Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be angry we were subjected to Social Services Section 47 Investigation?

733 replies

Morbihanmum33 · 05/08/2023 10:13

Long post - sorry: My husband and I have 4 children, 14, 11, 7 & 2. No prior involvement with social services whatsoever. No ‘risk factors’ - criminal records / addiction issues / mental health problems / domestic violence / no issues at schools. Both of us have enhanced DBS. Professional jobs.

Our family recently had to endure the considerable distress and intrusion of a Section 47 child protection investigation.

Our 2 year old had light bruising across his thighs. Both my husband and I saw it but did not know how he’d done it. We flagged it when we took him to nursery, he is very active, trying to keep up with his bigger brothers. In the last 6 months at nursery, the nursery has filed 6 accident reports for incidents in their care, so they know what he’s like.

They rang me to tell me they had a statutory duty to report the bruises as they were unexplained and on a part of his body not normally associated with bruising. However, they assured me it was routine and nothing to worry about. They told me they made it clear on the referral that they did not believe we were responsible for the bruising.

The next morning a social worker called me and told me I had to take my son for a medical examination. This had to be done at the hospital - 45 mins away - immediately. I was due at work and had an important meeting so asked if it could be another time. I was told they could take my son into care if I did not go.

My son was given an examination by 2 doctors and I was interviewed at length. While waiting the social worker told me this was a Section 47 and that they would also have to see my other 3 children, and could go into their schools that same day if necessary to interview them! They also told me they had chosen not to involve the police at this stage!

The Drs found no evidence of non accidental injury. This was communicated to me and the SW at the time.

Despite this, the investigation still had to run its course over a number of weeks, with a visit to our home and interviews with the other 3 children, and them speaking to our GP and schools.

We all found the whole process deeply distressing and a total invasion of our privacy. I was fraught with worry the entire time. We were made to feel like criminals, with SS adopting a ‘guilty until proven innocent approach’. I’ve been left traumatised by the whole experience.

Having read up on this I understand that bruising in a non mobile infant under 6 months is always a major cause for concern, and some local authorities authorise automatic Section 47’s for referrals like this. However, government guidance is that (even with a non mobile infant) an initial enquiry or assessment should be made with the family before initiating an investigation.

Secondly, my child is fully mobile and the original referral explicitly said the bruising was not considered suspicious - so I do not understand why this was escalated in this way.

The cases (against all 4 of my children!) have been closed, but I’m so angry we were put through this. I also understand the fact an investigation was carried out will stay on file for a long time. I’m considering pursuing a judicial review on the basis an initial assessment should have been carried out and the lack of medical evidence did not warrant an investigation.

AIBU to feel like this - or should I just let it go?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
dimorphism · 05/08/2023 13:49

There is a wider issue too which is that social services are understaffed and under-resourced and pursing this investigation probably meant a family in need didn't get the help they needed in a timely fashion.

Jujubes5 · 05/08/2023 13:49

Perhaps you could write to one of the SW and point out how stressed you were and that you would have appreciated knowing on the Monday instead of the Fri if that had been possible.

CaroleSinger · 05/08/2023 13:45

I think under the circumstances it wouldn't matter if you had a plausible explanation as they would still want to test that once the statutory report is made to see if it holds up anyway. I know it's horrible and you feel aggrieved but I would be inclined to put this down as a very unpleasant experience. Of course you shouldn't have been dragged through this but you know your children are not abused, you know you did nothing wrong. Since Baby P and Victoria Climbie the authorities told us how lessons would be learned and nothing like this would ever be allowed to happen again, yet every week every week with another child lost to the most horrific abuse. You can understand why the services have developed a sledge hammer approach when they are still failing so many children. I doubt fighting back because of the distress this caused will change anything other than use up more of your nerves and energy. It would probably be better for you as a family to try and put this down as a horrible and needless difficult time and try to move on now. The nursery manager seems to have her heart in the right place and be on your side. She will have known the hell you were enduring x

dimorphism · 05/08/2023 13:45

Morbihanmum33 · 05/08/2023 10:13

Long post - sorry: My husband and I have 4 children, 14, 11, 7 & 2. No prior involvement with social services whatsoever. No ‘risk factors’ - criminal records / addiction issues / mental health problems / domestic violence / no issues at schools. Both of us have enhanced DBS. Professional jobs.

Our family recently had to endure the considerable distress and intrusion of a Section 47 child protection investigation.

Our 2 year old had light bruising across his thighs. Both my husband and I saw it but did not know how he’d done it. We flagged it when we took him to nursery, he is very active, trying to keep up with his bigger brothers. In the last 6 months at nursery, the nursery has filed 6 accident reports for incidents in their care, so they know what he’s like.

They rang me to tell me they had a statutory duty to report the bruises as they were unexplained and on a part of his body not normally associated with bruising. However, they assured me it was routine and nothing to worry about. They told me they made it clear on the referral that they did not believe we were responsible for the bruising.

The next morning a social worker called me and told me I had to take my son for a medical examination. This had to be done at the hospital - 45 mins away - immediately. I was due at work and had an important meeting so asked if it could be another time. I was told they could take my son into care if I did not go.

My son was given an examination by 2 doctors and I was interviewed at length. While waiting the social worker told me this was a Section 47 and that they would also have to see my other 3 children, and could go into their schools that same day if necessary to interview them! They also told me they had chosen not to involve the police at this stage!

The Drs found no evidence of non accidental injury. This was communicated to me and the SW at the time.

Despite this, the investigation still had to run its course over a number of weeks, with a visit to our home and interviews with the other 3 children, and them speaking to our GP and schools.

We all found the whole process deeply distressing and a total invasion of our privacy. I was fraught with worry the entire time. We were made to feel like criminals, with SS adopting a ‘guilty until proven innocent approach’. I’ve been left traumatised by the whole experience.

Having read up on this I understand that bruising in a non mobile infant under 6 months is always a major cause for concern, and some local authorities authorise automatic Section 47’s for referrals like this. However, government guidance is that (even with a non mobile infant) an initial enquiry or assessment should be made with the family before initiating an investigation.

Secondly, my child is fully mobile and the original referral explicitly said the bruising was not considered suspicious - so I do not understand why this was escalated in this way.

The cases (against all 4 of my children!) have been closed, but I’m so angry we were put through this. I also understand the fact an investigation was carried out will stay on file for a long time. I’m considering pursuing a judicial review on the basis an initial assessment should have been carried out and the lack of medical evidence did not warrant an investigation.

AIBU to feel like this - or should I just let it go?

Have not RTFT but have you done a SAR OP? I would do this, and yes, I am extremely sympathetic to your inclination to take legal action. It appears that procedure was not followed correctly as the initial assessment by the doctor should not have resulted in a full blown enquiry.

From your description, the bruises described could have quite easily have happened from a fall onto something hard (like the bike which seems to be the actual explanation) or from something falling across the child's legs. For a very active 2 year old, it's not inconceivable this could happen.

The safeguarding system in this country does seem a bit messed up to put it mildly. I've done quite a bit of safeguarding training because of my job and some people in senior roles have IMO an inappropriate inclination to treat parents as guilty for the most ridiculous reasons. I have had to challenge this in training and recently sent an email after training challenging some of the things said and have not received a response. I actually think it's a safeguarding failure of sorts itself within the system to have this attitude because you are putting through all the children in the family (not to mention the adults) through a degree of trauma with this sort of investigation and this real harm should not be imposed lightly.

BananaSpanner · 05/08/2023 13:45

Morbihanmum33 · 05/08/2023 13:16

This only came out during the investigation when they interviewed our 7 year old who saw it happen, helped 2 year old but didn’t tell us.

That’s exactly why they speak to the siblings!!

I am not a social worker but I am involved in child protection strategy discussions where s47s are agreed. I represent a partner agency.

Whilst this could have been dealt with by a s17 assessment on the face of it, there could be other factors that raised it to a 47. However, even if it was a s17 assessment, they still would have spoken to the siblings.

Also, just because the medical stated that there was no evidence of non accidental injury doesn’t mean that there was no neglectful parenting (not saying there was just pointing out the deliberate physical harm would not be the only thing they were concerned about).

Speaking to the siblings provides information about their lived experience, chastisement, level of supervision by parents etc

By the way, if you are insinuating that in the future you would provide a false explanation if a similar situation were to arise, you will cause yourself no end of issues.

Willmafrockfit · 05/08/2023 13:38

time spent dealing with your complaint is time away from more constructive work op for the sw

Yellowlegobrick · 05/08/2023 13:34

How on earth is their professional status relevant ?The classism on this thread is vile.Middle class people can be just as horribly abusive. Their children deserve protection too.

Its not just classism. Surely its about what life is like for an employed professional and how that influences risk factors?

Children of parents employed outside the home tend to be more visible to society. Those parents are likely to pay for childcare, rely on other family members or neighbours for help, pay for things like football clubs and swimming lessons where other adults stand a higher chance of spotting signs of abuse.

Some cases of neglect also arise where parents just can't get it together to provide food and shelter etc for their child (can be due to severe sen, drug abuse, all sorts). This is less likely - someone who can hold down a job as say, a doctor or well paid lawyer, is more likely to have the money & organisational skills to care for a child. Their employer and colleagues are also more likely to spot substance abuse and help them engage with support, they may also get mental health support through work that may help head off issues before they get to breaking point.

caringcarer · 05/08/2023 13:34

It sounds like you had to endure a living nightmare. My sisters children are all grown up now but one of her sons was always getting injured. He fell off his bike and broke his collar bone and arm at 7. He was about 6 months later also was messing about in the garden with his brother 1 year younger and managed to break his same arm again squabbling over who went on swing. They were 6 and 7. He broke his same arm again at school in a rugby match when he was 13 too. In-between he had numerous bruises and scratches and scrapes from skatepark from falling off his skateboard but he always wore correct knee and elbow protection. Her other children didn't get Injured at all. She always said when she drove him to A&E she was always afraid a doctor might be suspicious of his same arm being broken 3 times. Hard as it is, and obviously raw I think you need to let it go. Fwiw I'm a Foster Carer and I had one SW complain to me because DFS bedroom was painted in 'Timeless' and not child themed. The child had football themed curtains and duvet cover he chose and matching bedside lamp and lampshade on ceiling. He was ND and struggled with too much bright stimulation. I got a consultants letter to say a less bright bedroom with less busy designs and colour would suit him best. She was not impressed when I sent a copy of the letter to her line manager.

Inkpotlover · 05/08/2023 13:32

The investigations have to be robust because for every 1,000 parents like you who have done nothing wrong there will one who has.

Fluff11 · 05/08/2023 13:31

I am a health care professional who does sadly have to refer families to SS on a very regular basis and I am very shocked and torn by this.

The response seems disproportionate to the circumstances and understandably traumatic for you and your family, for that I am sorry.

However I can see that a toddler cannot advocate for themselves so when you say “and why instead a decision was made to drag our other 3 children and their schools into this” I disagree. Of course they needed to speak to your other children who can give an insight into your home situation.

In regards to speaking to the schools, in many serious case reviews one of the key findings is that professionals do not speak to other agencies and things get missed. So I think it’s entirely appropriate they checked with the schools but this could have just been an email to their safeguarding officers asking if there were any previous historical concerns, alongside contacting the GP, HV etc and then if they all agreed there are no safeguarding concerns they should have closed the case quickly.

BlossomCloud · 05/08/2023 13:31

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 05/08/2023 12:27

It’s always the same on here when a MNetter faces SS. It’s always a ‘waste of time’, they’re always ‘professional people’ and they should go an bother someone else.

Yet when a child is abused or hurt it’s always “why were they not involved” and “why didn’t they ask questions”

If we want to protect children then SS need to be able to investigate parents. Abusive parents don’t wear labels on their foreheads. Nice professional people harm their children too.

The policy can’t be “investigate anything that seems suspicious unless the parent is a nice, professional MNetter”

Agreed.

According to this thread anyone with tattoos and a menial job is a child abuser and any boden-wearing professional should get an award for being the world's best parent.

I'm afraid I've experienced abuse from a "lovely middle class professional" and I have witnessed his abuse to our son (I then left, to keep myself and the children safe, but cafcass didn't want to believe how abusive dad is because they "had a lovely cup of tea" with him, and the judge referenced dad being "middle class" like it was a mark of honour... In the end my son had to vote with his feet)

I am tediously boringly MC and professional but I am astonished by the assumptions on this thread

Saywhanow · 05/08/2023 13:28

So your nursery have listed 6 accidents while your kid is in their care but one incident you self report of light bruises to nursery and they file to SS.

Something is up OP. I'd want to see the original referral too!

Personally I wouldn't let it go.

WobbIy · 05/08/2023 13:28

MySugarBabyLove · 05/08/2023 11:54

Innocent families comply with everything and dont make a fuss. Great for getting boxes ticked and targets met. my DP’s mum complied with SS, went to the weekly HV clinics, attended parent and baby groups, did everything that was being asked of her.

DP was made disabled due to his injuries, initially explained as an accident by the mother, and ultimately both he and his three other siblings were removed into permanent care. In fact his youngest sister was removed at birth and adopted.

The mother came from a well-to-do family, we’re talking middle class in the 60’s.

So the whole argument that if someone complies they’re innocent holds no water. In fact a lot of people will comply if they know there’s a chance that SS will stay on their back they’re wise.

DP’s mother never bothered with the kids again after that. The father (who was equally abusive) did for a few years but then he disappeared. Hopefully he’s dead.

That's not what she said. She said the innocent parents do, not that guilty people can't pretend to comply!

Example:

If people with remorse will always apologise, does that mean everyone who has remorse?

Answer:

Of course not.

Yellowlegobrick · 05/08/2023 13:27

The reality is the children most at risk, who slip through cracks, are often the off radar ones and that's where resource should be directed.

The parents who never bring baby to weighing clinic. Who decline HV visits. The kids who are born, but are then missing vaccines, who aren't registered with with a doctor, who don't appear in EYFS funding paperwork anywhere, don't appear on school registrations.

Although it is horrifying when children die and people have been raising the alarm for years - teachers, doctors, neighbours, HVs. I never quite understand how that happens.

Yetanothernewname101 · 05/08/2023 13:27

I read 2 year old, bruises on thighs, and went 'he's bumped into the coffee table or a table at nursery '. Because I used to get similar 'no idea where they came from' bruises on my thighs when I taught in early years.
I'm so sorry that you went through all of this, it's not overreaching to say it's traumatising for you as a family.
If your son has already had 5 accidents at nursery, I'd be questioning if they are supervising adequately, or it may just be that you've got an active into everything boy, but I'm not sure I would be keeping him at that nursery given what's happened.

BlossomCloud · 05/08/2023 13:24

6WeekCountdown · 05/08/2023 12:16

They are professional people with well looked after kids, what a waste of space they are. Easy couple of weeks work for them though. Bet they said yes to a brew in their house too 🤣 (my friend is a social worker and says there's only ever been 1 or 2 houses ever she accepted a brew in, the rest she wouldn't even want to sit on the sofa!).

I'd go mad if this was my kids. Teenagers aren't stupid and will know why they are being asked leading questions about their parents. Distressing all round.

How on earth is their professional status relevant ?

The classism on this thread is vile.

Middle class people can be just as horribly abusive. Their children deserve protection too.

And equally non-professionals can be amazing, wonderful, dedicated parents and have every right to be just as unsettled by an investigation.

Humpobottomous · 05/08/2023 13:23

OP this does sound really annoying and the nursery sound a bit overzealous and possibly box-ticking for ofsted however sadly lack of risk factors, enhanced DBS and professional jobs doesn’t prevent people from abusing their child.

Willmafrockfit · 05/08/2023 13:23

please dont raise a complaint op.
it is over now

truthhurts23 · 05/08/2023 13:22

wlana · 05/08/2023 10:26

It seems astonishing that they wasted all that time investigating you, when children who are really being abused aren’t identified and sometimes die as a result.

I was about to say this ,
it always seems like social services are there scrutinising accidental injuries
but children like jacob crouch, victoria climbie, baby p and arthur hughes always fall through the cracks, where they had multiple signs of horrific abuse, it doesnt make sense to me

LakieLady · 05/08/2023 13:22

Summertiempo · 05/08/2023 11:59

Maybe from SS point of view, it is easier to investigate professional people, than those living in shit conditions, druggies.

Looks like they prefer through investigations of easier cases. Otherwise at some point in this case, they would have decided to stop the investigation when they found nothing suspicious.

I've raised safeguardings in respect of children living in exactly those "shit conditions", with drug using or alcohol dependent parents, or where an abusive partner has moved in. A couple of them have been for families living on some of the roughest estates in the county.

I have never known them fail to investigate thoroughly or take appropriate action, including where it required the removal of the child. In one case, the father ended up going to prison for threatening to kill the SW who was trying to protect his kids, but even being threatened like that didn't stop them from doing what was necessary to protect the children.

Ime, the notion that SWs prefer to investigate "professional people" is absurd.

Yellowlegobrick · 05/08/2023 13:21

Think a lot of people are missing the point. The nursery had a mandatory duty to report, but in this situation, it didn't need to lead to the full invasive investigation it did. There's an interim step that it appears SS chose to ignore, which is the initial assessment. OP has every right to ask why the report triggered an automatic S47 investigation when that doesn't seem to be the agreed process.

This. Public resource has been wasted when they should have identified via an initial assessment that there was nothing here to investigate. They are trained and have the experience and expertise to make judgement calls from the evidence they have. Imagine investigating all families for weeks every time a toddler has an unexplained bruise?! Completely pointless.

BlossomCloud · 05/08/2023 13:21

HarrietJet · 05/08/2023 12:43

I'm finding the whole "but we're professionals! A decent family" thing a bit jarring, tbh.

I know. And it's the reason I can't keep my kids safe and away from their dad. A judge literally referenced him being "middle class" as a quality that meant he could not possibly be abusive.

Rachie1973 · 05/08/2023 13:21

GoodChat · 05/08/2023 13:13

I disagreed @Rachie1973
I'd think any communication from SS was them treating something as a serious issue regardless of how minor I thought it was

But we’re not supposed to live in fear of a group of people because they are ‘social workers’. I wouldn’t jump because a policeman told me to either.

As an adult I believe I’m entitled to an explanation as to why this needs to happen. When the explanation was forthcoming OP responded accordingly. Not reacting blindly because a person in authority demands it isn’t the awful response you seem to believe it is.

Morbihanmum33 · 05/08/2023 13:16

Willmafrockfit · 05/08/2023 13:11

@Morbihanmum33 you said he tripped over a bike

This only came out during the investigation when they interviewed our 7 year old who saw it happen, helped 2 year old but didn’t tell us.

OP posts:
Mischance · 05/08/2023 13:16

wlana · 05/08/2023 10:26

It seems astonishing that they wasted all that time investigating you, when children who are really being abused aren’t identified and sometimes die as a result.

It was not a waste of time. Professional middle class families abuse their children too.

I absolutely sympathise with the OP and others who have had to undergo this sort of investigation - it can be very traumatic.

But what else can SSD do? If they miss an instance of abuse, everyone comes down on them like a ton of bricks; if they investigate an innocent family, everyone piles in with criticism.

I have to assure you that no-one is more pleased than the SWs involved when it turns out that all is well.