Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To put a complete ban on buying anything for my children from shops?

90 replies

DustyGlow · 04/08/2023 16:11

DS is 4.5. He is a nightmare in shops!

He gets completely overwhelmed and whips himself up in to a frenzy.

He wants to buy something, and this could be absolutely anything, that alone will calm him down.

We tried to manage it by giving him a small amount of pocket money but he will just search high and low to find something that can be bought for the amount he has. I thought giving pocket money would give him a sense of control but I think he's too young to understand.

He's a bit like a drug addict looking for his next high.

We have very reasonable conversations beforehand. But it all goes to pot. If he kicks off / starts to spiral we leave straight away but it happens every time and sometimes I just need to go in a shop, i can't always avoid them!

I might ban any shop purchases and say he can choose something to save up for and I will get it for him. How can I manage this better?

OP posts:
Rollawaythestone · 04/08/2023 17:46

BoohooWoohoo · 04/08/2023 16:35

Are you and his dad on the same page with this ?

I would put something on the list beforehand that he will like (and you are happy to buy) and if he behaves then buy it and if not then leave it at the shop.

It may take a few goes because it's become a habit but if there's no squash at home and he knows it's because he kicked off yesterday then he will hopefully be motivated to behave. He needs to feel the repercussions of kicking off (no squash)

Is he restrained in a trolley which you shop?

The other tactic is have you considered putting him in a trolley and giving him a device so he doesn't notice his surroundings? This pushes the problem down the line but I often see children in trolleys who are so absorbed by a device that they wouldn't notice their favourite characters doing backflips down the aisles. My son was a nightmare at the supermarket when he was 2 or so and I'm convinced that the lighting made him loopy because his behaviour was very different elsewhere.

I think "restraining" a 4 and a half year old in a trolley is a bit much, even if he would fit in it or be willing to sit in a baby seat. He's not a toddler. Saying no, and sticking to it, is one answer; not taking him shopping at all for a while and giving him a chance to break the pattern, is another and probably the best. I really think he's just a bit too young to understand the concept of being able to afford something, or saving up, but he's really not too old to understand that if he's told he can't have something, he can't have it.

DustyGlow · 04/08/2023 17:46

I do wonder whether there might be some neurodivergence (autism but what used to be called Asperger's). He is a completely delightful and bright child but this is something he really finds difficult. I can reason with him and he says all the right things away from the situation.

I have 2 children, the eldest is absolutely fine in shops, if she was my only child I would be right there with the people saying 'just say no'.

OP posts:
June628 · 04/08/2023 17:33

Sorry OP no advice but I didn’t want to read and run. That sounds really difficult for you and your family. I’d say try not to panic that you’ll never be able to go into a shop again… think of it as a phase that will pass one way or another. Not helpful at the moment I know but it helps me to remind myself of that sometimes when the kids are driving me crazy.

Needmorelego · 04/08/2023 17:30

@DustyGlow seriously for now do a mix of online shopping and just one adult goes to the shops when you need an actual shop for something. The other adult stay home with the children.
My daughter was very similarly obsessed about buying things so I only took her shopping if I was prepared to buy her something.
I didn’t even take her clothes shopping. She outgrew something - just went to Primark or wherever and got something the next size up.
She is 15 now - still obsessed with buying stuff but is more understanding if we say “no” to something and we tend to have a specific plan of going to certain shops only (she is autistic btw).

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 04/08/2023 17:28

calmcoco · 04/08/2023 16:23

If it is as bad as you describe, I think you're being unfair on both him and yourself taking him to shops.

Give him a year off, see if he grows out of it.

Do you religiously stick to a list or do you browse/impulse buy?

But just stop taking him.

This. He doesn't need to be there.

Diddykong · 04/08/2023 17:24

We have a list. DC(4) picks up an item, desperately wants it, so we say "ok maybe we can add it to the list?"

The trick is to make the list sound like it's exclusive and you might not let the item on.

Of course there is no actual list, if there was it would be 9 million items long by now.

Wenfy · 04/08/2023 17:23

DS is 3.5 and I let him buy 2 types of fruit or vegbut only 2 & if he’s good and has no tantrums he gets to pay for them too. It’s fixed the tantrumns and exposed him to different types of food as he insists on eating them that day so it’s a win win lol

jods19 · 04/08/2023 17:21

Have you thought about doing online shopping and getting it delivered?

DustyGlow · 04/08/2023 17:16

Needmorelego · 04/08/2023 17:09

@DustyGlow but if you are both there shopping because you struggle to cope on your own - just send your partner shopping without you. He can do the shop. If he has time to be accompanying you already then you (and child) don’t need to be there.

It was more of a 'let's give up some weekend time to try and crack this' rather than that we all wanted to have the misery of a family shopping trip.

As that would make my life much easier in the long run.

OP posts:
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 04/08/2023 17:10

My DS has a thing about buying something - anything - from the shops. He has ADHD and it makes you seek the high of “getting something”.

He’s 9 and I do try to explain why not at this age as well as just saying “no” because they do deserve explanations as much as adults do

Needmorelego · 04/08/2023 17:09

@DustyGlow but if you are both there shopping because you struggle to cope on your own - just send your partner shopping without you. He can do the shop. If he has time to be accompanying you already then you (and child) don’t need to be there.

Shardonneigghhh · 04/08/2023 17:04

I had this problem but with sweets. With 3 kids nipping in for bread and milk got pricey, plus I didn't want them having so much sugar. So I introduced Friday treat, where they got a £1 each to spend as they liked. Every time they asked for sweets I would say "is it Friday?" They soon got the hang of it.

QuietDragon · 04/08/2023 17:00

Is he like this on other situations OP?

It sounds like you've tried a lot of different strategies and his reactions seem extreme.

DustyGlow · 04/08/2023 16:56

Ok, will go for a blanket no for everything. And try the photo idea. I also like the food bank idea.

The reason why we both take him is because it is so hard. I find it difficult to manage both kids alone due to this so we had an effort to break the behaviour, essentially trying to shop with strategies to help. So I could go out with them alone. I can't live my life never going into a shop. I work part time so it makes sense for me to go out to pick up essentials on my day off.

But we have now started online supermarket shopping.

We tried for ages. All the people saying we just said no, believe me, we did. He had never been allowed to buy toys etc.

I also tried the shopping list thing but it would all kick off if something wasn't available. I remember someone sniggering behind me as my tiny child sobbed 'but mummy, we will just have to cope with this salmon'

OP posts:
staroftheday · 04/08/2023 16:53

I think the OP has most probably of said No, but for some children No doesn't work.
OP I have the same problem with my DS he has autism.
We have found it's all to do with anxiety and the need to buy something gives him the 'feel good feeling' .
We got him a Go Henry when he was 6yrs which did help. He's now 8yrs and if we are going shopping and he's no money left I let him know in advance I've no pennies for xy&z, which does work now he's a bit older.

Comedycook · 04/08/2023 16:51

Could you give him something to be in charge of....so say you're food shopping and you're buying biscuits anyway, he's in charge of choosing the biscuits? Or he could be in charge of ticking things off the shopping list?

Zebedee55 · 04/08/2023 16:50

Just say no. It worked for me, years ago.

TeaKitten · 04/08/2023 16:49

The photo thing worked for us, especially if I let DD take the photo herself then she’s physically done something about her desire. Other than that it’s a no. End of story. Kids do better when they no exactly were they stand, it’s not mean, it’s a clear answer.

Sprogonthetyne · 04/08/2023 16:45

If you are shopping with two adults so one can remove him, why doesn't one of you just stay home with him.

Pocket money takes some guidance at that age. Maybe help him to choose something on the smyths website, then show him on a calendar how long it will take to save, and mark off days/weeks until then. Or make a chart and let him earn the toy by doing little jobs or homework.

If you want him to practice choosing and buying things, you could take him to the pound shop every once in a while, when your not doing any other shopping and let him pick one thing. That at least takes away the stress of finding something in budget, or getting upset if he doesn't have enough for the thing he wants.

Gymmum82 · 04/08/2023 16:44

Unfortunately you’ve set the bar that if you go in the shop he gets something. It’ll be hard to break that but not impossible. You just have to be firm no matter how much he kicks off.

Mine don’t even ask because I literally never say yes or buy them anything ever unless it’s their birthday or xmas. If they had pocket money they would also be looking for any piece of tat that cost the exact amount just to have something
My eldest was taken on a day out by a friend to a fete of some sort. I gave her a couple of pounds for an ice cream. She came home with a spanner because she had 50p left and that was the only thing she could get with 50p. A fucking spanner

sendismylife · 04/08/2023 16:38

I read somewhere about a mum who let her children choose something for the food bank in the supermarket, which they were responsible for holding - took the focus onto buying for someone else and meant their hands were full.

BoohooWoohoo · 04/08/2023 16:38

If he's overwhelmed by the sheer amount of stuff in the shop then it might be best to discuss what you're going to buy beforehand and have him pick something specifically. For example he might be allowed to pick some fruit that is specifically for him to eat later. I'm an adult and I sometimes find the amount of variety of items on an aisle staggering...

BoohooWoohoo · 04/08/2023 16:35

Are you and his dad on the same page with this ?

I would put something on the list beforehand that he will like (and you are happy to buy) and if he behaves then buy it and if not then leave it at the shop.

It may take a few goes because it's become a habit but if there's no squash at home and he knows it's because he kicked off yesterday then he will hopefully be motivated to behave. He needs to feel the repercussions of kicking off (no squash)

Is he restrained in a trolley which you shop?

The other tactic is have you considered putting him in a trolley and giving him a device so he doesn't notice his surroundings? This pushes the problem down the line but I often see children in trolleys who are so absorbed by a device that they wouldn't notice their favourite characters doing backflips down the aisles. My son was a nightmare at the supermarket when he was 2 or so and I'm convinced that the lighting made him loopy because his behaviour was very different elsewhere.

Lkahsvtv · 04/08/2023 16:35

I realised wr got into the habit of always buying something for DC at the shop (did at as a treat post lockdown and then it became a habit) and now I try to minimise it and prepare DC before we go in. There’s still the requests but I just say not this time, my 6 year old has started to now request things that are helpful such as specific cheese for her lunch box which I will then buy and irs helped increase the variety she eats

MuggleMe · 04/08/2023 16:35

Photos work for us if we're anywhere near a birthday or Christmas.