Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Crafters, if you copy someone's design that you've seen online you're not just a CF, you're a thief.

267 replies

ThingsBeingVarious · 04/08/2023 22:33

I have a small, successful craft business and mostly sell online, which means there are loads of photographs of my work for anyone to see. Yet again I've just been made aware of someone copying my original design and selling the product - she probably thinks it's okay because she's raising money for her local charity. And sometimes my 'followers' and customers will send me a photo of the copy they've made saying I've 'inspired them'.

I know people often say imitation is the sincerest form of flattery but it really fucks me off. People should think up their own designs, not scroll through Pinterest or Etsy or wherever looking for ideas to nick. Or if they haven't got any original ideas they can BUY patterns from other crafter's.

OP posts:
NorthernGirlie · 05/08/2023 11:01

I'm guessing amigurumi too. There are a couple of crafters I follow whose work is very distinctive and I'd know, for example, 1 ladies' bunnies anywhere!

AnneAnon · 05/08/2023 11:00

Kangaroos are utterly terrifying to be honest.

ThingsBeingVarious · 05/08/2023 10:58

Just to be clear, I have not, nor will ever, make a kangaroo amigurumi. Nor any other kind of 🦘🦘🦘

OP posts:
Mammyloveswine · 05/08/2023 10:58

Ffs op what is that you actually make?

Hate threads like this where the op wont share meaning we lose all bloody context!!

BarbaraV · 05/08/2023 10:57

What's fibre arts?

ThingsBeingVarious · 05/08/2023 10:55

@TheCountessofFitzdotterel aye you're right about the voting. And tbh I was particularly wound up last night because of the photo I'd been sent that they told me they were selling 'for charity'. In reality I do try and ignore that people will be copying my work as their hobby crafting, until they demand a pattern or ask for advice on how to fix some problem they've come up against - then I tell them firmly that my work is protected by copyright.

But I still think that as patterns and tutorials or kits can be bought for most things online people should not be freeloaders.

OP posts:
Tatzelwyrm · 05/08/2023 10:53

ThingsBeingVarious · 05/08/2023 08:20

@Caprisunny I don't look at photos of (for example 😂) kangaroos that other people have made, I would look at images of real life kangaroos!

But where are you getting the images of real kangaroos? Someone else's work

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 05/08/2023 10:47

Again I think there’s a distinction to be made with the pictures you get sent depending on why they are sending them… people expecting a free tutorial from you on how to improve their copies are indeed CFs. Even if for personal use, because it’s not your job to give free crafting advice. But if it’s ‘I loved your kangaroo so much I made a little friend for him, thought you might like to see it!’ - would you really object to that?!

AnneAnon · 05/08/2023 10:44

The thing with the personal use argument.

I reckon in most cases it’s not taking money away from the original seller. I have a Cricut. Sometimes I’ll see, for example a tshirt or a water bottle. Love the design, happen to have the right vinyl, make it for myself. Or maybe I just want to try out the technique for myself.

Would I actually buy it? No. I was never going to buy it. I’ve made it because I’ve either already had the stuff, or because I want to try a new technique to increase my own skill set.

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 05/08/2023 10:42

I’m guessing it’s Amigurumi or something fibre arts.

ThingsBeingVarious · 05/08/2023 10:41

@killim and @My3dahliasarebloominlovely how awful.

@GeekyThings my work is 3D not 2D however I suspect there are artists who's image of a kangaroo would be instantly recognisable as their work and so anybody else replicating that would be breaching the artists copyright.

I take your point that having given a free tutorial could be taken as giving permission to use my technique to copy any of the other items I make. But the thing that people seem to want to copy (my most popular and expensive item) is far more complex and detailed - my tutorial was for my simplest product, tbh I think a child could make that, whereas the thing people send me pics of is almost always a really, really poor imitation - they use the similar embellishments and try to capture the style but can't crack the method or, usually, source the materials I use. So they ask for advice on how to make it more accurate!

But the photo I was sent last night was from a really skilled crafter (in a different craft) who had bought my product seemingly in order to work out how to copy it. That really pissed me off, especially as I admired her own work. Though now I'm thinking she has probably copied that too.

OP posts:
Tatzelwyrm · 05/08/2023 10:41

Giggorata · 04/08/2023 23:24

I think I agree with the OP.
Designs for original art and craft works belong to their creator.
Having cheap imitations and knock offs must be infuriating.
I am also surprised that so many people disagree and are suggesting that her original works are not all that original. Ouch.

We don't know if he/r designs are original or not

As (at this point of your post) yet, s/he hasn't shared what they are

Could be amazing and original or (based on probability) not that original and based on/inspired by someone else

WilkinsonM · 05/08/2023 10:39

Say I want to make a kangaroo (I've never made a kangaroo!). I don't scroll through Pinterest looking for the most appealing kangaroo then just try to copy that. I would look at images of real kangaroos, notice their shape, expressions, colours, the way they stand and move, make a few sketches and work out what position and size would work best in the medium I use

that's because you're an artist with a level of training and expertise that most people don't have. Most people into a bit of art/craft as a hobby don't have that level of skill.

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 05/08/2023 10:32

I think it is a real pity the op is muddying the waters between serious infringement and personal use copies. In the first the creator really does lose out, when someone copies an idea and actually makes money off it, such that the nobody is going to want to buy the creator’s original version when you can get a mass market one cheaper. This is a proper problem for independent makers, and it is a great shame there is so little protection against it, and when you have a situation where small makers aren’t protected from blatant illegal rip offs because the bigger companies have deeper pockets to pay lawyers, the law is not working as it should and it is a scandal. It’s equally unacceptable if small scale makers copy your work and you are forced to compete with them even though it was you that did all the development.

But someone wanting to make their own kangaroo for fun, their skills are in making rather than design and they love your version so much they copy it rather than get one from a book - seriously, that bothers you? You haven’t lost anything because buying a kangaroo isn’t what they wanted to do in the first place, they wanted to make one.

I wonder what the different YABU/YANBU percentages would be if you had posed the two questions separately. My guess is if you had asked ‘AIBU to not want people to rip off my creation and sell it?’ you would have far more than 60% of posters on your side. ‘AIBU to think nobody should ever copy work even in private because they should be using their own creativity?’, not so much.

Iforgotmyusernameagainandagain · 05/08/2023 10:30

I sell personalised pictures on FB. I had a buyer who had bought a few pics from me who then decided this is easy - I'll do it myself. He set up a FB selling page and posted photos of MY pics that he'd bought and passed them off as his own. I posted a comment on his selling page - he quickly removed them. He's not the only one - it's happened a few times, and I always call them out.

narrichi · 05/08/2023 10:23

Say I want to make a kangaroo (I've never made a kangaroo!). I don't scroll through Pinterest looking for the most appealing kangaroo then just try to copy that. I would look at images of real kangaroos

But photographs are afforded copyright protection under UK law. Unless you took those photographs yourself or you have the permission of the photographer to use their work for commercial purposes, then how is it really any different from being inspired by photos of someone's kangaroo amigurumi?

MorePressureMoreRelease · 05/08/2023 10:17

You can't protect an idea just the expression of an idea. If, as is said upthread, someone copies the thing but then changes a part of it so as to appear slightly different to the original thing then there's not much you can do.

With lawyers and ££ behind you you can go after the copiers who haven't tweaked enough but in the real world if you are not a big company you'd have to ask yourself whether it was worth it. Most things have a value tied to the brand they come from as much as for what they are. I'd focus on making sure your brand is one people look out for as a maker of quality.

GeekyThings · 05/08/2023 10:11

ThingsBeingVarious · 05/08/2023 08:20

@Caprisunny I don't look at photos of (for example 😂) kangaroos that other people have made, I would look at images of real life kangaroos!

This comment brings up the reason why I'm finding this one difficult to judge this OP - so one person copies a picture of a picture that another person has done of a kangaroo, and you make a picture of a kangaroo from a real life kangaroo. But it's a kangaroo, and there's really only so many images of it you can make until huge numbers of them start to look similar, or the same.

People have been making images of kangaroos as long as there have been people and kangaroos, that's millions, or even billions, is images. It's hugely unlikely, to outright impossible, for one person to make one now that is so unique that it doesn't look like any other image of a kangaroo that's ever been made before. It doesn't matter how much more time you spent on it, or how you went to look at an actual kangaroo, if it looks almost exactly the same as thousands of other kangaroo representations that are already in existence.

I don't disagree that copying your work exactly, then emailing you and telling you that they've copied it and they're going to sell it is probably a breach of copyright law - they've literally told you they're doing it. But I'm struggling to believe that your work is so unique that you'd be able to sue for copyright infringement just because you see something that looks really similar to yours. You also said you've done online, free tutorials on how to create your crafts, which could be used as an argument against breach of copyright because you were clearly ok to share your ideas then with the public, meaning that if they then choose to create something that you've created before it could be down to the technique that makes them look the same, not because they've seen it and copied it.

Basically it's just hard to tell without seeing what you do, and how unique it actually is, but I think it's unlikely it's so unique that you'd reasonably be able to sue without the person actually stating to you that they used it for the purposes of making money. And I think it's unreasonable to get annoyed at people making their own copies for their personal use, that falls under fair use. It's also a great ad for your stuff, as their friends will ask them where they got it, they'll say they made it but they copied it from your website, so the less crafty person may go to your website and buy it. That's a win, really!

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 05/08/2023 10:10

Inkpotlover · 05/08/2023 09:58

If you're copying patterns that other people have willingly sold, legally you are not doing anything wrong. But morally your attitude is appalling. Perhaps if you ever bothered to make anything original you would understand how frustrating it is to see your hard work ripped off.

Whether it’s legally wrong depends whether the patterns were sold for personal use only or for commercial use. Most patterns I buy for knitting or dressmaking have a statement that they’re personal use only, so even if it was just a little Etsy shop or for charity you would still be breaking the law if you sold them.
Occasionally they say you can use them for any purpose but please credit the designer.

My3dahliasarebloominlovely · 05/08/2023 10:06

I'm an artist. Years ago I owned an art gallery (with a different name to mine). Business partner excitedly told me an artist had come in with work very like mine. Had a look at it. The painting was an exact copy of a print she'd bought of one of my paintings...... I looked at this woman's website. It featured originals for sale including 4 copies of my paintings, one copy of my business partner's work, and several more paintings which were clear copies of other artists.....
She rang the plagiarist and asked her to come and pick up her work. When they saw me, their face was a picture. The website disappeared.

Inkpotlover · 05/08/2023 09:58

Aprilx · 05/08/2023 09:50

I think you need to get over yourself. Whatever it is you make, I seriously doubt that it is so unique that no other person in the world ever has done something similar.

I have a little ETSY shop, I make things, but I make them following patterns. No I am not embarrassed, I am not interested in being creative, I just like making things and I make them well. Too bad if you don’t like that.

If you're copying patterns that other people have willingly sold, legally you are not doing anything wrong. But morally your attitude is appalling. Perhaps if you ever bothered to make anything original you would understand how frustrating it is to see your hard work ripped off.

ThingsBeingVarious · 05/08/2023 09:50

VinEtFromage · 05/08/2023 09:48

Oh the irony...

Jeez, the infographic actually has, printed on it, permission to share 🙄

OP posts:
Aprilx · 05/08/2023 09:50

ThingsBeingVarious · 04/08/2023 23:50

There is something called 'unregistered rights' which does give a measure of protection to artists/makers when people copy their work. I've sent polite but strongly worded emails to people I've been made aware of who are copying my work to sell, and when followers/customers send me pics of their copies I reply with a friendly but very clear message telling them that they do not have the right to use my design without my permission (which I am not giving!). So far I've always had apologetic responses, basically saying they didn't realise, but tbh I've no idea if it's stopped them making copies.

@DPotter thanks for your advice, it's very helpful. I'm not going to make a pattern to sell until I've decided I no longer want to make what I'm making.

All PP's admitting to copying work you see online - I can't understand why you don't feel ashamed of stealing someone else's ideas, why don't you try to create something using your own imagination? It might not be completely original but at least you've had some creative input into your own work.

I think you need to get over yourself. Whatever it is you make, I seriously doubt that it is so unique that no other person in the world ever has done something similar.

I have a little ETSY shop, I make things, but I make them following patterns. No I am not embarrassed, I am not interested in being creative, I just like making things and I make them well. Too bad if you don’t like that.

VinEtFromage · 05/08/2023 09:48

ThingsBeingVarious · 04/08/2023 23:55

@Mousehoel that's an excellent infographic, I might attach that to any messages I have to send to copiers in future. Thank you.

Oh the irony...

ThingsBeingVarious · 05/08/2023 09:47

@NorthernGirlie I didn't think you were being an arse. We're not in the same situation but I thought the point you were making, which I completely identify with, is the bloody rude way in which quite a few people demand to know how you've made something. I've also have had people comment just 'send me the pattern'.

OP posts: