Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What makes visitors CFs?

109 replies

RedLeicesterRedLeicester · 05/08/2023 16:51

I’m remembering the thread that ended in tears over a steak dinner. I’m thinking when people aren’t obviously such CFs but have crossed the line.

What is the subtle turning point when family & friends become CFs?

OP posts:
PTSDBarbiegirl · 09/08/2023 10:21

For me it's the act of turning up annanounced expecting to visit or worse stay. I've gone NC with plenty of people over this, sounds ridiculous but for me unplanned dropping in is totally unwelcome.

pacifictime · 09/08/2023 10:18

365BeachDays · 05/08/2023 17:01

Asking for a tour of your house. Just no. We're not friends anymore.

What's wrong with this?!

passiveaggressivechoppedcarrot · 09/08/2023 10:13

My parents had a BBQ at their house once so I was being the dutiful daughter and offering drinks when people arrived - one guest informed me that he would look in the fridge himself to see what we had. This was the first time he'd ever stepped foot in the house!
Same guy (on the same day) when I was offering top ups of drinks told me to "serve the ladies first" with a dismissive flick of his hand!
He was never invited back!

MiMouse · 09/08/2023 10:10

@OhComeOnFFS That's just not how I see it. DH and I have been living together for over 20 years; parents have long ago left the family home. Besides, I often bring my mum flowers when we go and visit her, especially on special occasions.

EsmeSusanOgg · 09/08/2023 10:02

Yourebeingtooloud · 09/08/2023 09:50

No see this attitude annoys me - why is it the woman’s job to sort gifts? Presumably she comes with your son (& in the earlier example brother) but you’re not cross with them. Think about why that is.

Agree. DH is supposed to sort his family. I remind. If he forgets, that is on him.

OhComeOnFFS · 09/08/2023 09:59

But @MiMouse you are guest in their home, which is why you should bring flowers or whatever. Their son is just going home, so he has less need to bring anything like that.

Blossomtoes · 09/08/2023 09:56

Yourebeingtooloud · 09/08/2023 09:50

No see this attitude annoys me - why is it the woman’s job to sort gifts? Presumably she comes with your son (& in the earlier example brother) but you’re not cross with them. Think about why that is.

I’ll tell you exactly why it is. It’s because when we go we take gifts for her. She’s a chocoholic and loves flowers. He doesn’t give a stuff about them. It’s called reciprocation.

Yourebeingtooloud · 09/08/2023 09:50

Blossomtoes · 09/08/2023 08:18

Dil is the same, despite us taking nice food, wine, flowers and chocolates to theirs every single time. Actually I lie - she managed a £1 bunch of daffs when she was trying to impress us.

No see this attitude annoys me - why is it the woman’s job to sort gifts? Presumably she comes with your son (& in the earlier example brother) but you’re not cross with them. Think about why that is.

MiMouse · 09/08/2023 09:49

I'm a DIL who never brings anything (flowers, chocolates, wine) when we visit my PIL, not even on their birthdays. I think that's my husband's job, since they are his parents. And I know the fact that he never does it somehow makes me look bad, but I refuse to give in to this ridiculous sexism. Although recently I did buy a present for his niece when we were invited to her birthday party. He would have had us turn up empty handed, and I couldn't do that to a six year old.

Anyway, I'm a CF according to lots of people on this thread, but honestly, I think it's just cultural / individual differences. I would hate for my own guests to for example start doing dishes and stripping their beds at my home. I have a system; I don't want anyone messing with that. I don't want them to see the stain on the guest duvet that I haven't been able to wash out.

How about if you'd like some help, you just ask? I would always be happy to help out if someone asked. I'd just never presume to offer.

Azaeleasinbloom · 09/08/2023 09:41

All of the above, but dumping 2 spoiled brats on me to ‘have a long lie’ as they were going back to work next day - right back at you , mate - was the nail in the coffin for me.
Never again.

EsmeSusanOgg · 09/08/2023 09:37

We have a dog, we love dogs, but people trying to bring their dogs with them without checking first really annoys me..especially as some dogs are better trained/ less hassle than others. If I allow X's well behaved dashund to stay it does not mean I will allow your reactive, dog aggressive bully to stay.

EsmeSusanOgg · 09/08/2023 09:33

Taking obscenely long showers (20/30 mins plus) in the main family bathroom - also note, we are on a water meter.

Staying in bed until nearly midday, when everyone else has been up since 8/9am.

Arriving late in the evening and expecting to be picked up from the train station rather than getting a taxi - especially when staying with family who have young children.

Expecting everything to be catered for you and cleaned up after you.

Uppersop · 09/08/2023 09:09

A terribly bully who made my husband’s childhood a nightmare visited from abroad (sort of obliged to put him up after a death in the family). Used our house a base, but in the few days he was with us he ruined the shower curtain by dying his hair. Wandered around half naked. Deliberately left sharp knives in reach of the children, wouldn’t come to the dining table for at least 15 minutes after being told the meal was served. Screwed up a pile of his clothes that l had just laundered and ironed for him (in front of me). And many, more weird behaviours. The last straw was when we took him to a restaurant and he tried to bully our child into giving him their dessert as he thought it looked better than the one he’d ordered for himself. He was so used to dominating my husband that he obviously thought he could do the same to our five year old. He was asked to leave (he had other people to stay with), but a couple of weeks later we received a hand written letter from him outlining everything he felt was wrong with us. Amongst other things, he was shocked at how fat and lazy I was, the house was filthy, what dangerous drivers we were, and how, if he was resident in the UK, he would have gone to court to get custody of our children. It was such a bizarre diatribe that we were able to laugh about it. Needless to say, we have had absolutely no contact since.

Meeting · 09/08/2023 09:05

SidekickSylvia · 09/08/2023 08:20

The only thing I've ever minded is when friends of dh brought their dog for the weekend, without any prior warning. We had an 8 month old baby who had just settled into a routine and finally slept from 7 pm until 5.30 am. The dog barked all night, both nights and it took a month to reestablish ds' routine. You should always check with hosts if it's okay to bring your dog.

But why allow the dog to stay? I would have said no, especially after the first night of barking.

SidekickSylvia · 09/08/2023 08:20

The only thing I've ever minded is when friends of dh brought their dog for the weekend, without any prior warning. We had an 8 month old baby who had just settled into a routine and finally slept from 7 pm until 5.30 am. The dog barked all night, both nights and it took a month to reestablish ds' routine. You should always check with hosts if it's okay to bring your dog.

Blossomtoes · 09/08/2023 08:18

Yogazmum · 09/08/2023 08:15

My SIL in the 20 years of being with DH has always turned up empty handed…. even on Christmas Day! It’s turned into a joke between DH & I now 🤣
I presume she just thinks it’s because she’s family.

Dil is the same, despite us taking nice food, wine, flowers and chocolates to theirs every single time. Actually I lie - she managed a £1 bunch of daffs when she was trying to impress us.

Yogazmum · 09/08/2023 08:15

My SIL in the 20 years of being with DH has always turned up empty handed…. even on Christmas Day! It’s turned into a joke between DH & I now 🤣
I presume she just thinks it’s because she’s family.

Ragwort · 09/08/2023 08:12

Rach ... I never stay with anyone apart from family or one very close friend, we have known each other since primary school.

Just as there are CF guests.... some people are not very good hosts. .. the awkwardness of knowing when to get up ... I stayed with a family once and they just didn't get up .. in the end I got up, went for a long walk and to a coffee shop, DH got up and did some DIY (quietly) that they had asked him to do ... they finally surfaced around midday!

DH recently stayed with a friend, the friend said he always had a takeaway on a Saturday night, my DH offered to pay and sort it, friend said no bother, he'd do it ... the meal was just a packet of chips! In the morning the friend didn't get up .. DH needed to leave (friend knew this) but needed a key to get out of the door, spent an hour looking for it! Never again!

elsieandthepooch · 09/08/2023 08:07

Not liking the sleeping arrangements. Expecting the house to be quiet whilst they lie in until mid-day. Questioning how much wine has been consumed whilst they were out.... This is a member of DH's family. He is 40 and single.

Rach247 · 09/08/2023 07:55

Other than in my parents’ house, which I think is different, I would never stay with anyone longer than three nights, even family.

I never want guests to strip the bed, much prefer to leave it and wash the sheets at a time my choosing.

UsernameNotAvailableNow · 09/08/2023 07:47

I find it really stressful to stay at someone’s house as we never did it as kids so I am not really sure of expectations. I get anxious about over staying our welcome. But broadly, would never turn up empty handed, keep in touch re plans, thank them for hosting, tidy up after ourselves, never stay more than 2 nights, often 1.

Would never have thought to strip the beds though. I’d have thought that a bit weird if someone did that at ours.

FourEyesGood · 09/08/2023 07:43

Reading this thread has made me almost thankful that I have a tiny house (with no spare rooms) in a location that no-one ever really wants to visit!

Meeting · 09/08/2023 07:40

To be honest I think there has to be a conversation about letting people walk all over you. I would never allow most of these situations to happen in my home.

BeenThereDoneThat101 · 09/08/2023 07:37

Rivermedway · 09/08/2023 07:09

I think the concept of hosting has changed over time.

As the host, I would expect to cook, clear up etc. It’s nice if people offer, but not mandatory. Similarly, I wouldn’t expect them to strip beds. They’re here as my guest.

This.

And tbh I wonder if the same people complaining that the guests didn’t offer to clean up did and then put the dishes back in the wrong place.

That being said, I had one lot of guests who:

took their dog upstairs with them despite the fact I had told them that the dogs were not allowed upstairs.
The woman stayed in bed until 2:30 and at about 1:30 the bloke came down and asked if I could provide them with a cooked meal right now as she would get sick when travelling later if she ate too close to travelling.

She got up, had dinner, and they left almost straight after.

Oh and before they arrived he rang to ask if it would be ok to come a day early as the accommodation they had arranged had fallen through (they were essentially passing through) I said yes, and they didn’t arrive until 10:30 at night because they’d decided to meet up with friends at the last minute (without telling us), and went straight to bed.

Another lot arrived with nothing, and then proceeded to eat us out of house and home. I’m a generous cook, and was more than happy for him to finish the stir-fry which was left in the pan after everyone had eaten, but the next morning I served pastries for breakfast, put them all out on the table while I made coffee and he helped himself to all the ones which were left after dp and his dp had had some meaning there were none left for me. Then my ds came down and asked if he could have a bacon roll and he said “oh yeah that sounds great I’ll have one of those,”.

I’ve since got a new job and converted my spare room into an office. ;)

Effingmagicfairy · 09/08/2023 07:31

Family member used to turn up with 3DC every summer, breathe a sigh of relief on arrival as had been looking forward to their annual holiday and do absolutely nothing until departing, date of which never confirmed as they would go by the weather. Their DC were fussy eaters, I was left to cater while they had an afternoon nap, clear up after them etc, then had to provide dinner for adults. This could be for a week or two at a time, we worked full time and had taken annual leave to accommodate. After the 2 week stint, which was only supposed to be a week but I had mentioned we were having a second week off to ourselves as the weather was good they decided without invitation to stay on, leaving us to return to work exhausted. Never see much of family member now the DC have grown.

Swipe left for the next trending thread