Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Biological truth should be taught to children?

168 replies

Tryingmuchharder · 04/08/2023 20:19

AIBU for thinking that biological truth should be taught to children rather than trans ideology.... men can give birth, people can change sex, etc etc.

A teacher was suspended and appealed and recently his appealed was overturned. He was sacked for 'misgendering' a girl by calling her a girl rather than a boy. He taught biological fact and not ideology so was sacked.

Surely biological facts should be taught to our children? AIBU

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Gerrataere · 05/08/2023 08:45

The mental health of my DD's flatmate was so fragile that any removal of support could have led to much deeper problems.

So instead of dealing with mental health issues that were evidently so severe that even referring to the person in a truthful manner could cause (presumably) a meltdown, the whole of society has to tiptoe around this person so not to trigger them? In any other circumstances this would be considered shitty, controlling behaviour - ‘I’m reacting badly because of you’ is never acceptable unless one is being put through genuine abuse. Referring to a biological female as the ‘she’ she is is not abuse.

NotBadConsidering · 05/08/2023 08:45

Facilitating children’s self delusion about their self is one of the biggest failures of our modern times. It wouldn’t be so bad if it was as harmless as stupid pronouns, but teenage girls are getting their breasts cut off because no one has the ability to tell them they can’t change their sex.

Anyone who supports preferred pronouns is tacitly supporting mastectomies.

nolongersurprised · 05/08/2023 08:28

Essentially, Ocaptain, you’re back to #bekind.

Yet teen girls have watched that lead to the loss of single sex spaces, sport and the language they use to describe themselves.

Gender ideology has hurt women and girls the most, and yes, it’s fair that they push back. And the 107 genders is funny - if you believe in them all, could you name them?

nolongersurprised · 05/08/2023 08:20

OCaptain · 05/08/2023 08:08

@nolongersurprised

And yes, this incident took place, and no, my DD’s team didn’t use the preferred pronouns, which included Xir, Xie 🙄. They got on fine with speaker 1/2/3 and referring to “the affirmative”.

I'm sorry. I'm believing this less and less.

But, as a thought experiment, what would have happened, do you think, if an obviously female child was called she rather than Xie? I would guess - not much 🤷‍♀️

If that was a chosen pronoun, that child would be deeply offended and hurt. But you've demonstrated already that doesn't bother you.

One of the former flatmates of my DD - a female - went by the pronouns they/them. My DD always referred to her correctly and even corrected me when I slipped up as she knew how important it was to her flatmate's mental and emotional health.

With any particular person, these things may or may not last. While they do last, though, I think it's important to simply support that person as you would anyone else. The mental health of my DD's flatmate was so fragile that any removal of support could have led to much deeper problems.

Why would I care if you believed it, or not?

While they do last, though, I think it's important to simply support that person as you would anyone else. The mental health of my DD's flatmate was so fragile that any removal of support could have led to much deeper problems

Why does lying about someone’s sex help them? Everyone pretending a woman isn’t a woman doesn’t protect a female from biological reality.

And again, we’re back to compelled speech. Your DD’s friend is saying - pretend I’m not female or my mental health will get worse. How does going along with their delusion help them in the long run? Would you agree with the delusions that other mentally unwell people may have, or just when it comes to “gender”.

EarringsandLipstick · 05/08/2023 08:20

If that was a chosen pronoun, that child would be deeply offended and hurt.

No. I'm not prepared to use made up language to avoid 'offence or hurt' to anyone. Zie / Zer is nonsense.

The PP's DD & her teammates approached it sensibly - they avoided using any pronouns so no offence was caused.

In your they / them example, I've been in this position with someone working briefly on my team. They were lovely, and of course I didn't want to cause upset. In reality, there were very few occasions that I needed to use they / them. On those occasions, it did in fact cause confusion as it assumed a plural that was confusing. We managed & it was ok but it did make it clear to me that it subverts the meaning of language and is problematic.

OCaptain · 05/08/2023 08:08

@nolongersurprised

And yes, this incident took place, and no, my DD’s team didn’t use the preferred pronouns, which included Xir, Xie 🙄. They got on fine with speaker 1/2/3 and referring to “the affirmative”.

I'm sorry. I'm believing this less and less.

But, as a thought experiment, what would have happened, do you think, if an obviously female child was called she rather than Xie? I would guess - not much 🤷‍♀️

If that was a chosen pronoun, that child would be deeply offended and hurt. But you've demonstrated already that doesn't bother you.

One of the former flatmates of my DD - a female - went by the pronouns they/them. My DD always referred to her correctly and even corrected me when I slipped up as she knew how important it was to her flatmate's mental and emotional health.

With any particular person, these things may or may not last. While they do last, though, I think it's important to simply support that person as you would anyone else. The mental health of my DD's flatmate was so fragile that any removal of support could have led to much deeper problems.

bellac11 · 05/08/2023 07:58

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

bellac11 · 05/08/2023 07:51

Cucucucu · 04/08/2023 23:13

Do you really think children don’t know the facts ? My 7 year old knows how babies are made and what a biological men and woman are , she also knows some people are not happy with their gender and choose to identify and live as the other . She really is nit confused about anything . I think everyone is worried with something that really is getting to much attention due to everyone’s fixation on the subject

So she thinks that someone has a 'gender' which is seemingly affixed to their sex and if they're not happy with that, they choose to live as another 'sex'

Thats not really accurate though. Everyone can wear what they want, act how they want (within legal and social parameters), name themselves what they want, but they are still the sex they are.

EhrlicheFrau · 05/08/2023 07:42

@Tryingmuchharder what you (think you) mean by 'biological facts' exactly?
I ask because it's a term which is commonly misused/misunderstood.

nolongersurprised · 05/08/2023 07:41

OCaptain · 05/08/2023 06:18

@nolongersurprised

They don’t think children can change sex, and vehemently disagree with compelled speech.

They're correct in the "children can't change sex" opinion - and that isn't even an opinion. It's a fact. No-one can can change their biological identity. However, they can change their gender.

With regards to controlled speech, are you referring to pronouns? If this incident actually took place, did your DD's team refuse to refer to the other side by their preferred pronouns?

And no, I don't think I'd be proud of my DD laughing at other people in the way you describe.

And yes, this incident took place, and no, my DD’s team didn’t use the preferred pronouns, which included Xir, Xie 🙄. They got on fine with speaker 1/2/3 and referring to “the affirmative”.

But, as a thought experiment, what would have happened, do you think, if an obviously female child was called she rather than Xie? I would guess - not much 🤷‍♀️

MariaVT65 · 05/08/2023 07:35

Yes my son isn’t quite school age yet but I will be keeping a close eye on what he’s eventually taught.

My personal view is that I should not have to accept or play along with someone else’s view that they have changed their gender. The reason for this is that for example, if a male says they are female, they are trying to cover up the reason why ultimately, I would not be comfortable to share certain situations or spaces with them ie their sex.

nolongersurprised · 05/08/2023 07:14

OCaptain · 05/08/2023 06:18

@nolongersurprised

They don’t think children can change sex, and vehemently disagree with compelled speech.

They're correct in the "children can't change sex" opinion - and that isn't even an opinion. It's a fact. No-one can can change their biological identity. However, they can change their gender.

With regards to controlled speech, are you referring to pronouns? If this incident actually took place, did your DD's team refuse to refer to the other side by their preferred pronouns?

And no, I don't think I'd be proud of my DD laughing at other people in the way you describe.

Gender is a load of bollox though, isn’t it. How many are there now? 70?

How can kids NOT laugh at the stupidity of it all? They know who the boys and girls are

Annaishere · 05/08/2023 06:58

You just have to be the one to tell your children the truth

Flibbertigibbettytoes · 05/08/2023 06:57

fullbloom87 · 05/08/2023 02:57

I think Disney parades are for CHILDREN and should remain being about characters from Disney movies not about sexuality or gender/sex confusion.

Yeah it's for CHILDREN and those movies definitely do not feature older characters in romantic (ie sexual) relationships 🙄

WoopDeDoo · 05/08/2023 06:54

OCaptain · 05/08/2023 06:18

@nolongersurprised

They don’t think children can change sex, and vehemently disagree with compelled speech.

They're correct in the "children can't change sex" opinion - and that isn't even an opinion. It's a fact. No-one can can change their biological identity. However, they can change their gender.

With regards to controlled speech, are you referring to pronouns? If this incident actually took place, did your DD's team refuse to refer to the other side by their preferred pronouns?

And no, I don't think I'd be proud of my DD laughing at other people in the way you describe.

What is "gender"?

loislovesstewie · 05/08/2023 06:49

As a certain India W thinks they now have a cervix, apparently, I think it's essential that everyone understands biological facts.

OCaptain · 05/08/2023 06:18

@nolongersurprised

They don’t think children can change sex, and vehemently disagree with compelled speech.

They're correct in the "children can't change sex" opinion - and that isn't even an opinion. It's a fact. No-one can can change their biological identity. However, they can change their gender.

With regards to controlled speech, are you referring to pronouns? If this incident actually took place, did your DD's team refuse to refer to the other side by their preferred pronouns?

And no, I don't think I'd be proud of my DD laughing at other people in the way you describe.

nolongersurprised · 05/08/2023 03:58

LiOLeary · 05/08/2023 00:07

Take your half-researched, sensational thoughts off to the Gender forum.

Please show me the research that demonstrates people can change sex

nolongersurprised · 05/08/2023 03:32

*proud, not rapid!

nolongersurprised · 05/08/2023 03:30

OCaptain · 05/08/2023 02:11

@nolongersurprised

One of my daughters does debating and after they won they were (privately) mercilessly taking the piss of a school they debated where no one’s sex marched their pronouns. A few years ago they wouldn’t have laughed.

How lovely and mature of your daughter and the rest of the debating team. I'd suggest acceptance is the healthier road here. The people in the other team were hurting no-one.

They don’t think children can change sex, and vehemently disagree with compelled speech.

#bekind in this setting has done untold damage to women’s rights to same sex spaces, sports and even language.

Gender ideology is deeply damaging and hurtful to girls and women. I am rapid of her for appreciating this at a young age.

Someoneonlyyouknow · 05/08/2023 03:14

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 05/08/2023 00:04

Depends on the child. The lessons get more content the older the children get and it can confuse some children

Well some children are confused by the 8 times table, or the metric system, or foreign languages or European history. Even reading can be difficult if you are dyslexic or not supported adequately. Are you saying nothing should ever be taught that might "confuse some children"?

fullbloom87 · 05/08/2023 02:57

SometimesMaybe · 04/08/2023 22:55

I think that children should be told biological truth and I also have no issue with LGBTQ+ being recognised at a Disney parade.
I think we need to step back from the wide divisive positions and consider that the majority of people think
a) womans safe spaces need to be protected and sex is real, and
b) lgbtq+ individuals are also a marginalised section of society and if they want to walk down a street waving their flag then that isn’t hurting anyone

I think Disney parades are for CHILDREN and should remain being about characters from Disney movies not about sexuality or gender/sex confusion.

fullbloom87 · 05/08/2023 02:53

Speaking with my 13 year old daughter on this topic and she said that her school does teach biological truth and that it's social media that pushes this agenda as well as her peers who don't have parents that talk to them and are too busy.
I have noticed a big correlation myself amongst my daughters friends that when their parents are busy with work a lot and socialising etc that they're more likely to be influenced by the internet and other kids.
Our children have always spoken to us and spent a lot of time with us, so we've been able to have open discussions about these things and as a result they haven't fallen for it.
They're definitely more PC then we are but they've not been 'captured' just perhaps a little more immune to it.

WandaWonder · 05/08/2023 02:44

I can identify as a horse if I wanted too doesn't mean I am one or that people can't think I have lost my marbles but I see it as the new mods, rockers, punks just a trend that in 10/20 years it will move on to some other thing that people think they are the first ones to think up till the next generation finds the next thing

Swipe left for the next trending thread