Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask opinion of people who have literally walked the mile

64 replies

Toastiesforever · 04/08/2023 14:10

We have booked a villa family holiday for our family next year.
DH parents are coming, and DHs brother was looking to come with his DD (3) also.

For context he has split form his partner for around 2 years, the split was his fault, his partner had no fault in the split, it appears amicable.

They are sharing custody with no formal agreement which seems to be going well although she seems to call most of the shots ( this is only my opinion as someone looking in from the outside)

However it now transpires that ex partner is saying he is only allowed to take daughter for 1 week of the holiday, not 2.

Quietly, I think this is so unfair as their DD is the one who will be missing out spending time with her cousins and I feel like ex partner is being selfish, but, I’m also aware I’ve never walked a mile in her shoes and feel like maybe I need some perspective.

Is she being fair allowing a week?

OP posts:
WedRine · 06/08/2023 09:55

Yeah it's a long time. Even now at 5 DD would not cope with longer than a week away from me. Tried and tested, it would result in a lot of tears and not having a good time, but at least I was in a position to drive over and pick her up. Children want their mums more than their cousins.

DrLightman · 06/08/2023 09:46

Choccyp1g · 06/08/2023 09:18

If you all get along with the mum, how about suggesting she swaps with dad and comes on the holiday for the second week?

I was going to suggest this, get them to swap over for the second half

BlossomCloud · 06/08/2023 09:46

You are casting adult opinions and desires onto a 3yo and considering the adults desires over the childs.

Yep

maryberryslayers · 06/08/2023 09:44

My children are pretty independent but there's no way I'd want my 3yo (or 5yo) to be away from me for more than a week. Neither of my children would want it either, even with their dad and we are married.
Playing with cousins in the sun would be lovely but they'd be pretty unsettled and miss home/mummy come bedtime.
I think she's being quite reasonable allowing a full week at 3yo, let alone 2.

Blueblell · 06/08/2023 09:31

As everyone is saying - two weeks is too long for a 3 year old. It’s a villa holiday so they can come and go and to be honest a weeks holiday is the norm for most people these days. A week will seem like a long time for kids of that age and plenty of time for them to have fun together.

TheSandgroper · 06/08/2023 09:22

When I was 3, I went to my dgp’s for a week. Years later, my dm said it shouldn’t have been that long. I did not do well once I was home again.

zingally · 06/08/2023 09:21

2 weeks is a long time for a little one to be away from her primary caregiver, AND in the company of people she won't know very well.

3yos don't have any interest in the whole "spending time with" and "making memories" thing. You are casting adult opinions and desires onto a 3yo and considering the adults desires over the childs.

1 week is more than enough for a 3yo.

Workawayxx · 06/08/2023 09:19

I think she’s being reasonable and it’s probably based on what the 3 yo will cope with rather than not wanting to allow her a full holiday. On that basis however they should both agree to limit holidays to just 1 week till ages older. This is what ex and I did with ds.

BlossomCloud · 06/08/2023 09:19

BillyNotQuiteNoMates · 06/08/2023 09:04

It broke my heart when my daughter first went to stay with her dad for two weeks, but he was still her dad, no matter what he'd done, and I wouldn't have dreamed of trying to restrict their time together in that way.

It's not about amount of time, it's about the amount of time in one block. I think alternating weeks when they are little is best. building up to longer. That's sensible based on child development.

Choccyp1g · 06/08/2023 09:18

If you all get along with the mum, how about suggesting she swaps with dad and comes on the holiday for the second week?

BillyNotQuiteNoMates · 06/08/2023 09:04

It broke my heart when my daughter first went to stay with her dad for two weeks, but he was still her dad, no matter what he'd done, and I wouldn't have dreamed of trying to restrict their time together in that way.

ChampagneBlossom44 · 06/08/2023 08:54

You are being really, really unreasonable. Can’t you put yourself in her shoes, if you & DH broke up would you really be happy with not seeing your kids for a fortnight? Age 3! My husband has 2 & I’d never expected their mum to have OK’d a fortnight away from them when they were that little

BellaJuno · 06/08/2023 08:40

Menopants · 04/08/2023 14:14

2 weeks is a long time for a 3 year old to be away from their mother. I get it

Yes this for me. I think it’s a normal request. I’d take her for the second week so she doesn’t feel she’s going home when the others are staying on having fun.

jumpingbean1810 · 06/08/2023 08:38

I became a single parent when daughter was 18mths old, and I wouldn't let her be away for more than a week until she was c. 7-8. This wasn't me being spiteful, it was because as her primary carer she would be desperate to get back home and her routine and what was familiar to her by the end of a week. Advice I read on co parenting was short and frequent contact when they're young building to longer stays and a more regular routine when they're older. Even now at 14 she stays away for longer but gets homesick. She was in tears last Christmas as she was with her paternal family and wanted to be at home. She adores them but home is where her heart is. Since school age she is with her dad every other weekend and c, 3wks holiday a year so 80% of her time is with me.

BlossomCloud · 06/08/2023 08:27

It's awful to take a child away from their mother for two weeks. Even 1 week is a long time at 3.

And knowing they are abroad and a plane flight away if anything happens is horrific.

She will be fine with it once the child is older, don't rush it.

AmazingSnakeHead · 04/08/2023 14:55

My child is that age and I can promise you that he would much rather not spend two weeks away from me than go on a two week holiday. Two weeks is a long time for a kid that age to be on holiday anyway. I would also never consider taking him away from his dad for half a month.

yogasaurus · 04/08/2023 14:53

There’s a lot of factors to consider in a situation like this.

Happiness of their cousins is way, way down that list.

Stompythedinosaur · 04/08/2023 14:53

Of course a 3yo should be away from their mum for two weeks!

Tbh I think suggesting taking her away for two weeks is not really acting in the child's interests.

She is not missing out, it's far more important to regularly see her main carer that to see her cousins.

This is just one way life changes when you are separated.

melj1213 · 04/08/2023 14:51

Toastiesforever · 04/08/2023 14:25

Yes, as a mum of literally children that age at the moment I couldn’t imagine being away from them for 2 weeks.

But in the flip side, I couldn’t imagine not being allowed to take them a 2 week holiday if we did split up and I wouldn’t not allow their father to take them either.

Its also easy for me since I’m in a happy marriage ( at the moment) and therefor my opinions are based on my feelings right now in the situation I’m in.

Nobody is saying he can never take her for more than a week at a time, just not yet.

There may be any number of reasons why she may not be comfortable with her ex taking their child away for a 2 week trip or it could be something as simple as she can only get certain weeks off work and the holiday falls in that time so she wants to ensure she gets time to have a holiday with her child too.

My DDs dad and I split up when she was little, we were living in Spain at the time and he moved back to the UK. I was more than happy for him to visit us and see her for as long as he liked if he was in our city but I did not want him taking her away from home for more than a week initially. Partly because I didn't want to be away from her for so long but also because it was such a huge change from her normal routine that I wanted to build it up just in case there were issues, especially as she was so small and they don't understand time at that age so a week can seem like forever to them). I preferred that she had a great, but short, trip first and then build that up to longer trips than have her go on a 2 week trip initially and it potentially all go wrong and sour the idea of a holiday with her dad again in future.

Fbshe · 04/08/2023 14:43

I was the child in this and I remember being 4 or 5 and all I wanted to do was see my mum because I missed her so much.

Ted43 · 04/08/2023 14:34

I think a week is very fair, it may be the case that his ex has her own holiday plans and can only take a week off herself so wants to do something with her daughter. Weirdly our family had a similar thing this week - my sister's mother in law - quite overbearing at the best of times rang out of the blue and asked could she take my sister's 3 yr old son to America for 3 & a half weeks - now the boy has a relationship with his grandparents which is pretty typical - visits them maybe once every 2-3 weeks with parents that's about it - he doesn't live with them or anything. Anyway the MIL is upset now that she's been told absolutely not by my sister - she simply has no concept of how inappropriate it is to ask to bring the child to America for nearly a month at 3 years old and with no parents.

Toastiesforever · 04/08/2023 14:27

MrsTerryPratchett · 04/08/2023 14:26

A 3 yo wants to spend time with her mum massively more than her cousins I can guarantee it. It's not unfair on her at all.

The divorce is the thing that's hard on her and you said that's his fault.

That’s a good way of putting it, I hadn’t thought of it that way, thankyou

OP posts:
Toastiesforever · 04/08/2023 14:26

Re the split of custody, it’s hard to tell as it seems really flexible at the moment but I’d probably at a push say it’s 55/45 in the mums favour.

OP posts:
MrsTerryPratchett · 04/08/2023 14:26

A 3 yo wants to spend time with her mum massively more than her cousins I can guarantee it. It's not unfair on her at all.

The divorce is the thing that's hard on her and you said that's his fault.

Toastiesforever · 04/08/2023 14:25

Lostmyway86 · 04/08/2023 14:17

I've walked it but from the other side as a SM to DSDs who were 3 and 5 when I met them. I think a 2 week holiday at 3 years old away from the other parent is too long. We would never have asked for that at that age and I know my DSDs mum found a week's holiday abroad with us tough. As a mum now to 2 and 4 year olds, I could never be away from them for 2 weeks. So in that respect I understand why she's only saying 1 week.

However if that means others holidays are cut short because of this decision then that does seem a little unfair so I understand all points of views, but I'd probably do the same as her I'm afraid.

Yes, as a mum of literally children that age at the moment I couldn’t imagine being away from them for 2 weeks.

But in the flip side, I couldn’t imagine not being allowed to take them a 2 week holiday if we did split up and I wouldn’t not allow their father to take them either.

Its also easy for me since I’m in a happy marriage ( at the moment) and therefor my opinions are based on my feelings right now in the situation I’m in.

OP posts: