Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People looking after children while wfh

493 replies

paws732 · 05/08/2023 08:22

My company operates mainly remotely, so we mostly work from home with occasional office days. We have a lot of Teams meetings for connectivity.

With the summer holidays, I have had meeting with a lot of colleagues who have their children sitting on their laps during the meetings. These children range from 5-8, and they are not behaving themselves either. One child kept putting things on their mum's head, and another was having a tantrum about being bored.

AIBU to think they shouldn't be looking after children while wfh, even if it's the school holidays? I feel it will eventually spoil wfh arrangements for everyone, as employers will not tolerate this is many companies.

OP posts:
DontJumpInTheFountain · 08/08/2023 08:49

I fought hard to get one day a week wfh available for those who chose to do so in my team, and to overcome the assumptions that those doing it would take advantage and not pull their weight. In fact, due to the nature of our work, we were able to show benefits not just to the individuals but also to the team on site. It was accepted as a really positive change for all.

But then it became apparent that one individual was using their wfh day for childcare during school holidays. It caused so much resentment from those who were paying for childcare on their wfh days and from the team in general who could see that the person at home was not working as effectively as they were in term time.

It's a beach of our contact to have caring responsibilities while wfh so for us it's clear that if you wouldn't leave your child home alone then you shouldn't be wfh while they're there. I don't believe it should ever just be down to the individual to decide if it's acceptable; they should be transparent with their work about what they intend to do and have it agreed if appropriate.

This individual was reprimanded and now has to provide evidence of childcare, but the damage it's done to the perception of wfh within our department can't be underestimated. It makes me so angry that the actions of one person has made it harder for everyone else.

magicalkitty · 08/08/2023 08:48

Coffeelotsofcoffee · 08/08/2023 08:31

I do it. And not just in the school holidays .
My son has addional needs and very restricted access to childcare due to the crap system and recent ALN act here in Wales cutting all support for ALN kids.

It's incredibly hard.
Wouldn't wish it on anyone.

As for the mainstream population then I don't blame them
What honestly are we supposed to do?
Spend £500 a week on holiday clubs?

The system needs to change and employers need to be more family friendly if they are to retain staff.

Luckily my employer is OK about it

How are you able to get your job done efficiently if you are looking after a child with additional needs at the same time? What sort of job do you do?

Genuinely interested if you are making it work. Sometimes I don't even have time to make a tea or go to the loo between meetings and tasks.

Katela18 · 08/08/2023 08:46

I have a 1 and 3 year old and even I agree this isn't ok.

Both my children are in childcare for the hours we work and during emergencies we either use leave or occasionally ask family to help.

I have colleagues who don't do the same. Recently I was on a call with a colleague who's 3 year old was wandering about in the background naked (she's potty training). Just completely inappropriate. I do worry these people will ruin it for others.

My boss has always sAid she doesn't mind what happens as long as she doesn't know, ie she shouldn't be able to see children or see workload suffering. I know I can't work effectively with 2 toddlers at home hence they are in childcare

Applesonthelawn · 08/08/2023 08:45

It really is unacceptable below school age at least. Obviously for teenagers it's generally fine, there's a sliding scale as to when it becomes acceptable and much depends on the individual child. But there is no way any child below school age can be looked after whilst the carer is also doing an honest day's work. Obviously it's not what people want to hear, but the lack of honesty about this is detrimental to the whole debate.

Zanatdy · 08/08/2023 08:45

Coffeelotsofcoffee · 08/08/2023 08:37

There's 💯 no way my son would cope in a holiday club due to his addional needs .

Additional needs is different. A colleague had a child with additional needs and she received a certain number of free days per year, not enough but she used some of his DLA money to fund more. Luckily she had her mum there to help, no way she could have got her job done with him around. If she didn’t have family to help maybe she would have had to reconsider the job she had and find work in the evenings / weekend around her partner. She wouldn’t have expected colleagues to pick up the slack whilst she ‘wfh’ looking after him too.

Ohhhhhhhhh · 08/08/2023 08:41

Yanbu. Dp has a colleague who looks after his toddler all the time while wfh and its really bloody annoying. We also have a toddler and we bend over backwards to work around childcare so it feels totally unfair. Dp also ends up picking up his slack regularly. He has been pulled up on it by managers but just carries on.

PuttingDownRoots · 08/08/2023 08:40

Back when my mother was a child in the Hebrides, the mothers used to take the children peat cutting with them...

Nowadays... could you imagine if a checkout assistant had their child with them? Or the train driver had their child in the cab or day? Children waiting in the fire engine?

Coffeelotsofcoffee · 08/08/2023 08:37

Zanatdy · 08/08/2023 08:36

Pre Covid that’s what people did. Paid for holiday clubs. That’s what you factor in when having children if no family nearby. I paid for childcare every school holiday. It wouldn’t be fair to my children sitting around bored whilst I worked or to my employer. People are taking it too far now and giving WFH a bad name. Now and again is ok, every day if children are screaming or making a noise in the background isn’t ok.

There's 💯 no way my son would cope in a holiday club due to his addional needs .

Zanatdy · 08/08/2023 08:36

Coffeelotsofcoffee · 08/08/2023 08:31

I do it. And not just in the school holidays .
My son has addional needs and very restricted access to childcare due to the crap system and recent ALN act here in Wales cutting all support for ALN kids.

It's incredibly hard.
Wouldn't wish it on anyone.

As for the mainstream population then I don't blame them
What honestly are we supposed to do?
Spend £500 a week on holiday clubs?

The system needs to change and employers need to be more family friendly if they are to retain staff.

Luckily my employer is OK about it

Pre Covid that’s what people did. Paid for holiday clubs. That’s what you factor in when having children if no family nearby. I paid for childcare every school holiday. It wouldn’t be fair to my children sitting around bored whilst I worked or to my employer. People are taking it too far now and giving WFH a bad name. Now and again is ok, every day if children are screaming or making a noise in the background isn’t ok.

Mummytotwonow · 08/08/2023 08:34

For those saying, well if you were in the office what did you do before for childcare. Holidays clubs since COVID have rocketed, most clubs are £28-£50 per day, if you have two children that’s a fortune. Plus cost of living crisis. If people are getting the work done, leave them alone.

Coffeelotsofcoffee · 08/08/2023 08:31

I do it. And not just in the school holidays .
My son has addional needs and very restricted access to childcare due to the crap system and recent ALN act here in Wales cutting all support for ALN kids.

It's incredibly hard.
Wouldn't wish it on anyone.

As for the mainstream population then I don't blame them
What honestly are we supposed to do?
Spend £500 a week on holiday clubs?

The system needs to change and employers need to be more family friendly if they are to retain staff.

Luckily my employer is OK about it

Flowerpowera7 · 08/08/2023 08:31

I will have to do this for 4 days with my 2 year old this year because the nursery is closed. Have booked my neighbour to babysit for important calls. On others will just turn video off. Work will have to be done and is done as always. I log in late evenings and work whilst others chill out. The best work ideas come to me out of nowhere when out and about anyway and I work for large corporation.

magicalkitty · 08/08/2023 08:29

I was on the phone to someone from our IT company and I couldn't even hear him due to his child screaming in the background. He kept having to leave the call to address it, and then left altogether and said he would sort my problem out later.

HappiestSleeping · 08/08/2023 08:24

MumsGoneToIceland · 05/08/2023 08:37

YANBU - I think people are forgetting that if they were in the office, they would have to have had childcare in place. WFH is supposed to be just that not childcare.

My children weee young pre Covid when we were all in the office and I had to have childcare in place. DH and I used to stagger our leave and the rest involved holiday clubs.

This 👆

The only way childcare and working from home are compatible is if someone else does the childcare while the parent works from home. As a manager, I would be calling people back to the office if this happened regularly, mainly as the parent would need to work longer to compensate for being interrupted. This would eventually lead to burn out, and then the parent is no good to either their employer or their family.

Dingbats876 · 08/08/2023 08:18

This would never have happened pre-pandemic but because of necessity during lockdown people think it’s ok now. I have one of my team who has his two primary school kids at home every holiday and during term time collects them at 3 to bring them home.

I raised with HR and their view was to manage via performance management if performance became an issue so clearly it’s deemed acceptable.

HaveANiceFuckingDay · 08/08/2023 08:15

I was on the phone to 4 , yes FOUR different people yesterday as I can't load the banking app. That is all . Loading a banking app!!. At least 2 of those were WFH i know this because of background noise . Its totally unacceptable and due to this complete incompetence I've cancelled my credit card and closed the account only having the CC for 2 weeks..
Do the job you're bloody paid for !

apigandasheepandsomerabbits · 08/08/2023 08:15

I don't really like it either. It feels like one of those things which should make work more accessible for women but actually means a lot feel even more expectation to work and provide childcare at the same time, meaning both are done poorly.

I agree with this. And like others have said, most of the time it seems that the kids are with mum whilst she WFH. It’s much rarer to see men with children on their laps in Teams calls.

Just another example of women being expected to do it all whilst men carry on like they always have!

I sometimes have my 7 year old in the background from 9-10 and 3-5 as I can’t always find holiday clubs that last the full day. I try to avoid it though. I don’t think it makes me a great parent and I feel bad for her being shunted off with a book (or even worse an iPad).

NoNoNoYoureWrong · 08/08/2023 08:12

Mine are 12 and 13, and on days I’m out at a meeting they are home alone. I don’t have any choice but to WFH at the moment (office shut) so it’s me working in their home - not me working without childcare. While I think our policy is you need childcare for primary age children, they’re probably more disruptive than a pair of well behaved 10 year olds.

We do use a mixture of childcare and grandma but not every day. Very hard to find holiday clubs for 13 year olds, we use one that runs to age 15 but it’s only 3 days a week and only 4 weeks of our nearly-7 week holiday.

As a manager I would, hypocritically, be having words about someone with a younger child on their lap in a meeting. And someone babysitting a baby grandchild whilst on training (a PP mentioned) would be a warning.

Thosesummernights · 08/08/2023 08:08

Absolutely not. And no, it wasn’t fine during Covid which is why we used furlough (enhanced) for our working parents. We have a duty of care to ensure the safety of our team. How on earth can you do your job properly and ensure your child’s welfare, particularly when they are young.

Segway16 · 08/08/2023 08:00

I think it’s ok occasionally, as long as you can still work. As a manager I would have no problem with a child being present here and there, as long as it wasn’t disruptive.

I appreciate not everyone has family help, childcare can be prohibitively expensive and annual leave doesn’t cover all of the school holidays.

However, once work begins to suffer, or it’s clear there are no other arrangements in place at all I would become concerned.

Whyohwhywyoming · 08/08/2023 08:00

No, YANBU. It’s just not on.

my children were 10 and 13 at the start of Covid and so are used to me wfh - which I now do permanently- and are old enough not to really need supervision. I do benefit in the sense that my 13 year old, who has adhd and a below age maturity level, is too old for a lot of holiday clubs but I wouldn’t be comfortable leaving him alone 5 days a week. However, I have as much interaction with him in the course of a day as I would with another adult who was also working from home. I’d also be unhappy about them being on camera.

Showdogworkingdog · 08/08/2023 07:59

It’s in our wfh policy that we can’t wfh while looking after children. There’s an exception for emergencies, but that must be agreed with a manager. In practice, a child at home quietly watching tv or whatever would fly under the radar but any of us can be asked to go in at any time for a meeting or if systems fail. If that should happen and you’ve suddenly got a child to palm off somewhere else before you go in then that’s going to be a problem. Sounds like this hasn’t been made clear by your employer if people are blatantly showing off the fact that they’re babysitting while they’re supposed to be working. That sort of thing will breed resentment because of course it will impact on their working day.

Somewhereovertherainbowweighapie · 08/08/2023 07:58

It’s between the employer and the employer. But this is the reason where my dh works has stopped anyone working from home.

Imisssleep2 · 08/08/2023 07:56

I personally do no or very little work if needed when I have my child, he is 2 and still does a 2-3 hour nap luckily. I have flexible hours so I work 4am to 8.30/9 when my husband starts work, then I restart when he naps around 12 and then my husband will lunch when he wakes up and by the time that is done I have forfilled my hours. The only time I do an occasional but of work with my child awake is if someone requires something done urgently but this is usually only a 10-20min thing at most.

This way my work isn't interupted and I can concentrate when needed etc. As he gets older and goes to school I will adapt my hours to be more sociable with the school day but in holidays would look to do early hours again and or evenings, or do half days so I am not trying to do both working and parenting, as you can't do both like that. Maybe an occasional strike or inset day where you can plan tasks for the kids to get on with on their own while you work in advance but not for a 6 week holiday.

SunshineCrescent · 07/08/2023 23:14

As someone who pays for Childcare, or arranges family to support for the 35 Hours I work this gets my goat..