Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People looking after children while wfh

493 replies

paws732 · 05/08/2023 08:22

My company operates mainly remotely, so we mostly work from home with occasional office days. We have a lot of Teams meetings for connectivity.

With the summer holidays, I have had meeting with a lot of colleagues who have their children sitting on their laps during the meetings. These children range from 5-8, and they are not behaving themselves either. One child kept putting things on their mum's head, and another was having a tantrum about being bored.

AIBU to think they shouldn't be looking after children while wfh, even if it's the school holidays? I feel it will eventually spoil wfh arrangements for everyone, as employers will not tolerate this is many companies.

OP posts:
PinkCherryBlossoms · 05/08/2023 12:41

Nanny0gg · 05/08/2023 12:28

It's one thing to say the working world has changed since covid, but there are companies that cannot have WFH employees and some business that can but absolutely cannot have children around.

So are all their employees with children just going to walk or are they going to have to suck up paying for childcare?

I don't believe for one second that if WFH was banned that there would be a mass walkout of staff

Well, some of them will be looked after by the other parent who does wfh and can have DC there, for starters.

But for those where that isn't the case, in some cases yes that is going to involve them working less. There are permutations of that stopping well short of mass walkout- part time work and parental leave, for example.

None of which is to say that some parents wouldn't be able to suck it up, source and pay for suitable childcare. But they wouldn't all, and some of those who could would still choose not to. The reality is that a need for childcare doesn't mean it exists.

bonzaitree · 05/08/2023 12:40

It’s ok in an emergency/ if a child is sick. I don’t think it’s ok normally though. Not fair on workers who are child free or who do pay for clubs.

TeenLifeMum · 05/08/2023 12:35

I have 3 dc ages 11-15 and wfh some days - they bring me coffee and leave me alone. They started age 9 but that’s because of Covid and definitely not ideal. They were too young but it trained them quickly. I think from 10 up it’s possible to wfh but under that they need childcare.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 05/08/2023 12:34

Yeah, it’s rife in my public sector role and does my head in.

I have a cat that sits on the windowsill where he can be seen. He’s looking out the window and not interested in me, so he doesn’t try to climb onto the desk. If he did I’d put my arm up and stop him. I know that nobody is interested in my pets so I don’t allow that to be an issue.

Unfortunately it’s not the same for the parents in my team and the work quality goes down the pan every summer. I wish someone would tackle it but, y’know, public sector - even my boss does it!

TheCrystalPalace · 05/08/2023 12:33

@transparentday "And so there will be the occasional interruption or background noise, and that can't be helped because I want the children to be able to treat their home like a home, and not a workplace."

It CAN be helped! It's because you WANT your kids to have that attitude. Why should your employers/clients suffer the consequences of that choice? Nothing stopping your kids from treating their home like home but they need to learn, due to your choice to wfh, that there are times when they can't make a noise and interrupt (age-dependent, of course, but any child too young for that should have proper childcare arrangements).

TheYearOfSmallThings · 05/08/2023 12:29

User1755387908 · 05/08/2023 12:25

Why do children that age need to be on laps, can't they go and play or watch tv.

A child that age will never sit on your lap... except when your attention absolutely needs to be on something else. This is why DS goes to summer camp even when I am WFH.

Nanny0gg · 05/08/2023 12:28

It's one thing to say the working world has changed since covid, but there are companies that cannot have WFH employees and some business that can but absolutely cannot have children around.

So are all their employees with children just going to walk or are they going to have to suck up paying for childcare?

I don't believe for one second that if WFH was banned that there would be a mass walkout of staff

User1755387908 · 05/08/2023 12:25

Why do children that age need to be on laps, can't they go and play or watch tv.

melj1213 · 05/08/2023 12:23

I think the problem is that pre-Covid WFH with kids was seen as a very last resort and w as acknowledged as a "one off" situation ... Then COVID rolled round and we all went into survival mode, which included people balancing WFH and childcare because there was no other choice and everyone was understanding of the occasional interruption due to the situation. Post COVID and some people have decided that because they managed to balance WFH/childcare during COVID they can manage now without taking into account that people are a lot less understanding of interrupted work as there are now childcare options available.

I am currently helping family members by babysitting through the summer holidays and there's no way that you can get anything productive done with under 5s in the house and over 5s can be left but not all day every day. When I'm watching the 5+s I can get some respite to sit and read a book for half an hour or watch some TV with a cup of coffee whilst they are entertained with independent play, but even then that's only for an hour or so and there's no way I could get anything productive done without leaving the children to their own devices for long periods of time, which isn't really fair if it's done every day. Every child will need some downtime during the holidays of they're booked on lots of activities so if it's just for a day or two then it's fair enough but if it's the default then it's not fair on anyone - child, parent or employer.

I work in a supermarket pharmacy, I can't WFH at all so I had no choice but to get childcare for DD when she was in primary. She's secondary now so we organised a language camp and a couple of other summer programmes for things she is interested in but it's purely for her enjoyment rather than because I need childcare. Some years when she was in primary I pretty much worked all summer just to pay for her activities but it meant I didn't lose my job.

Yes employers need to be more flexible now but I do think that a lot of parents have come to have the expectation that their work will accommodate their childcare issues and are not happy when their employer is not as flexible as they want them to be because of the business needs.

Nanny0gg · 05/08/2023 12:21

coeurnoir · 05/08/2023 12:10

We've just had to update our policy on wfh to ban this. This is after a member of my team seriously pissed off one of our clients to the point where we lost a major contract. Her child was constantly heard screaming in the background in meetings and she messed them around with not turning up on time due to child issues, not getting the work done on time due to child issues and generally making us look like a bunch of amateurs rather than a professional company delivering healthcare provision.

Wasn't it possible to just deal with the member of staff? Or were others taking the piss?

Nanny0gg · 05/08/2023 12:21

B) for the same reason if a company is serious about promoting women thriving in their workplace they need to understand and respect that there will be a juggle between workload and caring load and make allowance for that.

Why? Do they have to do that for men? If not, why not?

If the father is WFH I bet he's shut in his 'office' with Do Not Disturb explicitly understood or his management would have something to say

TheCrystalPalace · 05/08/2023 12:17

On what planet does the OP's colleague think it's OK to attend an online meeting with a child on their lap (of an age that ought to know better) mucking around putting stuff on their head whilst they're trying to work?
Where is her professional pride.
I'd be pissed off as a colleague attending that meeting as it would seriously distract me from the matter in hand.

coeurnoir · 05/08/2023 12:10

We've just had to update our policy on wfh to ban this. This is after a member of my team seriously pissed off one of our clients to the point where we lost a major contract. Her child was constantly heard screaming in the background in meetings and she messed them around with not turning up on time due to child issues, not getting the work done on time due to child issues and generally making us look like a bunch of amateurs rather than a professional company delivering healthcare provision.

IcedPurple · 05/08/2023 12:06

queenofthewild · 05/08/2023 11:32

A good friend is really struggling at the moment. She has a disabled child with SEND and has been unable to secure suitable childcare. Her usual holiday club say they can't cope with him any more and her attempts to find a childminder or nanny have been fruitless. I'd like to hope her employers and colleagues are sympathetic as her and her husband juggle childcare and working from home over the summer.

But if her child's needs are such that childcare professionals feel they can't cope with him, then clearly he requires a lot of attention. So it's hard to see how your friend could possibly be doing her job effectively while also 'juggling' childcare for a high needs child.

GenieGenealogy · 05/08/2023 12:03

Agree, have no interest in seeing your cat on your desk, or hearing your dog barking.

SpongeBabeSquarePants · 05/08/2023 11:59

MrsJBaptiste · 05/08/2023 09:40

YANBU @paws732

I've had this with cats this week, every other person had a bloody cat walking over the keyboard getting in the way. I can't stand it, especially when everyone makes the obligatory comments about how cute it is and the meeting goes off on a tangent 🙄 Really pisses me off.

This. Pet owners tend to massively overestimate non pet owners interest in their animals in my experience.

Robbiesraft · 05/08/2023 11:54

Mine are late Primary school age and I do wfh 2 days a week. They are mainly watching TV or gaming the whole of those days which isn't great. I feel guilty for that. I saw a PP talk about a parent setting up a 30 min schedule. Mine would need me chasing them around to stick to that. I'm in the office 2 days while they are at childcare, friends or grandparents. I've booked one day off each week to go on a big trip with them, when I spend my way out the guilt of abandoning them to the ipads earlier in the week.

I couldn't have wfh when they were under 8. They wouldn't understand and I wouldn't be able to concentrate on my work. I think it would have been taking the piss.

Clefable · 05/08/2023 11:34

Hayliebells · 05/08/2023 11:25

What do you mean by "over school age"? A child of secondary school age could be at home alone, so there's no real reason why they can't be there. If they have a parent who WFH, what are they supposed to do? Go out and wander the streets until the working day is over?

They mean kids who are old enough to go to school, not preschoolers or babies.

queenofthewild · 05/08/2023 11:32

A good friend is really struggling at the moment. She has a disabled child with SEND and has been unable to secure suitable childcare. Her usual holiday club say they can't cope with him any more and her attempts to find a childminder or nanny have been fruitless. I'd like to hope her employers and colleagues are sympathetic as her and her husband juggle childcare and working from home over the summer.

maddiemookins16mum · 05/08/2023 11:28

Loads of ours do it (but pretend the kids are at holiday club).
The performance of those doing this varies from no issues to dire.
One in particular clearly has all three under 9 at home, blurring her teams background does not hide the shrieking, arguing and crying. She also disappears for extended periods of time.
She has been explicitly asked if she has childcare in place and days yes.
However, I have some sympathy, her partner has fecked off, pays no money and she literally cannot afford childcare for a 2, 5 and 8 year old.

Another (single parent) has a really well behaved 6 year old and again struggles financially, she’s been forced to take unpaid parental leave for 4 of the 6 weeks. Mainly because she admitted she was going to be wfh with him there.

Hayliebells · 05/08/2023 11:25

Zanatdy · 05/08/2023 08:48

We allow it for children over school age - it says occasionally in the policy but it’s kind of accepted that means the school holidays. I’d be having a word with anyone who had children present during video meetings though, very unprofessional. I wouldn’t have let my kids just sit there all day every day whilst I worked. An odd day a week maybe but parents need to sort childcare like if they were in the office.

What do you mean by "over school age"? A child of secondary school age could be at home alone, so there's no real reason why they can't be there. If they have a parent who WFH, what are they supposed to do? Go out and wander the streets until the working day is over?

CornishGem1975 · 05/08/2023 11:21

As a rule, we have to have childcare when we work from home (aside from sickness etc) but holidays I work from home for the duration and it's perfectly acceptable that we have our kids around. My employer does not expect us to put them in childcare all summer. That said, the littlest is in nursery as usual but the older ones who can entertain themselves/each other are around. I only have internal meetings, as I am not client facing so that's never an issue.

Motheranddaughter · 05/08/2023 11:20

I don’t see how you can WFH and look after young children
Not fair on anyone
Also people who say it’s better for mums ,I am really not sure it is,must be really stressful
We would not want our staff WFH and looking after DC
We have made this clear and breaching this would be a disciplinary matter

RememberWhy · 05/08/2023 11:18

BeeBelle16 · 05/08/2023 08:28

As a manager I wouldn't be adverse to people having their children around when WFH but I would expect usual workload to be done on time and targets to be met.

I would also stipulate that of a client calls you/you have a virtual meeting with a client children not around then, and if client wants a face to face meeting you accommodate it and sort childcare

If it was an internal meeting and the child was around but behaving then I wouldn't mind this, but that's my view as a manager and mum.

My boss who has no kids and has never experienced the horror of the long holidays vs childcare and wrap around care may disagree!

I run a company and agree with the above 100%

SophieTheWonderCat · 05/08/2023 11:17

Floralnomad · 05/08/2023 11:03

I know a man who wfh and has his kids in the holidays some days . He writes them a daily schedule set out in 30 minute slots with what they are supposed to be doing and if they bother him at all he refers them to the schedule - they are 6 & 8 ish . It’s all very organised .

I suspect it is mainly Mothers who are landed with this but it's not a great situation for the advancement of women in the workplace. I think WFH has led to a feeling with some people that they are entitled to this.