Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Crafters, if you copy someone's design that you've seen online you're not just a CF, you're a thief.

267 replies

ThingsBeingVarious · 04/08/2023 22:33

I have a small, successful craft business and mostly sell online, which means there are loads of photographs of my work for anyone to see. Yet again I've just been made aware of someone copying my original design and selling the product - she probably thinks it's okay because she's raising money for her local charity. And sometimes my 'followers' and customers will send me a photo of the copy they've made saying I've 'inspired them'.

I know people often say imitation is the sincerest form of flattery but it really fucks me off. People should think up their own designs, not scroll through Pinterest or Etsy or wherever looking for ideas to nick. Or if they haven't got any original ideas they can BUY patterns from other crafter's.

OP posts:
neverwakeasleepingbaby · 06/08/2023 07:43

@CatMum27 ah interesting, thanks. Yes I find copyright law very subjective and open to interpretation.
In contrast, in UK patent law it's not an infringement to do something which otherwise would infringe but is done privately for non-commercial purposes.
Anyway, as you say, enough of the geekery 😄

I think the real issue that the OP has is less to do with the actual law and more to do with whether they are justified in feeling annoyed that people are openly copying. Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery and all that, but I guess maybe not when it's your business

PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog · 05/08/2023 21:04

If they're not selling them, YABU

CatMum27 · 05/08/2023 20:47

neverwakeasleepingbaby · 05/08/2023 20:26

Would this not fall under Section 29 of the CPDA? Or as you have said, would you just argue that defence in court (which it almost certainly wouldn't get to)? I'm genuinely interested because I work in IP law but not in copyright and I find copyright law very complicated!

OP YANBU to be pissed off about people copying your designs

A fellow copyright geek :)

I don’t think the use described would fall under S29 as I don’t think it qualifies as research/private study. I work in higher education so this is the area I tend to deal with most. However, that doesn’t mean someone else couldn’t use it as an argument. As I understand it that is essentially what copyright law is - people arguing over interpretations until something becomes case law which can be used in the future. But that’s probably enough geekery for a Saturday night!

Basically you’re right - it IS complicated once you get past the basics.

Soggysoggydew · 05/08/2023 20:38

ThingsBeingVarious · 05/08/2023 13:01

@Saz12 I don't know, but for me that would not be enjoyable. I love the idea and design stage - making is just something I have to do to make what's in my mind's eye become actual. It can be a frustrating process at times but when it works that's complete job satisfaction.

I also hand sew my own clothes sometimes. For example I have a top I love the shape of but I want it in a colour is isn’t sold in, the easiest way is to lie the top on the fabric I want and use it as a pattern… should I be feeling bad for copying m&s? Who, btw were not the first creator of this shape of blouse- I just happened to buy mine from them.

neverwakeasleepingbaby · 05/08/2023 20:26

CatMum27 · 05/08/2023 19:45

@EducatingArti Technically they are but no one would ever go after them for it. As with recording films etc from the tv, copyright holder know it goes on and turn a blind eye. Same with people who do art projects for personal use. Most of copyright (and other) law is arguing over interpretation of the rules. Strictly speaking an unauthorised copy is a breach but it would be pointless to pursue. Although the Disney corporation has been known to be pretty litigious in the past.....

Would this not fall under Section 29 of the CPDA? Or as you have said, would you just argue that defence in court (which it almost certainly wouldn't get to)? I'm genuinely interested because I work in IP law but not in copyright and I find copyright law very complicated!

OP YANBU to be pissed off about people copying your designs

Soggysoggydew · 05/08/2023 20:26

Is what you make genuinely vastly different to what others make?

Depending on the craft, so much is fairly standardised… like trinkets made from resin for example- loads of people will buy the same moulds.

I do hand embroidery- I draw my patterns free hand but so many stitches are usual, like edging in blanket stitch, in filling with satin stitch that one person’s black top with red roses will look very similar to someone else’s.

LadyPoison · 05/08/2023 20:21

Part of the difficulty is that we are all unconsciously influenced by what we see.

I'm a silver jewellery designer and maker. There are a certain number of techniques. Plain bezel rings and basket sets are universal. I make them. Every silversmith I know makes them. Some are tweaked using embellishment plates. They all look like variations on a theme as the plates are commercially available and the number of designs are limited. There is no way to claim copyright on this style. It is universal.

There is a popular design out there at the moment of a circle with some mountains and a sun inside it. I have no idea who first came up with the concept but there are now lots of variations. All different, using different metals in different combinations but clearly based on the same idea. Not technically a copyright infringement but certainly based on one person's work.

I, myself, will sit at my bench, pull out some silver and some stones and let them be what they want to be. Even if I start with a design in mind it will be substantially different at the end from what I may have thought at the start. I do not set out to copy but I can never be sure that someone somewhere hasn't gone through the same thought process either before or after me. I spent this afternoon making silver mushrooms. I hope no one else has come up with the exact same interpretation I have but I don't know, I haven't gone looking.

The problem is I don't know what my subconscious has picked up and retained from the many thousands of mushrooms and mushroom images I've seen over the years! Maybe I am100% original. Maybe I'm not...

Ffsmakeitstop · 05/08/2023 20:03

Dh does wood turning as a hobby and sells at craft fairs and quite often people will ask how stuff is made or ask to take photos. He will explain if someone seems genuinely interested but always says no to photos.
The ones that get me are the ones that say "oh Bob could make one of them" aye right course they can. Folk are cf.

CatMum27 · 05/08/2023 19:45

@EducatingArti Technically they are but no one would ever go after them for it. As with recording films etc from the tv, copyright holder know it goes on and turn a blind eye. Same with people who do art projects for personal use. Most of copyright (and other) law is arguing over interpretation of the rules. Strictly speaking an unauthorised copy is a breach but it would be pointless to pursue. Although the Disney corporation has been known to be pretty litigious in the past.....

Tatzelwyrm · 05/08/2023 19:43

EducatingArti · 05/08/2023 19:30

@CatMum27
So what about the example of a child who traces a picture of a Disney princess and colours it in and puts it on their bedroom wall?
Are they breaking copyright?

I think technically yes?

(I'm not a lawyer though)

EducatingArti · 05/08/2023 19:30

@CatMum27
So what about the example of a child who traces a picture of a Disney princess and colours it in and puts it on their bedroom wall?
Are they breaking copyright?

ThingsBeingVarious · 05/08/2023 19:03

Thank you @CatMum27 What you've outlined is my understanding of copyright, I wish all the CFers scrolling away at home, looking for images of work they can copy rather than put in any creative effort of their own, understood it too.

OP posts:
CatMum27 · 05/08/2023 16:36

And to the poster saying that copyright doesn’t apply if you’re using something for private purposes I can promise you it does. All laws apply whether an action is public or private!

CatMum27 · 05/08/2023 16:31

Lots of misunderstandings about copyright on this thread. As someone who works in copyright I can tell you that if you copy someone else’s original work then yes you are in breach of the rules and there is always “something they can do about it”. There are two main sets of rights in copyright- the right to make money and the right to be identified as the creator. It makes no difference whether you make money from it or not, although publicly sharing something makes you easier to catch. in copying you are taking away the right of the creator to make money from their work as you are not purchasing the original from the creator. And you’re probably not crediting them either! Fair use does not apply. It’s a defence to be used in court, not blanket permission to do what you want. It means you are allowed to use a PORTION of a copyrighted work as long as the use is fair and reasonable. Unfortunately there is no exact specification as to amount but copying the whole thing is definitely not fair use.

A copyright owner is always within their rights to take action but practically they are not always able to. Those who are old enough will remember recording films from the tv or songs from the radio. This was illegal as it breached copyright - you weren’t buying the DVD if you were recording it from the tv for free. Copyright owners were hardly likely to have the time or resources to track down everyone who did it though. Same with World Book Day. You can copy costumes instead of buying official ones but technically you are still breaking the law. Highly unlikely people are going to sue you ... but they could if they wanted to.

OP - I’m sorry this is happening to you. I’ve had something similar and it sucks. Ignorance of the law is no excuse but one which is often used. If you want to take things further try something like Citizens Advice or the local library (if there is one left). They often have lists of legal professionals who will give you limited free legal advice and may also be able to point towards further sources of help.

londonmummy1966 · 05/08/2023 13:39

I agree with you OP - it is really annoying to see your ideas copied. I ran up some clothes for my DC when they were really little using vintage towelling only for a friend of mine who was a designer to rip off the idea for the major brand she worked for. My clothes were no longer in any way unique.....

A friend of mine sold craft kits using recycled fabrics and got a warning letter from a major brand as one of her kits used some of their fabric in amongst a range of others. (bit like patchwork). I had a wry smile at that one as I own a 1930s vintage sugar bowl that has the exact same pattern as a fabric in that brands range so no way was that an original design....

TyneFilth · 05/08/2023 13:34

OP I think I appreciate your position and I would like to comment with a cautionary tale of a very amateur crafter showing why it is worth paying someone like you for a good pattern...

For a couple of weekends I have been making ten little cotton bags for kids which will be given as party bags with a few goodies in them. I've also made a D&D dice bag with internal sections in it. For these I bought three different patterns from Etsy for about £2 each. The D&D pattern was really easy to follow as it had step by step instructions written on the pages. The other two were just the printed pattern pieces and the instructions were on a YouTube link. One was a simple messenger bag with a large flap over, the other involved a zip and a loop tag in a side seam.

Now, I cannot hold verbal instructions in my head for any time at all. I didn't set up my sewing space to have a laptop there as a tutorial that I'd have to play and pause through. So, for the five messenger bag I got away with guessing at the order of construction. It's not something I'd sell at a craft market but as a freebie for a 9 year old it's perfectly robust and it'll do. The other five were the zip one, and oh boy did I wish I'd had written step by step instructions. I had to take my first attempt apart twice, I didn't put the zip in at the right stage, I've not been able to press out the seams, I've ended up hand finishing them which has taken far longer than all the other stages put together.

Paying a couple of quid more for a full-instructions well thought out pattern that works reliably is my lesson here. I'll probably still rate the patterns with YouTube tutorials at a 4, because they're sound just not the style of instructions that work for me. But I will look more carefully at descriptions in future to ensure I'm getting step by steps.

ohtobeme · 05/08/2023 13:31

Copyright doesn't apply for anyone who makes a copy for their own private purposes - for their own wall for example

The only copiers who are acting illegally are those who profit from it

catscatscurrantscurrants · 05/08/2023 13:18

I understand where you're coming from. As a dressmaker, I was often brought a picture of a very expensive dress by a client and asked to make a straight copy for a lot less money. Every time I refused, explaining that I was happy to make something similar but there would have to be changes or it was unfair to the original designer, as well as being a form of intellectual property theft. Similar but with differences is fine IMO, a straight copy is not.

EducatingArti · 05/08/2023 13:17

I don't think there is an issue in copying ideas for personal use, especially when not making an identical product but taking inspiration from form, shape or technique.
I love doing a variety of making/crafting but I am not a particularly good fine artist.
I was inspired by carvings of rowan berry sprays that are everywhere in an arts and crafts house in the Lake District. I used the carvings as an inspiration to do cardboard printing of similar sprays. They are nowhere near as good as the carvings but I enjoyed trying to get something of the same feel/vibe.

I was inspired by an image of a running hare on a piece of Roman Samian ware in a museum. I painted hares on slate coasters to imitate Roman style fresco. I traced one hare from an image of a Roman hare brooch, one from an image of a running hare that an illustrator had put on line and drew round a hare I had on a decorative metal panel at home.
I couldn't draw a decent looking hare on my own to save my life!

It was probably cheeky to trace the illustrator's hare picture, but I am not selling my product. I reckon that displaying these tiles on my mantelpiece takes away nothing from her as I'm not selling it or even putting a photo online. It has been interpreted differently ( colour and style of painting) . If a friend asked me about how I did the pictures, I would say I traced the basic shapes.

If you were to take this to the extreme, what about a child who traces a Disney princess from a book and colours it in and puts it on their bedroom wall. Would that be wrong?

Obviously selling items for profit is a different issue.

ThingsBeingVarious · 05/08/2023 13:01

@Saz12 I don't know, but for me that would not be enjoyable. I love the idea and design stage - making is just something I have to do to make what's in my mind's eye become actual. It can be a frustrating process at times but when it works that's complete job satisfaction.

OP posts:
ThingsBeingVarious · 05/08/2023 12:56

@Brefugee I haven't replied yet but I am going to. I normally would have replied straight away but I was really bothered by the fact we'd had quite a lot of chat about our crafts over the last couple of weeks (since she became a customer rather than only a follower') - her copying with the intention to sell was quite a surprise. Then I posted here, in a bad mood, and have been distracted ever since...

OP posts:
ThingsBeingVarious · 05/08/2023 12:49

@ohtobeme the design is protected legally. Copyright is automatically conferred on me as the creator. Problem is that many people either don't know or ignore this and other than, firstly, a friendly message and next a 'cease and desist' letter there's not much you can do to stop people copying.

OP posts:
Saz12 · 05/08/2023 12:48

PS - op yanbu!

Saz12 · 05/08/2023 12:48

What about buying from Shein (or other large unethical businesses) and copying their designs? Probably using better quality materials and with more care. Then sell them small scale craft fairs for lical small charity (ie unlikely to get caught).

Is that also immoral, or poetic justice, given how many designs they rip off?

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 05/08/2023 12:42

If it is Amigurumi then it generally mainly is just a combo of single crochet/double crochet in various configurations. A lot of artists are very similar

Swipe left for the next trending thread