Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think divorce is selfish?

316 replies

Readyforafallout · 05/08/2023 17:31

( Totally different for abusive relationships so not including those in this post)

Am I wrong to think that the following are excuses for basically gaining a moral green light for being selfish and swapping your own discontent for a child’s upheaval and distress ?

’ Kids are resilient’
‘ they will pick up on it so you are better of to divorce !’ ( even if the parents DO hide it well, people being convinced they will notice feels again an excuse)
‘ You only have one life OP! …’ ( so do the children)

it just seems that people ‘ grow apart…’
‘ want different things’ and put themselves ahead of their children…. I know this is likely an unpopular opinion
but hearing how ‘ brave ‘ people are for ‘ having the guts to do something about their situation’ seems selfish to me ….

because the children’s world are being opened to who knows who!…. As potential step parents !…. Complete upheaval And emotional distress … That’s worse than ‘ picking up’ on not much in my opinion .

it’s not a post intended to be unkind to divorces but more to not hold it in the highest regard like some achievement of braveness. It feels selfish ?

OP posts:
FarmGirl78 · 06/08/2023 09:20

OP I think you are oblivious to the significant "emotional distress" that a child can suffer living in a family where either one or both parents are unhappy, or they spend months or even years witnessing arguments, fall outs and general cold atmospheres and not-getting-on-ness. That can, and does, massive long term harm to a child.

DrSbaitso · 06/08/2023 09:15

royalwatch · 06/08/2023 08:53

Are you stuck in an unhappy marriage?

I wondered initially if OP was just on a wind up, but actually I'm starting to think this is it. She's in a miserable marriage but can't bear to divorce, so she's peddling some rubbish where she's not struggling with inertia or a lifestyle change, she's just a noble, selfless altruist. And anyone who did what she wishes she could do is morally inferior.

It feels more plausible than simply being a silly wind up.

royalwatch · 06/08/2023 08:53

Are you stuck in an unhappy marriage?

Herejusttocomment · 06/08/2023 08:46

Well, my parents didn't divorce until I was 18 (I also have an older sibling). They had a huuuge argument when I was around 5 or 6 and things deteriorated so badly by the time I was 15 that my mum got violent and demanded he left.

I was 15 and we lived in a flat so I knew exactly why my mum did that, let's just say my dad was NOT the one in the wrong.

That was 10 or so years of experiencing tensions in the house, poor parenting because of their own conflicts and stress of a bad marriage, a very bad example of what marriage looks like and zero conflict resolution. I cannot even begin to tell you how much damage that did to me, especially being a highly sensitive person. And you're getting the abbreviated version of the abbreviated version.
My mother refused a separation/divorce until that fateful night because apparently she was thinking of us 🙄

So yeah, think of the kids and what they'd actually go through!

StorminanDcup · 06/08/2023 08:41

What is the alternative? Being quietly unhappy, unsatisfied and unloved (and your spouse feeling the same), failing to demonstrate what a loving, healthy relationship looks like?
You can try counselling but what if it doesn’t work, what if you have grown so far apart as people there’s just no connection. What if one partner changes so much that the other cannot reconcile them to the person they fell in love with?

your view is very black and and that’s just not the reality of complex human relationships.

chopc · 06/08/2023 08:35

@greydressinggownofdoom @SpongeBobJudgeyPants

It takes two people to make a marriage work so your partners failed on their part. I meant both parties in the marriage need to make the same commitment

talkitup · 06/08/2023 08:34

MisschiefMaker · 05/08/2023 18:01

That's awful. Did you ever ask them why they waited until you were finally in a position to be free of the horrible atmosphere before divorcing? I imagine if they said "we did it for you" that would go down pretty badly!

He refused to divorce and made life hell if my mum tried to separate. Controlling narcissist. There was a huge power differential. I was the driving force behind the eventual successful divorce, even landing my mum money from a student luan to afford it. It was the best day of my life when the degree absolute came through.

greydressinggownofdoom · 06/08/2023 08:16

chopc · 06/08/2023 07:28

Once you have committed to marrying someone at the right time for the right reasons and therefore commit to for better or for worse, I feel you actually have a "duty" to try and be happy and make the other person happy.

Totally agree it is not pleasant to be around unhappy parents.

However I must admit when I was younger I didn't appreciate the love between my parents as there was a lot of bickering and sniping. However as an adult I could appreciate that life is stressful and you can even snap at people you love. So PP may have been experiencing this with their own parents and misunderstood???

So I had a "duty" to be happy when my ex was fucking someone else?

SpongeBobJudgeyPants · 06/08/2023 07:54

Once you have committed to marrying someone at the right time for the right reasons and therefore commit to for better or for worse, I feel you actually have a "duty" to try and be happy and make the other person happy

That's fine as long as it's BOTH parties doing this. Most people get divorced, as did I, because one of the parties does not care about the other person enough to be bothered that their actions are making the spouse very unhappy indeed.

whiteroseredrose · 06/08/2023 07:52

@IWantOutDoI 'I don’t know what planet you live on but I have not met a single divorced person, not one at all, that had not been in a marriage were some sort of abuse was happening.' My parents. Absolutely no abuse but my dad wasn't really right for my mum. This is from her. She left because although he was a really nice guy, they didn't have much in common.

Friends Sue and Tom seemed to have a great marriage, but Sue had her head turned by a doctor at work and left. Huge shock to everyone including Tom. According to Sue she still loved Tom and he would still be her best friend but she was in love with Dr. This was most definitely not the best thing for her DC who then had a mix of step siblings coming and going. DS called their son Sam the saddest person he had ever met. Unfortunately he still is 13 years later.

It isn't clear cut. In an unhappy marriage you are modelling that for your children. Setting their expectations for what marriage looks like. I'm fortunate in that both of my parents had very happy second marriages so I knew what I was looking for.

@ArabeIIaScott said 'Children need happy parents, not married parents.' Unhappy parents are definitely not good for children but it doesn't automatically mean that happy parents mean happy children; particularly when it means blending families. Mum might be happy with her new guy having great sex and feeling fulfilled but her DC are shifting between homes, lose their safe space and have to share their lives with another man's children. This was the situation with my neighbours growing up. The 'blended' siblings absolutely hated eachother.

I'm not sure what the solution is. We all only have one life so shouldn't waste it in misery. Split and divorce if necessary. However don't rush in to setting up home with someone else.

chopc · 06/08/2023 07:28

Once you have committed to marrying someone at the right time for the right reasons and therefore commit to for better or for worse, I feel you actually have a "duty" to try and be happy and make the other person happy.

Totally agree it is not pleasant to be around unhappy parents.

However I must admit when I was younger I didn't appreciate the love between my parents as there was a lot of bickering and sniping. However as an adult I could appreciate that life is stressful and you can even snap at people you love. So PP may have been experiencing this with their own parents and misunderstood???

PopGoesTheWeaselYetAgain · 06/08/2023 06:30

X6hfyib4ms · 06/08/2023 06:23

Divorce is horrible for children and they are likely to be living in circumstances that are less comfortable than if their parents had stayed together (though not in all cases, I appreciate that if you're divorcing a gambler or alcoholic etc).

I agree that some people don't try hard enough to make their marriage work and throw in the towel too soon.

I am getting divorced but it is not my choice. My husband left for another woman. I would have tried to make it work but he wasn't willing.

We used to have a lovely house and the kids went to private school. We will lose all of that now. My eldest daughter cries most days about the situation.

I'd find that really hard. Your kids having to move school and make different friends on top of everything else.

X6hfyib4ms · 06/08/2023 06:23

Divorce is horrible for children and they are likely to be living in circumstances that are less comfortable than if their parents had stayed together (though not in all cases, I appreciate that if you're divorcing a gambler or alcoholic etc).

I agree that some people don't try hard enough to make their marriage work and throw in the towel too soon.

I am getting divorced but it is not my choice. My husband left for another woman. I would have tried to make it work but he wasn't willing.

We used to have a lovely house and the kids went to private school. We will lose all of that now. My eldest daughter cries most days about the situation.

Transmummy · 06/08/2023 05:32

@BeautyGoesToBenidorm you could just scream.

Escapetofrance · 06/08/2023 05:24

I think every circumstance is different for each person.
I stayed with my dh after he had an affair, mainly because I couldn’t bare the thought of a stepmother with my dc and for stability. I’ve worked hard to keep my family together and as happy as possible. I sometimes read the comments on here about step-mums & think I’ve made the right decision although it has not been easy.

Furries · 06/08/2023 04:36

Hope the film was good - what did you go to see?

With regards to divorce - your musings are not worthy of responding to.

Chickenkeev · 06/08/2023 04:29

Haven't RTFT, but this OP is all kinds of wrong. For so many reasons. Grrr.

BeautyGoesToBenidorm · 06/08/2023 04:04

I wish my parents had divorced. They were both selfish and toxic in their own ways, and they were even worse together. I bore the brunt of their resentment towards each other growing up, and I was such an unhappy kid. I'm nearly 40 and it still affects me now.

BeautyGoesToBenidorm · 06/08/2023 03:57

Transmummy · 06/08/2023 03:46

I’ve learned that, no matter what the man has done, it’s always the woman’s fault because she ‘didn’t try hard enough’ and ‘you have to work at marriage’. Not sure what swearing is allowed so 🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬

Also that divorced women are seductresses after happily married men. Honestly?

I got this from my ExMIL! ExH couldn't keep his messages to other women in his pants, amongst other things, and ExMIL said "Well you probably weren't giving him enough attention."

This coming from the woman who divorced ExH's dad for cheating 🙄🙄🙄🙄

Transmummy · 06/08/2023 03:46

Baconisdelicious · 05/08/2023 22:16

It's selfish to put your wants before your children's needs. Children do better in life with two married parents

My ex was having sex with someone else. He moved in with her. He no longer wanted to be with me.

Why are you blaming me?

I’ve learned that, no matter what the man has done, it’s always the woman’s fault because she ‘didn’t try hard enough’ and ‘you have to work at marriage’. Not sure what swearing is allowed so 🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬

Also that divorced women are seductresses after happily married men. Honestly?

IWantOutDoI · 06/08/2023 03:32

ActDottie · 05/08/2023 21:29

I definitely agree to some extent. Growing up divorced parents were not very common but now it’s very common and I don’t know why.

Because it is more common for women these days to work and have their own income, therefore they do not need to put up with the shite our mother’s generation put up with.

PopGoesTheWeaselYetAgain · 06/08/2023 02:56

Readyforafallout · 05/08/2023 22:14

Thank you all so much for sharing your thoughts and beliefs and giving some thought provoking responses.
I don’t fully know what mumsnet etiquette is, It seems more response was required on my part …. I didn’t realise this- so apologises for that.
Thank you all again for responding . I am leaving this post now as I feel I have read a lot more responses than I intended to ever receive!

It seems Readforafallout wasn't actually ready for a fallout! 😄

Johnisafckface · 06/08/2023 01:56

My parents were very toxic. I knew something wasn’t right with them when I was a small child. I never saw them being loving or affectionate with each other. I remember yelling and silent treatments that went on for days, bickering and nasty remarks. It has effected many aspects of my life. They divorced when I was 21… wish they had done it when I was a kid and before I experienced the toxicity of their relationship.

user1473878824 · 06/08/2023 00:41

Are you always this stupid or is it just this post?

Willyoujustbequiet · 06/08/2023 00:39

Vegetus · 05/08/2023 17:40

Are you suggesting kids are better off in an environment where their parents are together but permanently miserable?

It's not always that though. I have friends that thought their families were very happy and the husbands still upped and left with no warning at all. Kids were absolutely torn apart.

So yes sometimes it's incredibly selfish.

Swipe left for the next trending thread