Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think divorce is selfish?

316 replies

Readyforafallout · 05/08/2023 17:31

( Totally different for abusive relationships so not including those in this post)

Am I wrong to think that the following are excuses for basically gaining a moral green light for being selfish and swapping your own discontent for a child’s upheaval and distress ?

’ Kids are resilient’
‘ they will pick up on it so you are better of to divorce !’ ( even if the parents DO hide it well, people being convinced they will notice feels again an excuse)
‘ You only have one life OP! …’ ( so do the children)

it just seems that people ‘ grow apart…’
‘ want different things’ and put themselves ahead of their children…. I know this is likely an unpopular opinion
but hearing how ‘ brave ‘ people are for ‘ having the guts to do something about their situation’ seems selfish to me ….

because the children’s world are being opened to who knows who!…. As potential step parents !…. Complete upheaval And emotional distress … That’s worse than ‘ picking up’ on not much in my opinion .

it’s not a post intended to be unkind to divorces but more to not hold it in the highest regard like some achievement of braveness. It feels selfish ?

OP posts:
bellsandwhistles333 · 05/08/2023 19:35

As someone who's parents stayed together for me as a child and only divorced at 19 I can honestly say the 'fake' crucial marriage was just as obvious and hurtful and I really do wish they had been more selfish when I was 5/6 and divorced then and found happiness elsewhere...

I may of had a different life and I'm grateful for the things I had and opportunities I got but I wish for them they had been happier younger especially my mum

FrogsWormsandCaterpillars · 05/08/2023 19:35

YABU

And your incorrect use of full stops is equally annoying

DowntonCrabby · 05/08/2023 19:35

I disagree, the the subsequent blending of families often is.

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 05/08/2023 19:33

Readyforafallout · 05/08/2023 18:24

Thanks for your replies …. It’s interesting that people think I may be trolling just because I have asked an opinion on a very common issue . I haven't replied Because I have been reading responses !! I’m going to go to the cinema shortly …. So won’t reply for a while, if that’s ok?!

Replied but not to say if you are a divorcee or if you came from parents who divorced 🧐

fuchiaknickers · 05/08/2023 19:32

Yeah it’s an unpopular opinion OP but I think YANBU.

Two of my friends’ parents divorced when they were in university. They had held it together for years for the children, came as a total bolt from the blue - children had no idea the marriage was on the rocks.

IMO parents should put their children first (obvs with the exception of domestic abuse).

PopGoesTheWeaselYetAgain · 05/08/2023 19:31

I once heard a relationship psychologist say that they saw a lot of people who imagined that they would be happier with somebody else - and may even think they've found that person - but that they were deceiving themselves. They'd be better dealing with the problems they had relating to their current partner, and were most likely simply going to repeat the pattern in the next relationship.

Problem is, though, if you're on the receiving end of that, what can you do except divorce the self-deluded, difficult to get on with, cheating person?

Lastnightschips · 05/08/2023 19:29

Also, I used to think maybe my parents didn’t try hard enough, but talking to my mum about her divorce has made me see that she really did try, and that she was miserable. When you’re trying to tell your partner you’re unhappy and they don’t listen there isn’t a lot of choice. My dad is a tricky bugger, and he never treated her like an equal, more like a slightly stupid child, which is how he still occasionally treats me even though I am definitely neither.

My DH isn’t a bad person, but he wasn’t able to be my partner, my support. And eventually that broke us. But I’m a nicer happier person now, and a better mum.

BIWI · 05/08/2023 19:28

Oh, and @vipersnest1 - you do realise that @DojaPhat was being sarcastic, don't you?!

BIWI · 05/08/2023 19:28

OK. The OP hasn't come back. Has deliberately 'taunted' us by saying they're not going to be around for at least the next 2 hours.

I think he's a man, who is being divorced by his wife. So he is now very resentful of all the things that will be expected of him, like paying for his children, looking after them at certain times during the week, and no longer having a housewife on tap.

ToWhitToWhoo · 05/08/2023 19:27

No more or less than marriage is selfish.

Some marriages, and some divorces, are selfish: people may walk in or out of marriages for money, or brief sexual attraction, or trivial social reasons, or out of pure capriciousness. Some are carried out for altruistic reasons, or are simply inevitable. Most are probably a combination of noble and less noble reasons. In any case, it takes two to marry or to divorce, and often enough one of the partners has no choice in a divorce.

While I agree that children should not simply be assumed to be 'resilient', being in a seriously quarrelsome or abusive relationship is likely to be worse, sometimes much worse, for the children than divorce.

Many of the things you mention seem to be more reasons for not rushing into remarriage, or involving the children in a new relationship too quickly, than against divorce as such.

theleafandnotthetree · 05/08/2023 19:27

AmazingSnakeHead · 05/08/2023 18:10

I agree with what everyone else is saying: just because it's selfish doesn't mean that it's wrong. Loads of things are selfish, but morally permissable. You owe your children a good life: you don't owe them the best possible life they could have had, if giving them that makes you miserable.

And anyway, often it is better for the children. My parents divorced when I was about 10, I was fine with it.

That is so very well put...you don't owe them the best possible life, just a good life. I am divorced because I didn't love my ex-husband any longer, felt pretty much nothing for him even though he was OK, not the worst etc. So to separate was undoubtedly selfish and very bad for him and not great for the children. There are no 'buts' there, I chose to put myself first. I have tried to minimise the harm by very much putting themselves first in the separation, as has my ex. Neither of us have so much as had a serious relationship let alone created another family unit (7 years in), we live very close to one another to minimise disruption and we parent pretty well together even if occasionally through gritted teeth. And O do believe that it is how it is done that is the key factor in how damaging divorce is. But still, I was selfish and I own that and may well suffer a backlash when the children become more conscious of this as they mature. I'll have to own that too.

MistyMorningMelons · 05/08/2023 19:27

No, you're quite right. It's better to raise children in an unhappy home, with resentful parents who argue and make each other miserable Confused

Butchyrestingface · 05/08/2023 19:25

YABU. My parents splitting up was the highlight of my teenage years. With hindsight, I wish they'd done it sooner preferably when I was born.

vipersnest1 · 05/08/2023 19:23

@DojaPhat, Gilead is calling you....

OrangeCrayon · 05/08/2023 19:22

Madamecastafiore · 05/08/2023 17:56

I bet 99% of adult children would be horrified at either parent being unhappy for years just to keep the family unit together.

Yeah.

But, even more horrified when they then go on to separate and say horrible things to you about each other and both go on to marry again to absolutely vile and abusive people that they move into your homes and then expect you to accept as "family".

MissRoo1982 · 05/08/2023 19:21

I often feel like my mum used kids as an excuse to stay in a bad marriage because she didn’t want to leave. She had money, her own house and a good job. Literally there was no financial reason why she couldn’t. I never got it for years until I finally concluded that she didn’t want to leave. Even if was really bad. Even it drastically affected us. I stopped believing it when she said she would because I asked her several times to as a teenager.

She kept saying she would but never did. So I got out and became independent as quickly as possible. Which she initially resented me for because I had escaped.

I don’t buy it when people say they stay married for the children. I just don’t believe it. I think it is because they don’t want to leave themselves.( unfamiliarity, fear of the future maybe finances depending on situation, cultural reasons and just not wanting to be seen mistakenly as a failure).

caringcarer · 05/08/2023 19:21

If you're unhappy in your relationship what is the point of staying? Seriously do you think a parent should sacrifice 20 years of their life instead of just divorcing and children can still have 2 parents and live with them both. If one of your DC got married and they weren't happy would you want/expect them to sacrifice 20 years or more until any DC were away at uni.

adriftabroad · 05/08/2023 19:19

marriage is selfish, having a baby is selfish ...

OrangeCrayon · 05/08/2023 19:18

Newphony · 05/08/2023 17:48

Yes I agree, exposing children to step parents is far more damaging. They rarely have the children's best interests at heart. Mostly just out for themselves.

This.

All of the evidence shows that if parents divorce and co-parent amicably the children's outcomes are roughly equivalent to thise whose parents stay married.

The biggest problems for children are the dangers of step parents and the emotional complications of blended families/ half siblings etc. People who divorce don't have to inflict that on their children and many do not.

Ultimately the balance of probabilities of a good outcome in each individual situation will be different but negative outcomes from divorcing are only present when the adults behave in a selfish way after separating rather than putting the children's needs first.

bladebladebla1 · 05/08/2023 19:17

DojaPhat · 05/08/2023 19:10

I'm actually with the OP on this and I think after we've outlawed divorce we should ban married couples from accessing any form of contraception too. A family unit much like the OP says is fundamentally a moral one.

To that end I also think if a man or a woman haven't found a person of their own choosing to marry by 21 years old then the government should allocate every woman and man on the cusp of their 22nd birthday a partner of the opposite sex to marry.

Following marriage couples can then use their marriage certificate as a license to create a family unit. This license also grants family units priority access to housing, healthcare, parking spaces etc. Should the marriage breakdown irretrievably a couple can only be granted divorce following a 20-year waiting period, after which they will only be able to marry again via the government allocation scheme pending an investigation to their first primary marriage.

Lol

MintJulia · 05/08/2023 19:15

Katey83 · 05/08/2023 19:06

As a stepmother I can see how completely f-*ed up my dad’s emotional development has been because of the divorce and her parents’ subsequent marriages. The truth is no one was putting her first when they split up, and would have stayed together if they had been. There is no world in which it is good for the kids to divorce. Granted it might be better than the alternative if there is abuse or complete disharmony, but it’s damaging to the child.

Then perhaps it is the subsequent marriage which is selfish.

DS & I left his dad 13 years ago. I have put DS first, and not found a new partner. I won't even try until ds is 18 and at university. He is a happy confident secure child because he has a secure comfortable relaxed home, knows his place in it, and knows that I have his back. We treat each other with courtesy and consideration. Plenty of love and affection.

I'm so glad that he has had the opposite upbringing to me & my siblings..

CleansUpButWouldPreferNotTo · 05/08/2023 19:15

DojaPhat · 05/08/2023 19:10

I'm actually with the OP on this and I think after we've outlawed divorce we should ban married couples from accessing any form of contraception too. A family unit much like the OP says is fundamentally a moral one.

To that end I also think if a man or a woman haven't found a person of their own choosing to marry by 21 years old then the government should allocate every woman and man on the cusp of their 22nd birthday a partner of the opposite sex to marry.

Following marriage couples can then use their marriage certificate as a license to create a family unit. This license also grants family units priority access to housing, healthcare, parking spaces etc. Should the marriage breakdown irretrievably a couple can only be granted divorce following a 20-year waiting period, after which they will only be able to marry again via the government allocation scheme pending an investigation to their first primary marriage.

😱😂😂😂😂😂😂

ArabeIIaScott · 05/08/2023 19:15

CleansUpButWouldPreferNotTo · 05/08/2023 19:14

Yes I agree, exposing children to step parents is far more damaging. They rarely have the children's best interests at heart. Mostly just out for themselves.

Oh please, watch your language!!! Not every person who marries a partner with children is an evil step parent. Honestly, it's such a sickening attitude considering how many second- and blended- families there are now, don't judge everyone by the actions of some.

It's also just complete bollocks. Obvious bollocks.

OP, to expand: there are good and bad ways to do divorces.

Rathouse · 05/08/2023 19:14

Caprisunny · 05/08/2023 18:36

Your post is absolutely designed to be unkind. Of course it is.

kids do pick up on their parents being unhappy. And it messes them up.

People who say they are staying for the kids, usually aren’t. They simply don’t want to change the situation. Don’t want to sell the house, or will have less money and so on. The kids usually grow up wishing their parents had split sooner and the parents often act like the kids owe them for giving up years of happiness for their benefit. Except no one benefitted.

Your post that suggests it’s selfish to want to be in a happy home environments is unkind. You are telling people they should live unhappily or morally lacking.

I actually suspect you might be one of the ‘I am staying for my kids’ and trying to convince yourself that you are morally superior and a more selfless parent. Why else would you do it?

👍

CleansUpButWouldPreferNotTo · 05/08/2023 19:14

Yes I agree, exposing children to step parents is far more damaging. They rarely have the children's best interests at heart. Mostly just out for themselves.

Oh please, watch your language!!! Not every person who marries a partner with children is an evil step parent. Honestly, it's such a sickening attitude considering how many second- and blended- families there are now, don't judge everyone by the actions of some.