Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think divorce is selfish?

316 replies

Readyforafallout · 05/08/2023 17:31

( Totally different for abusive relationships so not including those in this post)

Am I wrong to think that the following are excuses for basically gaining a moral green light for being selfish and swapping your own discontent for a child’s upheaval and distress ?

’ Kids are resilient’
‘ they will pick up on it so you are better of to divorce !’ ( even if the parents DO hide it well, people being convinced they will notice feels again an excuse)
‘ You only have one life OP! …’ ( so do the children)

it just seems that people ‘ grow apart…’
‘ want different things’ and put themselves ahead of their children…. I know this is likely an unpopular opinion
but hearing how ‘ brave ‘ people are for ‘ having the guts to do something about their situation’ seems selfish to me ….

because the children’s world are being opened to who knows who!…. As potential step parents !…. Complete upheaval And emotional distress … That’s worse than ‘ picking up’ on not much in my opinion .

it’s not a post intended to be unkind to divorces but more to not hold it in the highest regard like some achievement of braveness. It feels selfish ?

OP posts:
ladyvivienne · 05/08/2023 18:42

I agree to a certain extent. People are more selfish in general these days. No one wants to 'work things out' - they just want instant gratification. Grass is greener? Off they go. All of the children I know who have divorced parents have problems. Could be a coincidence of course. It is a pattern that tends to repeat.

I have a lot more respect for those who take marriage vows seriously - for better or worse and actually work things out. Accept that things aren't going to be amazing 24/7 and that you can have some pretty crap times too. I'll be amazing if anyone currently in their 20s or 30s manages 50+ years of marriage like a lot of my parents generation have. They can't seem to manage 5!

That's before the whole addition of step parents and step siblings - so fucked up for the children involved generally. But hey, so long as Mum is happy and getting more attention off the new man!

JenWillsiam · 05/08/2023 18:41

I’m the child of parents who did what you’re suggesting. And frankly it sucked. Being the child of two parents who just weren’t that bothered with eachother. And has meant as an adult I don’t know what a loving relationship is. Or didn’t. Until finally in my early 20’s my parents split and met new partners. I wish they had done it earlier.

CUDet · 05/08/2023 18:40

My MIL told my DH she was going to divorce his Dad when he was 11, he cried and so she didn't go through with it. He felt so guilty about keeping her in an unhappy marriage, and helped her divorce his Dad when he was 19. Staying was not good for the children.

twinkletoesimnot · 05/08/2023 18:39

MolkosTeenageAngst · 05/08/2023 18:11

Surely the selfish thing is not leaving a marriage in which you are unhappy, but jumping into new relationships which involve the children or not putting the children’s needs first when it comes to new relationships. Just because parents are divorced doesn’t mean step-parents have to be involved, it’s possible to have a new relationship without marrying/ moving in together until you are sure that your children won’t be adversely effected. Step-parents aren’t always a negative, they can bring many positives, but usually only if they are introduced at the child’s pace and where the parents haven’t moved the relationship forward until they knew their children and new partner were able to get on.

I agree with this.
A lot of the time you can't help a marriage ending, but what you do next is your choice.

ChrisPPancake · 05/08/2023 18:39

@Readyforafallout I'm going to go ahead and guess that you are a child of divorced parents?

Eggandcresspleasemummy · 05/08/2023 18:39

I don’t think it’s selfish, no. I do think it’s sometimes too easy an option though. I know of a couple of very short marriages, ended for reasons which could have been worked through, but stubbornness got in the way.

IWantOutDoI · 05/08/2023 18:38

Totally different for abusive relationships so not including those in this post

I don’t know what planet you live on but I have not met a single divorced person, not one at all, that had not been in a marriage were some sort of abuse was happening.

People who stay together after the love is gone end up hurting each other and the people around them. They neglect the other, they get fed up, the environment gets toxic and things just escalate until someone has the courage/guts/bollocks to break free.

People who choose to divorce are not quitters or selfish, many have spend years or even decades trying to save/resurrect their marriages, they are the brave ones who escaped a bad situation. Because believe me, it so so much easier to stay in a bad marriage than to leave.

You may think differently if you were the one who was left, but then, why would you expect someone to stay with you against their will?

MrReflection · 05/08/2023 18:37

GCAcademic · 05/08/2023 18:28

I wish my parents had got divorced. OP clearly has no idea of what it's like being brought up in a household of constant tension, conflict and unhappiness. I left home 30 years ago and am still massively affected by it.

Absolutely.

Interestingly my FIL cheated, many times, and it was swept under the carpet. Clearly it's affected their children because my OH sees it as acceptable behaviour in her marriage....

Caprisunny · 05/08/2023 18:36

Your post is absolutely designed to be unkind. Of course it is.

kids do pick up on their parents being unhappy. And it messes them up.

People who say they are staying for the kids, usually aren’t. They simply don’t want to change the situation. Don’t want to sell the house, or will have less money and so on. The kids usually grow up wishing their parents had split sooner and the parents often act like the kids owe them for giving up years of happiness for their benefit. Except no one benefitted.

Your post that suggests it’s selfish to want to be in a happy home environments is unkind. You are telling people they should live unhappily or morally lacking.

I actually suspect you might be one of the ‘I am staying for my kids’ and trying to convince yourself that you are morally superior and a more selfless parent. Why else would you do it?

ttcat37 · 05/08/2023 18:36

My parents had an acrimonious split when I was in my 20s. I wish they’d split when I was young and before it turned nasty, before the affair. As it turned out i knew all the gory details and am estranged from one parent now.

6WeekCountdown · 05/08/2023 18:34

I'm happily married with children, but if my marriage died a death and I didn't want to be with my husband anymore I absolutely would leave.

One of my best friends I met at uni, her parents stayed living under the same roof for years "for the children" my friend says the distress this caused her and her brother was totally avoidable. Her dad ate separately as her parents couldn't stand one another, it was silent treatment and a toxic atmosphere. They eventually moved to different houses and both remarried once my friend was 16, she always says she has no idea what their thought process was to carry on living as they did. People shouldn't stay together for their kids, imagine the atmosphere when 2 people just don't want to be together, hardly a warm loving home.

TheOGCCL · 05/08/2023 18:32

Would you advise your son or daughter to stay in an unhappy marriage that is making them miserable?

I think every case is different but your kids are going to be affected regardless of whether you divorve or not, imo it's a bit of a no win but on balance I think it's better to demonstrate to your children how to live a happy life and to put your own oxygen mask on first.

FictionalCharacter · 05/08/2023 18:32

Bubbleses · 05/08/2023 17:35

Are you yourself a child if divorce?

My parents finally divorced when I was 15. It was a huge relief when they did. They spent years not really being “together” - I knew they didn’t love each other and it was horrible; you just can’t fake it 24/7.

Same here except I was older. The atmosphere in the house was tense and horrible, my parents argued and shouted all the time, they were constantly not talking to each other and making me mediate between them. It was hell and leaving home was a huge relief.
Back then people were encouraged to stay together for the sake of the children. My parents should have divorced sooner for the sake of the children.

Thepeopleversuswork · 05/08/2023 18:32

I think people sometimes do minimise the impact of divorce on children.

But it doesn’t follow that divorce is always the worst thing to happen to children. Far from it.

It’s far more selfish in my view to struggle on in a marriage which is sufficiently unhappy that it poisons the atmosphere in the family just because you can’t do the grown up thing and admit to your children that you and your partner are not compatible, or because you fear the loss of stability or material comfort.

And while parent’s separation can be traumatic, it’s far more damaging long term to send children the explicit or implicit message that a marriage (even a desperately unhealthy one) takes priority over the emotional wellbeing of the parents or the children. People recover from change. They don’t recover from having their sense of self systematically poisoned.

honeyandfizz · 05/08/2023 18:31

Readyforafallout · 05/08/2023 18:24

Thanks for your replies …. It’s interesting that people think I may be trolling just because I have asked an opinion on a very common issue . I haven't replied Because I have been reading responses !! I’m going to go to the cinema shortly …. So won’t reply for a while, if that’s ok?!

Nobody really gives a shit TBH.

EpicChaos · 05/08/2023 18:29

Getting divorced and getting a new partner, are 2 completely separate things imo.
Kids get far more upset living in homes where it is quite obvious that parents don't get on.
What is selfish, imo, is making a partner stay in a loveless marriage to suit yourself.

GCAcademic · 05/08/2023 18:28

I wish my parents had got divorced. OP clearly has no idea of what it's like being brought up in a household of constant tension, conflict and unhappiness. I left home 30 years ago and am still massively affected by it.

CandyflossKaren · 05/08/2023 18:25

You've been sat reading responses yet you have no....response?

Eddyraisins · 05/08/2023 18:25

FizzyFucker · 05/08/2023 17:36

I think you sound like you are quite ignorant. What has shaped your opinion?

Agree

I could not disagree more OP. You don't have to be a martyr.

Itsnotrightbutitsok · 05/08/2023 18:25

My only happy memories as a child was when my parents got divorced.

When you have kids you have to put them first and if that means separating so they don’t have to walk around on egg shells then so be it.

Why should your kids have to live the lie that you’re still in love and happy when you’re obviously not.

Ask any child of parents who were unhappy with each other for a long time which they’d prefer - staying in the home with both mum and dad or after they’ve been divorced.

Of course the actual separation can be difficult as emotions are raw but it’s up to you as adults to do it as amicably as possible to protect your kids.

I’m assuming your DH wants a divorce and then means you having to get a job and pay your own bills which you aren’t happy about, so you’re trying to make it about the poor children.

Confuzzlediddled · 05/08/2023 18:24

My ex DH pretty much decided he didn't want to be a parent any more. I only realised afterwards how abnormal it was that I wasn't allowed anywhere on my own, even mum and tots!

I bet my current DH 3 years later, it was another 2 years before we moved in together and he is 100% my children's parent, they're 20 now and even though they don't call him dad, he is to all intents an purposes their dad. Even my ex in-laws say he's better than their own son!

Readyforafallout · 05/08/2023 18:24

Thanks for your replies …. It’s interesting that people think I may be trolling just because I have asked an opinion on a very common issue . I haven't replied Because I have been reading responses !! I’m going to go to the cinema shortly …. So won’t reply for a while, if that’s ok?!

OP posts:
StillPerplexed · 05/08/2023 18:23

I can see what the OP is saying, but even in the most trivial seeming divorces, it's usually pretty obvious the couple aren't well suited.

I recently learned the reason for my parents divorce (they split when I was a toddler, I have memory of them being together). It was something like, my dad wanted to spend every weekend doing a hobby —let's call it windsurfing— and my mum didn't want to spend every weekend watching him windsurf, she wanted to do other things and probably get more help with the kids. This seems like something they could have worked through!

But even still, I can't really blame them. Other than the actual 'reason', knowing them both as I do now I can see that they were ill-suited and would have found all new ways to make each other unhappy.

Rewis · 05/08/2023 18:23

In order to make a loveless (and sexless) marriage last for 50+ years requires a lot of skills and commitment from both parents which is unrealistic. It's unrealistic to expect both to feel committed to their spouse, share finances, housework etc. Without any bitterness. Go out together and model a good marriage when you don't feel love.

Youcancallmeirrelevant · 05/08/2023 18:23

Why can't people be a bit selfish? Just because you become a parent doesn't mean all your wants and needs don't matter anymore.

In my opinion kids deserve to see happy patents and hopefully be shown what good loving relationships are