Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People looking after children while wfh

493 replies

paws732 · 05/08/2023 08:22

My company operates mainly remotely, so we mostly work from home with occasional office days. We have a lot of Teams meetings for connectivity.

With the summer holidays, I have had meeting with a lot of colleagues who have their children sitting on their laps during the meetings. These children range from 5-8, and they are not behaving themselves either. One child kept putting things on their mum's head, and another was having a tantrum about being bored.

AIBU to think they shouldn't be looking after children while wfh, even if it's the school holidays? I feel it will eventually spoil wfh arrangements for everyone, as employers will not tolerate this is many companies.

OP posts:
Spirael · 05/08/2023 09:15

In some areas the childcare provision simply isn't available - especially for the 7-11 age range. And I say this as someone who lives in a (northern) city suburb. I imagine it's even worse for rural families!
School clubs don't cover the whole summer holiday because the buildings are closed for maintenance. The local hobby clubs only operate 10am to 3pm.
Massive reductions since Covid mean there are less big holiday clubs available. The nearest 8:30am to 5:30pm holiday club to me is an over 2 hours round trip each journey, because various major roads are closed for maintenance over the summer months.
Parents don't have enough leave to cover the whole summer, or enough money to hire a nanny, and don't always have family/friends available to pick up the slack.
Yes it's not ideal to WFH with kids and I think you'll struggle to find many people who enjoy it. But what's the alternative?

TheKeatingFive · 05/08/2023 09:15

In theory, I totally agree with you. In practice however, I've found getting 9-5 childcare across the summer holidays to be an impossible task. So something has got to give.

horseymum · 05/08/2023 09:15

My dd looks after some friends kids when the parents are wfh. The parent just don't want the kids set on screens all day so she does baking/ craft/ games with them. Cheaper than childcare and nice for kids to be in own home. She generally does 10-4 or similar so kids get long lie etc.

Clefable · 05/08/2023 09:12

Disruptive behaviour during meetings is not acceptable. But a child at home during the holidays who is largely amusing themselves, I don't see the problem. I WFH 100% of the time and my kids are too young to be around while I do that, but my bosses and other colleagues sometimes have an older child visible in the background watching TV or walking past the screen during holidays or after school and it's never really an issue. You can't get away with not doing work in my job (without being too specific, we have fixed daily deadlines that have to be met at all costs and people have specific roles to enable that to happen, so if someone wasn't doing their job it would be abundantly obvious as the whole thing would fall apart).

babbscrabbs · 05/08/2023 09:12

I'd count your blessings you can afford childcare/ have family available to help/ are living in a part of the UK with free childcare hours available.

If only it was that easy!

We are driving DC 3 hours to relatives to be looked after and then having to commute back from there ourselves - that covers a few days.

We have also arranged complicated childcare swaps with other parents.

We have used all our holiday, built up time in lieu, and had to take some unpaid leave too. Not easy or fun. It would be much easier to keep them at home!

DreamItDoIt · 05/08/2023 09:10

I think it's very unprofessional to have a child on your lap/in the room when you are in a meeting. If i wfh I would be hiding the fact I was doing childcare.

I wonder how many men are doing this? I'm prepared to bet not many. I expect yet again women are pressured into doing more. Wfh - great can do childcare/laundry/walk the dog/get dinner ready (said no man ever).

I also don't think it's about 'well if they get the job done'. If this were the case, if we were in the office, we'd all be able to go home after we'd 'got the job done'! It's no wonder service levels and productivity are so low.

Hollyhead · 05/08/2023 09:08

It’s fine for 8/9 year olds plus as they just entertain themselves. I’d expect anyone with a child under 7 to have childcare in place for at least most of the day.

EarringsandLipstick · 05/08/2023 09:06

Marmite27 · 05/08/2023 09:02

Mine are in this age group and there’s always an available adult in the house to provide care but they’re magically attracted to the study, so do appear from time to time.

Your 'available adult' needs to do a better job then.

The occasional interruption is fine, it will happen in a different way in the office (eg a call from a child you have to take).

But otherwise children need to be kept away or know to stay away from your home working space.

babbscrabbs · 05/08/2023 09:06

Lapflop · 05/08/2023 08:38

Unless childcare has fallen through unexpectedly or there's illness and they have to be home then no it's wild that it's seen as acceptable. How crap for the children more than anything else.

This.

You can't be a present, attentive parent and do a full day's work at the same time.

Something will suffer - likely both.

Different for teenagers who are pretty self sufficient but for DC under 8/9 I'd say no.

Lavender14 · 05/08/2023 09:04

I think it can work when you take a few things into account. A) people stay with flexible and family friendly companies for longer especially mums who juggle the lions share of caring responsibilities. This saves the company money that would otherwise go into recruitment and training. B) for the same reason if a company is serious about promoting women thriving in their workplace they need to understand and respect that there will be a juggle between workload and caring load and make allowance for that. C)I think it's fine when it's reasonably temporary such as school holidays or sickness- obviously not every employee with children can be off during the school holidays and with col and childcare fees so extortionately high not everyone will have family handy to take this on. D) I think it's up to the employee to get their work done and for a lot of parents wfh this often means working later in the evening when kids go to bed so they're possibly doing more/different hours and this level of flexibility helps them stay in their job. I work in a very family friendly workplace. There are certain types of meetings I wouldn't bring ds into but outside of that it wouldn't be an issue. I wouldn't think twice about other people having their kids there provided their work isn't suffering and they aren't unavailable. It's one of the main reasons I've stayed with my company as long as I have despite having better options for progression elsewhere. I don't stop being a parent just because I'm employed and it's unreasonable for employers to expect us to act like that's the case. I'd count your blessings you can afford childcare/ have family available to help/ are living in a part of the UK with free childcare hours available.

Marmite27 · 05/08/2023 09:02

Mine are in this age group and there’s always an available adult in the house to provide care but they’re magically attracted to the study, so do appear from time to time.

Purplecatshopaholic · 05/08/2023 09:02

SpainToday · 05/08/2023 08:28

My employer does not allow people to WFH while looking after children (emergencies are different)

We wouldnt allow this either (a one off if the manager is ok with it isn’t an issue - I have allowed it in my team occasionally). It’s clear in our policies it’s not allowed and we expect parents to have the same arrangements in place as if they were in the office. To some extent I suppose it depends on the age of the child - if they are self sufficient then fine, you can get on with work. At the end of the day, if performance at work is fine, then I as a manager might not know if someone was attempting to work and do child care at the same time - but if performance was dipping, and I found out about children being at home, I would have to tackle it. Ultimately we would remove the right to home working until performance improved.

PuttingDownRoots · 05/08/2023 09:00

Massive difference between having a child at home getting on with stuff while parent works, and having them on your lap playing with you while you try to have a meeting.

If they need that level of interaction, your mind isn't on your work.

SaltyGod · 05/08/2023 08:59

As a manager I don’t mind one of my reports who has kids at home in the holidays. The youngest is 7 and they’ve never impacted her work quality or quantity.

If her work was slipping that would be a different conversation with her about ensuring she was in the right environment to achieve her goals.

Yellowlegobrick · 05/08/2023 08:59

Yanbu. Its not allowed (specified in company policy) at my work.

We aren't dicks - if someone has an odd day with a poorly child at home who can't be sent to childcare we get it, we've all been there. Same applies for things like having kids home 3.30- 5 in summer holidays and catching up in the evening - we know summer clubs are a nightmare for not including wraparound. But routinely expecting to work with younger children at home to try and save money on childcare - not acceptable and you'd likely get put on a performance plan if you were doing it.

Hufflepods · 05/08/2023 08:57

An 8 year old during the summer holidays for a day or 2 a week, or half day after a club is very different from a toddler who isn’t enrolled in nursery during the work day imo.

rockingbird · 05/08/2023 08:56

I've worked from home / remotely for over 10 years. Obviously in that time my children have grown up. When they were very young I was part time and had a nanny. This helped me focus more whilst they were out and about etc. now much older and a little more self sufficient during school holidays I'm able to juggle both and arrange my working hours to suit afternoons out and such like. I'd be a little annoyed to have teams calls with colleagues and children misbehaving.. the odd occasion fair enough, but certainly not the norm! How can you do an effective job with that sort of chaos. The irony is the one thing working parents have already wanted is flexibility in the working environment. Since lockdown we've all changed the way we work (I was already working remotely so very used to it). This seems to have been abused somewhat and now companies are doing a full 360 and asking employees to get back in the office and do a 9-5 job.. not surprisingly!! Like anything, take the piss and it's taken away.

mellysq · 05/08/2023 08:54

@paws732 surely if you have children you understand the massive pressure on people to pay for childcare and stay in work? I am currently in this position. It’s awful. You will always be entitled to work from home unless there’s a business need for you to go in. Don’t kick up a fuss and make life even harder for working parents.

LKM23 · 05/08/2023 08:54

No it's not acceptable, you're either working or looking after your kids but you can't do both. I'm a manager and if my team were doing this I'd revoke the ability to WFH 🤷‍♀️

Rosti1981 · 05/08/2023 08:52

Mine are in late primary and early secondary and I do it, but they never interrupt me and just get on with chilling in their rooms. I book some childcare for my younger child so he has a mix though, but that is actually less flexible as it runs 9-5 so I have to manage drop offs/pick ups etc. (and if I was going into the office after it would need to be a shorter day because of the commuting time).

Not sure I could get that much childcare for my 12.5 year old either, but I wouldn't leave her at home regularly for the entire day either (few hours is fine and the odd longer day).
I wouldn't with young children or with children that interrupted me. Or every day as it's not fair on the children to be ignored all day (bar lunchtime when I feed them). But my colleagues don't really know whether my kids are there or not, so it works for us, some of the time, in the context of annual leave and some childcare provision as well. Like everything it's a juggle!

HunterHearstHelmsley · 05/08/2023 08:52

HunterHearstHelmsley · 05/08/2023 08:50

I'll sometimes look after a 6 year old for a few hours when I'm WFH, he's a dream though and will entertain himself when I have meetings etc.

However, I sometimes get lumbered with an 18 month old... he is not a dream! Constantly into everything and have to have eyes everywhere. When I have him, I'll speak to my manager and make the hours up on the evening. I would not have him if I had calls planned. I couldn't keep him safe and do my job effectively.

One of the people I work with has her 6 year old with her a few hours twice a week. They schedule internal calls only.

I work in health care so our patient facing staff can't have children with them when they're working from home. It can cause a few problems as they don't think it's fair that central staff can. It's the nature of the roles, unfortunately. They get other perks we don't.

drpet49 · 05/08/2023 08:51

No not acceptable and it is very unprofessional.

HunterHearstHelmsley · 05/08/2023 08:50

I'll sometimes look after a 6 year old for a few hours when I'm WFH, he's a dream though and will entertain himself when I have meetings etc.

However, I sometimes get lumbered with an 18 month old... he is not a dream! Constantly into everything and have to have eyes everywhere. When I have him, I'll speak to my manager and make the hours up on the evening. I would not have him if I had calls planned. I couldn't keep him safe and do my job effectively.

One of the people I work with has her 6 year old with her a few hours twice a week. They schedule internal calls only.

Zanatdy · 05/08/2023 08:48

We allow it for children over school age - it says occasionally in the policy but it’s kind of accepted that means the school holidays. I’d be having a word with anyone who had children present during video meetings though, very unprofessional. I wouldn’t have let my kids just sit there all day every day whilst I worked. An odd day a week maybe but parents need to sort childcare like if they were in the office.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 05/08/2023 08:47

Depends on the age of the child. A child who is too young to be left alone but capable of entertaining themselves all day - eg late primary? - not really a problem. A toddler/ young child who can't be left to their own devices? Absolutely not!