Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Crafters, if you copy someone's design that you've seen online you're not just a CF, you're a thief.

267 replies

ThingsBeingVarious · 04/08/2023 22:33

I have a small, successful craft business and mostly sell online, which means there are loads of photographs of my work for anyone to see. Yet again I've just been made aware of someone copying my original design and selling the product - she probably thinks it's okay because she's raising money for her local charity. And sometimes my 'followers' and customers will send me a photo of the copy they've made saying I've 'inspired them'.

I know people often say imitation is the sincerest form of flattery but it really fucks me off. People should think up their own designs, not scroll through Pinterest or Etsy or wherever looking for ideas to nick. Or if they haven't got any original ideas they can BUY patterns from other crafter's.

OP posts:
MumUndone · 05/08/2023 07:28

This is bonkers. Of course people shouldn't copy your designs to sell, but copying from a photo for their own personal use is hardly 'disgraceful' as they aren't receiving any financial benefit, just enjoyment - and surely that is flattery?

Theraffarian · 05/08/2023 07:17

I craft in a few different techniques and areas , in general I guess we all use existing ideas to inspire new ones .

I think you need to be really clear on all your selling sites and socials that you do not want your original ideas sold even for charity . Also stating the follow up action you will take if it happens , and be prepared to do so .

One online craft group I belong to has 125k members and we positively encourage sharing ideas , methods and techniques including tutorials on how to make the items . However in this particular craft it’s a saturated market and many make for pleasure , it’s hard to make a profit from . I think some crafters are used to these types of sharing groups and they wouldn’t necessarily think there was a problem using your ideas , although selling them is a step too far and I understand your annoyance.

I used to sell another of my crafts , but again with anything popular the market becomes saturated by sellers and in the end the products and ideas once out there are just too easy to break down and copy.

unfortunately there is fairly little out there that is completely unique .

Fimofriend · 05/08/2023 07:11

I once saw a very expensive sweater in a designer shop in Copenhagen.

I had an identical sweater. My mum had knitted it based on a pattern from a pattern book she had inherited from her grandmother. As far as I remember it was from around 1910.
So sure paintings I usually accept as original art but knit designs, crochet designs and seeing patterns have to be extremely excentric in order to be truly original.

FireflyJar · 05/08/2023 07:05

ThingsBeingVarious · 05/08/2023 00:46

@TenOhSeven so you admit to stealing other people's cross stitch designs and think it's their own fault for actually showing you their work online. You are exactly the type of person my thread title is about. Disgraceful.

I saw a knitted square on Etsy that the seller had knitted herself and was selling for baby comforters. It was perfect. Easy and quick to knit and so so popular, a really good money spinner. I could do the same, but i guessed she had created the stitch herself as I couldn't find one the same at all. She had also had the idea herself to make and sell them on various platforms. So yes, if I had the stitch and the same yarn (again I couldnt source) I would have made and sold them. But I couldnt do all of this.
So I'm guessing it was something similar to this

Wokeuptired · 05/08/2023 07:03

Years ago I breathed something I called a frogs mouth, it was a fitted coaster that goes onto the base of a wine glass (looked like a frogs mouth when making it)
Anyway it got copied and I have actually seen Debbie shore do a tutorial on it. I used to be pissed off about it but too much time has now passed.

Prescottdanni123 · 05/08/2023 06:50

A lot of crafters write a sentence or two explaining that copying is breaching copyright and what action they will take if they catch anyone doing it.

A needle felted I follow says that we can copy and make her designs but we have to mention that it is her that we got the idea from.

Caprisunny · 05/08/2023 06:03

SpidersAreShitheads · 05/08/2023 04:39

Generally they get away with it by not being caught. There are an absolute ton of copyright and trademark breaches - the market is saturated with them. Just look at Etsy - they seem to turn a blind eye to some sellers while clamping down on others. I have no idea how they work behind the scenes. There seems to be no logic.

OP, you’re not wrong.

I run a really large online craft group and over the last 12-13 years or so I’ve dealt with quite literally hundreds and hundreds of complaints of this nature.

Sometimes the person claiming g a “unique” idea just hasn’t realised that they’re not the first to think of it. Or they’re trying to protect something that is rather generic.

However in the vast majority of cases, it’s lazy copycat sellers who are trying to make a quick buck from someone else’s creativity and talent.

The craft world is creaking under the weight of poor quality sellers - people who don’t care about the originality or quality of what they do. Often they don’t even particularly enjoy crafting. It’s a means for many to make money. There’s nothing wrong with that!! However so many aren’t willing to practice the craft or put the time in to become skilled and genuinely creative. The result is lots of poor quality items which have been copied from other crafters who DID put in the time and effort. Crafting was traditionally all about high quality, handmade, original items - but it’s being ruined by some bad apples.

To all of you who think it’s Ok to copy another crafter and sell the result….. Do you think it would be ok for one big company to set up a business copying another? Of course it wouldn’t! The established business would take the other to court. Small crafters typically don’t have the finances for a big court battle - and don’t have a heavyweight legal team on speed dial. That doesn’t mean they should be considered as fair game for anyone who wants to rip them off.

If someone can guess the original item from your “inspired” make then it’s not “inspired”, it’s a copyright infringement. And if you want to see how seriously companies take that then have a look at Disney. Anything vaguely resembling their items is crushed with the full weight of the billion pound corporation.

Just have a bit of decency, eh? It’s not a lot to bloody ask.

Who said they are copying and selling? Or that, that was ok?

Actually your second to last paragraph is wrong. It’s not necessarily a copyright infringement, just because you can tell where something has been inspired from. How would that even work? Not everyone has seen everyone else’s work. But also there are tolerances. The tolerances are not high enough to make sure everything created is unique or that you can’t see where the inspiration is from.

Quite frankly, most crafters are not doing anything entirely unique. Even if they genuinely believe it is.

Caprisunny · 05/08/2023 05:38

Hmmm I think where you mention Pinterest the argument regarding copying for personal use falls down.

Pinterest is designed as an inspiration social media. It’s the whole point. You can shop through Pinterest. But it’s primarily always been for inspiration. For people then to create themselves.

I think you need to understand that if people see something they may always want to create their own version. I don’t get the problem with personal use. Selling it, yes, I get that. But I haven’t seen anyone here saying they would use a design as their main inspiration and sell it.

I have just started embroidery so using patterns I bought off esty. One is an autumn themed one. If next autumn I am at the stage of creating my own Pinterest will be the place I look for inspiration. Photos, autumn themed interior design etc.

I do also think that many professional crafters really think their items are unique when they aren’t. Obviously can’t comment in this case as we don’t know the item.

WilkinsonM · 05/08/2023 05:13

To all of you who think it’s Ok to copy another crafter and sell the result

has anyone on this thread actually said that??

WilkinsonM · 05/08/2023 05:12

YANBU about people copying to sell, that's awful and wrong. But this attitude -
All PP's admitting to copying work you see online - I can't understand why you don't feel ashamed of stealing someone else's ideas, why don't you try to create something using your own imagination? and calling people 'disgraceful' is nasty and wrong.

I like drawing but I'm not very good at it. I can copy really quite well and I enjoy the process of making the images, but I could never just draw something from life or my imagination. I'm not talented or educated enough. So I sometimes scroll Pinterest and pick a beautiful mandala design or something similar and spend time copying it. I don't show it to anyone or even look at it again let alone publish or sell it, and the reason I do it is because I enjoy it. I don't consider I'm doing anything wrong doing that and it harms the original creator not at all.

SpidersAreShitheads · 05/08/2023 04:39

AnneAnon · 05/08/2023 00:15

to be fair I’ve never understood how so many small businesses get away with selling wall art with song lyrics. How is that not a total copyright breach

Generally they get away with it by not being caught. There are an absolute ton of copyright and trademark breaches - the market is saturated with them. Just look at Etsy - they seem to turn a blind eye to some sellers while clamping down on others. I have no idea how they work behind the scenes. There seems to be no logic.

OP, you’re not wrong.

I run a really large online craft group and over the last 12-13 years or so I’ve dealt with quite literally hundreds and hundreds of complaints of this nature.

Sometimes the person claiming g a “unique” idea just hasn’t realised that they’re not the first to think of it. Or they’re trying to protect something that is rather generic.

However in the vast majority of cases, it’s lazy copycat sellers who are trying to make a quick buck from someone else’s creativity and talent.

The craft world is creaking under the weight of poor quality sellers - people who don’t care about the originality or quality of what they do. Often they don’t even particularly enjoy crafting. It’s a means for many to make money. There’s nothing wrong with that!! However so many aren’t willing to practice the craft or put the time in to become skilled and genuinely creative. The result is lots of poor quality items which have been copied from other crafters who DID put in the time and effort. Crafting was traditionally all about high quality, handmade, original items - but it’s being ruined by some bad apples.

To all of you who think it’s Ok to copy another crafter and sell the result….. Do you think it would be ok for one big company to set up a business copying another? Of course it wouldn’t! The established business would take the other to court. Small crafters typically don’t have the finances for a big court battle - and don’t have a heavyweight legal team on speed dial. That doesn’t mean they should be considered as fair game for anyone who wants to rip them off.

If someone can guess the original item from your “inspired” make then it’s not “inspired”, it’s a copyright infringement. And if you want to see how seriously companies take that then have a look at Disney. Anything vaguely resembling their items is crushed with the full weight of the billion pound corporation.

Just have a bit of decency, eh? It’s not a lot to bloody ask.

Someoneonlyyouknow · 05/08/2023 04:37

You are not unreasonable to be miffed that people pass off their copies as something they have designed and made themselves. You are unreasonable to label everyone who makes something very similar to your work CF and thief.

If you sell online (and even if you don't) pictures of your work will be widely available. I might decide to 'copy' it because I am inspired or because I want to try out the technique or because I can't afford the original. I might not be able to track back to the original to give due credit and you don't want to sell a pattern which I could legitimately copy. I. agree your original artistry and skill is probably not being adequately recognised or rewarded but I don't see how it can be

Trixiefirecracker · 05/08/2023 03:46

Charlize43 · 05/08/2023 02:35

Is this about the knitted courgettes?

I do hope so.

Charlize43 · 05/08/2023 02:35

Is this about the knitted courgettes?

Frabbits · 05/08/2023 01:51

YANBU.

People who wholesale rip off other people's work are cheeky fuckers. Part of being an artist is being original.

Magneta · 05/08/2023 01:26

To my mind these are two massively different things. Reproducing your designs to make money is a clear, obvious "no".

People copying it for their own pleasure, without having access to pattern/instructions, and making a one off for themselves is completely different. I would have thought that falls under the Fair Use box in the infographic. Otherwise anyone who's ever made their child's birthday cake by copying a picture they found on the internet is committing some heinous crime.

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 05/08/2023 01:19

Anotherparkingthread · 05/08/2023 01:17

I think that's a bit different because it's for personal use. If they were making them to sell then the owner of the brand could force them to stop, but if you're just making a scarf for yourself there's not much they can do about it.

Op we really need to know what it is before we can pass judgement. I am also in the camp that your idea is probably also derivative of others works and so isn't as original as you think but I'm happy to be proven wrong.

Would also depend on the scarf as the Weasley esque scarfs are just normal scrappy scarves

Byllis · 05/08/2023 01:18

I’m surprised the vote is currently a small majority saying the OP is unreasonable. Commercial considerations aside, it’s just dishonest; taking credit for someone else’s talent and labour.

Based on the comments, I’d say the voting is explained by a mixture of simply not understanding the subject (thinking anyone can copy anything, being confused about intellectual property, believing all art and craft is just a copy of something else) and undervaluing creativity. We live in a society that doesn’t value creativity and originality, though, so I guess it’s to be expected.

Anotherparkingthread · 05/08/2023 01:17

Changingmynameyetagain · 05/08/2023 01:09

I’m a knitter and crocheter, loads of patterns are just copies of other designs.
If you look at ravelry there are hundreds of patterns for Harry Potter jumpers, Dr who scarves and superhero’s stuff. They are literally direct copies of things made for films and TV, no one says anything about that.

I think that's a bit different because it's for personal use. If they were making them to sell then the owner of the brand could force them to stop, but if you're just making a scarf for yourself there's not much they can do about it.

Op we really need to know what it is before we can pass judgement. I am also in the camp that your idea is probably also derivative of others works and so isn't as original as you think but I'm happy to be proven wrong.

narrichi · 05/08/2023 01:16

It really depends on how unique the item is and if it's truly unlike anything that's been done before. If it's clothing or crochet then a lot of designs are considered too generic to be protected by copyright. Hence why fast fashion brands can get away with blatantly copying Balmain dresses etc. However if your product is something truly unique then I understand your frustration.

I have noticed a huge amount of material on Etsy that blatantly violates trademarks e.g. homemade Disney and Nintendo toys. Both companies are notorious litigious so I don't know how Etsy get away with it.

Changingmynameyetagain · 05/08/2023 01:09

I’m a knitter and crocheter, loads of patterns are just copies of other designs.
If you look at ravelry there are hundreds of patterns for Harry Potter jumpers, Dr who scarves and superhero’s stuff. They are literally direct copies of things made for films and TV, no one says anything about that.

LightDrizzle · 05/08/2023 00:51

Yes you can copy art and crafts as a personal exercise to improve, you just can’t sell, publish or pass it off as your own work.

I’m surprised the vote is currently a small majority saying the OP is unreasonable. Commercial considerations aside, it’s just dishonest; taking credit for someone else’s talent and labour.

For most arts, craft, design and scholarship it’s not the physical ability to create the end product that has the value, it’s the idea, composition and design. I can write and type, that doesn’t mean it’s okay for me to type out an Emily Dickinson poem and share it on Facebook as my own work. I’m not as gifted as Emily Dickinson because I can write out her poem. That’s an extreme example but a real life one is that I’m currently copying Cezanne, Gauguin and other similar artists works in oils to help me be more expressionistic and hopefully learn from how they apply paint and colour and simplify and suggest form and light. I also paint from life. Now I’ve painted a belting Gauguin still life, even if I say so myself, so much more effective and energetic than my paintings from life are, and that’s because I’m not as fucking good as Gauguin! When I’m not slavishly copying his marks, composition and colours, I’m back to being an unremarkable hobbyist.

Can’t people see why it would be wrong for me to post photos of these copies without acknowledgement of them being copies? Let alone selling them.

At least Cezanne and Gauguin are dead and wouldn’t be missing out on income as the people currently creating things to sell do. Imagine the frustration of coming up with something really effective and getting the affirmation and income from reviews and sales only to see 3 other sellers undercutting you within weeks.

Yes you can’t stop someone cross-stitching a crinoline lady because you’ve done one, but you CAN stop them producing identical patterns or copies and passing them off as their own work or selling them without permission.

FelicityBeedle · 05/08/2023 00:48

Fair enough for people selling their copies, but to get the hump with people
Copying from photos for their own personal use is insane. That’s just human nature, when I see a dress in a shop and sew a copy from memory that’s not cheating, my embroidery of Van Gogh’z sunflowers isn’t immoral. I do admit it’s a bit crass to message you with photos of the copy

ThingsBeingVarious · 05/08/2023 00:46

@TenOhSeven so you admit to stealing other people's cross stitch designs and think it's their own fault for actually showing you their work online. You are exactly the type of person my thread title is about. Disgraceful.

OP posts:
Throwingpots · 05/08/2023 00:37

I totally understand your frustration op. I’m a painter, have my work at a few galleries. I sell the painting but still own the copyright, which means legally no one can copy the art in any way and sell it on. That’s actually against copyright law. So totally reasonable for someone in your position to expect the same rights. Why should someone else profit from your hard work and creativity, and quite possibly steal your customers. This is way more than just being inspired by someone’s work.