Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think divorce is selfish?

316 replies

Readyforafallout · 05/08/2023 17:31

( Totally different for abusive relationships so not including those in this post)

Am I wrong to think that the following are excuses for basically gaining a moral green light for being selfish and swapping your own discontent for a child’s upheaval and distress ?

’ Kids are resilient’
‘ they will pick up on it so you are better of to divorce !’ ( even if the parents DO hide it well, people being convinced they will notice feels again an excuse)
‘ You only have one life OP! …’ ( so do the children)

it just seems that people ‘ grow apart…’
‘ want different things’ and put themselves ahead of their children…. I know this is likely an unpopular opinion
but hearing how ‘ brave ‘ people are for ‘ having the guts to do something about their situation’ seems selfish to me ….

because the children’s world are being opened to who knows who!…. As potential step parents !…. Complete upheaval And emotional distress … That’s worse than ‘ picking up’ on not much in my opinion .

it’s not a post intended to be unkind to divorces but more to not hold it in the highest regard like some achievement of braveness. It feels selfish ?

OP posts:
Dentistlakes · 05/08/2023 18:11

My parents divorced when I was 14 and it was a very traumatic experience for me. However, my childhood was always marred by the fact they weren’t remotely suited and the trauma of the divorce was mostly due to how badly my mother behaved throughout and for many years afterwards. I was certainly made to ‘pay’ for her failed marriage, over and over.

Had they remained together, I have no doubt my life would have been miserable. As it turned out, my father remarried and had been very happy ever since, which has been lovely to see.

There really is nothing good about remaining together ‘for the kids’. You can however make it less traumatic by not behaving like a complete arsehole though.

SpongeBobJudgeyPants · 05/08/2023 18:11

greydressinggownofdoom · 05/08/2023 18:09

Also. Why would you think that anyone owes you the real truth of why they are divorcing rather than the socially soft answer of "we grew apart"?

This, with knobs on. If you're getting this said to you a lot, you might like to think about MYOB.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 05/08/2023 18:11

Surely the selfish thing is not leaving a marriage in which you are unhappy, but jumping into new relationships which involve the children or not putting the children’s needs first when it comes to new relationships. Just because parents are divorced doesn’t mean step-parents have to be involved, it’s possible to have a new relationship without marrying/ moving in together until you are sure that your children won’t be adversely effected. Step-parents aren’t always a negative, they can bring many positives, but usually only if they are introduced at the child’s pace and where the parents haven’t moved the relationship forward until they knew their children and new partner were able to get on.

halfthesun · 05/08/2023 18:11

YABU.

Itsbeenabadday · 05/08/2023 18:11

*unhappy 🙄

Grendell · 05/08/2023 18:10

I remember some super-conservative person saying there are only 3 reasons to divorce - the three A's - Abuse, Addiction and Adultery.

That's nuts. GTFO if you want to - for any reason.

Itsbeenabadday · 05/08/2023 18:10

In my experience it is better for the child if the parents in an I happy relationship separate. Mine didn't until I was 17 and I felt like I had been waiting for it my whole life. Children are extremely perceptive and hiding the truth about an unhappy relationship is both dishonest and setting a terrible example of marriage.

AmazingSnakeHead · 05/08/2023 18:10

I agree with what everyone else is saying: just because it's selfish doesn't mean that it's wrong. Loads of things are selfish, but morally permissable. You owe your children a good life: you don't owe them the best possible life they could have had, if giving them that makes you miserable.

And anyway, often it is better for the children. My parents divorced when I was about 10, I was fine with it.

greydressinggownofdoom · 05/08/2023 18:09

Also. Why would you think that anyone owes you the real truth of why they are divorcing rather than the socially soft answer of "we grew apart"?

vodkaredbullgirl · 05/08/2023 18:09

🤔divorce or stay in an unhappy marriage. Divorced 14 yrs, happier than ever.

JMSA · 05/08/2023 18:08

Your view seems very blinkered, OP.

Coffeaddict · 05/08/2023 18:08

My parents stayed together because in ireland in the late 80s divorce wasn't a thing.

They despised each other, it was a horrible horrible environment to grow up in. I remember the divorce referendum I must have been 8-9. When my mum explained what it was my first thought was you and dad should do that.

I remember being shocked at my friends parents kissing. I just assumed all parents hated each other.

YABU to assume every situation is the same

Arabels · 05/08/2023 18:07

Bit baffling tbh. Why get married in the first place, if not because you want to? Surely, therefore, the inverse is also valid?

I agree that some of the reasons that get trotted out for divorcing can sound glib. The socially acceptable reasons I roll out certainly do-‘we were better as friends’ etc. In fact that relationship was not emotionally survivable and we chose to walk away with our dignity intact rather than destroy one another by hanging on til grim death. We’re coparenting amicably now.

greydressinggownofdoom · 05/08/2023 18:07

Baconisdelicious · 05/08/2023 18:06

@greydressinggownofdoom

No doubt we will be told we should have been more careful about who we married. That's the usual line.

Yip. I was told on another thread that it was my fault. (The post was deleted but the sentiment stands)

pointythings · 05/08/2023 18:07

I think saying 'if there's no abuse or infidelity, divorce is always selfish' is far too simplistic.

My mother grew up in a toxic marriage - her mother was left a widow after WW2 and remarried quickly, had two more children and then realised her mistake. She finally divorced in 1979 when all her DDs were grown up, but all of them were damaged by the toxicity between their parents. Constant low level negativity and disrespect, whether from one partner or both, absolutely will have an adverse effect on children.

What does the damage IMO is having a really negative adversarial divorce and either parent prioritising new relationships. I very nearly got divorced (my husband died 12 days before the nisi was pronounced) and believe me, my DDs were counting down the days (but he was abusive) - but I was always determined not to engage in another relationship until they were grown. I've since realised I love being single.

I also know a couple who split when their DD was very young, made it amicable, co-parented properly 50/50 and are now better as friends than they ever were as a couple.

The bottom line is that if people are grown up and put their DC first, it doesn't have to be bad. The issue is that so few people handle it that way.

Baconisdelicious · 05/08/2023 18:06

greydressinggownofdoom · 05/08/2023 18:00

My ex had an affair.

Are you counting that as abusive?

@greydressinggownofdoom

No doubt we will be told we should have been more careful about who we married. That's the usual line.

Whataretheodds · 05/08/2023 18:06

Children do pick up on their parents being unhappy in relationships. They pick up on tension, on the small ways in which they express disdain, contempt or even a lack of consideration for them. It can be extremely destructive. They also most likely won't be set an example of functional and happy adult relationships which makes it harder for them to know what's good and health when they embark on relationships themselves.

Is that better?

muppetmayhem · 05/08/2023 18:05

What a naive thing to think. I’ve watched my parents exist in a relationship of contempt. It was a relief to everyone when they got a divorce.

I’m divorced my children don’t remember me being with their father. I’m pleased about that I was a shell of my self living with him. Afraid to speak, walking on eggshells and when I left I was raped and had the shit kicked out of me for my troubles. What would my children have seen if they had grown old enough to remember and how would that have scarred them?

Circe7 · 05/08/2023 18:05

I think it’s very difficult to stay in some marriages even if there’s no abuse. My ex got to the point where he refused to do any parenting or housework. He didn’t even make excuses. Just said he wasn’t doing it even when I was ill etc. The only way we could have stayed together without fighting was for me to do everything with no complaints. It would be very hard to keep that up for 18+ years and I’m not sure it would be best for the children anyway. You’d be showing them that the mother’s role is to do everything without ever voicing their feelings. My ex is actually more involved as a father now we’re separated. I agree to an extent that children are usually negatively affected by divorce but it can be very very hard to remain in a relationship where you want to divorce. It would mean faking most of your feelings for years and I don’t think I would even have been capable of that if I’d wanted to.

greydressinggownofdoom · 05/08/2023 18:04

Also - people do grow apart. I recognise that my ex and I probably did that. He hadn't changed and grown, I had.

Was I supposed to just stay and let him have affair(s)? And be miserable? Was I supposed to have an affair too? Was it selfish of me to say, no, we need to be apart I am not doing this any longer?

Daffodilwoman · 05/08/2023 18:02

I had an ex who told me he longed for his father to die as a child. Every single day as he walked home from school he would prey that today might be the day. He knew his abused mother would never have the guts to leave. His father had told all his dcs and wife that over his dead body would he ever leave. That left him free to beat the living daylights out if each and everyone if them. He also control every single thing they did with an iron fist. Told them what to do and what to think. His parents are still married.
How on earth is this better than divorcing?

INeedAnotherName · 05/08/2023 18:02

Sometimes it is worse to grow up with two unhappy parents.

I really wish my parents had divorced when I was younger. My mother raised me, my father was a waste of air.

BreadInCaptivity · 05/08/2023 18:01

Newphony · 05/08/2023 17:48

Yes I agree, exposing children to step parents is far more damaging. They rarely have the children's best interests at heart. Mostly just out for themselves.

I think that should be correct to CAN be more damaging.

I know many happy blended families (including my own where DH has a child from a previous relationship).

However, those are families that have worked to prioritise the best interests of the child/children, taken things slowly and with sensitivity.

Just as I wouldn't generalise about divorce being selfish, neither would I damn all subsequent relationships.

Ontheperiphery79 · 05/08/2023 18:01

I'd rather be thought of as selfish than have stayed in an unhappy marriage.

MisschiefMaker · 05/08/2023 18:01

talkitup · 05/08/2023 17:55

Interesting thread. I'm the adult 'child' of unhappily married parents who did not divorce. I spent most of my childhood and adolescence on tenterhooks and dearly wishing they would divorce; which eventually they did, when I was 19.

That's awful. Did you ever ask them why they waited until you were finally in a position to be free of the horrible atmosphere before divorcing? I imagine if they said "we did it for you" that would go down pretty badly!