Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be so embarrassed by my 5yo DD behaviour

233 replies

hellosunshin3 · 05/08/2023 10:05

I just had a friend over for the night.

DD,who is usually very pleasant, hardly acknowledged her and was so rude.

When she walked into the kitchen this morning, she walked straight past my friend without saying morning. When I said "what do you say to [friend], she bowed her head as though she had nothing to say.

When friend was leaving an hour or so later, she did the same thing and turned her head when I said "are you saying goodbye".

DH is socially awkward and was turning his back to do other stuff, butter his toast, make his coffee etc, when dear friend was talking to him. Made his breakfast and took it into the living room to eat it with the kids, saying he was looking after the kids but actually it was his way of escaping any social chat.

I'm so humiliated at them both. So cross at DD as she knows better and it's out of character. Was going to take them out for the day in this rain but feel as though she doesn't deserve to be treated after that behaviour. WWYD.

OP posts:
LaMaG · 05/08/2023 11:34

OP you are getting a hard time here and I think its been a bit harsh, especially since your update.

I have to agree with @Jacky86 , its OK to feel a bit embarrassed by your family's behaviour. I personally think shyness and rudeness can be one and the same, shy people opt out when they feel like it because they are uncomfortable and in return shift the uncomfortableness onto the other person, but dont seem to care. I don't think there is any excuse for it, my son has ASD and doesn't have the same social instinct as most but he has to learn you must say hello, goodbye, thank you etc. I agree children shouldn't have to perform or be interviewed but they have to learn the basics. Even saying 'I'm feeling shy' is acceptable.

That said, at 5 I think its very normal to blank someone and quite typical of her age. I wouldn't make a big deal out of it. Maybe next time before someone comes into the house have a chat about just say hello and that's all etc. I agree your DH was rude, he didn't have to give your friend 100% attention but then he could say 'excuse me but I'll just get my breakfast etc'. I'd be having a chat with him too!

Grannyknowsbest · 05/08/2023 11:33

I cannot believe l am reading this. She is five and not a preforming seal. It's a natural response to what may seem like a scary or overwhelming situation... why are you embarrassed? Why are you punishing her for something so natural.At first l thought this was one if those wind up / made up stories.
Think you need to go to parenting lessons.
I'm actually crying for your little girl.
This is so so sad.

Buxtonwaters · 05/08/2023 11:29

You said it yourself, your husband is socially awkward. You child might also be. Their safe space has been “invaded.” You were forcing social interaction on them without letting it naturally happen. Many people aren’t open to interaction first thing. It’s possible that you and their friend kept them awake? Or were drinking and at some point made them feel awkward? Your friend, as the visitor could have introduced conversation. I truly feel sorry for your husband and child if you’re always as controlling as this. Many of us are naturally shy. If your daughter usually isn’t, to me it suggests that something about last night has made her feel uncomfortable this morning.

ReturnoftheMuck · 05/08/2023 11:27

nobodysdaughternow · 05/08/2023 10:17

You are also teaching her that she has to comply or she will incur anger. It is a classic grooming technique.

Imagine a scenario where a man tells her to 'smile' and that he's 'only being nice' and she doesn't have the self-belief to say no?

This entirely.

Children are not your performing monkeys, maybe she isn't gelling with your friend and doesn't like the vibe she gets, maybe a small interaction that's stuck with her has caused it. Just shrug it off with "kids, eh?"

Tbh, although I'd never force my husband to be friendly with my friends, he's an adult and I'd find it more rude. You can muster up a few exchanges while you have your back to someone and do some toast.

ichifanny · 05/08/2023 11:27

Maybe neither of them could be arsed with a stranger staying overnight . I don’t have people to stay as my kids would find it unsettling , I take it doesn’t happen often though OP .

HarrietJet · 05/08/2023 11:24

God, everyone having a go at op's dh for having the temerity to make his breakfast (at breakfast time!) whilst the friend was talking are equally weird! Just what sort of adulation does op feel was due to this woman?

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 05/08/2023 11:19

What is going on on in your life that you're so worried about appearances and what will people think, that no only you expected at a 5 yo to preform in a way you deem appropriate, you were so angry you wanted to punish her?

You friend didn't even complain (most sane ,well adjusted people wouldn't notice or care) you just THINK she felt x and y.

Priorities OP... yours need readjusting.

Winterscomingagain · 05/08/2023 11:18

Teaching a child social skills is a gradual process but I'm sure most would appreciate it's significance .Being quite introverted myself I'd really struggle with having to perform socially in my own home especially if it was a weekend.
Perhaps it's best to practice these skills outside the home firstly.

itsmyp4rty · 05/08/2023 11:11

pinkyredrose · 05/08/2023 10:57

DH is socially awkward and was turning his back to do other stuff, butter his toast, make his coffee etc, when dear friend was talking to him

What the fuck is wrong with him!?

Perhaps he's undiagnosed autistic and dd will also be? Mine didn't speak to people he didn't know very well at 5 either. He wasn't diagnosed till nearly 11 when his behaviour could no longer be put down to 'just his age'.

Katey83 · 05/08/2023 11:11

A kind word or two when she’s feeling happier and you have calmed down might be more appropriate than a punishment here. I get it’s hard when they embarrass you, but maybe asking her if she is ok, and explaining it is polite to make an effort with guests, will get more results than acting from anger.

jannier · 05/08/2023 11:11

Her behaviour is totally normal for a 5 year old it's you DH that you need to sort....yes leaving you alone to talk fine but basic civilities of saying hi how did you sleep eTC need to be addressed.

ShouldGoToBed · 05/08/2023 11:10

I think you’re directing your disappointment at the wrong person. Have a proper chat with your DH about it at some point so you both understand each others point of view.

All 5 year olds are a bit weird and all you have to do to teach them good manners is to have good manners yourself - you don’t need to do the annoying and awkward “what do you say” routine to try to make her perform - just show her what to do by doing it yourself, and she’ll copy you, in her own time, as she grows up.

Jigglypuff87 · 05/08/2023 11:10

I'm literally shocked you are thinking of punishing her for this. She's literally 5 years old.

Thefamilywaster · 05/08/2023 11:09

You don’t punish children for being shy, that doesn’t cure the problem. Believe me my mother did her best to make me suffer for my shyness and the shyness didn’t go and our relationship only went downhill from there. Teaching your child to be comfortable in her skin and her home
os more important. Explaining basic social rules (even a wave is better than nothing when she’s feeling words won’t come out) might help but punishment isn’t fair

Noitisntgettinguptime · 05/08/2023 11:08

@NIparty absolutely agree. I was (and still am!) quite a shy person. This wasn't always tolerated when I was a child - think getting shoved forward to speak to unfamiliar adults, having my hand put up to to go on the stage with children's entertainers 😱 etc. It made me really anxious about social situations and actually quite angry looking back on some things.

As a teenager, I definitely struggled with a bit of social anxiety that was probably prompted by being expected to go into situations and "entertain". I see it in my DD and totally let her do her own thing. I'm trying to learn not to apologise for her if there is an adult in her face trying to get her to chat or take part in something. Rather than saying "I'm sorry, she is shy", more like changing the subject or being firm and intervening with "This isn't (DD's name)'s sort of thing". For the most part adults should be able to read the body language and make allowances for a small child and I don't want her to think she needs to apologise for being herself.

watcherintherye · 05/08/2023 11:07

I think you’re probably worried that your friend will feel unwelcome, as your dh doesn’t seem to feel that he is required to interact with her, and your dd ignored her! I would have a conversation with your dh, rather than your dd. She’s only five, and I think you would have taken less notice of her awkwardness if your dh had been the chatty sociable person you crave. You can’t make him perform, or care, but maybe you could point out that his current behaviour is likely to make guests, and you, feel uncomfortable. He should be making more of an effort. Your dd is just being 5, and you can’t expect the social backup from her that your dh should be providing.

FictionalCharacter · 05/08/2023 11:06

nobodysdaughternow · 05/08/2023 10:13

At five she will be shy of an adult who she doesn't really know.

You are being way too hard on her. She is her own person not part of a social army you get to deploy to make up for your dh lack of social ability.

It is worrying you are so angered by this. Your dd will do many things over the course of her lifetime that you disagree with.

I agree. She’s only five and you expect her to socialise with a stranger as though she’s an adult. The poor child didn’t do anything terribly rude for a child of that age.

Would she even know what you meant by “what do you say?” You meant you wanted her to say good morning to your friend, but would she know that?

Have you considered that your friend might not be very likeable and might give off vibes a child doesn’t like? One of my mother’s friends was like that. Just because she’s your friend doesn’t mean she’s a nice person, and it certainly doesn’t mean she’s the kind of person a child would warm to.

I don’t blame your DH for keeping out of the way if you force your family to interact with someone who’s a stranger to them. This woman is your friend, not theirs, and it’s their home.

35965a · 05/08/2023 11:06

Even the most sociable children can be ‘off’ sometimes - they’re young, they’re still learning and sometimes a routine change (like a guest) can throw them off. Your DD sounds totally normal, honestly don’t worry about it, it’s not a reflection on you or anything.

StopStartStop · 05/08/2023 11:06

OP, get over it.
That was your visitor. Your baby doesn't have to 'perform'.

Whatoflife · 05/08/2023 11:04

Why don’t you stop now, everyone?
We’re not all perfect parents and sometimes need to take a lead or hint from someone else.
She’s been called some unpleasant things on this thread.
I’m sure she gets a the message.
Have a lovely time at SP OP (if that’s possible!) and don’t post on AIBU again, it’s not pleasant.

HarrietJet · 05/08/2023 11:02

Clefable · 05/08/2023 10:59

I don't get what is so wrong with what DH did either. Was he actually ignoring her or just making breakfast during a conversation? If I had a guest at breakfast time I would talk to them while I was making tea, making toast, whatever. Isn't that totally normal? Confused It's always the case when I stay with people too.

Agree. Op seems to have wanted some sort of ceremony performed for this friend, who nobody else in the house was particularly bothered by.
Weird.

IMustDoMoreExercise · 05/08/2023 11:02

5 year olds can be shy.

HarrietJet · 05/08/2023 11:01

YouAreAlwaysOnMyMind · 05/08/2023 10:49

Weird of the nursery teacher to share this with you...

Far weirder for the weirdo other mum to tell the nursery teacher in the first place....

Yes, finding the gossiping teacher odd doesn't mean I think her behaviour was ok.

Blinkinbloodyhayfever · 05/08/2023 11:00

It makes me laugh how posters are still handing op's arse to her 40 minutes after her update acknowledging she got it wrong.

Clefable · 05/08/2023 10:59

I don't get what is so wrong with what DH did either. Was he actually ignoring her or just making breakfast during a conversation? If I had a guest at breakfast time I would talk to them while I was making tea, making toast, whatever. Isn't that totally normal? Confused It's always the case when I stay with people too.