Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

...to want my baby born in September (not August)?

155 replies

chickpea1982 · 05/08/2023 11:04

I'd be really interested to hear other Mumsnetters' experiences on this question.

I'm currently pregnant with DC3, who is due on 31 August. My plan was to try to hold on until 1 September (unless the baby decides otherwise!) so DC3 is born in September and so is the oldest/one of the oldest in her year. It feels to me like it could make such a big difference to her life - either the oldest in her year, or the absolute youngest. Or am I overthinking things?

The doctors want to induce at 39 weeks as I have gestational diabetes, but I'm not completely convinced it's necessary, or that waiting a few extra days will make much difference.

Looking forward to receiving your wisdom!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MumsGoneToIceland · 08/08/2023 06:08

DD1 was due late August but born early Sep so the oldest in the year. DD2 is June born. DD2 doing better academically than DD1. Also Dd1’s NCT friends are all August born and one in particular is very academic. So my feelings are that it doesn’t make a difference. Yes you’ll notice the difference in the early years but my experience is that by year 3, the younger ones in the year have caught up and it makes no difference from there onwards.

RadoxRita · 08/08/2023 06:00

As someone who timed my children’s pregnancies (and was lucky to be able to do so) to ensure they were all born in Sept, I still wouldn’t risk compromising my child’s health. I would defo defer a school year though! Good luck.

urbanbuddha · 08/08/2023 05:51

Glad you’re going to take the doctors’ advice. You’ve got 3 years to read up about the pros and cons of deferring.
With a late August baby I think I would. School isn’t all about academia - social skills are just as important.

scarceiron · 08/08/2023 05:37

Hi OP, I’m a 1st September baby! I was academic in school (and remember feeling really ready to start primary school especially). I was quite frustrated when my friends in the year above were all going off to uni - but by the time I did graduate, I was glad of the extra year to figure out what I wanted to do career wise. One of my closest friend is an August 31st baby and is the smartest person I know - it doesn’t seem to have held them back in any way. What I’m trying to say is congratulations and I’m sure they’ll be ok whenever they’re born :)

Ellie1015 · 06/08/2023 20:03

The debate isn't is it best to be older in the year. Of course it can be and of course there will be plenty of children who do brilliantly even thoigh they are younger.

The question is would you go against dr's advice for birth to have later school start? And i can't imagine the risk being worth the potential benefit.

Tumbleweed101 · 06/08/2023 16:49

I've got a mid August baby. The only thing I've really found is that she was a little immature to fully focus on her GSCE revision - she did much better at college for getting focused. And she hated being last in her year and friend group to learn to drive. She otherwise enjoyed and did well at school.

HalloumiLuvver · 06/08/2023 16:31

Clefable · 05/08/2023 12:06

And actually although everyone on MN has the ubiquitous bright child who is ready for GCSEs at the age of 7 and a social butterfly, a lot of kids do struggle with starting school so early, either academically or more usually socially, some of which isn't apparent till later in their school career when it comes to sitting exams, etc. Anecdotes about individual kids who achieved this and that aren't really useful. We need to look at a population level generally and also consider individual children.

DD could start school in August at 4.5 and would probably be 'fine', but deferring her a year will give her a whole year of social maturity and growth in a quality early years setting and set her up as best as possible at no real cost to me (thanks to the 30 hours of funding we get here). Speaking to friends and family who are teachers, I've yet to find one with anything negative to say about deferral, but they all have lots to say about sending kids too soon.

Yep agree. Nearly everyone I know with kids Jan/Feb deferred in Scotland so they started that little bit older.

Rainn21 · 06/08/2023 16:29

Speaking as someone who has just had a very sad loss of a baby in the family, don’t be so pathetic. Prioritise the health of your unborn child.

cptartapp · 06/08/2023 16:26

I agree with you OP. In both my DC years those that seemed to struggle least and did best academically were among the oldest. There will always be outliers of course.
The youngest were also the last to learn to drive, to turn 18 and drink legally.
I tried to conceive tactically and luckily it worked out.

HalloumiLuvver · 06/08/2023 16:20

Babdoc · 05/08/2023 11:20

My DD was born in August. She got 5 straight As in her Highers (Scotland), ditto her 5 Advanced Highers, (one sat a year early) and a maths degree from Durham university.
She was correcting her teacher’s spelling in reception year, where she had a reading age of 12 on arrival.
There is no disadvantage to being an August baby.

If she was an August baby in the standard Scottish system she would be halfway through the year of ages, not the youngest born. So rather irrelevant to the OP.

HalloumiLuvver · 06/08/2023 16:18

Gooseysgirl · 05/08/2023 11:19

I sympathise but you must follow the doctors advice! There are always very mixed views on here re. summerborns and starting school. My own view is that the cut off should be end of April not end of August, meaning kids wound be at least 4.5 starting school.

I'm in Scotland and our school intake is March to February so everyone is at least 4.5 when they start primary school. And you can defer Jan/Feb birthdays too so they are 5.5 when they start if needed.

I've always felt this is much more suitable for kids than starting full time just turned 4.

JenniferAllisonPhillipaSue · 06/08/2023 16:12

Our son was due in early November. He arrived very prem in mid-August 😁So despite already havng issues and attending SEN school, he's also doing his entire schooling with one year 'delay' written into his EHCP to compensate.

richteaftw · 06/08/2023 16:04

There is 3 weeks between my daughter and my best friend's daughter.

Friend's little girl starts school this September, whereas mine will go 2024. I'm glad I have the extra year with her.

It seems mad that such a couple of weeks or even days makes such a difference'

WellINever1 · 06/08/2023 15:59

I haven't read everything but I'm a teacher and had an early September due date which is ideal for teachers' maternity leave. I would have been gutted with August because you get a bit screwed over with pay as a teacher then. I'm so glad he is the oldest in the school year and had more time playing and being free! In my local authority, it is easy to defer though so actually, August would be great if I wasn't a teacher because you get your 30 hours earlier and then can defer school entry so you get the best both ways. Local authority dependent. Not sure if they are all like mine?!

More likely to have a warm birthday too 😉

namechange003 · 06/08/2023 15:55

My ds was born 31st august and we deferred his school start by a year and all has worked out well

Ridethewavesheadabovewater · 05/08/2023 17:12

My son was born 30th Aug and myself 22nd Aug. Neither of us have had issues in school and my son is in top set for Maths and Science.

lanthanum · 05/08/2023 16:58

Mine was due late September, and turned up mid-August. I would been ready to fight for her to stay down a year (it was before that became more of an option) had it been necessary, but as it turned out, she was totally ready to start school three weeks after turning four. I'm quite relieved she was prem, because I don't think the pre-school would have been enough for another year.

Being the youngest in the year has not been a problem at any point, and although technically she could have done slightly better in her GCSEs, I'm not sure she would have done.

It may all work out for the best, and you actually now get more choice with an August than a September baby.

Linning · 05/08/2023 16:49

As an august born person, it boggles my mind that people obsess over this (on Mumsnet at least) it just so bizarre to me.

Admittedly I am biased due to being born in August but I have siblings born in all kind of months (February, May, June and November) and I was the one who did best academically and currently the highest earner. Similarly (and ironically) in my cousins the most successful one is also August born. So it’s quite sad to think that some people somehow wish their kid weren’t born when they are meant to be born.

I think pushing so much expectations onto an unborn child (to the point for even a second considering to go against medical advice and what’s safest for baby & you to make a September birthday potentially happen) is a lot more likely to prejudice them long-term than being born in august.

I love being born in August, and I have no clue if it’s what’s made me successful or not but it definitely didn’t hold me back in any way and I

would absolutely not recommend going against medical advice in general, but especially for (wishful) academic purposes when in today’s world a degree and good academics don’t really hold the weight and future it once used to.

KAM1997 · 05/08/2023 16:29

I think it depends on the child. Persoanllly I wouldn't go against doctors advice. My daughters was born on 31st August and is 100% ready for reception after going to the school nursery.

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 05/08/2023 16:27

Just have the baby when it’s best to have the baby. Lots of august born kids are fine going to school at just 4 and if they’re not ready you can always defer.

getmeoutofherenoww · 05/08/2023 16:22

@Dotcheck just every person I've ever known to cause trouble or be nasty in my life have been a ScorpioGrin.

Very disciplined and driven though!

barbieseyebrows · 05/08/2023 15:48

I'm in NI and I intentionally conceived so my children would be born in the "correct months"

I would have stopped trying in the months that would have made for a "young" baby

I was completely neurotic about it

For NI this means the baby had to come after the 2nd July

For one of my children I got pregnant immediately after coil removal and had a panic on 😂.. thankfully, she held on and came in the middle of July

I sound insane. I think you can defer children now, that wasn't an option available to us at the time

Jellycats4life · 05/08/2023 15:43

I had a Sept baby and was glad I didn’t give birth early.

But you might have very good medical reasons to give birth in August. You can always defer entry to school. So, in that sense, whether you have an August or September baby, you don’t have to worry.

AmazingSnakeHead · 05/08/2023 15:39

Do what's safe for your baby and then defer school entry by a year.

ginandtonicwithlimes · 05/08/2023 15:37

CoachBeardsJane · 05/08/2023 15:26

You posted about this the other day op, you were told by your dr that you are high risk for shoulder dystocia..

If she knew what that is like she would realise how silly she is being. Get a grip OP.

Swipe left for the next trending thread