Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Biological truth should be taught to children?

168 replies

Tryingmuchharder · 04/08/2023 20:19

AIBU for thinking that biological truth should be taught to children rather than trans ideology.... men can give birth, people can change sex, etc etc.

A teacher was suspended and appealed and recently his appealed was overturned. He was sacked for 'misgendering' a girl by calling her a girl rather than a boy. He taught biological fact and not ideology so was sacked.

Surely biological facts should be taught to our children? AIBU

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
NotBadConsidering · 05/08/2023 12:19

dresses and make up on male bodies.

Can you provide an example of a male in the LGBTQ+ community who wears a dress and make up but describes themselves as man, instead of a woman because of these things?

NotBadConsidering · 05/08/2023 12:16

The LGBTQ+ community is the one showing me hairy pits on female bodies, dresses and make up on male bodies. They are the ones challenging the expectations. They might be using different language, but who cares. The message is be who you are and I can't help but get behind it.

But this is bullshit. The TQ community is telling the world that a female having hairy pits makes them a man. They’re not challenging expectations, they’re reinforcing the stereotypes by applying them rigidly as opposites. They’re not saying “be who you are” at all, haven’t you been paying attention? They’re saying “if this is who you are or how you want to be, it actually makes you this.” There is no one in the LGBTQ+ community role modelling to young girls that they can dress/present how they want and it makes them a normal girl/woman who refuses to conform. They’re all describing themselves as “gender fluid”, “non-binary” or “queer”.

lifeturnsonadime · 05/08/2023 12:16

Social expectations of the sexes may be bullshit that we want to be rid of, but they areverypowerful. I applaud people who are trying to fuck with expectations and experiment.

I think most people who consider themselves gender critical would feel the same.

The issue is that we are supposed to accept this expression means that women/ girls no longer have the right to single sex spaces or sports. I mean a woman was told that there is no single sex rape crisis support in Brighton any more! https://twitter.com/SarahSurviving/status/1586256979822944257

And we're supposed to accept that expression of gender means that teenage/ young adult girls go on to have radical elective mastectomies because their bodies are wrong.

This has gone beyond wear what you want.

https://twitter.com/SarahSurviving/status/1586256979822944257

WandaWonder · 05/08/2023 12:15

A silly made up example but

If I go to work and tell my employers and colleagues I forever want to be addressed as God is that OK?

Or a pigeon or a man on Thursdays but a woman the rest of week? is this all OK?

nolongersurprised · 05/08/2023 12:13

Ladybrrrd · 05/08/2023 12:10

Agender 😀.
#notliketheothergirls

Yeah, as in an agender female/woman. Like you I'm assuming, I don't feel any 'gender', but know my sex, and I say 'agender' as a political choice because I don't believe in gender or gendered things. I don't want the way I dress to be associated with what 'gender' I am. But it's not that important to me and gender is very important to some others.

The whole discussion is fairly new and it's no surprise to me that people are experimenting with what they are called and how they present themselves.
Let's say for example, The vast majority of women for example remove body hair in some way - even if it's only sometimes. They've only VERY recently shown an advert for razors with any visible hair on it! And I've never seen a female lead in a film with any at all. Even women in combat zones or outside civilizations somehow have smooth pits.
What if you're a woman who doesn't want to remove any body hair at all. Doesn't it make sense for those women to look around at what others are doing, and say 'I don't fit in here'?

What if you're a biological male who wants to wear skirts and blouses and look pretty. Do you really expect that society would be kind? Wouldn't the FWR board be calling him a pervert? It makes sense to me that such a person may think 'well real men don't do that/want those things so I'm not a man'.

Social expectations of the sexes may be bullshit that we want to be rid of, but they are very powerful. I applaud people who are trying to fuck with expectations and experiment. The whole point of the message is that sex==gender==presentation. The LGBTQ+ community is the one showing me hairy pits on female bodies, dresses and make up on male bodies. They are the ones challenging the expectations. They might be using different language, but who cares. The message is be who you are and I can't help but get behind it.

As notbad said - we are all agender. You have your sex and you have - in a lengthy way- described your personality

CloudyMcCloud · 05/08/2023 12:12

NotBadConsidering · 05/08/2023 11:57

Repeatedly calling someone by the wrong name, title or pronoun, deliberately, is just in disrespectful. It's also not a delusion. It could be a political rejection of gender - GC by another name! This person could be agender like me.

Wrong name: maybe disrespectful.

Wrong honorific: possibly, if it’s a genuinely earned honorific, but not if someone has claimed an honorific that isn’t correct.

Wrong pronoun: there’s no such thing. 3rd person pronouns are sex-based, always have been and the English-speaking world hasn’t all given our permission to change that rule. So there is only the pronoun that determines the sex of the person being talked about.

A political rejection of gender would subscribe to the realities of sex as a starter, because it’s sex discrimination that determines one’s behaviour.

We are all agender. There’s your sex, and your personality.

I agree with this breakdown

Ladybrrrd · 05/08/2023 12:10

Agender 😀.
#notliketheothergirls

Yeah, as in an agender female/woman. Like you I'm assuming, I don't feel any 'gender', but know my sex, and I say 'agender' as a political choice because I don't believe in gender or gendered things. I don't want the way I dress to be associated with what 'gender' I am. But it's not that important to me and gender is very important to some others.

The whole discussion is fairly new and it's no surprise to me that people are experimenting with what they are called and how they present themselves.
Let's say for example, The vast majority of women for example remove body hair in some way - even if it's only sometimes. They've only VERY recently shown an advert for razors with any visible hair on it! And I've never seen a female lead in a film with any at all. Even women in combat zones or outside civilizations somehow have smooth pits.
What if you're a woman who doesn't want to remove any body hair at all. Doesn't it make sense for those women to look around at what others are doing, and say 'I don't fit in here'?

What if you're a biological male who wants to wear skirts and blouses and look pretty. Do you really expect that society would be kind? Wouldn't the FWR board be calling him a pervert? It makes sense to me that such a person may think 'well real men don't do that/want those things so I'm not a man'.

Social expectations of the sexes may be bullshit that we want to be rid of, but they are very powerful. I applaud people who are trying to fuck with expectations and experiment. The whole point of the message is that sex==gender==presentation. The LGBTQ+ community is the one showing me hairy pits on female bodies, dresses and make up on male bodies. They are the ones challenging the expectations. They might be using different language, but who cares. The message is be who you are and I can't help but get behind it.

NotBadConsidering · 05/08/2023 11:57

Repeatedly calling someone by the wrong name, title or pronoun, deliberately, is just in disrespectful. It's also not a delusion. It could be a political rejection of gender - GC by another name! This person could be agender like me.

Wrong name: maybe disrespectful.

Wrong honorific: possibly, if it’s a genuinely earned honorific, but not if someone has claimed an honorific that isn’t correct.

Wrong pronoun: there’s no such thing. 3rd person pronouns are sex-based, always have been and the English-speaking world hasn’t all given our permission to change that rule. So there is only the pronoun that determines the sex of the person being talked about.

A political rejection of gender would subscribe to the realities of sex as a starter, because it’s sex discrimination that determines one’s behaviour.

We are all agender. There’s your sex, and your personality.

lifeturnsonadime · 05/08/2023 11:50

And @Ladybrrrd do you think that a teenage boy who decides he is girl gender should use the girls loos, change with teenage girls and stay with the girls on a school residential?

lifeturnsonadime · 05/08/2023 11:47

Ladybrrrd · 05/08/2023 11:43

The heartbreaking irony is that your dd and yourself were doing harm my affirming her delusion. It's not kind and it's not helpful to mental health.

Such utter tosh. Referring to someone as they/them is no more difficult than remembering they've changed their surname or title. It's really not in that hard, and generally people are done if you slip up sometimes. Repeatedly calling someone by the wrong name, title or pronoun, deliberately, is just in disrespectful. It's also not a delusion. It could be a political rejection of gender - GC by another name! This person could be agender like me. (Though I don't care about pronouns)

Anyway where is OP? This was supposed to be about the teacher who was rightly barred from teaching. Is anyone going to concede they were wrong about that or are we just ignoring that point now you've lost?

2 points.

  1. Some people, especially those who are neurodivergent will find it very hard to use they / them or pronouns that are the opposite to those they see with their eyes. Pronouns are not just a matter of respect, they are an acknowledgement that you agree with something that you may not agree with, in other words, you refer to yourself as you wish but expecting others to lie about what they see is compelled speech. They are also not benign when used with children, social transition can be hard to back down from and can lead to harmful future pathways.
  2. This guy may have been rightfully dismissed for things that are not to do with gender. Stop trying to police discussion about the broader point that biological truth should be taught in schools and that belief gender can be harmful to women and children (especially female children).
nolongersurprised · 05/08/2023 11:46

This person could be agender like me. (Though I don't care about pronouns)

Agender 😀.
#notliketheothergirls

Ladybrrrd · 05/08/2023 11:43

The heartbreaking irony is that your dd and yourself were doing harm my affirming her delusion. It's not kind and it's not helpful to mental health.

Such utter tosh. Referring to someone as they/them is no more difficult than remembering they've changed their surname or title. It's really not in that hard, and generally people are done if you slip up sometimes. Repeatedly calling someone by the wrong name, title or pronoun, deliberately, is just in disrespectful. It's also not a delusion. It could be a political rejection of gender - GC by another name! This person could be agender like me. (Though I don't care about pronouns)

Anyway where is OP? This was supposed to be about the teacher who was rightly barred from teaching. Is anyone going to concede they were wrong about that or are we just ignoring that point now you've lost?

OCaptain · 05/08/2023 11:29

@NewNovember

The heartbreaking irony is that your dd and yourself were doing harm my affirming her delusion. It's not kind and it's not helpful to mental health.

I've ignored every other comment about this situation - all of them berating my DD for respecting her flatmate's preference, particularly as her mental health was so tenuous - but this one bothers me. My DD was endlessly kind at the expense of herself. Sometimes I didn't want her to be but I'm proud of her. Don't ever say she was doing harm. She was only doing what she could in a tough situation.

NewNovember · 05/08/2023 10:52

OCaptain · 05/08/2023 08:08

@nolongersurprised

And yes, this incident took place, and no, my DD’s team didn’t use the preferred pronouns, which included Xir, Xie 🙄. They got on fine with speaker 1/2/3 and referring to “the affirmative”.

I'm sorry. I'm believing this less and less.

But, as a thought experiment, what would have happened, do you think, if an obviously female child was called she rather than Xie? I would guess - not much 🤷‍♀️

If that was a chosen pronoun, that child would be deeply offended and hurt. But you've demonstrated already that doesn't bother you.

One of the former flatmates of my DD - a female - went by the pronouns they/them. My DD always referred to her correctly and even corrected me when I slipped up as she knew how important it was to her flatmate's mental and emotional health.

With any particular person, these things may or may not last. While they do last, though, I think it's important to simply support that person as you would anyone else. The mental health of my DD's flatmate was so fragile that any removal of support could have led to much deeper problems.

The heartbreaking irony is that your dd and yourself were doing harm my affirming her delusion. It's not kind and it's not helpful to mental health.

lifeturnsonadime · 05/08/2023 10:47

They're correct in the "children can't change sex" opinion - and that isn't even an opinion. It's a fact. No-one can can change their biological identity. However, they can change theirgender.

What is a gender?

If a boy changes his gender and says he's a girl should he be allowed to be in girls changing rooms and girls accommodation if there is a school residential? What about if he is 14 / 15 when he says he is girl gender?

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 05/08/2023 10:39

Is PSHE still taught by form teachers?

Snugglemonkey · 05/08/2023 10:38

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 05/08/2023 09:33

Tbf it’s done en the government as it’s in the curriculum they are forced to teach

He was supposed to be teaching maths. What part if the maths curriculum has stuff other than maths?

CecilyP · 05/08/2023 10:36

One of the former flatmates of my DD - a female - went by the pronouns they/them. My DD always referred to her correctly and even corrected me when I slipped up as she knew how important it was to her flatmate's mental and emotional health.

So it would affect her flatmate’s mental and emotional health if you referred to her as she when she wasn’t even there? That sounds like exertion an exceptional level of control over other people - even people you barely know!

Snugglemonkey · 05/08/2023 10:25

Tryingmuchharder · 04/08/2023 23:51

What did he say then that was so awful apart from people cannot change sex? Please share?

He is homophobic, is misogynistic and encourages toxic masculinity, has no respect for other religions and no respect for his pupils. He has said lots of awful things that demonstrate the former. He is not someone who should be teaching children.

jeaux90 · 05/08/2023 10:19

@Tomorrowillbeachicken I don't care how people want to be treated, I mean how in earth do you live as a boy or a girl anyway? Cut your hair? Wear trousers? All seems very regressive and stereotypical to me.

Bottom line is it's a single sex school so however the girl wants to identify, she's female.

Theunamedcat · 05/08/2023 10:16

Cucucucu · 04/08/2023 23:13

Do you really think children don’t know the facts ? My 7 year old knows how babies are made and what a biological men and woman are , she also knows some people are not happy with their gender and choose to identify and live as the other . She really is nit confused about anything . I think everyone is worried with something that really is getting to much attention due to everyone’s fixation on the subject

So did mine when she was 7 now she is 23 she is offering up her uterus to anyone who wants it telling them she would have major surgery to feed their fantasy (silly girl won't even have a blood test in reality) she has totally drank the kool aid on this subject

I'm ashamed to say I raised her somedays

It's not that I have anything against trans people I just think life is safer and easier if everyone stays in their lane

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 05/08/2023 10:13

Tryingmuchharder · 04/08/2023 20:21

The sacked teacher is called Joshua Sutcliffe, who taught Mathematics at Oxford’s Cherwell School, had previously been suspended and then dismissed from his duties in 2017 for calling a girl a girl. This week a teaching ‘professional conduct panel’ chose to permanently ban him from teaching.

There is a petition to try to reinstate him but you are not allowed to put links to petitions so I won't.

The madness is pervasive in society.

The hearing was months ago. The decision was published in May.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 05/08/2023 10:11

Here is the original displinary outcome if anyone wants to read it. I don’t know of any feminists who know the facts of this case that think this is a simple misgendering case.

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/teacher-misconduct-panel-outcome-mr-joshua-sutcliffe

Teacher misconduct panel outcome: Mr Joshua Sutcliffe

Professional conduct panel outcome, including decision and reasons.

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/teacher-misconduct-panel-outcome-mr-joshua-sutcliffe

BigButtons · 05/08/2023 10:09

At work this year we had an INSET day and had some bloke come and tell us that we should never refer to a child as girl boy because they might identify as the opposite and we could confuse and damage their mental health. This is primary. What a load of bollocks.

Swipe left for the next trending thread