Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Crafters, if you copy someone's design that you've seen online you're not just a CF, you're a thief.

267 replies

ThingsBeingVarious · 04/08/2023 22:33

I have a small, successful craft business and mostly sell online, which means there are loads of photographs of my work for anyone to see. Yet again I've just been made aware of someone copying my original design and selling the product - she probably thinks it's okay because she's raising money for her local charity. And sometimes my 'followers' and customers will send me a photo of the copy they've made saying I've 'inspired them'.

I know people often say imitation is the sincerest form of flattery but it really fucks me off. People should think up their own designs, not scroll through Pinterest or Etsy or wherever looking for ideas to nick. Or if they haven't got any original ideas they can BUY patterns from other crafter's.

OP posts:
NorthernGirlie · 05/08/2023 09:46

@Caprisunny it was the lack of please / thanks / general Crafty niceties that annoyed me! To be fair I always tagged the pattern writer in the posts 🤩

killim · 05/08/2023 09:45

I get it OP. I'm a silversmith. I get inspired by many things, including other jewellery designers at times. I see a technique they use and want to try it, I see a certain stone in a piece and I want to make something with that stone, or that shape etc. I make something, in my own style. Most of the time it creates something completely different. That's inspiration. Out right copying a design isn't the same thing. I've been copied, design for design, then they have taken very similar photos, and used a very similar logo to mine or a similar brand name. Marketed themselves exactly the same. This is more than being 'inspired' by me. It's disheartening. I get many messages asking me where I get such and such a tool from or how do you do such and such, where is this and that from. Most of the time they are curious to learn a new skill. But others think they can profit off your hard work without taking the time to properly learn something that took me years and ££ to learn. I've stopped replying to these messages now as a lot of the time it is people just wanting to copy. And some of them, quite a lot of them actually, aren't very polite in how they ask. I forward everyone on to a jewellery school where they can learn the craft. It's a shame because I used to enjoy sharing this knowledge with other crafters.

Caprisunny · 05/08/2023 09:43

NorthernGirlie · 05/08/2023 09:39

I think I fluffed my response

What I meant was that I fully understood why op was mad, that even though I bought a pattern and didn't design it I was still peeved that others were rude about demanding information from me so it must be way way more frustrating when the idea is yours!

Genuinely wasn't trying to be an arse to the op!

Sorry, I don’t think you were being an arse to the Op.

I was pointing out it wasn’t the same. Yours wasn’t an original design. So it’s just simply not the same.

If op was selling designs for other people to use in their business I am sure they would appreciate you pointing people in their direction.

Some people won’t purchase your item as they prefer to make their own. For those people, I don’t get why you got annoyed and didn’t just point them where to go. Since they are only doing what you did.

ThingsBeingVarious · 05/08/2023 09:39

@Inkpotlover perfect!

@ScarlettSunset ❤️

@PostOpOp thank you for describing so well what I'm trying to say. And I suppose, tbh, I'm only with myself here up to a point too. I do get why people try and copy other people's work as their own hobby and without permission. Creativity isn't taught in schools and most people aren't confident to try designing stuff themselves. But I'd like people to realise it isn't nice for the original maker, it feels disrespectful that someone is taking something of yours (however intangible, such as an idea, or a style) when if they really want the item they could buy it from me, or buy a kit or pattern or watch a tutorial by an artist who has decided to share their method.

OP posts:
NorthernGirlie · 05/08/2023 09:39

Caprisunny · 05/08/2023 09:30

Right ok. You happened to buy from a Designer that sells for people to make and sell. But you didn’t say that.

If that’s true, you don’t understand the Op.

The op isn’t selling her designs for other people to use for profit. So it an entirely different situation.

You didn’t create something unique from a scratch. You changed the colours.

I think I fluffed my response

What I meant was that I fully understood why op was mad, that even though I bought a pattern and didn't design it I was still peeved that others were rude about demanding information from me so it must be way way more frustrating when the idea is yours!

Genuinely wasn't trying to be an arse to the op!

electriclight · 05/08/2023 09:36

I do think it's cf if it's copied in a professional capacity, to sell. But very few successful products aren't open to copying so it's to be expected and the originators responsibility to protect themselves imo.

electriclight · 05/08/2023 09:33

If I see something that I know I could easily recreate myself then I'm going to do that and not feel any guilt whatsoever, whether that's an outfit, a cake or a painting.

Other customers might not have the skills, time or materials to recreate it and be willing to pay you for it but that doesn't mean everyone must.

If it's truly unique, get it patented or subject to copyright. If it doesn't meet the threshold for that then it isn't truly unique.

Even on dragons den one of the first comments is usually 'anyone could copy this so I'm out.'

bellac11 · 05/08/2023 09:33

LightDrizzle · 05/08/2023 09:26

No. That wouldn’t be wrong.

If you copied the Mona Lisa and posted your effort somewhere as your own original work “Enigma” as in “A lady in renaissance style”, that would be wrong.

Obviously copying the Mona Lisa isn’t a good or fair example because it’s so famous and obvious. People would comment that it was a great copy of the Mona Lisa so it’s not passing off. However in your analogy, if people didn’t know the Mona Lisa and were commenting about the cleverness and power of the direct gaze, hint of a smile and focus on face rather not dress in an otherwise classically composed and painted Renaissance style portrait, - and you didn’t acknowledge it was actually a copy of the work of another artist, then that would be wrong. You would be accepting the credit due to another artist. You might be due the credit due to a good copyist, a skilful thing, but not the credit for the creative skill which is the greater part.

Well I just used that as an example as its the first thing that came into my head

Ok, just looking around the room then, I have a number of cushions with pictures or designs on them

What if I painted a picture of them for myself, OP seems to feel that would be infringement, either morally or legally

What if I painted pictures inspired by the colours and shapes on them, and sold them, is that infringement, the cushion covers are cheap old things from Amazon, tons of different manufacturers.

Except for the Ikea ones, which appear to be based on traditional folk patterns (at a guess)

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 05/08/2023 09:31

Caprisunny · 05/08/2023 09:30

Right ok. You happened to buy from a Designer that sells for people to make and sell. But you didn’t say that.

If that’s true, you don’t understand the Op.

The op isn’t selling her designs for other people to use for profit. So it an entirely different situation.

You didn’t create something unique from a scratch. You changed the colours.

This. Then you moan that people are wanting to copy you on a design that isn’t even yours originally

Caprisunny · 05/08/2023 09:30

NorthernGirlie · 05/08/2023 09:25

I'm.not sure I understand your reply? I bought a pattern from.a designer who is happy for people to make and sell items (but not resell the pattern obvs)

Right ok. You happened to buy from a Designer that sells for people to make and sell. But you didn’t say that.

If that’s true, you don’t understand the Op.

The op isn’t selling her designs for other people to use for profit. So it an entirely different situation.

You didn’t create something unique from a scratch. You changed the colours.

Inkpotlover · 05/08/2023 09:29

NorthernGirlie · 05/08/2023 09:25

I'm.not sure I understand your reply? I bought a pattern from.a designer who is happy for people to make and sell items (but not resell the pattern obvs)

Technically you didn't do anything wrong - the designer was selling the pattern specifically for people to copy, unlike OP who hasn't gone down that route. However, you might be on dodgy ground tweaking it to sell for your own commercial gain but it sounds like the designer doesn't mind that.

Inkpotlover · 05/08/2023 09:27

LightDrizzle · 05/08/2023 09:26

No. That wouldn’t be wrong.

If you copied the Mona Lisa and posted your effort somewhere as your own original work “Enigma” as in “A lady in renaissance style”, that would be wrong.

Obviously copying the Mona Lisa isn’t a good or fair example because it’s so famous and obvious. People would comment that it was a great copy of the Mona Lisa so it’s not passing off. However in your analogy, if people didn’t know the Mona Lisa and were commenting about the cleverness and power of the direct gaze, hint of a smile and focus on face rather not dress in an otherwise classically composed and painted Renaissance style portrait, - and you didn’t acknowledge it was actually a copy of the work of another artist, then that would be wrong. You would be accepting the credit due to another artist. You might be due the credit due to a good copyist, a skilful thing, but not the credit for the creative skill which is the greater part.

The Mona Lisa is also a bad example because copyright expires 70 years after the creator's death!

LightDrizzle · 05/08/2023 09:26

bellac11 · 05/08/2023 08:34

So if I was a painter for pleasure and decided to paint myself the mona lisa, that would be wrong?

No. That wouldn’t be wrong.

If you copied the Mona Lisa and posted your effort somewhere as your own original work “Enigma” as in “A lady in renaissance style”, that would be wrong.

Obviously copying the Mona Lisa isn’t a good or fair example because it’s so famous and obvious. People would comment that it was a great copy of the Mona Lisa so it’s not passing off. However in your analogy, if people didn’t know the Mona Lisa and were commenting about the cleverness and power of the direct gaze, hint of a smile and focus on face rather not dress in an otherwise classically composed and painted Renaissance style portrait, - and you didn’t acknowledge it was actually a copy of the work of another artist, then that would be wrong. You would be accepting the credit due to another artist. You might be due the credit due to a good copyist, a skilful thing, but not the credit for the creative skill which is the greater part.

NorthernGirlie · 05/08/2023 09:25

Caprisunny · 05/08/2023 09:22

That’s exactly what the Op is moaning about.

you bought someone else pattern and tweaked it. No one copying the Ops work will have it exactly the same. They will have all been tweaked.

You tweaked someone else’s design and then sold it. And we’re annoyed others wanted the design? Which was publicly available.

I'm.not sure I understand your reply? I bought a pattern from.a designer who is happy for people to make and sell items (but not resell the pattern obvs)

takealettermsjones · 05/08/2023 09:24

Eh, if you can't copy a design/character for personal use then a thousand parents will be in trouble come World Book Day.

bellac11 · 05/08/2023 09:24

The other thing is, and people dont like to be reminded of this, humans are not that unique to each other

Of course each human is unique in that there is only one of you/me, but the way we think and live is not really that unique and therefore the things we create are not likely to be either

I love food and cooking, Ive 'invented' many a dish that later I find out is a cultural dish of many centuries old. Yet I knew nothing about it, didnt even know of the culture until I found out about it, people had got there before me.

Inkpotlover · 05/08/2023 09:23

ThingsBeingVarious · 05/08/2023 08:48

@bellac11 "Don't you think its likely that someone is seeing your work and thinking to themselves how cheeky it is that you copied them?"

No, I genuinely don't think that's the case - I've been making my stuff for a few years now, lots of online sales and occasional fairs, and I've never had anybody even say they 'remind them' of another person's work. I get lots of comments about how original my work is and people asking how I come up with my ideas. I'm not surprised people are sceptical that my work is genuinely all my own ideas because lots of art and craft is generic (and clearly from the responses here the majority do copy!).

@ConfusedBear I have done a couple of free tutorials of my simpler designs, mostly as a way to engage followers and that's worked well. I used to naively think people would understand the stuff I didn't make tutorials/sell patterns for was not to be copied. I think I will write something about this on my sales platforms.

@Inkpotlover I love the idea of sending the copiers an invoice! I really don't enjoy the awkwardness when I message telling people not to copy my original designs, although I have, so far, received only nice apologies and promises to stop.

Sympathy to anyone else who also feels their work gets ripped off. It's definitely a losing battle going by the responses here 😢

A straightforward response and invoice would take away the awkwardness.

"Dear rip-off merchant

I am flattered you found my design so inspiring that you have chosen to copy it. However, it is my intellectual property that I earn a living from and cannot be copied without permission. I have therefore attached my invoice for use of my design. The payment terms are 30 days.

Kind regards

Things"

Caprisunny · 05/08/2023 09:22

NorthernGirlie · 05/08/2023 09:19

I crochet and do understand op

I've never sold to make money particularly but started a Facebook page with a fellow crocheter who does.

We bought a pattern for a star blanket, I made a rainbow one for a friend's 'rainbow baby' and our page went wild with orders

It took me ages to get the perfect colours and I tweaked the pattern a little. I had literally dozens of messages asking for the pattern and colour pallette.

Some were from people who hobby make and were really polite. I was happy to share with them

Others just said "send me the pattern" or "pattern and colours?" And when I clicked their profile they were sellers

Nah!

That’s exactly what the Op is moaning about.

you bought someone else pattern and tweaked it. No one copying the Ops work will have it exactly the same. They will have all been tweaked.

You tweaked someone else’s design and then sold it. And we’re annoyed others wanted the design? Which was publicly available.

NorthernGirlie · 05/08/2023 09:19

I crochet and do understand op

I've never sold to make money particularly but started a Facebook page with a fellow crocheter who does.

We bought a pattern for a star blanket, I made a rainbow one for a friend's 'rainbow baby' and our page went wild with orders

It took me ages to get the perfect colours and I tweaked the pattern a little. I had literally dozens of messages asking for the pattern and colour pallette.

Some were from people who hobby make and were really polite. I was happy to share with them

Others just said "send me the pattern" or "pattern and colours?" And when I clicked their profile they were sellers

Nah!

PostOpOp · 05/08/2023 09:12

The thing is that so many people haven't grown up learning and being given the opportunity to be creative that they genuinely don't understand what it is to design something from scratch. OP has outlined the process, but people think that, for example, replicating something they've found on Pinterest is creative. It's not. It can be clever and skilled, both of which are positive in themselves, but it's not creative.

If you copy a crocheted cat you find on Etsy or Pinterest to figure out how to do it, that's not creative. When you've figured out the technique and then make crocheted penguins from that technique, that's creative.

OP I'm with you to a point. We all copy as a form of learning. It can even be necessary. But in that process we usually say, "I'm copying X" or in some way let people know we're not the designer and/or credit them and we're trying something out. The moment that someone copies and then claims the design as their own, then to me they're stealing.

And yes, as time goes on there are less original ideas. That's the same in academia, which is similar in the area of studying the work of those who've gone before you to hone your art. We still reference every time we use someone's idea though and the academic community expects that, in part because they value their own work. Many people craft as a hobby and see other art-craft work as a bit like their hobby, so undervalue it. There aren't many people off reading academic journals at weekends to write academic essays just for the fun of it! So it's far easier to keep that form of "craft" as something to be respected.

Georgeandzippyzoo · 05/08/2023 09:10

XenoBitch · 04/08/2023 22:39

I craft, and I have copied... but for my own personal use. I would not think of selling what I have copied.

I have done this, but as with uou, for my OWN personal use. I would never sell it on.

I also do cross stitch and the fb page I'm on are red hot on copyright of designers work, they even publish sites to stay clear of because they sell copies/'allow' sellers to sell copyrighted images.

Caprisunny · 05/08/2023 09:09

ThingsBeingVarious · 05/08/2023 08:20

@Caprisunny I don't look at photos of (for example 😂) kangaroos that other people have made, I would look at images of real life kangaroos!

Other peoples photos?

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 05/08/2023 09:09

Tbf the caterpillar was in a Jane Asher cakes book before M and S brought out their cake. I’m guessing she’d copied it from somewhere too

ThingsBeingVarious · 05/08/2023 09:08

@Allthegoodnamesarechosen I neither make kangaroos nor believe in God.
But I do like what you said about the 'I'm only selling it for charity' line. I get that quite a lot.

OP posts:
Alargeoneplease89 · 05/08/2023 09:07

That's life, Aldi do it to M&S etc.

As annoying as it is (I used to have a small craft business with the same problem - i stopped because I fell out of love with doing it- not because of competition). Normally if you do it well you won't lose customers, hence why I still buy Colin the caterpillar and not the cheaper alternatives.

Swipe left for the next trending thread