Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be angry we were subjected to Social Services Section 47 Investigation?

733 replies

Morbihanmum33 · 05/08/2023 10:13

Long post - sorry: My husband and I have 4 children, 14, 11, 7 & 2. No prior involvement with social services whatsoever. No ‘risk factors’ - criminal records / addiction issues / mental health problems / domestic violence / no issues at schools. Both of us have enhanced DBS. Professional jobs.

Our family recently had to endure the considerable distress and intrusion of a Section 47 child protection investigation.

Our 2 year old had light bruising across his thighs. Both my husband and I saw it but did not know how he’d done it. We flagged it when we took him to nursery, he is very active, trying to keep up with his bigger brothers. In the last 6 months at nursery, the nursery has filed 6 accident reports for incidents in their care, so they know what he’s like.

They rang me to tell me they had a statutory duty to report the bruises as they were unexplained and on a part of his body not normally associated with bruising. However, they assured me it was routine and nothing to worry about. They told me they made it clear on the referral that they did not believe we were responsible for the bruising.

The next morning a social worker called me and told me I had to take my son for a medical examination. This had to be done at the hospital - 45 mins away - immediately. I was due at work and had an important meeting so asked if it could be another time. I was told they could take my son into care if I did not go.

My son was given an examination by 2 doctors and I was interviewed at length. While waiting the social worker told me this was a Section 47 and that they would also have to see my other 3 children, and could go into their schools that same day if necessary to interview them! They also told me they had chosen not to involve the police at this stage!

The Drs found no evidence of non accidental injury. This was communicated to me and the SW at the time.

Despite this, the investigation still had to run its course over a number of weeks, with a visit to our home and interviews with the other 3 children, and them speaking to our GP and schools.

We all found the whole process deeply distressing and a total invasion of our privacy. I was fraught with worry the entire time. We were made to feel like criminals, with SS adopting a ‘guilty until proven innocent approach’. I’ve been left traumatised by the whole experience.

Having read up on this I understand that bruising in a non mobile infant under 6 months is always a major cause for concern, and some local authorities authorise automatic Section 47’s for referrals like this. However, government guidance is that (even with a non mobile infant) an initial enquiry or assessment should be made with the family before initiating an investigation.

Secondly, my child is fully mobile and the original referral explicitly said the bruising was not considered suspicious - so I do not understand why this was escalated in this way.

The cases (against all 4 of my children!) have been closed, but I’m so angry we were put through this. I also understand the fact an investigation was carried out will stay on file for a long time. I’m considering pursuing a judicial review on the basis an initial assessment should have been carried out and the lack of medical evidence did not warrant an investigation.

AIBU to feel like this - or should I just let it go?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
MistressoftheDarkSide · 06/08/2023 13:08

Also the AIBU is whether the OP has a right to feel angry about the situation. Anger is a side effect of fear. The fear of losing your child is a powerful force. Should allegedly routine safeguarding practice generate that level of fear?

ILJ28 · 06/08/2023 13:07

Jellyx · 06/08/2023 12:24

@ILJ28

It's unlikely the social worker phrased it that way but the potential action would be true?

Are you telling me you'd send a toddler, with unexplained bruising on thigh, home to parents without any investigation???

Also please note this decision would have been made by all agencies but just communicated via the social worker.

No, that’s not what I said. It’s not about the action. It’s about the communication. If that was an initial contact, raising the spectre of possible child removal is not helpful at all. In this scenario, if the parent, who reportedly has had no issues with statutory services previously, said something along the lines of ‘oh, I was going to work, is there any possibility this could wait until tomorrow?’ I’d likely respond with ‘I know it’s difficult organising work, but it’s really important we get this done today so we can get the most accurate and recent medical report’ 9/10 this works just fine. If I still encounter resistance, then I can allude to options to enforcement, but it doesn’t need to be first line. As you’re aware, and have alluded to, numerous times, there are a lot of steps between referral and removal and a CP practitioner doesn’t have the authority to do that unilaterally… would require a judge. So to even be talking that way would be alluding to my having a power that I don’t have and can be perceived as a threat, hence my original point of not being helpful in building that therapeutic alliance which is so incredibly helpful if you’re working with families on an ongoing basis.

im not suggesting any of the actions were wrong in the case, obviously we only have very limited info here and only from one perspective… but it does sound like the communication content and tone could have been improved. and as the contact point with families it’s the CP practitioners responsibility to explain the WHY the team have formed this opinion, not just that they have.

Jellycatspyjamas · 06/08/2023 13:06

And an investigation taking place “over a number of weeks” isn’t quick. Do you really have no empathy for parents who have an investigation imposed on them? You can be concerned for the child and seek to protect them while still acknowledging how devastating it can be for parents going through the process.

Jellyx · 06/08/2023 13:05

Jellycatspyjamas · 06/08/2023 13:01

The OP is questioning why a referral regarding unexplained bruising to a child resulted in a quick investigation? Because if they didn't a child might die or continue to be abused. Pretty straight forward.

The OP is asking why a bruise on a healthy, cared for child with experienced parents where there have been no previous concerns resulted in a full multi-agency CP investigation, as opposed to the other options available to social services.

She’s asking why a referral from nursery (who have told her they said they had no concerns) resulted in such intrusion to her family and private life.

Either the nursery lied about what was on their referral, or other information came up in the strategy meeting, to merit full investigation. A bruise in and of itself, in the absence of other concerns wouldn’t usually merit a S47, the parent is entitled to know.

How would they know the child is healthy and cared for without doing an investigation?

And the child wasn't out in a child protection register- they opted not to go down that route immediately. Decisions appear to be proportionate.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 06/08/2023 13:03

So. One instance of unexplained bruising with no supporting concerns always merits a full S47 in a mobile child? Even when the parent is the one who has mentioned it to a nursery that has recorded multiple events regarding said child while in their care?

If one wanted to go the conspiracy route one might wonder if the nursery were covering their backs for lack of supervision there.

The OP has a right to know the details of the referral.

Jellycatspyjamas · 06/08/2023 13:01

The OP is questioning why a referral regarding unexplained bruising to a child resulted in a quick investigation? Because if they didn't a child might die or continue to be abused. Pretty straight forward.

The OP is asking why a bruise on a healthy, cared for child with experienced parents where there have been no previous concerns resulted in a full multi-agency CP investigation, as opposed to the other options available to social services.

She’s asking why a referral from nursery (who have told her they said they had no concerns) resulted in such intrusion to her family and private life.

Either the nursery lied about what was on their referral, or other information came up in the strategy meeting, to merit full investigation. A bruise in and of itself, in the absence of other concerns wouldn’t usually merit a S47, the parent is entitled to know.

Jellyx · 06/08/2023 12:53

Jellycatspyjamas · 06/08/2023 12:43

The point is no parent should need to get potential reasons from an online forum, from people speculating on what might have happened.

They should know why in their particular situation those decisions were made from the person leading that process, ie their social worker.

The OP is questioning why a referral regarding unexplained bruising to a child resulted in a quick investigation? Because if they didn't a child might die or continue to be abused. Pretty straight forward.

Jellycatspyjamas · 06/08/2023 12:53

When our SW told us she assumed we were lying about everything and I said that’s ridiculous, she replied “But in this job people constantly lie to us”. In other words - we were being punished by the actions of others.

The reality is that people do lie to social workers, sometimes those lies aren’t important, sometimes they are and you can get very jaded about human nature, and very defensive in your approach.

That isn’t reason to assume everyone is lying about everything - investigation gives multiple sources of information so it’s easy to assess quite quickly where there may be anomalies which you then address on a piece by piece basis. Often there are reasons for anomalies which aren’t about the family lying, so even that doesn’t justify an “everyone lies” approach.

Social work is a high stakes profession where being wrong can have life ending/life changing consequences so social workers need to be sure in an area of work where surety is hard to come by. We also work with very traumatised people, which brings its own impact for the worker. Both can lead to defensive, oppressive practice and can mean workers find it very hard to hear things could be done in a different way, but that closed off mindset is harmful and needs challenged.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 06/08/2023 12:47

I have had multiple circular discussions with CP workers of all stripes, and HCPs.

They went like this:

”Why am I being asked to do X?”

”It’s part of the investigation process”

“I understand that, but can you explain the reasoning behind it?”

”It will help us understand what might have lead to your son’s injuries”

Case in point - after I had to do contact at the Family Centre because I got on too well with the foster mother, I had to follow a strict routine, including bathing, bottle preparing, appropriate handling, play etc.

I was told that the bottle preparation was obviously partly because baby needs feeding, but also it was to see how I dealt with the pressure of preparing feed for a hungry screaming baby. Perhaps that was why I’d randomly started torturing my tiny baby very carefully, leaving no bruises….

Thing is I was EBF when he was taken from me. If he was hungry nature took its course.

I could understand that going forward my capability to do these things would be important, but it was absolutely not relevant to the situation prior to his removal.

They made a massive deal of any nervousness around my handling of my son, but who wouldn’t be nervous after being told that despite passing the six week check with flying colours, somehow the child you knew had not been abused had developed 21, or 15, or 12 occult fractures, according to three different reports, only two of which showed a symptom and for which I sought appropriate medical attention. It’s a lot to process.

I could go on and on about the processes and illogical things I experienced. Always there was an implication that I was a very clever devious monster desperate to get one over on the professionals, when actually all I wanted was my baby to be safe and ok and to find out WTF is happening here.

Theres a strong chance that there was a combination of nutritional and genetic factors at play, but because metaphyseal fractures are )or were) considered pathognomic of child abuse, investigation was blocked.

When I first sought attention for one of the symptomatic fractures, the hospital did blood tests. I found out 6 months later that a type of anaemia had been detected. It was sometimes associated with bone fragility. This was because I saw the foster mother dosing him with Vitamin D and multi-vitamins - Abidec I think it was. She had been told it was to help his bones heal. That information was actively withheld from me. The SW shrugged it off as irrelevant.

Thats the sort of thing that needs addressing.

WeetabixTowels · 06/08/2023 12:43

I certainly found the ‘computer says no’/jaded attitude of SWs very problematic. When our SW told us she assumed we were lying about everything and I said that’s ridiculous, she replied “But in this job people constantly lie to us”. In other words - we were being punished by the actions of others. All I asked is that she looked at our case - no previous intervention, no concerns whatsoever from nurseries, schools etc and a doctor who says there are no concerns and no NAI - as us as a family, not with the jaded view passed down from other families.

I don’t think that’s unreasonable but me even voicing that was a concern to them.

Jellycatspyjamas · 06/08/2023 12:43

The point is no parent should need to get potential reasons from an online forum, from people speculating on what might have happened.

They should know why in their particular situation those decisions were made from the person leading that process, ie their social worker.

Jellyx · 06/08/2023 12:40

Jellycatspyjamas · 06/08/2023 12:35

*It's unlikely the social worker phrased it that way but the potential action would be true?

Are you telling me you'd send a toddler, with unexplained bruising on thigh, home to parents without any investigation???*

Are you telling me you’d accommodate every toddler with an unexplained bruise? In the absence of any other concern? Good luck getting that past a Sherriff.

Its not an either/or - the reality is we don’t medical every child with a bruise, we don’t accommodate every child who doesn’t attend a same day medical, we don’t start a full CP investigation for every referral made.

We do use professional judgement, we do visit, observe and speak to parents and assess the home to be safe, we do check in with nursery and get their sense of the family, we do return home with safe care plans and continue our investigations in the background.

The choice isn’t full CP investigation or nothing at all, as those defending this practice claiming to be social workers well know.

It’s OK for the OP to want to know why, in her case, the decision was a full investigation.

Yes. Lots of toddler bruises are in other places and parents can explain them. Do not all are reported or investigate.
Certain facts were present. And sure parents have a right to know - but I think potential reasons have been shared all over the thread.

Jellycatspyjamas · 06/08/2023 12:37

@Jellycatspyjamas
So all 3disciplinrs decided to misuse their power - for fun? Whilst being extremely busy.. unlikely to say the least.

Where did I say in this case anyone misused their power?

Jellycatspyjamas · 06/08/2023 12:35

*It's unlikely the social worker phrased it that way but the potential action would be true?

Are you telling me you'd send a toddler, with unexplained bruising on thigh, home to parents without any investigation???*

Are you telling me you’d accommodate every toddler with an unexplained bruise? In the absence of any other concern? Good luck getting that past a Sherriff.

Its not an either/or - the reality is we don’t medical every child with a bruise, we don’t accommodate every child who doesn’t attend a same day medical, we don’t start a full CP investigation for every referral made.

We do use professional judgement, we do visit, observe and speak to parents and assess the home to be safe, we do check in with nursery and get their sense of the family, we do return home with safe care plans and continue our investigations in the background.

The choice isn’t full CP investigation or nothing at all, as those defending this practice claiming to be social workers well know.

It’s OK for the OP to want to know why, in her case, the decision was a full investigation.

Jellyx · 06/08/2023 12:30

@Jellycatspyjamas
So all 3disciplinrs decided to misuse their power - for fun? Whilst being extremely busy.. unlikely to say the least.

Jellycatspyjamas · 06/08/2023 12:26

People cry out about the system being broken but it appears that they want SWs to magically know who to investigate and who to not. If you believe you have this magic power then please train to be a SW and get on to a child protection team ASAP. You're needed!

I have no issue with the investigation being undertaken, communication with the parents seems to have been very lacking and I’d wonder what was in the nursery referral to go straight to a CP investigation. I can’t see that a report of bruising in a small, mobile child who is well cared for (as far as the OPs description) with three older children where there have been no concerns, would result in a full multi-agency CP response, so in the OPs shoes I’d want a clear explanation of what the strategy meeting threw up that merited full investigation.

I do take issue with the idea by some that the decision was made and therefore must have been the right one. That social workers don’t misuse their power (perceived or otherwise), that bias never plays a part and that the ends justify the means. Even if everything was right from a process point of view social workers need to hear about the impact on the family and consider not just what they did but how they did it, while CP is inherently stressful, a lot of distress could have been saved through communication and relationship based practice.

And I’ve more than served my time in CP social work so I’ll decline your kind offer, thanks.

Titicacacandle · 06/08/2023 12:26

WeetabixTowels · 06/08/2023 12:22

We also need to remember that the 80,000 children in care are not now happy flourishing children leading happy lives. It isn’t the movies - their life chances and outcomes are not much poorer, as SWs would know. I’m not entirely sure it’s something to celebrate

Better then dead as to be so blunt. Unless it was section 20 than they would have had to be at risk of serious harm and/or death.

And actually it's their parents responsibility to not have abused them or neglected them to end up in foster care in the first place. Not the SW.

But foster care is a different debate to CP processes.

Fitflop5 · 06/08/2023 12:25

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Jellyx · 06/08/2023 12:24

@ILJ28

It's unlikely the social worker phrased it that way but the potential action would be true?

Are you telling me you'd send a toddler, with unexplained bruising on thigh, home to parents without any investigation???

Also please note this decision would have been made by all agencies but just communicated via the social worker.

HarrietJet · 06/08/2023 12:24

ILJ28 · 06/08/2023 12:21

Likewise the CP practitioner who had the initial contact. IF it was presented as starkly as ‘take your child to the medical exam today or we can remove your child’ that is not the most appropriate way to develop a therapeutic alliance.

I wonder was it initially presented like that? Or maybe op claiming she couldn't possibly prioritise her child over her important meeting raised some red flags?

WeetabixTowels · 06/08/2023 12:22

We also need to remember that the 80,000 children in care are not now happy flourishing children leading happy lives. It isn’t the movies - their life chances and outcomes are not much poorer, as SWs would know. I’m not entirely sure it’s something to celebrate

Jellyx · 06/08/2023 12:22

Jellycatspyjamas · 06/08/2023 12:15

Gosh people complaining it's same day alongside complaining it all wasn't done soon enough.. same old damned if you do..

No the OP was complaining that she was told her child would be removed if she didn’t attend on the same day. Surely you can understand her distress about that.

Yes in cases where you're worried about physical abuse of a toddler you don't send them straight home!!

Imagine that happened and the kid was killed or injured further,

Completely sensible thing to do and thank god a medical could be arranged same day.

Please also note it's likely extended family would be considered for caring before foster care.

ILJ28 · 06/08/2023 12:21

Jellyx · 06/08/2023 12:16

@ILJ28

It's clear the parent leant understand the risks associated with unexplained bruising - they've been somewhat covered in the thread.

There may have been a better start to the working relationship and less distress had the nursery not spoken so unprofessionally

Likewise the CP practitioner who had the initial contact. IF it was presented as starkly as ‘take your child to the medical exam today or we can remove your child’ that is not the most appropriate way to develop a therapeutic alliance.

Jellyx · 06/08/2023 12:16

@ILJ28

It's clear the parent leant understand the risks associated with unexplained bruising - they've been somewhat covered in the thread.

There may have been a better start to the working relationship and less distress had the nursery not spoken so unprofessionally

Jellycatspyjamas · 06/08/2023 12:15

Gosh people complaining it's same day alongside complaining it all wasn't done soon enough.. same old damned if you do..

No the OP was complaining that she was told her child would be removed if she didn’t attend on the same day. Surely you can understand her distress about that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread