Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not insure my pets?

191 replies

Chevrotains · 05/08/2023 15:33

Does anyone here just put away savings each month for their pets? I'm aware there is definitely a risk to this as well, but just tired of the amount going up each renewal.

OP posts:
LammasEve · 05/08/2023 17:48

I thought about putting the insurance money aside each month, then 2 £3k bills for one cat, followed by another £500 for him, and £200 for another just in a year made me think again. All paid by insurance (excess £99, lifetime cover), so while the premium will go up it's still worthwhile.

I'd hate to be in a position where I had to have one PTS because I couldn't afford a big bill.

EvilElsa · 05/08/2023 17:47

Always have for our dogs and horses. Once had a 7k bill for a pony so thanked my lucky stars for it then. Also have the legal cover and public liability as we ride in areas used by the public like bridleways and roads. Compensation claims can be in their millions, so I'd rather have that insurance cover than risk my house etc!
I've got (and always had) lurchers so no pure breed premiums here. The monthly cost is affordable.

Seeingadistance · 05/08/2023 17:47

Have two cats who've been insured for two years now. I took out the insurance after losing another cat who became suddenly and unexpectedly unwell - cost me almost £1,000 over 3 days of illness, then he was put to sleep.

In the two years the current cats have been insured, one of them has had surgery twice - total cost of about £4,000 which the insurance paid, less total excesses of £75.

So yeah, after years of pet ownership with no insurance I think I'm committed to it now.

Tinytigertail · 05/08/2023 17:41

My dog slipped a disc and was paralysed in her back legs. Total cost was £7k, we'd had her less than two years. I've never been so pleased that we didn't just 'put a bit up each month' insurance for us was worth every penny.

eatdrinkandbemerry · 05/08/2023 17:40

I've always insured mine until the premiums got insane when they reached their senior years.
I wouldn't put an older animal through big surgeries or cancer treatments so I found it pointless paying insane premiums after age 10

Forgoodnesssakewhatnow · 05/08/2023 17:38

I have pet insurance but I do this for all other things - appliances, boiler cover etc (including life cover and income protection actually). Overall you end up quids in.

But pet bills can be astronomical so it’s the one insurance I think is worth it.

DRS1970 · 05/08/2023 17:38

We tried insurance. But ultimately find it easier, and better value, to save money each month.

Maggiesgirl · 05/08/2023 17:36

I stopped DDogs insurance when she reached 8 and we had never used it.
She is now 13 and apart from check ups and diazapan for her anxiety of fireworks, which cost were both under our previous excess, she has never needed anything.

SunBarelyHuman · 05/08/2023 17:36

By the time my dog died at 11.5 I was paying £80 per month. I payed a lot less at first, but can't remember how much. But say it was £80 the whole time, that's £11,040.
Given a single big vets bill for a serious injury will be at least half that (her brother cost £6k for a three day vet hospital stay alone) then good luck having enough saved if you use that method.
My grandfather always said "insurance is a luxury, until you need it"

ttcat37 · 05/08/2023 17:31

I used to just put away £50 a month for my dog. This was fine when he needed a minor op to the tune of £450. Then he started to need monthly injections at £85 each and it soon disappeared! He is a large breed and when he turned 11 and was seemingly pretty healthy I knew anything that happened would be expensive so I took out a policy that covers £2000 of vet bills a year, just to at least take the edge off anything pricey. It was about £35 a month but the first year we used it all up on one emergency incident requiring an out of hours hospital stay. Renewal came around and it went up to £45 but I kept paying. We’ve claimed once already and now found that he needs a £4000-5000 operation. So although we will have to fork out most of it, at least a good chunk is covered.
The thing that costs the most, I’ve found, is out of hours care and 24/7 hospital care. More than the actual procedure or drugs.

My advice would be, could you afford thousands on operations if needed? If you can afford the monthly payments for peace of mind for insurance I would do it. I do slightly regret not getting a more comprehensive policy but that’s the gamble you take.

@Showdogworkingdog I know you didn’t say what your dog’s mobility issues were but ours has arthritis (and cdrm) and has monthly librella injections. They’ve been a game changer. Day before injection his legs give way, the day after he bounds around the garden like a much younger dog.

ChiPawPrint · 05/08/2023 17:29

I just cancelled my pet insurance for a chihuahua. You have to pay the vet up front anyway so you have to have the money available to start with.

Also the premiums were near on £30 a month so I decided to have a separate pet account and put the money in there instead so it's there when needed.

Nearlyadoctor · 05/08/2023 17:28

Guiltyfeethavegotnorhythm0 · 05/08/2023 17:12

I can't believe the amount of posters here leaving themselves wide open to financial ruin , not having third party for dogs .

Our pet dog is covered for third party on house insurance which we checked prior to choosing not to insure her. Vets fees have gone up extortionately mainly fuelled by people having pet insurance. One of the farm dogs broke his back leg and hip - we told the vets £2000 was the budget and could they sort it for that , answer was yes no problem . Insured I’m guessing nearer 5/6K .

Poppins2016 · 05/08/2023 17:27

I have 3 cats and two of them have had very minor operations (superficial wound revision/closure) that have cost a thousand pounds each. One of those two has also had treatments costing three figures a few times. I think the insurance has paid out about the same as we've put in over 12 years. I don't think we've have been as disciplined about saving into a "pet" account for that long, but could see that if we did and were good about not touching it, having no insurance could have worked out. The main thing that concerns me (and the main reason we have insurance) is that anything more than a superficial wound will cost many more thousands and we could just about deal with that as a one off, however I'd prefer to retain that savings cushion for other things... I sleep much better at night knowing that insurance will cover emergency expenses in case of accident or major illness.

MereDintofPandiculation · 05/08/2023 17:26

I might insure my cat if I had one cat. Since I have 3 I don’t, not because I can’t afford it, but because it’s unlikely they’ll all require treatment at once, so the money saved on premiums for two of them can pay vet bills for the third.

ClinkyWotsit · 05/08/2023 17:25

Depends on the animal being insured. I have an older indoor moggy cat and now put away the premiums each month into savings. She had a check up recently and will need a dental clean which might result in an extraction but insurance wouldn’t cover any dental work.

My other older cat who passed away last year was fully insured but there was an excess plus a reduction in payout due to her age, plus it didn’t cover, which we sadly ended up with, being put to sleep, so I think I ended up getting back £200 on a £700 claim. Since then I’ve saved the £60-odd a month premiums instead.

However if I had a horse, or a pug or similar which are known to be prone to some illnesses, I definitely wouldn’t take the risk.

DollyTots · 05/08/2023 17:20

It’s a gamble. We’ve insured our 1 year old cat for £12 a month. He got pyrexia last week and we ended up with a £500 vet bill. We claimed and got it back very painlessly, so I’m glad we did insure him.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 05/08/2023 17:19

One of our dogs managed to rupture both cruciate ligaments, needing two lots of orthopaedic surgery, and a further one when she dislocated her kneecap within a couple of months, then developed a gastric ulcer from the pain relief.

All in all Petplan paid out just over £10,000 - and she had several more happy healthy years, so worth every penny.

Pet insurance is a gamble, @Chevrotains - we definitely won, but plenty of people don’t so I guess it’s up to how risk averse you are.

senior30 · 05/08/2023 17:17

It’s your risk to take. Two of my dogs have never needed insurance, the other maxed out the limit and we had to top up for his treatment. He would have been put to sleep without his insurance, I would have to be in dire straits to ever cancel.

BCSurvivor · 05/08/2023 17:16

I have three young cats and donhsve insurance.
Previously I had two utterly adored cats, also without insurance, that lived to be nearly 17 and 19 and a half.
While they were relatively young it was just teeth ops and boosters that I was paying for, with a once in a blue moon consultation and treatment for something mild.
They did cost more from about 13 years onwards....one had hyperthyroidism, the other had stomatitis and suspected oral cancer.
But I still think I would have paid more if tgey had been insured.

Feelingfree · 05/08/2023 17:16

My cat chipped the top of her femur a couple of years ago and needed surgery, the vet bill came to £4k. Thankfully she was, and still is, insured.

KatieB55 · 05/08/2023 17:15

We didn't but then our 8yr old dog needed £10k surgery. She was too young to pts. She has recovered well and has a happy life at 10. We have insurance now and past the two year exclusion for pre-existing conditions.

GetOurraMeWay · 05/08/2023 17:14

Good question OP. I winced at the £500 premium when we got our doodle last year. One emergency vet visit (when he found marijuana in the park and ate it) later, it had paid for itself. I think where we live this is a fairly common problem! So that plus any other issue eg he eats something dodgy from the garden or damages a joint trying to jump over something, and it's worth it to me.

Showdogworkingdog · 05/08/2023 17:14

My dog is 14. We’re fortunate he’s always been well so we’ve never claimed on his pet insurance. As a young pup the premiums were ok but it increases every year as he gets older. We’re now paying £111 a month insurance premium. There’s no point in shopping around now so I’m sucking it up, grudgingly. Recently he’s been struggling with his mobility and he’s been to the vets a few times Each visit is a £50 consultation fee plus medication anther £50. The excess is now £100 plus 20% of the treatment so these visits don’t meet the threshold to claim. The vet has mentioned he might need an MRI which would cost around £3k, our excess would still be £700 or so on that but that would literally be the only thing we’ve ever claimed. It’s not been good value.

if I had another dog I’d put away £100 a month for any vets fees and wouldn’t insure. It is a risk of course, a friend’s dog needed emergency treatment and a referral to a specialist vets aged three which would’ve been thousands without insurance but I resent now that I’m being stung for my insurance premium and I’d still be left with a big bill if he needed treatment.

Guiltyfeethavegotnorhythm0 · 05/08/2023 17:12

I can't believe the amount of posters here leaving themselves wide open to financial ruin , not having third party for dogs .

Tara336 · 05/08/2023 17:08

My dog is insured as very young and it's good cover for very little money, however, I am also putting money away for the future when I will self insure as my last Ddog was insured all his life and I did make a couple of claims but majority of his treatment wither fell below the excess or wasn't covered in the end. When the last insurer put his premium up to 4 times the previous years premium when he had his 10th birthday I was pretty disgusted as we hadn't made any claims at all for a few years, unfortunately Ddog took very ill 2 weeks before his insurance was due for renewal and despite good cover the vet advised there was nothing that could be done for him, other than a couple treatments that were unpleasant and probably wouldn't work so I took the decision to have him put to sleep.

Swipe left for the next trending thread