Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why the FUCK this guy isn’t in jail?!

107 replies

AngeloMysterioso · 04/08/2023 13:08

A man has been given an 8 month suspended sentence after bashing the crap out of his 15 year old daughter with a metal bar. Apparently he did it because she’d committed the heinous crime of wearing make up to school… which she’d put on to cover up the bruises from previous times he’d bashed the crap out of her. Two years of abuse this child has endured at his hands.

But because this poor kid gave a statement asking for leniency, saying SHE feels guilty because SHE has brought shame on her family, he’s basically got away with it.

AIBU to think this man is a violent criminal who belongs in prison?!

(Daily Mail link, sorry but it was that or The ☀️)

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12372633/amp/Father-battered-daughter-metal-bar-school-meet-boy-GCSE-exam-jail-mercy-plea.html

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Crazyworldwelivein · 05/10/2023 01:45

Absolutely shocking.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 06/08/2023 16:22

Well done to the girl for speaking out despite the possible consequences

But do we know who reported this in the first place aand what's she really been able to speak out about? Especially when, once in court, her main thrust seems to have been to beg for leniency for her parent?

In the UK it's the CPS who bring cases rather than the victim, and when someone's been publicly beaten unconscious with an iron bar I'd like to think that's hard to brush aside
However, had this dreadful assault not happened in public I wouldn't want to assume we'd ever have heard about it

ReformedWaywardTeen · 06/08/2023 15:13

When are we going to protect all our girls and women? Where is the justice?

I knew what community that poor girl would be from before I even read it. It's like because of their customs, it's treated as that, as an excuse.

Someone must protect that poor girl before she becomes yet another statistic, another "lessons will be learned" case on the news.

Because lessons never really are learned are they? Not when it comes to women from, especially, that community.

Clearly she's so in fear she's done what she's been told and begged for leniency? How can the judge involved not see what is obvious? She is being controlled! She has been the victim of years of what I imagine are savage beatings in the place she should feel safer than anywhere else.

Sorry it just makes me so upset.

Sittingonasale · 06/08/2023 15:13

There's another thread on this. The man should have been locked up.
There's no way the girl and mother will get away with this scot free in that family. There will be consequences, that man will ensure that if he does it himself or gets others to do it.
Those poor kids need protection and they haven't got it.

Let's hope it's not another honour killing.

royalwatch · 06/08/2023 15:12

Disgusting

The teenager feels guilt and shame and still loves him

The judge had a chance to protect that girl and her family

And he didnt

Elephantsdontlikechocolate · 06/08/2023 15:08

Close to all girls and women in certain communities and religions suffer daily abuse from men controlling their lives and bodies from birth to old age, having no agency, being second class and facing severe repercussions for disobeying, speaking out or leaving their communities - that affect their whole families for generations.
A typical European, traditional to this country religion or no religion woman is able to leave her abusive environment, there is little consequence but a better life. A typical woman in the recently welcomed to this country cultures where women are the class of a goat will not just become ostracised but so will her family for generations and possibly will even get murdered.
The level of abuse and consequences cannot be even comprehended by those ignorant wooly morons that like to celebrate this to appear tolerant and liberal. Anything but.

Women aren't able to dress, live, work or love as they see fit because of the effect (shame and ostracisizing and personal insury or murder) that'll be brought on their families, particularly sisters, nieces and other females. If you know your going out in a mini-skirt or moving in with a white man means your sisters or nieces wont ever get married, even if you know that's wrong, most simply won't do it.
There is no freedom in that choice since the brainwashing starts from birth and values and women's freedoms normal for this country are rejected as they are for what's perceived as white whores. A lot of those women believe it's the right way to live.
Vile.
Well done to the girl for speaking out despite the possible consequences. Most normal people know and understand what life is like for women in her community, but for a few morons, who in their ignorance want to normalise it, it needs to be called out.
In some London boroughs and some cities such communities dominate in their numbers, and comprising large proportion of the UK population, it changes the culture and the rights of women in the UK for the worse.
Already on the London underground notices have had to be put up that sexual ogling, staring and touching isn't acceptable. This is done because of a large male population from abroad and from communities that don't understand how a male can sit beside a woman and still control his urges, having being raised in a segregated environment where a woman out on her own equals being a fair game.

Elephantsdontlikechocolate · 06/08/2023 14:13

Yes he is a a violent vicious criminal. Every time someone says it's their culture, or otherwise suggests they should be excused because of their culture, is colluding and supporting violence against women. Plenty of those of mumnsnet that fancy themselves liberal and declare anyone who disagrees racists. Couldn't be further from being liberal.
Living in the UK, fully benefiting from it and continuing to practice cultures and practices that have zero compatibility with living in a civilised society where women and girls have agency over the body and their life. We are told to celebrate it.

Naunet · 06/08/2023 10:32

Oatycookies · 04/08/2023 20:22

And I don’t know the stats for Asian men but I do know that white women are given the most lenient sentences, black women are sentenced similarly to white MEN and black men are punished the most harshly out of all groups.

This is based on heaps of research comparing the sentences given to people who have committed a similar crime.

so yeah less of the minorities get away with it crap. Rotherham or Rochdale etc happened because the girls were seen as damaged goods sadly from rough families or in care. I worked with kids in care from all cultures and they’re generally seen as an easy target from men of all races and police sadly don’t respond to them being at risk or missing the way they would to a normal kid especially a middle class white girl.

We all know how the media and police act differently when a white woman or child goes missing (unless she’s a sex worker etc) again there is research in media studies or prove this if you haven’t noticed. so again stop acting as if it’s minorities who get specially good treatment.

Do you happen to have a link to this, I’m genuinely interested to read. Thanks!

Naunet · 06/08/2023 10:27

HedgesNotFences · 04/08/2023 13:51

Is this not like Rochdale when authorities ignored the issue’s because of cultural fears/concerns? You would hope people would learn.

Nah, that was just the excuse they used to turn a blind eye, the police have never been particularly concerned with being called racist, it’s only when crimes impact women and girls that it’s suddenly a massive concern for them.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 06/08/2023 10:16

You also need to state that you have no personal connection to the case (see below, copied from the automatic response to my email)


If you are requesting that a sentence is reviewed under the ULS Scheme, the body of your email must include the following information:
· The name of the offender;
· The offence for which they were sentenced;
· The relevant Crown Court and date of sentence (if known);
· Whether you have a personal connection to the case, and what that connection is (if any); and
· Why you consider that the sentence appears to be unduly lenient.

Requests which do not contain the above information are not valid and will not be actioned. Links to news articles without the above information in the body of the email will not be accepted. If your email did not include this information, please provide it by way of a further email.

ilovethepug · 05/08/2023 23:07

www.gov.uk/ask-crown-court-sentence-review

More info here on what to include in email

ilovethepug · 05/08/2023 23:05

That poor child. I have just emailed the attorney General to ask for review. Please can everyone do the same. The email address is [email protected]

JMSA · 05/08/2023 22:59

The poor, poor love Sad

notahappybunny7 · 05/08/2023 22:54

roses321 · 04/08/2023 13:11

Coercive control really is a stonker isn't it.... if the justice system had ANY fucking idea what it did to people they'd see straight through her guilty feelings and give him life. Fucking joke to be honest.

They know… too scared to be labelled racist. I went to the same school. Many years ago and it was happening then, really threat for girls to be shipped back to Pakistan at the slightest hint they were becoming “westernised “ ie normal teen girls

Andthereyougo · 05/08/2023 22:30

I didn’t realise it was ok to carry a weapon for protection if you’re a delivery driver. Is this rule just for men as women can’t carry mace spray for protection?
That poor girl has been well and truly brainwashed and the judge is an idiot.

tt9 · 05/08/2023 22:22

and it's horrific and unacceptable how 'culture' is somehow being used as a way to give him a more lenient sentence.

tt9 · 05/08/2023 22:21

Jux · 04/08/2023 15:22

Trouble is if he'd been imprisoned it could have brought even worse treatment down on the poor child. She has brothers and uncles who could have murdered her (honour killing) for the shame she brought down on them all by causing her dad to be jailed, or she could have been packed off to Pakistan to a forced marriage where she could be treated even worse.

I have a friend who had made quite a study of the history and practices of Islam (he's Pakistani, Muslim) etc, while he was growing up in Pakistan.

Two possibly worse fates for her could be, he says,

"Being sent back to your parents country to be married to a jobless 65yr old bc you clearly can’t be trusted to live in the west but you’ve brought too much shame on your family to be married to a man your age with prospects"

and

"Or maybe your own mother will kill you for bringing dishonour on her and your siblings and it’s the only way for her to scrape their lives back together."

Complete corruption of what is actually in the Quran. My friend also thinks thatmost of the shitty stuff isn't in the Quran, it's the Hadiths - and you can pretty well pick and choose those, he says.

Gotta say, not sure what Islam your friend is researching.

hadith are the narration of the actions and sayings of the Prophet Peace Be Upon Him.

He never ever even raised his voice in anger to anyone let alone beat anyone. He admonished firmly anyone physically hitting anyone including animals and even asked us to treat plants with kindness.

He also said any man who raises daughters, educates them and helps them find a good husband will enter paradise with me.

Nothing in Islam justifies this man's behaviour. this is misogyny with a good dash of culture thrown in.

nolamesallowed · 05/08/2023 13:23

Of course this has quickly descended into calls of racism.

Ignoring cultural behaviours doesn't make them go away- it reinforces the belief that the abusers can get away with it.

I grew up in a 'cultural' environment. I liken it more to a cult now. I suffered abuse in ways many people couldn't comprehend and yes, my father/uncles/cousins/brothers and others got away with it.

Ihavenoauthority · 05/08/2023 13:11

Absolute scum, no place in a civilized society

IhaveanewTVnow · 05/08/2023 13:11

Weefreetiffany · 04/08/2023 13:29

Well quite. This implies there is a cultural justification for violence against women and children when it’s disgusting violent men exploiting the system to be disgusting and violent. No culture in the world says you can bite your daughter when angry. For shame. He looks like a religious man. I hope he goes straight to hell with the other demons.

That just feeds the racists too. Disgraceful from the judge.

TrishM80 · 05/08/2023 13:08

The way things are going, "honour beatings" will probably become legal in the UK.

Weefreetiffany · 05/08/2023 13:03

@Oatycookies it’s a moot point because the issue is him beating his own child- his own daughter. The sentence should be harsher for hurting those you are supposed to protect. I know most parents of any ethnicity or race can’t understand this mentality of beating your own child with a metal bar and biting their face. It is an exceptional level of violence. The point of the law is that everyone should be equal before it, I understand why this doesn’t always work in practice, but the cultural back ground and ethnicity of perpetrator and victim should not even be a factor. We don’t do this to children under the laws of this country, which he is subject to.

If you don’t know the stats for Asian men, don’t comment at all. Especially don’t comment to say that white women get special treatment as this minimises the real issue which is violence against women and girl of all races, where the first violence starts at home. If you make wedges between “white women” and “all other women” you make it harder for all people to be united against violence against women. People with families who care about them get media attention because the families make it happen. Everybody else is invisible regardless of race or background. We need to focus on making the invisible violence against women visible, by contacting the sentencing department above for example, not by making wedges between people based on incomplete data and tangential whataboutary.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 04/08/2023 20:42

or a white boy. Or any other race, ethnicity etc.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 04/08/2023 20:41

Oatycookies · 04/08/2023 20:22

And I don’t know the stats for Asian men but I do know that white women are given the most lenient sentences, black women are sentenced similarly to white MEN and black men are punished the most harshly out of all groups.

This is based on heaps of research comparing the sentences given to people who have committed a similar crime.

so yeah less of the minorities get away with it crap. Rotherham or Rochdale etc happened because the girls were seen as damaged goods sadly from rough families or in care. I worked with kids in care from all cultures and they’re generally seen as an easy target from men of all races and police sadly don’t respond to them being at risk or missing the way they would to a normal kid especially a middle class white girl.

We all know how the media and police act differently when a white woman or child goes missing (unless she’s a sex worker etc) again there is research in media studies or prove this if you haven’t noticed. so again stop acting as if it’s minorities who get specially good treatment.

I wonder what the stats would be if we took the victim`s race, ethnicity, age, sex etc. into account.

there is - clearly - a lot of bias in the justice system. But we tend to primarily focus on the perpetrator without factoring in how the identity of the victim may factor into this as well.

And I would wonder if this abuser had experienced the same leniency if he had victimised a member of an other race, sex etc.

a white girl, for example.