Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Biological truth should be taught to children?

168 replies

Tryingmuchharder · 04/08/2023 20:19

AIBU for thinking that biological truth should be taught to children rather than trans ideology.... men can give birth, people can change sex, etc etc.

A teacher was suspended and appealed and recently his appealed was overturned. He was sacked for 'misgendering' a girl by calling her a girl rather than a boy. He taught biological fact and not ideology so was sacked.

Surely biological facts should be taught to our children? AIBU

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
thedancingbear · 05/08/2023 10:09

ToWhitToWhoo · 05/08/2023 00:05

This was not about 'biological truth'; it was about the teacher pushing his Christian Right ideological views onto the pupils: on several occasions, and at two different schools.

He told pupils that he was against gay marriage; he told them that Muslims are following 'a false prophet'; and he showed them a PragerU video, which included such statements as:

'(i) The growing problem in today’s society is that men are not masculine enough;
ii. When men deny their masculinity, they run away from responsibilities leaving destruction and devastation in their wake;
iii. Children who grow up without a father are generally more depressed than their peers who have a mother and father. They are at a far greater risk of incarceration, teen pregnancy, and poverty. 71% of High School dropouts are fatherless;
iv. Woman want real men…I don’t know any woman of any age who is attracted to a passive man who looks to her to be his provider, protector, and leader;
v. Passive men don’t defend, protect, or provide. Passive men do not lead'

And Mr. Sutcliffe was a maths teacher, not a teacher of religious studies, or any subject where expressing these views could have been remotely relevant to a topic being taught.

In the case of the trans pupil, it wasn't just a matter of offending the pupil, but revealing the pupil's trans status to others who had not previously been informed.

Meh. You can prove anything with facts. We’re not interested.

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 05/08/2023 10:09

jeaux90 · 05/08/2023 10:07

@Tomorrowillbeachicken they are still female so yes. A trans identifying boy would not be because he's male.

But wants to be treated as a boy, so ineligible for entry as the boy they want to be?

it’s like the cat thing, a cat can’t have a place at a school… they are a cat

jeaux90 · 05/08/2023 10:07

@Tomorrowillbeachicken they are still female so yes. A trans identifying boy would not be because he's male.

Createausername1970 · 05/08/2023 10:06

nolongersurprised · 04/08/2023 22:46

You reckon?

I have 4 children, the oldest is 17. A few years ago they accepted gender ideology unquestioningly, now they think (and express) that’s it’s a load of made up crap. As a fad, I think it’s dying.

This has been my experience. My DS was at various times "gay" or "pan sexual" according to him when he was around 14 - 17. Now, at 21, he is definitely heterosexual and is slightly embarrassed about what he said on social media.

Plus, a friend of his - born female, wanted to be a boy at 13, even started taking medication to halt periods etc., is now very definitely identifying as female again, is engaged to be married to a male and expecting her first child.

That age group has so much hormonal upheaval to deal with, it's a time of change, becoming more of the adult they will be, rather than the child they were. It can be a confusing and scary time for some and a bit of escapism is common, it's just got rather out of hand.

I agree people should be allowed to be be who they are, but they shouldn't be pressured into being what they aren't. It's a fine line to cross.

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 05/08/2023 10:05

jeaux90 · 05/08/2023 10:00

Youth are staying to see this for what it is, absolute nonsense.

My DD14 doesn't care and her school doesn't teach gender ideology. It's an all girls school and if one of them said they were a transman, I would not allow my DD to be gaslighted into call them he.

She is ASD so truth is very important to her.

Would they still be eligible to be there as a boy?

Screamingabdabz · 05/08/2023 10:02

OCaptain · 05/08/2023 02:11

@nolongersurprised

One of my daughters does debating and after they won they were (privately) mercilessly taking the piss of a school they debated where no one’s sex marched their pronouns. A few years ago they wouldn’t have laughed.

How lovely and mature of your daughter and the rest of the debating team. I'd suggest acceptance is the healthier road here. The people in the other team were hurting no-one.

The ideology is hurting women. Laughing at it and taking the piss out of people who are earnestly enslaved and brainwashed by this insidious cult it is the most healthy and ‘mature’ thing young people can do.

Gerrataere · 05/08/2023 10:01

Her gender issues weren't the primary reason for her poor mental health, though they may have contributed to it.

Her gender issues are because she has undealt with MH issues and very likely neurodivergent. Every young person who identifies differently from their sex falls under one of three categories - has suffered mental trauma in childhood, has ND/autistic traits that haven’t been supported sufficiently or are same sex attracted and have internalised homophobia (usually due to parents/peers). All young people who ID as trans will have been let down severely at some point with their well-being, but the whole trans movement is so built up around the ‘Be Kind Or Else’ train of thought that accepting that we must all instantly change the way we recognise the two human sexes is like putting a plaster over a bullet wound.

If mental health care for young people (especially ND ones) actually was a functional part of health care, a lot of this ‘107 genders’ idea would have stayed on Tumblr 20 odd years ago where it started…

jeaux90 · 05/08/2023 10:00

Youth are staying to see this for what it is, absolute nonsense.

My DD14 doesn't care and her school doesn't teach gender ideology. It's an all girls school and if one of them said they were a transman, I would not allow my DD to be gaslighted into call them he.

She is ASD so truth is very important to her.

nolongersurprised · 05/08/2023 09:57

miniaturepixieonacid · 05/08/2023 09:51

@OCaptain Yes, that was my point earlier in the thread. That we can't change this new ideology because the younger generations totally accept it. But it seems not all do.

As a teacher of performing arts, you’re seeing a very non representative sample though 😀. In the same way that child psychologists/paediatricians and psychiatrists are seeing a huge spike in autistic girls saying they are boys.

In my children’s school rhe “non-binary” girls are the musical, creative ones who 💯 would have been the goths when I was a child, and the punks before that and the emos afterwards.

NotBadConsidering · 05/08/2023 09:55

Loads of kids think it’s nonsense. You only have to look at that video of those teenagers who caught their teacher telling them they need to be nice and telling them off for not complying with the ideology. More and more kids are cottoning on and saying no. It’s great.

bellac11 · 05/08/2023 09:52

OCaptain · 05/08/2023 09:42

@miniaturepixieonacid

One of my pupils was telling me recently about a student in her brother's year who is gender fluid. They are not permanently male, female or non binary. I asked how that works and she said the studebt wears a pink bracelet on days they want to be a 'she', a blue for 'he' days and a purple for 'they' days. All related without a hint of incredulity or mockery - just seen as another interesting facet on gender expression.

And isn't it interesting that you say "without a hint of incredulity or mockery" - that's because most kids don't care as much as adults appear to do. That one of the reasons I doubt nolongersurprised's story about the laughing debaters. Younger people don't have as much judgement or bring the weight of history and ideology into it.

@bellac11 @Gerrataere

Then her mental health needed to be treated appropriately so that she didnt feel the need to harm/kill herself at someone referring to her as she.

Her gender issues weren't the primary reason for her poor mental health, though they may have contributed to it. It is true at the time I - and my DD - felt her to highly manipulative and threatened certain things to get her own way. However, that doesn't mean doing one thing to help a person stay alive is a negative action.

She was receiving extensive outside assistance with her mental health.

Im sure you think you mean well, but just listen to the words you use

'doing one thing to help a person stay alive'

Really, what one thing can a human do (not withstanding being a medic performing life saving surgery or CPR type of thing) can someone do to prevent someone killing themselves.

You're right to say that the MH of someone saying they struggle with gender is not about the 'gender' at all, they are usually people who have experienced a trauma background, usually involving sexual abuse from an opposite sex perpetrator, usually either having an ASD diagnosis or ASD traits which are undiagnosed at the time. Struggling with MH because they feel disconnected to society, themselves and peers.
That is what the treatment should be about but instead if gets mixed up with a random off tangent concept (gender) and all focus goes on this.

miniaturepixieonacid · 05/08/2023 09:51

@OCaptain Yes, that was my point earlier in the thread. That we can't change this new ideology because the younger generations totally accept it. But it seems not all do.

nolongersurprised · 05/08/2023 09:50

I agree though that it still seems prominent in teens in the performing arts, with poor mental health and in autistic girls.

nolongersurprised · 05/08/2023 09:48

Younger people don't have as much judgement or bring the weight of history and ideology into it

You underestimate them. Your DD may have bought into it, but it’s a dying ideology. Largely because it’s so silly. Young people know what sex they are and for many teens now, the 107 genders is something to laugh at.

RufustheFactualReindeer · 05/08/2023 09:44

LiOLeary · 05/08/2023 00:07

Take your half-researched, sensational thoughts off to the Gender forum.

There isn’t a gender board so I assume you mean the feminism board

i do wonder sometimes if there should be a gender board 🤔 not sure how busy it would get

OCaptain · 05/08/2023 09:42

@miniaturepixieonacid

One of my pupils was telling me recently about a student in her brother's year who is gender fluid. They are not permanently male, female or non binary. I asked how that works and she said the studebt wears a pink bracelet on days they want to be a 'she', a blue for 'he' days and a purple for 'they' days. All related without a hint of incredulity or mockery - just seen as another interesting facet on gender expression.

And isn't it interesting that you say "without a hint of incredulity or mockery" - that's because most kids don't care as much as adults appear to do. That one of the reasons I doubt nolongersurprised's story about the laughing debaters. Younger people don't have as much judgement or bring the weight of history and ideology into it.

@bellac11 @Gerrataere

Then her mental health needed to be treated appropriately so that she didnt feel the need to harm/kill herself at someone referring to her as she.

Her gender issues weren't the primary reason for her poor mental health, though they may have contributed to it. It is true at the time I - and my DD - felt her to highly manipulative and threatened certain things to get her own way. However, that doesn't mean doing one thing to help a person stay alive is a negative action.

She was receiving extensive outside assistance with her mental health.

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 05/08/2023 09:33

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Tbf it’s done en the government as it’s in the curriculum they are forced to teach

Beautiful3 · 05/08/2023 09:31

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

nolongersurprised · 05/08/2023 09:31

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

It’s great how threads evolve though, isn’t it?

FiddleLeaf · 05/08/2023 09:29

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

nolongersurprised · 05/08/2023 09:26

One of my pupils was telling me recently about a student in her brother's year who is gender fluid. They are not permanently male, female or non binary. I asked how that works and she said the studebt wears a pink bracelet on days they want to be a 'she', a blue for 'he' days and a purple for 'they' days. All related without a hint of incredulity or mockery - just seen as another interesting facet on gender expression

It’s so funny how they end up reverting to regressive gender stereotypes😀. How exhausting for everyone

BravoMyDear · 05/08/2023 09:25

Cosyblankets · 04/08/2023 22:16

Hope this link works
This is the hearing that led to the prohibition order
Kids make stuff up all the time. Teachers are not struck off for no reason

Link

Wow! What an arsehole, I’m glad he was struck off.

miniaturepixieonacid · 05/08/2023 09:13

nolongersurprised 's story sounds totally plausible to me. Have you read recent YA fiction? No reason why you should have if you don't work with young people but authors like Juno Dawson (herself a transwoman, I think) and Clare Hennessey are almost an eyeroll a page in some books. But it's all expressed as totally normal. Many young people and younger adults (perhaps the more alternative and artistic ones as nolonger says) live this new (or nonsensical depending on your views) reality fully every day. And she did say her daughter laughed privately, not at the other team.

One of my pupils was telling me recently about a student in her brother's year who is gender fluid. They are not permanently male, female or non binary. I asked how that works and she said the studebt wears a pink bracelet on days they want to be a 'she', a blue for 'he' days and a purple for 'they' days. All related without a hint of incredulity or mockery - just seen as another interesting facet on gender expression.

nolongersurprised · 05/08/2023 08:59

I'm sorry. I'm believing this less and less

To be fair, the local high school debating scene is fiercely competitive and the teens are quick thinkers and intelligent and usually don’t subscribe to gender woo. I can see why it seems unlikely. However, the pronoun team weren’t very good, and didn’t progress to the knock out stage

bellac11 · 05/08/2023 08:51

OCaptain · 05/08/2023 08:08

@nolongersurprised

And yes, this incident took place, and no, my DD’s team didn’t use the preferred pronouns, which included Xir, Xie 🙄. They got on fine with speaker 1/2/3 and referring to “the affirmative”.

I'm sorry. I'm believing this less and less.

But, as a thought experiment, what would have happened, do you think, if an obviously female child was called she rather than Xie? I would guess - not much 🤷‍♀️

If that was a chosen pronoun, that child would be deeply offended and hurt. But you've demonstrated already that doesn't bother you.

One of the former flatmates of my DD - a female - went by the pronouns they/them. My DD always referred to her correctly and even corrected me when I slipped up as she knew how important it was to her flatmate's mental and emotional health.

With any particular person, these things may or may not last. While they do last, though, I think it's important to simply support that person as you would anyone else. The mental health of my DD's flatmate was so fragile that any removal of support could have led to much deeper problems.

Then her mental health needed to be treated appropriately so that she didnt feel the need to harm/kill herself at someone referring to her as she.

That is extreme gross thinking errors in the person that only they are able to overcome with treatment/support. Its not for other people around them to play into a delusion.

Equally it could be seen as highly controlling and manipulative to either tell people or certainly give the impression that if you dont use this language about me, Im going to kill myself and it will be your fault.

Swipe left for the next trending thread