Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Crafters, if you copy someone's design that you've seen online you're not just a CF, you're a thief.

267 replies

ThingsBeingVarious · 04/08/2023 22:33

I have a small, successful craft business and mostly sell online, which means there are loads of photographs of my work for anyone to see. Yet again I've just been made aware of someone copying my original design and selling the product - she probably thinks it's okay because she's raising money for her local charity. And sometimes my 'followers' and customers will send me a photo of the copy they've made saying I've 'inspired them'.

I know people often say imitation is the sincerest form of flattery but it really fucks me off. People should think up their own designs, not scroll through Pinterest or Etsy or wherever looking for ideas to nick. Or if they haven't got any original ideas they can BUY patterns from other crafter's.

OP posts:
GenieGenealogy · 05/08/2023 08:18

I think you're conflating two issues. I am a knitter. If I see an idea online, and work out how to create the same sort of pattern and knit it for myself, for my own use, that's fine. It's not fine to sell the pattern though. That scenario is the same as me seeing some fancy type of cake in Waitrose, decorated in a particular way, and baking my own version at home.

Eddielizzard · 05/08/2023 08:17

I agree it's not ok.

Fashion houses copy designs too, stitch for stitch. You'd think given their enormous creative talent they would try and come up with something original.

Here's Tom Ford ripping off a Romanian blouse.

Instagram

https://www.instagram.com/p/CkO-CpBs3Gq/?igshid=MzRlODBiNWFlZA==

Nemesias · 05/08/2023 08:15

LizzieSiddal · 05/08/2023 08:12

Respect to the 40% who don't think it's right to copy another person's work without permission, whether to sell, gift or keep for yourself. For the other 60% here's how I see it...

It’s bonkers that you think people aren’t allowed to copy your work for their own personal use. 😂

Yeah I voted Yanbu but actually I don’t think there’s an issue with someone copying it because they want one for themselves. Even giving one as a gift. Selling is a different kettle of fish.

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 05/08/2023 08:15

ThingsBeingVarious · 05/08/2023 07:48

Respect to the 40% who don't think it's right to copy another person's work without permission, whether to sell, gift or keep for yourself. For the other 60% here's how I see it...

Say I want to make a kangaroo (I've never made a kangaroo!). I don't scroll through Pinterest looking for the most appealing kangaroo then just try to copy that. I would look at images of real kangaroos, notice their shape, expressions, colours, the way they stand and move, make a few sketches and work out what position and size would work best in the medium I use. Then I'd make some templates and mock up a kangaroo, seeing if my idea worked, probably realise the tail was too thin so it fell down, or the ears made it look like a rabbit. So I'd keep tweaking until it looked right, then choose the perfect material and make a prototype, which I'd then embellish in the way that is noticeably my style. Then I'd spend a few hours finding the perfect place for a photoshoot of the kangaroo, set up a scene, then edit the photos. I'd then make another kangaroo, timing how long it took so I could price it above minimum wage for me but affordable for my customers. Then I put it online to sell.

Someone will then pin my photo to their board or share it somewhere online. Despite there being (I expect) hundreds of kangaroo patterns for sale and plenty of free kangaroo tutorials, 60% would rather not spend a few quid on a pattern or make the effort to think creatively themselves, instead they somehow feel entitled to piggyback on all the time and effort I've put in coming up with this particular kangaroo.

That IS being a CF and it is stealing someone else's idea. Makes me think of Burglar Bill - 'that's a nice kangaroo, I'll have that'.

But yeah I know there's FA I can do about it. Some people are shitty. I am grateful that my work sells well and I love what I do, so that's what I need to concentrate on. But it would be nice if people thought about what and who was behind the images they're copying.

You might do that but it doesn’t actually make you a better person than someone who would look at how other people have made kangaroos, see what their solutions are to the problems of kangaroo construction, and come up with the best kangaroo they can building on both their own kangaroo research and the kangaroos others have made.

If someone has only looked at one other person’s kangaroo and done a straight copy that’s not so creative, but it’s a continuum between that and looking at lots.

PaperDoves · 05/08/2023 08:14

Of course no one should be selling copies of another artist's work, but I don't understand why you're getting the hump with your fans who try to mimic your designs for their own personal use. They even send you photos thinking you'll say "oh, that looks great!" and instead they get a missive about how they're committing a moral crime? That's really mean spirited. There's nothing wrong with trying to reproduce something as long as you're not selling it and not passing it off as your own design. (And that's why copyright law only extends to public displays and selling, not personal use.)

LizzieSiddal · 05/08/2023 08:12

Respect to the 40% who don't think it's right to copy another person's work without permission, whether to sell, gift or keep for yourself. For the other 60% here's how I see it...

It’s bonkers that you think people aren’t allowed to copy your work for their own personal use. 😂

Xcv · 05/08/2023 08:10

I can’t stop people from copying my business as such (I didn’t invent it) but I now have quite a few Instagram followers and get lots of similar businesses following me. I remember when I first started up I followed someone else’s business and they blocked me. I found it so petty at the time but they were obviously feeling threatened so I can understand it now but I haven’t blocked anyone who’s done the same. Last week I had one of these businesses message me looking for tips on growing their business. I clicked on them and they’re literally doing the exact same thing I do. I couldn’t understand why they’d think it was okay to ask or why I would possibly reply. They’d be a direct competitor looking for ways to grow their sales (aka steal my sales when I’m just trying to pay my bills) 😵‍💫

Caprisunny · 05/08/2023 08:07

ThingsBeingVarious · 05/08/2023 07:48

Respect to the 40% who don't think it's right to copy another person's work without permission, whether to sell, gift or keep for yourself. For the other 60% here's how I see it...

Say I want to make a kangaroo (I've never made a kangaroo!). I don't scroll through Pinterest looking for the most appealing kangaroo then just try to copy that. I would look at images of real kangaroos, notice their shape, expressions, colours, the way they stand and move, make a few sketches and work out what position and size would work best in the medium I use. Then I'd make some templates and mock up a kangaroo, seeing if my idea worked, probably realise the tail was too thin so it fell down, or the ears made it look like a rabbit. So I'd keep tweaking until it looked right, then choose the perfect material and make a prototype, which I'd then embellish in the way that is noticeably my style. Then I'd spend a few hours finding the perfect place for a photoshoot of the kangaroo, set up a scene, then edit the photos. I'd then make another kangaroo, timing how long it took so I could price it above minimum wage for me but affordable for my customers. Then I put it online to sell.

Someone will then pin my photo to their board or share it somewhere online. Despite there being (I expect) hundreds of kangaroo patterns for sale and plenty of free kangaroo tutorials, 60% would rather not spend a few quid on a pattern or make the effort to think creatively themselves, instead they somehow feel entitled to piggyback on all the time and effort I've put in coming up with this particular kangaroo.

That IS being a CF and it is stealing someone else's idea. Makes me think of Burglar Bill - 'that's a nice kangaroo, I'll have that'.

But yeah I know there's FA I can do about it. Some people are shitty. I am grateful that my work sells well and I love what I do, so that's what I need to concentrate on. But it would be nice if people thought about what and who was behind the images they're copying.

But you do to all that effort because YOU want to sell it. Of course anyone wanting to create and sell something should be doing it themselves. No one said it was ok to copy something exactly and then sell it.

Saying someone can’t use your photos as inspiration when you do exactly that, is bizarre.

How did you learn your technique originally? You, probably, started crafting and the technique you use has come from your own experiences and things you have learned. You didn’t learn crafting without input from anyone else. So you are using other peoples work, as inspiration that you have learned to come up with your unique idea. You didn’t wake up one morning with no background in crafting with this completely unique idea.

If you have no pictures of the pattern online, people can’t copy it exactly can they? Because you will have started with a basic one and tweaked it to something (you believe) is unique. They are unlikely to get first try. If they see your kangaroo online, try one , don’t like it, try another, don’t like it and so on. They aren’t copying your pattern. They have taken inspiration and creating their own. And their final pattern is likely to be different if yours is so unique. If they naturally come to the exact same pattern as you, then yours was unlikely unique at all. It was just likely to involve a mix common techniques all crafters use when tweaking something.

Deciding that if someone wants to make something , for their own use, similar to something they have seen on Pinterest but not gone through all the same steps to tweak and get right, makes them a CF. Makes no sense.

It’s no different to you using photos of kangaroos other people own as your inspiration. You do realise someone owns those photos?

ConfusedBear · 05/08/2023 08:06

I'm on the fence with this, copying your design and then telling you that's what they've done is out of order, even if it is for charity. Certainly the person who copied your idea to sell themselves shouldn't.

On the other hand it is difficult to be completely unique -on trend colours, animals and crafts can mean people independently come up with similar ideas so it's hard to say someone has copied an idea unless they've admitted it.

Could you share one of your simplest designs (which wouldn't show someone how to do all the techniques you use) as one that followers have permission to make and sell for charity, provided that they share where the pattern is from and where they could buy other items?

Trixiefirecracker · 05/08/2023 08:04

I know a bit about this. Unfortunately they only need to slightly change the design/materials/colour and then there’s not much you can do. It’s incredibly hard to copyright an artistic design and once it’s out there it’s in the public domain and open to all sorts of use and abuse. I have posted pieces where people have casually asked ‘how I made it’ or even just blatantly said they are going to copy it, which I always say is fine but not for resale. I know they will ignore it though.

CrochetBug · 05/08/2023 08:04

ThingsBeingVarious · 05/08/2023 07:48

Respect to the 40% who don't think it's right to copy another person's work without permission, whether to sell, gift or keep for yourself. For the other 60% here's how I see it...

Say I want to make a kangaroo (I've never made a kangaroo!). I don't scroll through Pinterest looking for the most appealing kangaroo then just try to copy that. I would look at images of real kangaroos, notice their shape, expressions, colours, the way they stand and move, make a few sketches and work out what position and size would work best in the medium I use. Then I'd make some templates and mock up a kangaroo, seeing if my idea worked, probably realise the tail was too thin so it fell down, or the ears made it look like a rabbit. So I'd keep tweaking until it looked right, then choose the perfect material and make a prototype, which I'd then embellish in the way that is noticeably my style. Then I'd spend a few hours finding the perfect place for a photoshoot of the kangaroo, set up a scene, then edit the photos. I'd then make another kangaroo, timing how long it took so I could price it above minimum wage for me but affordable for my customers. Then I put it online to sell.

Someone will then pin my photo to their board or share it somewhere online. Despite there being (I expect) hundreds of kangaroo patterns for sale and plenty of free kangaroo tutorials, 60% would rather not spend a few quid on a pattern or make the effort to think creatively themselves, instead they somehow feel entitled to piggyback on all the time and effort I've put in coming up with this particular kangaroo.

That IS being a CF and it is stealing someone else's idea. Makes me think of Burglar Bill - 'that's a nice kangaroo, I'll have that'.

But yeah I know there's FA I can do about it. Some people are shitty. I am grateful that my work sells well and I love what I do, so that's what I need to concentrate on. But it would be nice if people thought about what and who was behind the images they're copying.

But, if someone else had already made a kangaroo in whatever medium it is that you use, how would you prove that you hadn't seen it and based your kangaroo on it? I mean sure you'd have you sketches etc, but how would you prove that their kangaroo hadn't given you the idea?

A couple of years ago I did a pattern test for someone. Then started a jumper using the same stitch because I loved it. They didn't invent the stitch, and I'd previously wanted to make something with it but didn't know what. About half way through the jumper I thought "ahhh! Never seen this stitch done with 2 colours, I wonder what that would look like?" ( not saying it hasn't been done. But I hadn't seen it). Before I had a chance to try, the original designer I'd tested for released a new pattern. A jumper, similar in style and shape to mine. Using that stitch IN 2 COLOURS.
So of course if I decide to do it now it will look like I copied. Even though we had the same idea independently of eachother.

In all of that no one copied anyone, yet we ended up 'designing' very similar things.

Marwoodsbigbreak · 05/08/2023 08:01

To be honest OP I suspect most people will think it’s absolutely fine to copy something for their own craft project that’s for their own family use.

Absolutely NOT OK to copy and sell. Morally the two feel very different. I haven’t a clue about legality.

EmmaPaella · 05/08/2023 08:00

I agree OP but it seems to be an unspoken rule you expect nice ordinary people who are just trying things out to somehow know. I’d make this clearer on your posts. Because Pinterest is, as a pp said, a site for inspiration.

Spirallingdownwards · 05/08/2023 08:00

They may be breaching your intellectual property rights but they aren't a thief within the definition of the law.

Lapflop · 05/08/2023 07:59

YANBU if its truly unique, unfortunately not a lot you can do about it, even huge corporations like Disney struggle to get anywhere with people ripping off their stuff to sell (they try though and do get a lot of accounts removed from Etsy etc)- some people are just shitty not that it makes it right.

I did go to a craft fayre a few weeks ago though and someone was selling miniature trees made out of twisted metal. I said these are beautiful, I have one similar to this at home and it always gets a lot of comments! She then demanded (I say this as angrily asked rather than just asked) to know where I'd got it from and when as she was going to take action as someone had obviously copied her work; I inherited it from my nan who (sadly) died many years ago- she said oh can't be like mine then as mine are the only ones but I wasn't even born then. Made me chuckle.

Mumsgirls · 05/08/2023 07:58

In the 1980’s my Mum used to copy the kids knitted jumpers from marks, they were fantastic as her knitting was superb. Would not have done it to a small business though

dressedforcomfort · 05/08/2023 07:52

You can't stop someone copying your design for their own personal use - isn't that pretty much the point of Pinterest, to find inspiration for stuff? If you are bothered by this then YABU

Copying your stuff for resale is shitty though. I can see why that would upset you.

FelineGood76 · 05/08/2023 07:51

As a crafter and attendee of craft fairs selling various things from crochet, jewellery, fabric items, pinboards, handbags, and cushions, I can attest that the craft world is rife with people taking "inspiration " from each other. I would literally be at a craft fair, attend a couple of weeks later, and see a copy of something I had made. One time a woman even stood at my stall and tried to deconstruct an item I had made to see how it was put together, she was another stall holder so I knew it wasn't just a customer interested in the piece. But on the flip side I was recently accused of stealing an idea for a crochet blanket which was a simple granny square with an identifiable summer flower in the middle of each square. The flower only comes in one colour, it really was a very simple design that i in fact followed from an online tutorial, but when I posted a picture of the finished blanket in my Facebook craft group, this woman outright accused me of seeing her design! Eh, no love, it's from a YouTube tutorial. And you don't own the rights to either granny squares or the image of this flower.
My point is that you will never stop people copying your stuff and as a crafter, to a large extent, you do have to accept this unless your item is genuinely a one of a kind thing that has never existed before, is copyrighted, or they are literally putting your branding on it.
I am sure you yourself have probably been influenced by things you have seen online and by other crafters?

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 05/08/2023 07:49

Yabvu to be pissed off with people for copying, crediting you and not attempting to make any money out of it. People who steal your ideas to sell are a different matter and are breaking the law, and those who copy and revel in the admiration without crediting you are behaving shabbily even if not breaking the law.

Creativity is a mixture of the idea and the execution. People copy in order to work on their execution, a process which was formalised in art school training for centuries. However copying a well conceived work can also help you understand the design and improve your own ideas.

Perhaps you learned your craft without ever looking at anybody else’s work but it seems unlikely.

ThingsBeingVarious · 05/08/2023 07:48

Respect to the 40% who don't think it's right to copy another person's work without permission, whether to sell, gift or keep for yourself. For the other 60% here's how I see it...

Say I want to make a kangaroo (I've never made a kangaroo!). I don't scroll through Pinterest looking for the most appealing kangaroo then just try to copy that. I would look at images of real kangaroos, notice their shape, expressions, colours, the way they stand and move, make a few sketches and work out what position and size would work best in the medium I use. Then I'd make some templates and mock up a kangaroo, seeing if my idea worked, probably realise the tail was too thin so it fell down, or the ears made it look like a rabbit. So I'd keep tweaking until it looked right, then choose the perfect material and make a prototype, which I'd then embellish in the way that is noticeably my style. Then I'd spend a few hours finding the perfect place for a photoshoot of the kangaroo, set up a scene, then edit the photos. I'd then make another kangaroo, timing how long it took so I could price it above minimum wage for me but affordable for my customers. Then I put it online to sell.

Someone will then pin my photo to their board or share it somewhere online. Despite there being (I expect) hundreds of kangaroo patterns for sale and plenty of free kangaroo tutorials, 60% would rather not spend a few quid on a pattern or make the effort to think creatively themselves, instead they somehow feel entitled to piggyback on all the time and effort I've put in coming up with this particular kangaroo.

That IS being a CF and it is stealing someone else's idea. Makes me think of Burglar Bill - 'that's a nice kangaroo, I'll have that'.

But yeah I know there's FA I can do about it. Some people are shitty. I am grateful that my work sells well and I love what I do, so that's what I need to concentrate on. But it would be nice if people thought about what and who was behind the images they're copying.

OP posts:
Copasetic · 05/08/2023 07:46

They can't be a thief if what they are doing isn't theft and it definitely doesn't meet the definition of theft (the dishonest appropriation of property belonging to another with the intention to permanently deprive the other of it) because there is no property being stollen.

I don't know too much about intellectual property, trademarks etc, but I do know that they cannot breach something that isn't in place.

greenteaandmarshmallows · 05/08/2023 07:44

It's a bit hard to judge without knowing exactly how unique the item is tbh.

I think copying and reselling is a big no. And if I was inspired and made my own for personal use I'm not sure why I'd then send you a copy to rub it in that I didn't buy yours!!

user1477391263 · 05/08/2023 07:38

Byllis · 05/08/2023 01:18

I’m surprised the vote is currently a small majority saying the OP is unreasonable. Commercial considerations aside, it’s just dishonest; taking credit for someone else’s talent and labour.

Based on the comments, I’d say the voting is explained by a mixture of simply not understanding the subject (thinking anyone can copy anything, being confused about intellectual property, believing all art and craft is just a copy of something else) and undervaluing creativity. We live in a society that doesn’t value creativity and originality, though, so I guess it’s to be expected.

I think people are saying YABU in part because it's really hard to know whether the OP is justified or not unless we can see the items in question. I've seen some blatently unfair cases of what the OP is talking about. I've also seen cases of crafters getting the hump because someone "copied" a design that is utterly generic and has been done by a million people already. I think we need to see the actual items here.

Dombasle · 05/08/2023 07:31

On the other hand I see people selling crochet patterns that are 'their' design which is absolute rubbish as I've seen the same pattern or stitch from 1974.

AllPlayedOut · 05/08/2023 07:28

Years ago I breathed something I called a frogs mouth, it was a fitted coaster that goes onto the base of a wine glass (looked like a frogs mouth when making it)
Anyway it got copied and I have actually seen Debbie shore do a tutorial on it. I used to be pissed off about it but too much time has now passed.

Surely similar coasters have been around for decades?

livereloved.co.uk/products/vintage-retro-linen-embroidered-glass-mats-coasters-with-matching-small-napkins-rooster-cockerel These are from 1971

And these seem to be from the '50s www.pinterest.co.uk/pin/vintage-wine-glass-coaster-6-linen-slip-on-coasters-pastel--320459329727181551/