrying a much lower earning man, people would be calling him a cocklodger and saying he's taking her for a ride. However the other way round it absolutely must be shared finances as they're married. I don't get it.

OP posts:
CreeperBoom · 06/08/2023 10:24

I have never came across this, except for women now in their 70s+, where housekeeping was more labour intensive. They only times I have seen women of my generation work part time before children, it has been for health reasons.

What I do see, is women who take on the bulk of the childcare responsibilities while their husband takes leaps ahead in their career, with no worries about sick days, or leaving work bang on time because hungry people need them to get dinner on the table.

Then the children grow up, and the women find they are miles behind the men who were their peers. They stick with the part time option, as no one will step up at home, and they struggle to get back to where they were at work. Then, before they know where they are, the are providing childcare for grandkids.

WimpoleHat · 06/08/2023 10:19

Some people make different decisions from other people. Some people value other things more highly than extra money. (Generally the richer you are, the less highly you value money - diminishing marginal utility and all that.) My lovely neighbour didn’t work at all; her DH was very wealthy and got poked off that her job only allowed her 25 days annual leave at prescribed times; he was older and wanted them to be able to travel together and enjoy themselves. That was a decision they took together. And it’s nobody else’s business but theirs. In the supply teacher example you gave, presumably that suits their particular set up (allows some term time holidays, for example). People make decisions to suit their own circumstances and it’s nobody else’s business.

Quisquam · 06/08/2023 10:14

apparently women should be able to work as few hours as they like and have access to 100% of partner's money.

Looking after children, maintaining the house and several cars, doing all the mental load, running around after elderly parents is all work - or haven’t you tried it? Given the choice between 3 children talking at me all day or doing an office job - no contest as to which was easier! DH and DS both agree! In the evenings, when DC were crying their eyes out over problems at school, DH just walked off saying “I can’t cope with all that emotional talk!”

I’ve just had to spend four days, helping grown up DD with ADD fill in an employment tribunal claim form! Which would be easier - my own field of work with decades of experience, or a whole new field in law?

hadhimoverabarrel · 06/08/2023 10:08

I joke with MrHadhim that he's going to retire first and be a househusband and cook the dinner and do the housework and pander to my every whim

oviraptor21 · 06/08/2023 10:07

Yep. Horses for courses. If it works for one couple who is anyone else to judge?

Fwiw, cleaning and household admin does not take only 10 mins a day. If you want a spotlessly clean and always tidy house it could easily take every morning. Then nice meals could take an hour a day.
I think it's quite easy to justify a part time job for one partner in a childless couple because it means that the full time worker really doesn't have to lift a finger when they're home and they can have a lot of couple time or hobby time if they want.

hadhimoverabarrel · 06/08/2023 10:06

Gummybears6 · 06/08/2023 09:58

Don't really care if it's patronising. I don't deserve to be sworn at for having an opinion.

Mumsnet is known as the sweary parenting site, you know. People do swear here.

Gummybears6 · 06/08/2023 10:06

If I don't want to be sworn at, that is my right.
Anyway, it is futile discussing any further.

OP posts:
Floofydawg · 06/08/2023 10:06

Gummybears6 · 06/08/2023 09:58

Don't really care if it's patronising. I don't deserve to be sworn at for having an opinion.

You know this is Mumsnet, right? People swear on here. It's allowed.

coreas · 06/08/2023 10:00

I don't think fairness in other peoples relationships is your business.

hadhimoverabarrel · 06/08/2023 09:59

What's it got to do with you?

I don't share finances, I have a partner but we keep different finances. I earn more than him - he benefits from nicer holidays and nicer things than he could afford alone.

He works full time but if he wanted to go part time that would be up to him - we pay bills proportionate to our incomes and there would have to be a discussion about how he intended to pay his share.

If he became disabled tomorrow and could not work, or had to take on caring responsibilities that would be a different discussion.

But you would never know the actual reason outside of the partnership - if his mental health meant he couldn't work for example, why would anyone else know that?

I don't see how the sex of the individual is relevant?

viques · 06/08/2023 09:58

Gummybears6 · 06/08/2023 07:40

Yes I meant if no children or caring responsibilities are involved. I have seen it a couple of times, as I said in the supply teacher example. Nobody is forcing her to work so little.

Pssst, you need to tuck your resentment back in your knickers, it is trailing on the ground behind you and it is not a good look.

Unless you know every aspect of this persons life you are coming across as nasty

for example

do either of them have elderly or disabled relatives who need support

does she have a disability of some sort

is she working at home on a personal project or business

Any of which would be a perfectly valid reason for part time working and would also be none of anyone else’s concern.

Or maybe she enjoys working part time and rubbing it in to annoy people like you just adds another layer to that enjoyment.

Gummybears6 · 06/08/2023 09:58

Don't really care if it's patronising. I don't deserve to be sworn at for having an opinion.

OP posts:
Floofydawg · 06/08/2023 09:55

Gummybears6 · 06/08/2023 09:53

Oh dear, shame you can't disagree with me without swearing. How vulgar.

Bit patronising.

Gummybears6 · 06/08/2023 09:54

I guess a lot of people are getting angry because I'm highlighting their situation. I'm not meaning to cause offence, I'm just sharing my opinion.

OP posts:
Gummybears6 · 06/08/2023 09:53

That was for @yogasaurus

OP posts:
Gummybears6 · 06/08/2023 09:53

Oh dear, shame you can't disagree with me without swearing. How vulgar.

OP posts:
TeenDivided · 06/08/2023 09:50

Gummybears6 · 06/08/2023 09:49

It's totally different if the other partner is looming after children. But how many cocklodger threads are there on here?
apparently women should be able to work as few hours as they like and have access to 100% of partner's money.

On those threads it is often the man not only not working but also not doing the household stuff either.

yogasaurus · 06/08/2023 09:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Gummybears6 · 06/08/2023 09:49

It's totally different if the other partner is looming after children. But how many cocklodger threads are there on here?
apparently women should be able to work as few hours as they like and have access to 100% of partner's money.

OP posts:
Gummybears6 · 06/08/2023 09:47

It's a huge double standard. If it were a husband/male partner choosing to only work part time and life a life of luxury on his wife's salary, he'd be called all sorts of names on here.

OP posts:
Sigmama · 06/08/2023 09:38

If I'm looking after mine and my husbands kids so he can go to work then the money he earns is half mine and vice versa

Jk987 · 06/08/2023 09:22

You say you feel bitter because you don't have access to big money. Well the world is your oyster! You can research higher paying jobs, sign up with agencies, talk to contacts, polish up your CV and start a journey to massive salary increase!

chopc · 06/08/2023 08:44

Yes both people in the couple would be happy with their unbalanced financial arrangement until it comes to divorce. Then you will get a large proportion of these people on here lamenting their vulnerable positions..........

Of course there are loads people could do outside of paid work to fill their time. But we are not talking about that are we?

CasperGutman · 06/08/2023 08:27

If you both see yourselves as a partnership facing life together, with a shared home and lifestyle, then can one partner really have less spending power just because their job pays less?

Being in less well paid work, or even choosing to work fewer hours, doesn't necessarily mean that person works less hard. Even in the absence of children, the person with a part time job, or no job at all, might spend a commensurately greater amount of time and effort on running the household. Or a couple may decide that one of them will continue in a certain job because it is an important contribution to society or because it is a rewarding role in other ways than financially.

As long as they're both people in a relationship are happy with their financial arrangements, why does it matter whether you consider them to be "fair"?

Lapflop · 06/08/2023 08:18

Huge swathes of the arts, education and healthcare would probably collapse without cross subsidy within households from the higher earner.

This is me! Thankfully with my qualifications if we ever split I'd be able to secure well paid work, but I love what I do now, its valuable to society but crap pay (of course). Thankfully DH who does the same job but in a different sector earns a decent wage and luckily he enjoys it so we have lucked out to be honest. You are right though, studying for the jobs above which many do as mature students and actually doing them often requires a high earner in the household to live a comfortable lifestyle.