Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not insure my pets?

191 replies

Chevrotains · 05/08/2023 15:33

Does anyone here just put away savings each month for their pets? I'm aware there is definitely a risk to this as well, but just tired of the amount going up each renewal.

OP posts:
SlightlygrumpyBettyswaitress · 05/08/2023 18:33

Most people are covered for liability under their household contents.
We are insured for our little dog.

LemonLight · 05/08/2023 18:28

I think it would be madness to not insure pets. Over the years our dog had giardia, then had hemorrhagic gastroenteritis then ate a sock and needed surgery and then had a chest infection and then heart failure. It would have cost us thousands had we not had insurance.

Ohthatsabitshit · 05/08/2023 18:25

Money is not love. Treating whatever the cost is not love.

HRTQueen · 05/08/2023 18:24

I have cancelled my cats insurance

was going up to £60

he is 19 no longer goes out so I do not bother with injections. He seems fine and I use herbal pain relief for his arthritis he sleeps most of the day, has decided social norms do not apply to him and purrs when cuddles up to me (it’s not as often)

Every time we went I was talked into blood tests all came back fine and remarkable for his age. Next time he goes it will be to pts (if can’t be at home) I wouldn’t give him any treatments now he has had an amazingly pampered life

Arniesleftleg · 05/08/2023 18:23

depends how much you love your Pet. My kitty is part of the family and has been insures since day 1, 9 years ago. It's cost us about 2.5k over the 9 years but I'd not dream of not having insurance. If something happened and she got sick and the vet said say 9k to make her better, we'd be stuffed, so insurance is essential.

My friend was on the cusp of stopping her cats insurance and a week later one of her fur babies got his fave half ripped off by a fox. It cost over 12k to fix the poor thing. Thankfully she didn't stop the insurance!

Ohthatsabitshit · 05/08/2023 18:23

Work2live · 05/08/2023 18:01

We’ve had over £2k from our dog’s insurance over the last couple of years, both for relatively minor/common things (removal of a cancerous lump being one). So it’s been well worth it for us. He’s a big dog too so any treatment generally costs more - as does his insurance!

But he’s getting on in years now and our most recent renewal went up so it’s now almost £90 a month.

I’m not sure we’ll renew again, we do have savings and will keep putting money away for him, but he’s getting to an age where we wouldn’t want to put him through complex surgeries etc anyway, sadly.

At £90 a month you’re paying over a thousand a year, so it seems an unusual decision

studentgrant · 05/08/2023 18:20

It's also about treatments you would pay for. My elderly cat died at 18, and I wouldn't have paid for extensive medication once she became ill. It wouldn't have been fair on her, or possibly affordable for us. As it happened, I paid for a x rat and she the vet thought that she wouldn't live anyway.

thetombliboo · 05/08/2023 18:20

I had a dog who's monthly prescription for allergies and skin problems was coming up to £200 a month In the end which was to be for her lifetime. She then died at 5 from something unrelated and sudden, they recommended a pet icu at just under 1k per night. She didn't make it there and it still cost over a thousand. When I brought our new dog home I insured her immediately.

I think vets can really be a lot when you're not expecting it or another monthly bill if they need ongoing treatment.

It also depends what type of owner you are, some people view their pets as pets and others don't. Unless money is no issue the cost most definitely impacts your decision making when you don't have the insurance.

Sarvanga38 · 05/08/2023 18:20

@Showdogworkingdog, surely all these visits are part of one ongoing condition too? I can’t see why you wouldn’t be able to claim these bills, having just paid the one excess?

BouncerFish · 05/08/2023 18:18

When my healthy, loved dog was diagnosed with cancer at age 6 and a half, we spent almost every penny of his £12k coverage on diagnosis and such treatment as we were able to give him. Thank goodness for insurance.

Sarvanga38 · 05/08/2023 18:16

Showdogworkingdog · 05/08/2023 17:14

My dog is 14. We’re fortunate he’s always been well so we’ve never claimed on his pet insurance. As a young pup the premiums were ok but it increases every year as he gets older. We’re now paying £111 a month insurance premium. There’s no point in shopping around now so I’m sucking it up, grudgingly. Recently he’s been struggling with his mobility and he’s been to the vets a few times Each visit is a £50 consultation fee plus medication anther £50. The excess is now £100 plus 20% of the treatment so these visits don’t meet the threshold to claim. The vet has mentioned he might need an MRI which would cost around £3k, our excess would still be £700 or so on that but that would literally be the only thing we’ve ever claimed. It’s not been good value.

if I had another dog I’d put away £100 a month for any vets fees and wouldn’t insure. It is a risk of course, a friend’s dog needed emergency treatment and a referral to a specialist vets aged three which would’ve been thousands without insurance but I resent now that I’m being stung for my insurance premium and I’d still be left with a big bill if he needed treatment.

My dog is 14 ... The vet has mentioned he might need an MRI which would cost around £3k, our excess would still be £700 or so on that but that would literally be the only thing we’ve ever claimed. It’s not been good value.

I am a firm pro-insurance person with much loved pet dogs, but I am also pragmatic about not putting elderly dogs through invasive procedures.

When my vet suggested an MRI on my elderly dog, I asked them what on earth they thought they were likely to be able to fix if they found it at that age, when the issues they were addressing were related to age. I then changed vet.

I would be asking your vet the same!

FoodFann · 05/08/2023 18:16

Two months of paying £30, and wracked up a £2500 bill. Best £60 I’ve ever spent

JMSA · 05/08/2023 18:12

My dog is insured. My cat (now passed away) was insured for YEARS and YEARS, then I let it slip. You couldn't make it up, after never making a claim, something went wrong in the month's gap between him being insured and not being insured. It cost me a lot of money ... never again!
I get the logic of putting money aside every month instead. But knowing my luck, something would go wrong when I'd put 100 quid aside.

SunBarelyHuman · 05/08/2023 18:09

pedigree Cockapoo
*
🤦‍♀️*

AgnesX · 05/08/2023 18:08

MrsMoastyToasty · 05/08/2023 15:58

I currently have our 2 cats insured with Petplan. When we got the renewal notice this year they said that they will be in contact next year when they are 10 years old about changes to their cover. I'll see how much it will be and make a decision then. However I'm wary of cancelling it as Toasty Boy Cat had calicivirus and toxoplasmosis in the same year and the claim amounted to £4k.

Be careful when renewing and check pre existing conditions are covered. We found out the hard way with a previous pet.

AgnesX · 05/08/2023 18:06

My cat has arthritis, his meds, which have given him a new lease of life, costs £150 every 5 weeks give or take. TF for insurance.

Ginandtoxic · 05/08/2023 18:05

I don't know why so many people think you only need insurance for extreme or life threatening conditions. I have a dog and two cats and have had to claim for all of them. Not for things like cancer or life long illnesses, but for biopsies, a broken leg, my kitten swallowed a massive hair bobble and had to go to emergency vets. None of those i would've been able to afford. And I'm not going to put a 5 month old kitten to sleep for swallowing a bobble because I couldn't afford the 5k the treatment it came to.

Ultimately it depends on whether you have enough savings to pay for any treatment that may crop up. If you are financially well off then I'd say just put money away, as some people never have to claim and it's a waste of money. However for myself I never wouldve had enough saved up to pay for the treatments. What if you just start saving, then a month later your pet needs treatment costing a couple thousand pounds? Its all personal choice of course but I feel like if your pet gets ill or injured it's more stressful to hear "this is going to cost 6k" if you've got to cough up that amount all at once, rather than just paying £100 a month and feeling safe in the knowledge that if anything happens they can be treated.

KingOfThieves · 05/08/2023 18:05

We have it. A few years ago I wouldn’t have bothered. The one of our cats degloved its leg and another needed its tail amputating in 2 freak accidents inside the home. The first required appointment after appointment and made a full recovery but required stitches, antibiotics, dressing changes etc. The latter was mostly just an extortionate one off cost. I would never risk not having it now

neither of these are things I think any pet owner would PTS for surely? Do I don’t understand that argument. They is a massive area between affordable treatments for common ailments and £100000 for cancer treatments

GymBergerac · 05/08/2023 18:04

We currently have five cats, and have been a multi car household for the last twenty years. Insurance now is so prohibitively expensive that for the last ten years we've had a "cat emergency fund" of a few hundred pounds ready for sudden vet bills. It's served us well, we top it up as and when needed, and on the one occasion treatment was looking to be way above what we had put away, we made the kindest decision to put a very elderly and unwell chap to sleep.
If you can afford to insure, then do it, if not, as long as you have some provision to ensure an animal isn't left in pain then you're doing the right thing.

Grumpyoldpersonwithcats · 05/08/2023 18:04

I've owned cats for over 35 years and never had insurance (it wasn't even a 'thing' when I first had a cat).
Had a couple of expensive vet visits over the last five years but overall I'm still quids in through not having had cover.
I think that there us a risk that sometimes insurance encourages treatment that may not be in the best interest of the animal. Just because something can be done (potentially at great cost) it doesn't necessarily mean it should be.

Work2live · 05/08/2023 18:01

We’ve had over £2k from our dog’s insurance over the last couple of years, both for relatively minor/common things (removal of a cancerous lump being one). So it’s been well worth it for us. He’s a big dog too so any treatment generally costs more - as does his insurance!

But he’s getting on in years now and our most recent renewal went up so it’s now almost £90 a month.

I’m not sure we’ll renew again, we do have savings and will keep putting money away for him, but he’s getting to an age where we wouldn’t want to put him through complex surgeries etc anyway, sadly.

Wherearemymarbles · 05/08/2023 17:58

We’ve had 2 cats for 25 years an never insured them.
but it seems cats are far less likely to need an expensive operation and as a pp said, we are not going to spend money on cancer treatment etc to keep a cat alive.

Ohthatsabitshit · 05/08/2023 17:57

Never have. I have a credit card for emergencies and wouldn’t pay thousands for a pets treatment so if it was more that would be it.

Upsizer · 05/08/2023 17:53

I never have had insurance either for cats and small animals. If something major was wrong I would have them pts. I adore them but there are so many animals needing love. I don’t know that I would want to put a cat through daily medication or a rabbit through traumatic dental surgery etc.

I did spend a fortune operating on my favourite one-eyed Guinea pig though, so who knows?!? 😃

Guiltyfeethavegotnorhythm0 · 05/08/2023 17:52

@EvilElsa I am the same , the awfulness if my dog freaked and ran in the road and caused a horrible accident in which people were badly injured. I'm not gambling my home.

Swipe left for the next trending thread