Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boyfriend's messy brother with poor hygiene coming to stay

34 replies

OpheliaABC · 05/08/2023 14:19

The brother (in his early 20s) is troubled with severe anxiety and suspected autism. He lives with his mum and doesn't go out unless a family member takes him out. He's very intelligent and fairly polite and I have nothing against him personality wise.

However, he is extremely messy and lazy with bad hygiene. Now, I know it's not by choice (mostly). But the smell, him not washing his hands after the toilet, not showering, not taking his dirty plates to the kitchen or rubbish to the bin etc drives me absolutely nuts. He makes zero effort to contribute to household chores when staying with us and my boyfriend does him no favours, just acts as his servant as he feels sorry for him.

The brother doesn't often stay with us but when he does it can easily be for 2 weeks or more so it's enough to drive me nuts. He also quite happily sits on our sofa the whole time and plays XBox so I feel like I can't put 'my tv' on. We have our own kids and don't need another, even temporarily.

However it's an extremely sensitive topic to my boyfriend as he feels like his brother has been neglected by their mum - no life skills taught, dysfunctional ways, no positive role models. So he refuses to be strict with him and has to find discreet ways of making him have a shower for example. He feels mortified if I ask him to ask his brother to tidy up. His response is that he is our guest. We have had arguments about this several times.

We are both busy hardworking people with our own mental health issues but my boyfriend doesn't see this as an obstacle as he feels like the visits really make a difference to his brother's wellbeing. And fair enough, of course they do. He has more sensible adults and stability/normality here than at home ever.
I've just heard my partner has invited him to stay again and I'm furious but feel so guilty. I want to say no but never could. I feel like coming up with an excuse why he can't come and stay.

AITA?

OP posts:
Seaweed42 · 05/08/2023 14:44

Your partner shouldn't be inviting people to stay without asking you first to see if the timing suits.
Doesn't matter who it is. It's your home too.
Do you jointly own the house?

Hadalifeonce · 05/08/2023 14:36

Our brother has SEN, he's 68, my sister and I regularly remind him to have a bath, do his washing or clean his flat. He is becoming more proactive now, it has taken over 3 years to get to this point, we don't live with him.

If he stayed with either of us, we would tell him to clean up after himself and tell him to have a shower or bath. The only way people learn any life skill is to be taught by others.

determinedtomakethiswork · 05/08/2023 14:35

Any visit should be conditional on a person being clean and not leaving a mess. That's not unreasonable of you. I would set those ground rules before saying he could stay.

itsmyp4rty · 05/08/2023 14:33

He thinks his mum failed him by not teaching him independence but then refuses to get him to tidy up after himself at all? Sounds like he's complicit.

Cherrysoup · 05/08/2023 14:31

Time for him to learn to be more self sufficient, it would be doing him a disservice to continue to treat him like a helpless child. Life skills like learning to clear up, wash etc are essential.

VictoriaVenkman · 05/08/2023 14:29

He wouldn't be allowed in my home if he stinks and is lazy.

Reugny · 05/08/2023 14:29

If you stay with your bf then his brother will be in your life forever and if their mother dies he may be living with you for a few months.

So either tackle it now by telling your bf that you both need to reach his brother life skills in terms of self-care and household chores including cooking, or you need to get out of this relationship.

Btw it may sound harsh saying you have to teach an adult life skills but myself and others have learnt how to do some household chores as adults from other adults.

Merryoldgoat · 05/08/2023 14:28

Your boyfriend’s brother is being failed by everyone.

Personally I wouldn’t have someone in my home who couldn’t keep the place tidy and keep himself clean.

There are lots of ways to encourage him and teach him to have some independence.

NancyJoan · 05/08/2023 14:23

Nothing wrong with asking him to pick up his plates and stack the dishwasher.

Maybe your DH needs to take some time off and go out and about with him and leave you at home.

How would he react if you said, “Simon, I’ve run you a bath. Go and have a soak while I start making dinner.”?