Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Crafters, if you copy someone's design that you've seen online you're not just a CF, you're a thief.

267 replies

ThingsBeingVarious · 04/08/2023 22:33

I have a small, successful craft business and mostly sell online, which means there are loads of photographs of my work for anyone to see. Yet again I've just been made aware of someone copying my original design and selling the product - she probably thinks it's okay because she's raising money for her local charity. And sometimes my 'followers' and customers will send me a photo of the copy they've made saying I've 'inspired them'.

I know people often say imitation is the sincerest form of flattery but it really fucks me off. People should think up their own designs, not scroll through Pinterest or Etsy or wherever looking for ideas to nick. Or if they haven't got any original ideas they can BUY patterns from other crafter's.

OP posts:
Ridemeginger · 06/08/2023 19:39

African, Indian, Native American, Aboriginal, Romany art, pattern, jewellery, pottery, fabric….how many Western artists still copy the original artistic ideas and emblems of these cultures? I don’t think there are any original ideas any more, everything is derivative of what came before it.

FlappyBirdsGone · 06/08/2023 19:36

How long have you been in the business @ThingsBeingVarious? because my job is…creative and this is very common. People steal ideas all the time and have done since the dawn of time. Sometimes they twist it to make it their own, other times it blatant. It just is. It’s happened to me many times. I’m over it.

ArticSaviour · 06/08/2023 19:34

ThingsBeingVarious · 05/08/2023 10:58

Just to be clear, I have not, nor will ever, make a kangaroo amigurumi. Nor any other kind of 🦘🦘🦘

Surely you mean Kangaroomigumi?

EpidermalLayer · 06/08/2023 19:28

LadyPoison · 05/08/2023 20:21

Part of the difficulty is that we are all unconsciously influenced by what we see.

I'm a silver jewellery designer and maker. There are a certain number of techniques. Plain bezel rings and basket sets are universal. I make them. Every silversmith I know makes them. Some are tweaked using embellishment plates. They all look like variations on a theme as the plates are commercially available and the number of designs are limited. There is no way to claim copyright on this style. It is universal.

There is a popular design out there at the moment of a circle with some mountains and a sun inside it. I have no idea who first came up with the concept but there are now lots of variations. All different, using different metals in different combinations but clearly based on the same idea. Not technically a copyright infringement but certainly based on one person's work.

I, myself, will sit at my bench, pull out some silver and some stones and let them be what they want to be. Even if I start with a design in mind it will be substantially different at the end from what I may have thought at the start. I do not set out to copy but I can never be sure that someone somewhere hasn't gone through the same thought process either before or after me. I spent this afternoon making silver mushrooms. I hope no one else has come up with the exact same interpretation I have but I don't know, I haven't gone looking.

The problem is I don't know what my subconscious has picked up and retained from the many thousands of mushrooms and mushroom images I've seen over the years! Maybe I am100% original. Maybe I'm not...

Currently shopping for wedding rings and most designs are variations on a theme. A mobius strip shaped ring for example - you can find thousands that look exactly the same online. Here's an example:
https://www.jacquelineandedward.com/product/the-laggan-ethical-18ct-gold-wedding-ring-with-single-twist/ 

The below however is unique:
https://www.jacquelineandedward.com/product/the-balwoges-18ct-gold-oak-twig-wedding-ring/

So would the jeweller be able to claim copyright for the second, not the first? @CatMum27

@LadyPoison There are lots of silver mushrooms but if you did, say a mushroom with a fairy on top. Or a mushroom with various flowers, that nobody else has the cases might be clearer cut. I follow quite a few artists (not silver smiths though) and as PP said their work has a certain style, I'd be able to recognise it anywhere

Btw hubs-to-be wants a silver hip flask so if you do those feel free to DM me your page

The Balwoges: 18ct Gold Oak Twig Wedding Ring

An 18ct gold wedding ring cast from a one of a kind Oak twig with either a polish or matt finish. Handmade from ethical recycled gold and enhanced using natural river gold, gifted to you by us. Choose your river gold location to make your ring extra sp...

https://www.jacquelineandedward.com/product/the-balwoges-18ct-gold-oak-twig-wedding-ring

Fightwithmyface · 06/08/2023 19:21

Lapflop · 05/08/2023 07:59

YANBU if its truly unique, unfortunately not a lot you can do about it, even huge corporations like Disney struggle to get anywhere with people ripping off their stuff to sell (they try though and do get a lot of accounts removed from Etsy etc)- some people are just shitty not that it makes it right.

I did go to a craft fayre a few weeks ago though and someone was selling miniature trees made out of twisted metal. I said these are beautiful, I have one similar to this at home and it always gets a lot of comments! She then demanded (I say this as angrily asked rather than just asked) to know where I'd got it from and when as she was going to take action as someone had obviously copied her work; I inherited it from my nan who (sadly) died many years ago- she said oh can't be like mine then as mine are the only ones but I wasn't even born then. Made me chuckle.

Ha, this reminds me of a time a woman demanded I remove an item of jewellery from my website as she was the original inventor of this type of jewellery and I was stealing her idea. I sent her a link to an example of a 15th century one in the British Museum 😂

toxic44 · 06/08/2023 19:10

If you decide to sell your patterns and someone buys one, makes the item and sells it, how would you react? Would you call that copying your work? Would want them to cease and desist?
I've earned my living by designing, making and selling for a good few years. People always copy, mostly quite badly. But they can't copy it until they've seen it; they can't see it until you've done it. So stay ahead.

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 06/08/2023 19:04

Or in terms of embroidery or tapestry it could be a 19th century design

anon666 · 06/08/2023 19:02

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 06/08/2023 18:57

How do you know you aren’t buying a copy of a design from the 80s/90s/00s?

Tastes and styles change so it's quite unusual not to be able to tell whether something in vintage in origin.

For example there is a resurgence of interest in Swedish/Scandinavian linen embroidery and yes, based on the original designs.

I agree with another poster saying that it's hard to know if you're not subconsciously absorbing influences, and artistic movements tend to move forward in waves. However, there are infinite combinations so it's pretty clear to me when "influence" moves into the territory of "copying".

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 06/08/2023 18:59

I say this as someone that cross stitched in the 90s/00s and see lots of the designs from then returning again now (although I no longer CS)

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 06/08/2023 18:57

anon666 · 06/08/2023 18:43

I've seen a lot of this in the craft community, and it's always bothered me.

I'm a crafter, and I always buy the pattern or kit of an original artist or creator's work, because it's only then that people will be able to continue creating such beautiful innovative things.

I have seen stuff so similar - particularly in the embroidery world where there are lots of makers and designers producing patterns or kits. I often wonder how they agree these things between themselves because there is often quite a lot of money changing hands.

I totally agree with you. I don't understand why people think it's okay to copy someone's original idea and sell it on as their own. Maybe copying something to learn how to make those type of things, or to learn a particular skill, but not just copying and passing it off as your own. 😳

How do you know you aren’t buying a copy of a design from the 80s/90s/00s?

Cucucucu · 06/08/2023 18:53

Is this “ pattern “ registered as yours ? If not then it’s really not yours

anon666 · 06/08/2023 18:43

I've seen a lot of this in the craft community, and it's always bothered me.

I'm a crafter, and I always buy the pattern or kit of an original artist or creator's work, because it's only then that people will be able to continue creating such beautiful innovative things.

I have seen stuff so similar - particularly in the embroidery world where there are lots of makers and designers producing patterns or kits. I often wonder how they agree these things between themselves because there is often quite a lot of money changing hands.

I totally agree with you. I don't understand why people think it's okay to copy someone's original idea and sell it on as their own. Maybe copying something to learn how to make those type of things, or to learn a particular skill, but not just copying and passing it off as your own. 😳

SultanOfPing · 06/08/2023 18:34

Are you able to register your design? It's not as expensive as it used to be, and is a fairly painless exercise (nowhere near as difficult as a patent!). You will have unregistered design rights, but a registered design will give you a bit of extra leverage. I've had items copied, and it's bloody annoying; using my ideas as a starting point? Fine. Copying my designs? Nope! Copying to the point of reverse-engineering the original though? Not only completely uncool, but totally illegal. The British Crafthouse seems to be a good platform to sell on, they actually give a crap if someone tries to sell stuff that's borne of someone else's design (and if other sellers recognise your work elsewhere, they'll let you know). If you need advice, try the Intellectual Property Office, they've always been helpful.

Cottagewitch · 06/08/2023 18:30

I don’t think it’s fair to directly copy. I design T-shirts which I sell in my own physical shop in my town. A lady came in, liked one particular design. I was out of her size and she said ‘I’ll just take a picture and then I can get one printed myself’. No you won’t. You can take my card and order online when I get your size back in stock.

Buggersticks · 06/08/2023 18:27

I've made stuff completely off my own imagination, no looking on Etsy or anywhere else. However, when I go to sell it, I find loads of similar things already there! I'm yet to 'invent' anything that hasn't already been thought of if only in a similar style. 😕 So. Who says you were first?

Iwant2stayanon · 06/08/2023 17:49

Unless you have protected it with IP and can sue said individual, I guess you have to just live with it

CoffeeWithCheese · 06/08/2023 14:12

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 05/08/2023 12:42

If it is Amigurumi then it generally mainly is just a combo of single crochet/double crochet in various configurations. A lot of artists are very similar

Yep and it’s just the ability to break an object down into basic shapes and count while going round and round in circles. I’ve looked at images of anigurumi before and just been fairly easily able to replicate the pattern to a good level for my own use (or because the kids have decided they really want an item).

I don’t make stuff to sell anymore anyway, and was careful not to do similar for selling - but there is so little genuine originality out there with crafting that these “she copied meeee” spats are always amusing, and the OP screeching and praising the poll percentage that agrees with her are adding to that.

ComeBackPeterComeBackPaul · 06/08/2023 13:54

Hi, a couple of questions, please. I can go onto Etsy, type “Sézane earrings “ into the search engine and be taken to any number of small traders. Is this wrong and, if so, why does Etsy seem to actively allow it?
Secondly, if I see a cotton bag on a retail website/shop and I then draft my own pattern and make one (for 1/10th of the price), is this also wrong?
It’s all very confusing especially as shop after shop are filled with remarkably similar items.
Thanks.

OneTC · 06/08/2023 12:06

I think asking people not to copy something for themselves is taking it a bit far. I used to copy panels from comics and my copies were rubbish because I couldn't draw. Most people who attempt to copy your thing will make a poor facsimile at best and even if they don't they are refining their technique which is a very valid step towards creating something of your own.

Skilled or unskilled craftsmen copying it and selling it however is totally unacceptable

CatMum27 · 06/08/2023 09:33

GeekyThings · 06/08/2023 07:57

If you understand copyright law then you'll also know that not all crafted goods fall under it, unless they are considered to be a 'work of artistic craftsmanship'. Without knowing what the OP is actually making we can't say for sure whether that law applies. That would be determined by a court.

And, as the poster above talking about the child's Disney drawing has highlighted, it is highly unlikely that they would consider most cases where the 'art' lives in a person's private home, not for show or sale. Otherwise the courts would probably collapse as it's very common. The child's drawing would also likely fall under one of the many major exceptions to copyright law, teaching, as they're learning to draw.

Partly true but the point I was making is that just because someone is doing something behind closed doors that doesn’t make it legal which is what the original post is implying. It also highlights one of the big issues with copyright in that the official terminology is really unhelpful. There is a lot of talk of non-commercial and educational use which to most people mean one thing but in copyright mean slight different specific things. For example, you mention that a child’s drawing would fall under the exception for teaching but this isn’t true. This exception has defined parameters such as the teaching being delivered to a specific cohort of students on a defined program of study, not just someone using someone else’s work to learn. But as you say, pointless for any action to be taken as it would cause the system to collapse.

Tatzelwyrm · 06/08/2023 09:17

GeekyThings · 06/08/2023 07:57

If you understand copyright law then you'll also know that not all crafted goods fall under it, unless they are considered to be a 'work of artistic craftsmanship'. Without knowing what the OP is actually making we can't say for sure whether that law applies. That would be determined by a court.

And, as the poster above talking about the child's Disney drawing has highlighted, it is highly unlikely that they would consider most cases where the 'art' lives in a person's private home, not for show or sale. Otherwise the courts would probably collapse as it's very common. The child's drawing would also likely fall under one of the many major exceptions to copyright law, teaching, as they're learning to draw.

Would there be anything about the age of the person? I mean as they are a minor? Can a minor be sued for this kind of issue?

I think the originality of ideas is tough to prove (to return to the op question) someone somewhere has probably done it before, similar to language. There are words that seemingly should come from the same root, but don't.

False cognates are pairs of words that seem to be cognates because of similar sounds and meaning, but have different etymologies; they can be within the same language or from different languages, even within the same family. For example, the English word dog and the Mbabaram word dog have exactly the same meaning and very similar pronunciations, but by complete coincidence. Likewise, English much and Spanish mucho came by their similar meanings via completely different Proto-Indo-European roots, and same for English have and Spanish haber. This is different from false friends, which are similar-sounding words with different meanings, but which may in fact be etymologically related.

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_cognate

Random789 · 06/08/2023 08:52

@GeekyThings "Artistic craftsmanship" isn't defined in the legislation but seems to be defined pretty widely in court cases.
Also, of couse you would have to be a bit of a fool to take a case to court if the copied art just lies in the home and isn't a source of profit or reputation. But I don't think the OP is talking about a possible court case.
That's part of the problem, in't it -- that for huge numbers of small-scale creative people who make an income from their work, there is absolutly no chance of taking expensive court action. So they rely on viewers and purchasers of their work understanding and respecting the broad principle of copyright law as set out in statute.
The OP's problem doesn't arise from finer points of the law that would need to be argued in court. It arises from a complete failure on the part of very many people to understand that very broad basic principle: that you must not copy a work of artistic craftsmanship without permission or licence from the copyright holder.

User98866 · 06/08/2023 08:35

To clarify I had bought the fabric before seeing her picture.

User98866 · 06/08/2023 08:34

Soggysoggydew · 05/08/2023 20:38

I also hand sew my own clothes sometimes. For example I have a top I love the shape of but I want it in a colour is isn’t sold in, the easiest way is to lie the top on the fabric I want and use it as a pattern… should I be feeling bad for copying m&s? Who, btw were not the first creator of this shape of blouse- I just happened to buy mine from them.

I was wondering this. I make my kids clothes and buy lots of sewing patterns but I have drafted my own and would be capable. I don’t sell them btw. But I have thought I might I might in the future. There are millions of patterns available to buy in the same style. I don’t think I’ve ever seen one that’s unique. Most patterns say they are for personal use yet no one could ever possibly know whose exact pattern was whose as they are all basically the same and many are quite vintage looking designs which the pattern drafter has probably copied. There really aren’t that many ways to make shorts/shirts/dresses!

I think some makers do get inflated egos. There was another maker I was following on IG that sold her items similar to the sorts of things I make. I think she thought they were truly unique and thought no one else brought the same fabrics as her, and asked people not to ask where she got them as she put a lot of effort in to ‘sourcing’. Most of them were from Liberty or another slightly niche but still very popular store Hmm. I once commented on her pic something like ‘lovely choice, I’ve just got some of that fabric it’s so lovely for autumn’. She deleted my comment!

GeekyThings · 06/08/2023 07:57

CatMum27 · 05/08/2023 16:36

And to the poster saying that copyright doesn’t apply if you’re using something for private purposes I can promise you it does. All laws apply whether an action is public or private!

If you understand copyright law then you'll also know that not all crafted goods fall under it, unless they are considered to be a 'work of artistic craftsmanship'. Without knowing what the OP is actually making we can't say for sure whether that law applies. That would be determined by a court.

And, as the poster above talking about the child's Disney drawing has highlighted, it is highly unlikely that they would consider most cases where the 'art' lives in a person's private home, not for show or sale. Otherwise the courts would probably collapse as it's very common. The child's drawing would also likely fall under one of the many major exceptions to copyright law, teaching, as they're learning to draw.