Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this lady is seriously underpricing these gorgeous bouquets of cupcakes?

260 replies

caringcarer · 05/08/2023 23:05

They look so real I genuinely thought it was a bouquet of real flowers. She told me it took her 3 years to learn to do them to this standard. How much do you think she charges per bouquet and you can choose the colour theme too?

To think this lady is seriously underpricing these gorgeous bouquets of cupcakes?
OP posts:
Rainbowshit · 06/08/2023 10:18

I bought the Russian tips to try these but it was so hard. I do a lot of cake baking and decorating but couldn't manage this. She should be charging £50

ZebraDanios · 06/08/2023 10:16

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 06/08/2023 08:22

it's sad for people with skills and dedication not to be able to see the results of that in financial terms.

Not every skill can be turned into a profitable business though. People are good at all sorts of things but that doesn't mean there's a market for them to make money from it.

I just find it bizarre (and a bit depressing) that someone can earn a small fortune as an influencer with absolutely no skills whatsoever whereas someone highly skilled at something gets paid so little for it…

CoffeeCantata · 06/08/2023 10:16

They are amazing and very pretty - a very skilled job.

But as others have said: just what do you do with cupcakes like that? Cupcakes are not popular with anyone I know because they are SO horrendously sugary. Most people I know would choose (as a treat!) a piece of tea loaf, banana bread or a scone. But these really are almost obscenely sugary (I bet you're looking at 500+ calories each) and they're gone very quickly.

Plus - there's a limit to how exquisitely decorated cakes can be before it becomes off-putting. I would feel like a vandal even breaking up the 'bouquet', never mind eating one. And...there's also that feeling with this kind of thing that someone has had their mitts all over it, and that's not a good feeling (I'm sure this woman is hygienic, but that's not the point). And at the end of the day it is just a sponge cake with butter cream, in terms of eating, I mean.

I think this level of skill is better reserved for wedding and seriously luxurious celebration cakes.

CarPour · 06/08/2023 10:14

GenieGenealogy · 06/08/2023 10:00

Yes they know that supermarket cakes, even the posh Rachel's ones from Waitrose are mass-produced. But some people are weird about hygiene and shun any "home made" cake as dirty and germ-ridden. Others have the palate of a child and think a mass produced cake from Costco is "delicious".

Lots just don't appreciate the effort/time which has gone into creating cake and make comments about "it's just 7 cupcakes". It is, but you could say that about a lot of things. A Banksy piece of art is just graffiti on the wall. A designer pair of trainers is just shoes. A Ferrari is just something to get you from A to B.

It's not about not appreciating the effort

It's that the product, regardless of the effort, is not actual £80 of enjoyment.

Buying things isn't charity. You buy things you can afford.

A cupcake lasts 10 minutes. My enjoyment of the cake will be the same regardless of how its decorated. I realise how much effort has gone in, but I would not enjoy those cupcakes to justify spending £80 on them. Deciration is essentially packaging. It's got to be destroyed to actually enjoy the product.

With any expensive, designer gear a lot of the price is brand and marketing. Designer trainers are not worth the cost. A ferrari you are paying for the brand. Banksi you are paying for the name. A random woman from my local town is not the same as banksi and would not be able to charge those prices for some graffiti

knitnerd90 · 06/08/2023 10:04

As someone who enjoys cupcakes and can decorate them -- the quality of the icing can vary dramatically. The issue with Russian tips is that they are finicky about the consistency of the buttercream, which places some limits on what you can do. There are cake decorators who will take shortcuts with the quality of the icing because they prioritise the visuals, for example using vegetable fat instead of butter as it will stay stable over a larger temperature range. It looks beautiful but isn't pleasant to eat.

the other issue is that getting these results is quite a thick layer of buttercream, and meanwhile, the cake layer is also tall. So you have one thick layer of sponge and then one thick layer of buttercream, instead of several thinner layers as you would with a large cake. This contributes to the cake having a dry feeling in the mouth, even if you use a very moist sponge recipe, and to the frosting being overwhelming. It's also quite easy to overbake cupcakes by just a minute or two.

GenieGenealogy · 06/08/2023 10:00

Sd352 · 06/08/2023 08:39

I am surprised by the comments saying £20-£30. People do realise that cupcakes at the grocery stores are mass produced?

In the heyday of the cupcake craze in America some 15 years ago, $5 per cupcake was completely normal and that was for cupcakes with generic decoration. I would probably pay c.£7 per cupcake for these so around £50-£60.

Yes they know that supermarket cakes, even the posh Rachel's ones from Waitrose are mass-produced. But some people are weird about hygiene and shun any "home made" cake as dirty and germ-ridden. Others have the palate of a child and think a mass produced cake from Costco is "delicious".

Lots just don't appreciate the effort/time which has gone into creating cake and make comments about "it's just 7 cupcakes". It is, but you could say that about a lot of things. A Banksy piece of art is just graffiti on the wall. A designer pair of trainers is just shoes. A Ferrari is just something to get you from A to B.

Oblomov23 · 06/08/2023 09:58

I too think cake making is underpaid generally. Sad.

WimbyAce · 06/08/2023 09:56

Never seen anything like this before. Love the idea and would definitely prefer it to actual flowers as I love cake 😋

N27 · 06/08/2023 09:54

I make these, unfortunately pricing is very dependent on where you live. A cake friend can charge £70 in a city centre, I charge £30 in a rural area and still get raised eyebrows that they’re so expensive

PurpleButterflyWings · 06/08/2023 09:52

They are very pretty you're right @caringcarer But is £30 really underpriced? Sounds about right to me. £35 would be pushing it... £40 too much. Many people are brassick right now, and if they were like £60 to £80 as some posters are charging, people simply won't pay it.

I am not denying that she has quite a skill, but this would be £60-80 for something that would potentially be consumed/gone in an hour ... I know you could say the same about a meal out, but I just don't think most people would want to pay £60-£80 for a handful of cupcakes, no matter how pretty they are...

I also agree that there looks to be a bit too much icing on them too. Would make them very sweet and quite sickly. If it's buttercream fine, but being made around 50% icing (which is what it looks like,) would make them hard to eat, as it would be like munching a bunch of sugar cubes! If you love to have a lot of icing then crack on. Wouldn't be for me.

5foot5 · 06/08/2023 09:51

Lapflop · 06/08/2023 09:44

Some people prefer the icing, like anything you wouldn't buy these and that's okay, just as some wouldn't be tempted by a sponge cake with no icing on. These look nicer as a gift of a lovely gesture than a plain cake, of course you'd hope the recipient also liked iced cupcakes though otherwise it would be a waste!

Oh I agree of course.

But I was responding to a PP who seemed to think that negative responses to cupcakes made you a cake hater. My view is the opposite. If you love cake, but not necessarily icing, then you will generally be underwhelmed by cupcakes.

CantFindTheBeat · 06/08/2023 09:48

A local lady here does them in a box of 6, so not a bouquet but the same beautiful cakes.

They are incredible and only £28.50.

A standard box of 6 cupcakes is £15.50.
I say standard - her quality is still exceptional.

sparkleshin · 06/08/2023 09:44

i wouldnt want to eat a cupcake w that much icing on

Lapflop · 06/08/2023 09:44

5foot5 · 06/08/2023 09:34

But it's not CAKE is it? I love CAKE (and I have been on mumsnet for yonks). But the trouble with cupcakes is that the amount and quality of the CAKE is usually disappointing because it is all about the icing. I don't love icing. I think these flower things look lovely but I don’t think I would enjoy eating them as much as I would a nice piece of well-made Victoria sponge with no icing but a filling of Raspberry jam and perhaps a light dusting of icing sugar.

Some people prefer the icing, like anything you wouldn't buy these and that's okay, just as some wouldn't be tempted by a sponge cake with no icing on. These look nicer as a gift of a lovely gesture than a plain cake, of course you'd hope the recipient also liked iced cupcakes though otherwise it would be a waste!

OrwellianTimes · 06/08/2023 09:43

£30-40.

its 7 cupcakes. Not many people will pay more than that.

5foot5 · 06/08/2023 09:41

CarPour · 06/08/2023 00:06

But not many people want a hand crocheted mouse for £50 no matter how beautiful.

I'm sure they are lovely, and take time and skill. But the number of people who have a spare 40 odd quid for a crocheted mouse is very small.

Not all skills are marketable.

I agree with this and I do lots of crochet, including, on occasion, crocheted animals. I am quite good and I flatter myself that the results are pretty good too. But I would never expect to sell them for a price that would reflect the time they take. Sometimes I make them for presents, but only for people I know would like that sort of thing.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 06/08/2023 09:41

Maybe she’s found that most people simply won’t pay any more.
From all I’ve ever heard, the hours of work and skill put into anything home made, whether edible or other crafts, isn’t anything like reflected in the price that people are prepared to pay.

5foot5 · 06/08/2023 09:34

5YearsLeft · 06/08/2023 02:06

In this thread:

  1. People who think cake making is an art and price it appropriately to reflect that opinion. (“That’s an amazing skill.”)
  2. People who think cake making isn’t an art and price it appropriately to reflect that opinion. (“It’s just seven cupcakes.”)
  3. People talking shit about cupcakes.
  4. People talking shit about cake in general.

How does Mumsnet have so many cake haters??? Where the hell did this site go wrong? I’ve always ignored those threads that complain MN isn’t what it used to be, but listening to person after person whinge about a foodstuff that is the second proof, after beer, that God loves us and wants us to be happy, is just… sigh. Really breaks one’s spirit. It’s CAKE. I mean yes, sure, it’s the devil’s pudding, but in the GOOD way. Fucking hell.

But it's not CAKE is it? I love CAKE (and I have been on mumsnet for yonks). But the trouble with cupcakes is that the amount and quality of the CAKE is usually disappointing because it is all about the icing. I don't love icing. I think these flower things look lovely but I don’t think I would enjoy eating them as much as I would a nice piece of well-made Victoria sponge with no icing but a filling of Raspberry jam and perhaps a light dusting of icing sugar.

AbsolutelyNebulous · 06/08/2023 09:34

They are beautiful to look at and I can certainly appreciate the skill. That said, the beauty and artistry is in the novelty presentation and these are a food item to be eaten same day, maybe next day? They’re not something you can really keep as presented for any length of time so once the recipient is over the “wow” appearance, well, then it’s a few cupcakes with a lot of very sweet icing.

I thinks she’s probably got her pricing about right. At @ £30ish a go she’s in the same territory as “bunch of flowers” occasions so marketed properly could get a steady stream of orders for birthday, anniversary, thinking-of-you, thank you type gifts that people would often say with actual flowers.

Assuming she’s doing it as a business she’s probably not buying ingredients, running the oven and mixing batches of icing for just 6 or 7 cupcakes at a time.

Anoooshka · 06/08/2023 09:32

30 is definitely too little. A bakery stall in our local market charges 2 pounds 50 for one doughnut! This is in the SE.

Fitflop5 · 06/08/2023 09:31

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

dottiedodah · 06/08/2023 09:30

They look beautiful and the lady is obv very skilled.However ATM money is quite tight for lots of people, and often they will struggle to obtain the higher figure.I personally think about £60/£70 would be about right

FrostieBoabby · 06/08/2023 09:30

I think it would depend if the person is a home hobby baker with no food safety certificates or insurance etc as if that is the case I wouldn't go near them and they would worth £0 to me.

An actual small bakery business with the correct set up and food hygiene etc, probably anything up to £40. Beyond that I would rather pay more for a proper decorated cake which would feed a lot more people and probably be nicer to eat as I'm not a fan of all butter icing and hardly any cake.

NotQuiteHere · 06/08/2023 09:25

Why would anyone buy this? It is not pleasant to eat with this amount of icing, and they are not as good looking as real flowers. Just to impress guests who would be expected to say "wow"?

Swipe left for the next trending thread