Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Crafters, if you copy someone's design that you've seen online you're not just a CF, you're a thief.

267 replies

ThingsBeingVarious · 04/08/2023 22:33

I have a small, successful craft business and mostly sell online, which means there are loads of photographs of my work for anyone to see. Yet again I've just been made aware of someone copying my original design and selling the product - she probably thinks it's okay because she's raising money for her local charity. And sometimes my 'followers' and customers will send me a photo of the copy they've made saying I've 'inspired them'.

I know people often say imitation is the sincerest form of flattery but it really fucks me off. People should think up their own designs, not scroll through Pinterest or Etsy or wherever looking for ideas to nick. Or if they haven't got any original ideas they can BUY patterns from other crafter's.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NatM70 · 10/08/2023 22:44

Eddielizzard · 10/08/2023 19:28

Thank you! Copyscape and DCMA both look very powerful. Great to have something in our corner for once

Forgot.
You can run any of your web pages through CopyScape and it will bring up any copies and show you any sites that have copied you.
Then you report it.

NatM70 · 10/08/2023 22:42

Eddielizzard · 10/08/2023 19:28

Thank you! Copyscape and DCMA both look very powerful. Great to have something in our corner for once

You're very welcome.
The more we can scare them off the better.
Pure laziness.
And theft.

Eddielizzard · 10/08/2023 19:28

Thank you! Copyscape and DCMA both look very powerful. Great to have something in our corner for once

NatM70 · 10/08/2023 18:27

I'm so sorry!
Still on holiday mode (got back yesterday!).
It is DMCA.
Although it is American, it applies here too as Google is American.
If I Google a company who have stolen my text (one copied and pasted my whole terms and conditions!), they have a DMCA strike against them and people can see the page has been taken down.
It doesn't look good for them.
Use CopyScape too, it is usually enough to scare the lazy gits off.

Eddielizzard · 10/08/2023 10:47

NatM70 · 10/08/2023 09:16

@ThingsBeingVarious
It is copyright infringement pure and simple.
You can't use any photo or even text you find online without prior permission from the owner.
People can and indeed are sued for it.
I used to get it a lot with my art, and I now use Copyscape (which is free to use) and it is plastered everywhere warning people, as I got sick of it.
You can also Google to DFMA, and have a notice sent to the perpetrator, and the content is removed and they receive a strike, with a notice so if you Google them that a page belonging to them has been taken down - highly embarrassing for them.

@NatM70 what does DFMA stand for? A google search says design for manufacturing and assembly, but I suspect that's not what you mean?

NatM70 · 10/08/2023 09:16

@ThingsBeingVarious
It is copyright infringement pure and simple.
You can't use any photo or even text you find online without prior permission from the owner.
People can and indeed are sued for it.
I used to get it a lot with my art, and I now use Copyscape (which is free to use) and it is plastered everywhere warning people, as I got sick of it.
You can also Google to DFMA, and have a notice sent to the perpetrator, and the content is removed and they receive a strike, with a notice so if you Google them that a page belonging to them has been taken down - highly embarrassing for them.

CasperGutman · 08/08/2023 10:11

Drews · 04/08/2023 22:55

Get it trademarked if it meets criteria.

More likely a registered design would be the most appropriate for of protection here. Possibly a patent, if there is anything really inventive, rather than just a distinctive appearance.

GlomOfNit · 08/08/2023 10:09

ThingsBeingVarious · 05/08/2023 07:48

Respect to the 40% who don't think it's right to copy another person's work without permission, whether to sell, gift or keep for yourself. For the other 60% here's how I see it...

Say I want to make a kangaroo (I've never made a kangaroo!). I don't scroll through Pinterest looking for the most appealing kangaroo then just try to copy that. I would look at images of real kangaroos, notice their shape, expressions, colours, the way they stand and move, make a few sketches and work out what position and size would work best in the medium I use. Then I'd make some templates and mock up a kangaroo, seeing if my idea worked, probably realise the tail was too thin so it fell down, or the ears made it look like a rabbit. So I'd keep tweaking until it looked right, then choose the perfect material and make a prototype, which I'd then embellish in the way that is noticeably my style. Then I'd spend a few hours finding the perfect place for a photoshoot of the kangaroo, set up a scene, then edit the photos. I'd then make another kangaroo, timing how long it took so I could price it above minimum wage for me but affordable for my customers. Then I put it online to sell.

Someone will then pin my photo to their board or share it somewhere online. Despite there being (I expect) hundreds of kangaroo patterns for sale and plenty of free kangaroo tutorials, 60% would rather not spend a few quid on a pattern or make the effort to think creatively themselves, instead they somehow feel entitled to piggyback on all the time and effort I've put in coming up with this particular kangaroo.

That IS being a CF and it is stealing someone else's idea. Makes me think of Burglar Bill - 'that's a nice kangaroo, I'll have that'.

But yeah I know there's FA I can do about it. Some people are shitty. I am grateful that my work sells well and I love what I do, so that's what I need to concentrate on. But it would be nice if people thought about what and who was behind the images they're copying.

OP, I get it, even if quite a startling number of posters here don't seem to. Hmm You explained it very well and clearly here.

OBVIOUSLY the OP isn't complaining about those who copy her work as a one-off for personal use (well she might have been but has made it clear it's the CFs who are copying and then selling on that are the real objects of her ire). It's irritating if someone copies something slavishly that you made, even in 'homage' or as a gift for one person, but that does happen. I once made a gorgeous felt Christmas ornament (and yes, it was inspired by stuff I'd seen on Pinterest! but not directly copied, it was my own design that I'd drawn out a couple of times in rough) and put it on my personal FB, and promptly someone I knew made an EXACT copy in felt, down to the embroidery on it, as (I think) a teacher gift. She wasn't selling it but I had to explain to her that IF I'd ever felt like developing the design (which was mine, though not strikingly original) and selling it online or selling the pattern, then her photos all over FB, Twitter etc wouldn't help matters!

But clearly the OP is talking about an original design she's researched, experimented with, tweaked, changed and developed. These are all stages in designing something. If they're sidestepped by someone going to the end product and ripping it off, for a start you can normally tell as the finished item doesn't really look 'right' (maybe because the person ripping it off hadn't spent all that time developing it) but also, that CF is basically stealing all the time and skill and effort you spent in developing your item, as well as the look of the finished design!

I'm a crafter. I do a lot (knitting etc) for fun/pastimes but I do also design and make jewellery, and also decorative items in a medium I'm not naming because it's searchable! There is someone I know slightly in the immediate area who has made these for a lot longer than me. I always wanted to make them and started over the lockdown. I do now sell them in a very limited way. She's been quite prickly about it and turned up at a recent 'open house' thing and almost told me to stop it - despite our styles being very different (and modes of manufacture too - I take a lot of time on mine and she's said in the past she goes for the 'fast and furious' mode of production for her bread and butter pieces. It shows, but I suspect most customers don't notice or care. She can make 5 pieces for one or two of mine of comparable size, so my business plan is crap! 😂 ) Anyway, I try really really hard with this new 'line' of items to make them as different in details from those I see on Instagram etc. It's hard. Everyone makes these items in the following shapes (which sell) - hearts, birds, stars Grin (god this is sounding properly naff!) so if I want to do those, I do try to make them different. It's a design challenge to keep different and keep flexible and ahead of the game, and that's something that a CF who rips things off just doesn't get.

The posters who are saying 'well if you post your things online to sell with photos, you only have yourself to blame' can get in the sea. Hmm It is WRONG to steal someone else's idea for profit. If you sell online it makes you very vulnerable, but that isn't an open invitation for CFs to rip you off.

Flufferblub · 07/08/2023 20:50

There's nothing new under the sun

Fightwithmyface · 07/08/2023 20:45

OhcantthInkofaname · 06/08/2023 23:14

No you weren't...

she so was 😂

Platypuslover · 07/08/2023 14:13

I would also like to point out it is highly possible to come up with the same idea completely independently.

For example the periodic system of elements. 2 a scientists in different countries came up with almost the same at pretty much the same time.

However Edison was a thief, he stole the ideas of his employees and this is to this day being perpetrated by employers via an unethical contract. Those contracts state anything the employee comes up with during employment belongs to the employer. Pretty standard in science, and engineering. Similar contracts apply today to musicians as well. It’s exploitation of the creatives.

Platypuslover · 07/08/2023 14:07

You can not copyright an idea!

So copying something that is a physical item from a picture means it is legal. You are in breach of copyright if they use the original picture or steal and resell the physical or digital pattern. If they make a new pattern from an idea they got from a picture of something that is again legal.

However copyright is not automatic. The onus is on you to proof you made it first or properly file a copyright or patent.

Toomuchtrouble4me · 07/08/2023 12:51

Giggorata · 04/08/2023 23:24

I think I agree with the OP.
Designs for original art and craft works belong to their creator.
Having cheap imitations and knock offs must be infuriating.
I am also surprised that so many people disagree and are suggesting that her original works are not all that original. Ouch.

But how do you know they are cheap imitations? Maybe copied and improved?
it’s normal in business - and healthy, otherwise there would only ever be Ford cars and Hoover vacuum cleaners.

T1Dmama · 07/08/2023 07:52

Of course it’s not theft…. They’ve seen your design and then come up with their own pattern for it… it’s not like they’ve stolen your pattern.

KM123456 · 07/08/2023 03:50

You are not being unreasonable at all, but good luck in trying to get people to understand the value of intellectual property. You see it everywhere, with tee shirt and poster/print makers flagrantly copying someone else's art and cutting them.out of the profits. Maybe you can hire a web designer/computer professional to help you figure out a way to display your designs yet make them very difficult to copy. Good luck.

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 06/08/2023 23:27

XenoBitch · 06/08/2023 23:19

Reminds me of the time that I did a lot of Zentangle, and also cross stitch. I thought I had genuinely invented something by combing the two... Nope! It is called blackwork and has been around since medieval times!

Yeah. I’ve done black work

XenoBitch · 06/08/2023 23:19

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 06/08/2023 19:04

Or in terms of embroidery or tapestry it could be a 19th century design

Reminds me of the time that I did a lot of Zentangle, and also cross stitch. I thought I had genuinely invented something by combing the two... Nope! It is called blackwork and has been around since medieval times!

OhcantthInkofaname · 06/08/2023 23:14

AnneAnon · 05/08/2023 00:13

Oh relax I was just joking

No you weren't...

Willyoujustbequiet · 06/08/2023 21:56

CatMum27 · 05/08/2023 16:31

Lots of misunderstandings about copyright on this thread. As someone who works in copyright I can tell you that if you copy someone else’s original work then yes you are in breach of the rules and there is always “something they can do about it”. There are two main sets of rights in copyright- the right to make money and the right to be identified as the creator. It makes no difference whether you make money from it or not, although publicly sharing something makes you easier to catch. in copying you are taking away the right of the creator to make money from their work as you are not purchasing the original from the creator. And you’re probably not crediting them either! Fair use does not apply. It’s a defence to be used in court, not blanket permission to do what you want. It means you are allowed to use a PORTION of a copyrighted work as long as the use is fair and reasonable. Unfortunately there is no exact specification as to amount but copying the whole thing is definitely not fair use.

A copyright owner is always within their rights to take action but practically they are not always able to. Those who are old enough will remember recording films from the tv or songs from the radio. This was illegal as it breached copyright - you weren’t buying the DVD if you were recording it from the tv for free. Copyright owners were hardly likely to have the time or resources to track down everyone who did it though. Same with World Book Day. You can copy costumes instead of buying official ones but technically you are still breaking the law. Highly unlikely people are going to sue you ... but they could if they wanted to.

OP - I’m sorry this is happening to you. I’ve had something similar and it sucks. Ignorance of the law is no excuse but one which is often used. If you want to take things further try something like Citizens Advice or the local library (if there is one left). They often have lists of legal professionals who will give you limited free legal advice and may also be able to point towards further sources of help.

I guess the crux is proving that work is original in the first place?

I've seen a lot of work claim to be original but it's not. We don't know if the Op's is in fact.

LadyPoison · 06/08/2023 21:03

EpidermalLayer · 06/08/2023 20:49

That makes sense! Although I don't think these are cast - they said each piece is handmade ('carved') and so is unique as they cannot get the exact same twig all the time. That sounds like what you term as 'fabricated', although I supposed they decided not to overload me with technical terms. I've seen a lot on Etsy but normally shops that also sells costume jewellery and all sorts as well.

As a PP have said even if copyright was breached I doubt that people have the time, nor the inclination to take them to court. It wouldn't bring them much revenue anyway, as long as people buy their stock and not 'competitors' they're good to go.

It sounds then like they are carving a twig from wax then and having it cast. Yes each will then be a one off unless they have a mould made. Sorry fabrication is making from scratch with silver wire and sheet. You can make some lovely twigs that way too!

EpidermalLayer · 06/08/2023 20:49

LadyPoison · 06/08/2023 20:13

The casting of twigs into precious metals is what most beginner smiths do sooner or later. I haven't myself but it's crossed my mind and I will probably do so at some point but as I prefer fabrication to casting, it's not a priority. It's not a unique idea at all. I've seen dozens made into necklaces, all slightly different but substantially the same.

That one will be unique as it will be made from one particular twig. If I was to do one, I would use another twig. Both will be unique as the twigs differ but the idea itself is far from unique, although the results will be very similar. As I understand it, if I was to cast an exact copy from that ring I would be breaching copyright, however if I use my own twig then I will not.

That makes sense! Although I don't think these are cast - they said each piece is handmade ('carved') and so is unique as they cannot get the exact same twig all the time. That sounds like what you term as 'fabricated', although I supposed they decided not to overload me with technical terms. I've seen a lot on Etsy but normally shops that also sells costume jewellery and all sorts as well.

As a PP have said even if copyright was breached I doubt that people have the time, nor the inclination to take them to court. It wouldn't bring them much revenue anyway, as long as people buy their stock and not 'competitors' they're good to go.

LadyPoison · 06/08/2023 20:13

EpidermalLayer · 06/08/2023 19:28

Currently shopping for wedding rings and most designs are variations on a theme. A mobius strip shaped ring for example - you can find thousands that look exactly the same online. Here's an example:
https://www.jacquelineandedward.com/product/the-laggan-ethical-18ct-gold-wedding-ring-with-single-twist/ 

The below however is unique:
https://www.jacquelineandedward.com/product/the-balwoges-18ct-gold-oak-twig-wedding-ring/

So would the jeweller be able to claim copyright for the second, not the first? @CatMum27

@LadyPoison There are lots of silver mushrooms but if you did, say a mushroom with a fairy on top. Or a mushroom with various flowers, that nobody else has the cases might be clearer cut. I follow quite a few artists (not silver smiths though) and as PP said their work has a certain style, I'd be able to recognise it anywhere

Btw hubs-to-be wants a silver hip flask so if you do those feel free to DM me your page

The casting of twigs into precious metals is what most beginner smiths do sooner or later. I haven't myself but it's crossed my mind and I will probably do so at some point but as I prefer fabrication to casting, it's not a priority. It's not a unique idea at all. I've seen dozens made into necklaces, all slightly different but substantially the same.

That one will be unique as it will be made from one particular twig. If I was to do one, I would use another twig. Both will be unique as the twigs differ but the idea itself is far from unique, although the results will be very similar. As I understand it, if I was to cast an exact copy from that ring I would be breaching copyright, however if I use my own twig then I will not.

Darlingx · 06/08/2023 19:59

I used to make a joke at College that u need to work in a workman’s builders tent because one would start using a technique or material then others in the class would get inspired . It was annoying seeing as it was degree level but an entree into the issues of the creative world. In order to sell it you have to display it and well once seen could be copied by a manufacturer from overseas. I made jewellery for Japanese dept store high end one. Topshop copied my design must have seen it in Japan so was instore in UK. I made a gift for a friend she put it into production copied it and was selling to boutiques it was my unique design and then when I had a label a bigger designer brand copied my design to precision except they changed the fabric . This was literally the next season . Then finally someone copied my entire concept and even lifted my ethos for my designs word for word for their website selling the copies. Literally by raising the profile of what I was doing I just got copied even more. It made me decide to see it as someone taking my design down a different avenue and watching where they went with it because they were always bigger more monied and more successful so it would have been David versus Goliath. Heard of one designer who challenged M& S over pant design she came from family money so could go the legal route with all the costs she won and they had to burn all the stock . Then years later looking through a 60s lingerie annual same keyhole with bow at back pants thaf designer sued for being her design is anything ever original? Even perhaps we are absorbing what we see into our subconscious unaware where later inspiration came from but just lifting your idea and selling is another hurdle creatives don’t need its tough as it is trying to survive . You have my sympathy and hope u find a solution to protect your designs 🤞

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 06/08/2023 19:51

ArticSaviour · 06/08/2023 19:34

Surely you mean Kangaroomigumi?

😂

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 06/08/2023 19:47

Fightwithmyface · 06/08/2023 19:21

Ha, this reminds me of a time a woman demanded I remove an item of jewellery from my website as she was the original inventor of this type of jewellery and I was stealing her idea. I sent her a link to an example of a 15th century one in the British Museum 😂

😀loving it

Swipe left for the next trending thread