Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why the FUCK this guy isn’t in jail?!

107 replies

AngeloMysterioso · 04/08/2023 13:08

A man has been given an 8 month suspended sentence after bashing the crap out of his 15 year old daughter with a metal bar. Apparently he did it because she’d committed the heinous crime of wearing make up to school… which she’d put on to cover up the bruises from previous times he’d bashed the crap out of her. Two years of abuse this child has endured at his hands.

But because this poor kid gave a statement asking for leniency, saying SHE feels guilty because SHE has brought shame on her family, he’s basically got away with it.

AIBU to think this man is a violent criminal who belongs in prison?!

(Daily Mail link, sorry but it was that or The ☀️)

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12372633/amp/Father-battered-daughter-metal-bar-school-meet-boy-GCSE-exam-jail-mercy-plea.html

OP posts:
Blackbyrd · 04/08/2023 20:31

@Oatycookies if you don't know the stats for Asian men, whose religion often allows the beating of wives and children, then hush your mouth. So easy to cry racism rather than address the real issues

Palmasailor · 04/08/2023 20:26

It’s fine.

He’s perfectly entitled to beat women, especially his wife as long as he doesn’t beat her any worse than he would an errant dog and provided he uses a stick which is no thicker than his thumb.

So it’s fine. Get used to it.

Oatycookies · 04/08/2023 20:24

AngeloMysterioso · 04/08/2023 20:20

I can’t honestly imagine that Dave from Dagenham or Nigel from Newcastle would have received such a sentence had they done the same to their child.

You can also look at it another way…So often I hear judges or police see they see their daughter in the victim as they have a child that age blah blah . I wonder if in this case they don’t feel that same empathy and have therefore not acted to protect this Asian girl. But they would likely see Nigel’s daughter as a more innocent and fragile victim worthy of protection.

but yea sadly there are horrendous cases with men of all races being let go after abusing kids. Of course the daily mail will spotlight certain ones more to further their agenda…

Oatycookies · 04/08/2023 20:22

And I don’t know the stats for Asian men but I do know that white women are given the most lenient sentences, black women are sentenced similarly to white MEN and black men are punished the most harshly out of all groups.

This is based on heaps of research comparing the sentences given to people who have committed a similar crime.

so yeah less of the minorities get away with it crap. Rotherham or Rochdale etc happened because the girls were seen as damaged goods sadly from rough families or in care. I worked with kids in care from all cultures and they’re generally seen as an easy target from men of all races and police sadly don’t respond to them being at risk or missing the way they would to a normal kid especially a middle class white girl.

We all know how the media and police act differently when a white woman or child goes missing (unless she’s a sex worker etc) again there is research in media studies or prove this if you haven’t noticed. so again stop acting as if it’s minorities who get specially good treatment.

Alexandra2001 · 04/08/2023 20:20

Should get a Whole life prison sentence, never released, would send a very clear message to men of any culture that we will not tolerate this.

If not, in a while, he 'll kill his daughter.

Hopefully this sentence will be appealed.

AngeloMysterioso · 04/08/2023 20:20

I can’t honestly imagine that Dave from Dagenham or Nigel from Newcastle would have received such a sentence had they done the same to their child.

OP posts:
Oatycookies · 04/08/2023 20:15

Pallisers · 04/08/2023 20:03

I don't know what exact culture he is from but the men and women of that culture should be up in arms about this. The idea that a conservative culture means you can hit your daughter and bite her in the face and that is what men will do unless they are reeducated- it is a racist attitude

There should be outrage from everyone about this but especially from the culture he is from - utter outrage demanding that he be locked up.

That poor girl. The judge is a fool.

Exactly it’s actually racist of the judge and many of the posters here too btw to put this down to culture. I know plenty of white teen girls knocked around by dads and stepdads.

most or at least many children will defend their parents, even some kids who have been sexually abused don’t want their abused parents going to prison so I’m amazed that her wishes were taken into account. She has grown up with abuse and also loves her father like most kids do so of course she’s not going to be thinking straight.

to me if anything it shows that this culture as a whole - ie the whole world- doesn’t value women and girls especially if they’re related to the man who has victimised them. It’s like when people used to say “it’s a domestic” and ignore a man hitting his wife or gf because they’re seen as the man’s property. I bets if this man had did this to a random unrelated Girl, especially a white middle class girl, he would have went down for it.

Deadringer · 04/08/2023 20:11

It's disgusting. What about when she does start going out with boys, and wearing make up, he will end up killing her.

Pallisers · 04/08/2023 20:03

Saucery · 04/08/2023 13:21

“Adapt to new cultural behaviour expected of him”? Wtf have I just read? What an insult to all the men who manage not to beat their daughters and bite their faces who come from the same cultural background as him .
He sounds so dangerous and he will do more violence, of that I am certain.

I don't know what exact culture he is from but the men and women of that culture should be up in arms about this. The idea that a conservative culture means you can hit your daughter and bite her in the face and that is what men will do unless they are reeducated- it is a racist attitude

There should be outrage from everyone about this but especially from the culture he is from - utter outrage demanding that he be locked up.

That poor girl. The judge is a fool.

BasiliskStare · 04/08/2023 19:51

Oh FFS there are cultural differences ( which is fine ) and then there is the law - and the law says you do not hit , bruise , bite your daughter. Bullying her about her friends - not sure where that stands but this man has got off too lightly I think ( but I am not a lawyer . ) I suspect his family are a bit scared of him so I only hope he will be very much monitored. And that the family will receive some help as to how to deal with him

am an expert in neither , but Goodness sake This man I think need a very strong lesson and not sure if this is it. I am sure the judge had a reason but it feels too lenient .

RecoveryNeeded · 04/08/2023 18:58

This makes me want to weep.

I am from a similar culture, though had a vastly different upbringing. Parents never laid a finger on me, I married my white boyfriend 20 years ago etc without issue.

How the hell is this ok? What does this teach the Neanderthals that don’t respect women or girls?? That statement was not without coercion, spoken or implied. That poor poor girl. She needs to be in a refuge and receiving therapy. She is clearly terrified. That man needs to be in jail. Local community leaders need to say this is unacceptable.

So many girls must be in this position right now. It makes me furious. Come to this country and be shocked when your kids want to adopt local norms..what do you expect?? Though in this case the girl hadn’t even done anything ‘wrong’. Monster.

Ffs I despair.

Zandra123 · 04/08/2023 18:57

Poor poor girl, it's very worrying what will happen to her now.
There's no excuse of culture none, the dark mark on his forehead is a. " look at me how much I pray" symbol. Sadly it seems a lot of this behind closed doors.

Sausagenbacon · 04/08/2023 18:51

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 04/08/2023 18:44

Redraddisho27 · 04/08/2023 18:24

Is there anything we can do? Anywhere we can complain? MPs etc... I feel awful for her...

You can email the office if the attorney general and ask them to review the sentence under the unduly lenient sentence scheme. I have just done it and it only takes two minutes.

Prescottdanni123 · 04/08/2023 18:34

That judge should never be allowed to practice again.

Redraddisho27 · 04/08/2023 18:24

Is there anything we can do? Anywhere we can complain? MPs etc... I feel awful for her...

Dixiechickonhols · 04/08/2023 18:23

That poor girl. I also wondered if it was deliberately timed attack on day of her English gcse - without a pass in that her prospects of getting on a college course or job were limited making it easier to keep her home and control her.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 04/08/2023 18:23

He should have been imprisoned regardless of the victim or her family's expressed wishes, and he should be allowed nowhere near any one of them in future.

He will continue to behave exactly as before.

Talapia · 04/08/2023 18:22

Jesus fuck, how is he still walking the streets.

How dare the judge accept cultural adjustment as an excuse for this vile monsters behaviour.Talk about set a precedent for using this excuse.

Groovee · 04/08/2023 18:17

She was wearing make up to cover the previous bruising he inflicted 😢

DeeCeeCherry · 04/08/2023 18:15

AutumnCrow
Members of the public can contact the Attorney general and ask a sentence to be referred to the Unduly Lenient Sentence scheme. Or you can ask your MP to do it, asap

Bumping this.

Thanks, I wasnt aware. Can we all do this please? Its just a few minutes of our time. I haven't clicked on link, I'm too much of a softy. But even reading this thread has upset me greatly. Condoning child abuse? In 2023, at that?

We have no-one.

SirSamVimesCityWatch · 04/08/2023 18:12

14 different sites of injury including facial bruising and was also treated for a bite mark to her left temple.

I can't imagine the sort of ferocity of attack which would result in biting someone on the temple. Jesus fucking Christ.

frustratednomad · 04/08/2023 18:10

It makes me so cross when people come here for a better lifestyle but still want to carry on their archaic beliefs. They should learn to live by our values or stay in their own countries, there is no place for some of their cruel behaviours.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 04/08/2023 18:03

At least he has moved out

Good luck with that, Xenia. Even if it's true - and I'm a bit "hmmm" since his defence claimed he was his wife's main carer - just how much resistence do you suppose there'd be to him moving back in if he wished to do so?

I'm not aware if staying away has been made a condition of his suspended sentence, but even if so a return would probably be swept under the carpet judicially, and that's in the no doubt unlikely event the family reported it ... after all he's "been on a parenting course" so must have taken it all onboard, right? Hmm

Americano75 · 04/08/2023 17:23

I knew exactly who you were talking about before I even opened the thread. It's disgusting, the fuck are these old fuckers on?

Swipe left for the next trending thread