Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People looking after children while wfh

493 replies

paws732 · 05/08/2023 08:22

My company operates mainly remotely, so we mostly work from home with occasional office days. We have a lot of Teams meetings for connectivity.

With the summer holidays, I have had meeting with a lot of colleagues who have their children sitting on their laps during the meetings. These children range from 5-8, and they are not behaving themselves either. One child kept putting things on their mum's head, and another was having a tantrum about being bored.

AIBU to think they shouldn't be looking after children while wfh, even if it's the school holidays? I feel it will eventually spoil wfh arrangements for everyone, as employers will not tolerate this is many companies.

OP posts:
FlibbedyFlobbedyFloo · 08/08/2023 09:58

JusthereforXmas · 08/08/2023 09:11

People can not tell me what to do with MY children especially not in MY home.

If you hire me you by my skills for the job, as long as that job is being done you have ZERO say in my family or who is allowed to be in MY home.

Firing people over it or moving the work goal posts is not only a 'control freak' move but it seems ripe for discrimination hearings.

Have you actually read your contract?

Do you realise it's a legally binding commitment?

FlibbedyFlobbedyFloo · 08/08/2023 09:56

It's not acceptable where I work - thank goodness. Here, you have to sign a declaration that states you have made arrangements for childcare and your right to WFH can be immediately revoked if that is untrue.
It's totally unprofessional for starters and it's totally impossible to do both. You're either fully focused on your work, in which case your child is in danger. Or you're fully focused on your child, in which case your work isn't being done. Or your fully focused on neither, which is bad both for your child and for your work.
If it's not acceptable in the office, it's not acceptable when WFH.
As far as I'm concerned, that also means no loud music, no TV, no friends "popping in for coffee"

CountryCob · 08/08/2023 09:51

I don't think it's great, when it suited employers to insist we did this though there was no support or consideration with most. They didn't want staff to leave and felt obliged to make it work taking up a lot of space in pressurised homes. I remember thinking I would be told off usually for what I am being asked to do now. Maybe these parents are now used to it, it's not great for anyone though and not what I would like to do

Winterday1991 · 08/08/2023 09:47

Dingbats876 · 08/08/2023 08:18

This would never have happened pre-pandemic but because of necessity during lockdown people think it’s ok now. I have one of my team who has his two primary school kids at home every holiday and during term time collects them at 3 to bring them home.

I raised with HR and their view was to manage via performance management if performance became an issue so clearly it’s deemed acceptable.

This is a sensible response. Is his performance down? If not what's the point in making an issue over nothing?

Poivresel · 08/08/2023 09:47

It’s the usual bad parenting though isn’t it?

Because if you know that your dc needs attention almost constantly then you cannot work unless you have childcare.
My ds would have been fine and happily watched a screen if I’d ever been in this situation, dd on the other hand would have needed another adult as she would definitely have interrupted me.

floribunda18 · 08/08/2023 09:40

Zanatdy · 05/08/2023 08:48

We allow it for children over school age - it says occasionally in the policy but it’s kind of accepted that means the school holidays. I’d be having a word with anyone who had children present during video meetings though, very unprofessional. I wouldn’t have let my kids just sit there all day every day whilst I worked. An odd day a week maybe but parents need to sort childcare like if they were in the office.

i over school age

Over 18?

I can tell you that I can have meetings at home without DD2 (14) , 5'11" and ten stone, sitting on my knee and putting things on my head.

Flowerpowera7 · 08/08/2023 09:38

It’s OK chill out! In my place they encourage to bring kids into the office! I work for a large corp in London!

Singlespies · 08/08/2023 09:36

I agree with you, but money is short at present and there is a shortage of childcare so I think having children at home is necessity. I didn't enjoy having small children at home when I worked, but times were different then - life was easier then.

FrustatedAgain · 08/08/2023 09:33

WFH during covid with a toddler and reception aged child was like hell on earth, I was neither being a good parent or a good employee, which just made me stressed. I would never choose to do that again, I now have a child about to start school and an 8 year old and childcare has been arranged for everyday of the holidays if I am not on leave. As they get older I might wfh with them there for a few days, but on these days they will just be looking at screens for most of the day, I want to limit that as it isn't good for them.

milveycrohn · 08/08/2023 09:27

I understand some latitude may have been allowed during lockdown, when employees not only had their school kids at home, but presumably were expected to supervise some home schooling.
However, as a general rule, WFH is not an excuse to avoid paying childcare.
One gains on commuting time and commuting fares, but one should also have somewhere private to work away from children, esecially pre-school.

Dentistlakes · 08/08/2023 09:22

When children are at an age where they need supervision, it’s not acceptable. My teenagers are sometimes around in the house when I’m working, but never interrupt calls. You can’t possibly give work your full attention when you are looking after younger kids.

magicalkitty · 08/08/2023 09:21

Yerroblemom1923 · 08/08/2023 09:09

I once thought wfh was the ultimate goal for women with kids as it meant they could still earn while also being present for their kids! There are often posts on MN asking about wfh jobs when women realise (usually too late!) the cost of childcare or that school holidays of 13 weeks a year aren't going to work with their annual 6 weeks holiday entitlement etc.
This and the many fbk ads for MLM pyramid schemes to sell beauty products heralded as the ultimate wfh job etc etc
I don't think covid helped the matter as meant people had to have their kids at home while wfh and no doubt many took the mick.
Covid is long gone and we need people back at work not doing school runs, dog walks, pegging the washing out, nipping to Tesco etc etc. A friend of mine even jokes she has to get back to "wiggle the mouse"!
Sadly people no longer take genuine wfh jobs seriously anymore and see is as a luxury in which they can take liberties.

I think it's the reason many companies are moving away from wfh / hybrid and getting people to come back to offices. That and some people just don't seem to be able to discipline and motivate themselves while working from home.

It worries me as it will hurt everyone in the end, including those who work well from home and hate working in offices. It will also hurt parents who are not taking the piss.

NoTouch · 08/08/2023 09:21

JusthereforXmas · 08/08/2023 09:11

People can not tell me what to do with MY children especially not in MY home.

If you hire me you by my skills for the job, as long as that job is being done you have ZERO say in my family or who is allowed to be in MY home.

Firing people over it or moving the work goal posts is not only a 'control freak' move but it seems ripe for discrimination hearings.

🤣🤣🤣🤣

On the slim chance that post is genuine, and I suspect there are people that think somewhat down those lines, unless you have a very niche highly sought after skill set you are deluded.

magicalkitty · 08/08/2023 09:18

JusthereforXmas · 08/08/2023 09:11

People can not tell me what to do with MY children especially not in MY home.

If you hire me you by my skills for the job, as long as that job is being done you have ZERO say in my family or who is allowed to be in MY home.

Firing people over it or moving the work goal posts is not only a 'control freak' move but it seems ripe for discrimination hearings.

Good luck taking an employer to court for 'discrimination' in that scenario.

Serenglas · 08/08/2023 09:18

Pisses me right off! I’m the only parent of my kids friendship groups who has used holiday club, they’re all balking at the cost, which they had to pay before WFH became common.

It simply isn’t possible to work and look after young kids. And it’s not good for the more self sufficient ones, say 7+ to spend the day on tablets/watching tv, which is honestly what the majority of these kids are doing.

TarquinOliverNimrod · 08/08/2023 09:11

JusthereforXmas · 08/08/2023 09:11

People can not tell me what to do with MY children especially not in MY home.

If you hire me you by my skills for the job, as long as that job is being done you have ZERO say in my family or who is allowed to be in MY home.

Firing people over it or moving the work goal posts is not only a 'control freak' move but it seems ripe for discrimination hearings.

Oh don’t be so ridiculous 😂

TarquinOliverNimrod · 08/08/2023 09:11

Looking after my 9 month old and WFH is one of the most stressful things I’ve ever done 😂 traumatising.

JusthereforXmas · 08/08/2023 09:11

People can not tell me what to do with MY children especially not in MY home.

If you hire me you by my skills for the job, as long as that job is being done you have ZERO say in my family or who is allowed to be in MY home.

Firing people over it or moving the work goal posts is not only a 'control freak' move but it seems ripe for discrimination hearings.

Yerroblemom1923 · 08/08/2023 09:09

I once thought wfh was the ultimate goal for women with kids as it meant they could still earn while also being present for their kids! There are often posts on MN asking about wfh jobs when women realise (usually too late!) the cost of childcare or that school holidays of 13 weeks a year aren't going to work with their annual 6 weeks holiday entitlement etc.
This and the many fbk ads for MLM pyramid schemes to sell beauty products heralded as the ultimate wfh job etc etc
I don't think covid helped the matter as meant people had to have their kids at home while wfh and no doubt many took the mick.
Covid is long gone and we need people back at work not doing school runs, dog walks, pegging the washing out, nipping to Tesco etc etc. A friend of mine even jokes she has to get back to "wiggle the mouse"!
Sadly people no longer take genuine wfh jobs seriously anymore and see is as a luxury in which they can take liberties.

magicalkitty · 08/08/2023 09:05

Ambi · 08/08/2023 08:59

It isn't the same for everyone. Some jobs are more formal or deal in confidentiality. Not all children are the same age or temperament. Not all employers are slavedrivers. Not all fathers are WOHP FT. It's impossible to compare situations.

It works well for me because: My DC are older, my job isn't full on, I have lots of down time. I don't have many phone calls or meetings. The MD has his little kids running around and is very family focused as long as the work is getting done, which it is. I have an office room where I can go and work in peace without disturbing the house. My DH works shifts and is home most days. So for me, wfh whilst having my lazy teen and tween around is not a problem, they are often playing out with friends anyway. When they were little however, I was in an office and they were at nursery. I was expected to work and homeschool through covid, no furlough for me. I don't take the piss and my work is always done.

Trying to concentrate on a full on job with confidentiality issues or constant meetings or phone calls with young lively kids or kids with SEN single handedly is a different situation and is completely understandable why that wouldn't work at all.

I think it's fine if the kids are teens /tweens and don't need your supervision and attention. It's very different to a toddler who is trying to kill themselves every 5 minutes and needs to be watched.

Ambi · 08/08/2023 08:59

It isn't the same for everyone. Some jobs are more formal or deal in confidentiality. Not all children are the same age or temperament. Not all employers are slavedrivers. Not all fathers are WOHP FT. It's impossible to compare situations.

It works well for me because: My DC are older, my job isn't full on, I have lots of down time. I don't have many phone calls or meetings. The MD has his little kids running around and is very family focused as long as the work is getting done, which it is. I have an office room where I can go and work in peace without disturbing the house. My DH works shifts and is home most days. So for me, wfh whilst having my lazy teen and tween around is not a problem, they are often playing out with friends anyway. When they were little however, I was in an office and they were at nursery. I was expected to work and homeschool through covid, no furlough for me. I don't take the piss and my work is always done.

Trying to concentrate on a full on job with confidentiality issues or constant meetings or phone calls with young lively kids or kids with SEN single handedly is a different situation and is completely understandable why that wouldn't work at all.

Caledoniadreaming · 08/08/2023 08:56

DontJumpInTheFountain · 08/08/2023 08:49

I fought hard to get one day a week wfh available for those who chose to do so in my team, and to overcome the assumptions that those doing it would take advantage and not pull their weight. In fact, due to the nature of our work, we were able to show benefits not just to the individuals but also to the team on site. It was accepted as a really positive change for all.

But then it became apparent that one individual was using their wfh day for childcare during school holidays. It caused so much resentment from those who were paying for childcare on their wfh days and from the team in general who could see that the person at home was not working as effectively as they were in term time.

It's a beach of our contact to have caring responsibilities while wfh so for us it's clear that if you wouldn't leave your child home alone then you shouldn't be wfh while they're there. I don't believe it should ever just be down to the individual to decide if it's acceptable; they should be transparent with their work about what they intend to do and have it agreed if appropriate.

This individual was reprimanded and now has to provide evidence of childcare, but the damage it's done to the perception of wfh within our department can't be underestimated. It makes me so angry that the actions of one person has made it harder for everyone else.

Interestingly, my DH's work has a clear no childcare while working policy; and they are STRICT about it (also a VVV safety conscious employer so it fits) - however, they do have a bank of "emergency childcare leave" that employees can use. In some ways they're really far ahead of the times/curve and in other ways they're well behind.

Caledoniadreaming · 08/08/2023 08:54

Ohhhhhhhhh · 08/08/2023 08:41

Yanbu. Dp has a colleague who looks after his toddler all the time while wfh and its really bloody annoying. We also have a toddler and we bend over backwards to work around childcare so it feels totally unfair. Dp also ends up picking up his slack regularly. He has been pulled up on it by managers but just carries on.

I am in the same boat - my colleague has a 1 year old who only goes to nursery in the afternoons, during term time. Trying to get a hold of her in the mornings or, like now, during the school holidays is something of a nightmare. Even worse at the moment because we are going through an insanely busy period which requires all my team to be working in the office most of the week.

Makes me feel that maybe I shouldn't have pushed so hard to put my baby into childcare full time from 7 months if it feels she can get away with it (I would have done anyway, no way can I work at home or concentrate with my DS running around like a mini tornado all day). Also doesn't help when there are comments like "oh, it's so nice when I'm on leave to take my child to the park and not worry about work" - um, it's core hours, you are supposed to be working. It's this attitude that gets me really pissed off.

ImTheOnlyUpsyOne · 08/08/2023 08:54

I have DS4 and DS7 at home while wfh but I don't have a role when I have to be on all day. I don't have many video calls, but if I do have a video call, I make sure they are not present. It is true that at some points I do need to log on after hours.

All my work gets done and I am always responsive.

CattingAbout · 08/08/2023 08:52

I WFH with my eldest 1-2 days a week in the holidays. He has SEN and can't go to any of the local holiday clubs (which generally only run 9-3 and are miles away anyway, so not super useful). His dad also does a day or so WFH and grandparents help us a bit, plus we have each booked a fair bit of annual leave so it's not all watching us WFH.

For me, WFH with a child around is an agreed arrangement (carer's passport) with my employer - I don't think they love it, but the pay is crap, my job is very niche and they agree that I shouldn't be forced out of the workforce just for having a child with SEN. Sometimes I have to catch up work in the evenings, but not loads. It gets reviewed regularly, if performance suffered it would change.

I don't have loads of meetings, but DS is never allowed onscreen during Teams calls and knows not to make loads of noise. I always set him up with an activity beforehand.